Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The Perennial Problem of Variability In Adenosine Triphosphate (ATP) Tests for Hygiene Monitoring Within Healthcare Settings

  • Greg S. Whiteley (a1) (a2), Chris Derry (a1) (a3), Trevor Glasbey (a2) and Paul Fahey (a1)

Abstract

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the reliability of commercial ATP bioluminometers and to document precision and variability measurements using known and quantitated standard materials.

METHODS

Four commercially branded ATP bioluminometers and their consumables were subjected to a series of controlled studies with quantitated materials in multiple repetitions of dilution series. The individual dilutions were applied directly to ATP swabs. To assess precision and reproducibility, each dilution step was tested in triplicate or quadruplicate and the RLU reading from each test point was recorded. Results across the multiple dilution series were normalized using the coefficient of variation.

RESULTS

The results for pure ATP and bacterial ATP from suspensions of Staphylococcus epidermidis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa are presented graphically. The data indicate that precision and reproducibility are poor across all brands tested. Standard deviation was as high as 50% of the mean for all brands, and in the field users are not provided any indication of this level of imprecision.

CONCLUSIONS

The variability of commercial ATP bioluminometers and their consumables is unacceptably high with the current technical configuration. The advantage of speed of response is undermined by instrument imprecision expressed in the numerical scale of relative light units (RLU).

Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2015;00(0):1–6

Copyright

Corresponding author

Address correspondence to Greg S. Whiteley, M Safety Sc, P.O. Box 1076, North Sydney, NSW 2059, Australia (gregswhiteley@aol.com).

References

Hide All
1. Griffith, CJ, Cooper, RA, Gilmore, J, Davies, C, Lewis, M. An evaluation of hospital cleaning regimes and standards. J Hosp Infect 2000;45:1928.
2. Aitken, ZA, Wilson, M, Pratten, J. Evaluation of ATP bioluminescence assays for potential use in a hospital setting. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2011;32:507509.
3. Sciortino, CV, Giles, RA. Validation and comparison of three adenosine triphosphate luminometers for monitoring hospital surface sanitization: a rosetta stone for adenosine triphosphate testing. Am J Infect Control 2012;40:e233239.
4. Smith, PW, Beam, E, Sayles, H, Rupp, ME, Cavalieri, RJ, Gibbs, S, Hewlett, A. Impact of adenosine triphosphate detection and feedback on hospital room cleaning. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2014;35:564569.
5. Carling, PC, Huang, SS. Improving healthcare environmental cleaning and disinfection: current and evolving issues. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2013;34:507513.
6. Mitchell, BG, Wilson, F, Dancer, SJ, McGregor, A. Methods to evaluate environmental cleanliness in healthcare facilities. Healthcare Infect 2013;18:2230.
7. Loveday, H, Wilson, JA, Pratt, RJ, Golsorkhi, M, Tingle, A, Bak, A, Browne, J, Prieto, J, Wilcox, M. EPIC 3 National Evidence Based Guidelines for Preventing Healthcare-Associated Infections in NHS Hospitals in England. J Hosp Infect 2014;86:Suppl 1.
8. Gibbs, SG, Sayles, H, Chaika, O, Hewlett, A, Colbert, EM, Smith, PW. Evaluation of the relationship between ATP bioluminescence assay and the presence of organisms associated with healthcare-associated infections. Healthcare Infect 2014;19:101107.
9. Malik, DJ. Assessment of infection risk from environmental contamination using rapid ATP surface measurements. Am J Infect Control 2013;41:469479.
10. Whiteley, GS, Derry, C, Glasbey, T. Reliability testing for portable adenosine triphosphate bioluminometers. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2013;34:538540.
11. Shama, G, Malik, DJ. The uses and abuses of rapid bioluminescence-based ATP assays. International J Hyg Environ Health 2013;216:115125.
12. Whiteley, GS, Derry, C, Glasbey, T. The comparative performance of three brands of portable ATP-bioluminometer intended for use in hospital infection control. Healthcare Infect 2012;17:9197.
13. Cooper, RA, Griffith, CJ, Malik, RE, Obee, P, Looker, N. Monitoring the effectiveness of cleaning in four British hospitals. J Hosp Infect 2007;35:338341.
14. Lewis, T, Griffith, C, Galo, M, Weinbren, M. A modified ATP benchmark for evaluating the cleaning of some hospital environmental surfaces. J Hosp Infect 2008;69:156163.
15. Mulvey, D, Redding, P, Robertson, C, Woodall, C, Kingsmore, P, Bedwell, D, Dancer, SJ. Finding a benchmark for monitoring hospital cleanliness. J Hosp Infect 2011;77:2530.
16. Boyce, JM, Havill, NL, Lipka, A, Havill, H, Rizvani, BS. Variations in hospital daily cleaning practices. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2010;31:99101.
17. Moore, G, Smyth, D, Singleton, J, Wilson, P. The use of adenosine triphosphate bioluminescence to assess the efficacy of a modified cleaning program implemented within an intensive care setting. Am J Infect Control 2010;38:617622.
18. Anderson, RE, Young, V, Stewart, M, Robertson, C, Dancer, SJ. Cleanliness audit of clinical surfaces and equipment: who cleans what? J Hosp Infect 2011;78:178181.
19. Smith, PW, Gibbs, S, Sayles, H, Hewlett, A, Rupp, ME, Iwen, PC. Observations on hospital room contamination testing. Healthcare Infect 2013;18:1013.
20. Smith, PW, Sayles, H, Hewlett, , Cavalieri, RJ, Gibbs, SG, Rupp, ME. A study of three methods for assessment of hospital environmental cleaning. Healthcare Infect 2013;18:8085.
21. Lautenback, E, Woeltje, KF, Malani, PN. Practical Healthcare Epidemiology, 3rd ed. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 2010.
22. Martin, P, Pierce, R. Practical Statistics for the Health Sciences. South Melbourne: Thomas Nelson, 1994.
23. Whiteley, GS, Derry, C, Glasbey, T. Sampling plans for use of rapid adenosine triphosphate (ATP) monitoring must overcome variability or suffer statistical invalidity. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2015;36:236237.
24. Deva, AK, Adams, WP, Vickery, KA. The role of bacterial biofilms in device associated infections. Plast Recon Surg 2013;132:13191328.
25. Lautenbach, E, Perencevich, EN. Introduction: addressing the emergence and impact of multidrug resistant Gram-negative organisms: a critical focus for the next decade. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2014;35:333335.
26. Wood, RJ, Durham, TM. Reproducibility of serological titers. J Clinical Microbiol 1980;11:541545.
27. Reed, GF, Lynn, F, Meade, BD. Use of coefficient of variation in assessing variability of quantitative assays. Clinical Diagnostic Lab Immunology 2002;9:12351239.
28. Wood, RJ. Alternative ways of estimating serological titer reproducibility. J Clinical Microbiol 1981;13:760768.
29. Malik, DJ, Shama, G. Estimating bacterial surface contamination by means of ATP determinations: 20 pence short of a pound. J Hosp Infect 2012;80:354356.
30. Rastogi, S, Shah, R, Perlman, J, Bhutada, A, Grossman, S, Pagala, M, Lazzaro, M. Pattern of bacterial colonisation in a new neonatal intensive care unit and its association with infections in infants. Am J Infect Control 2012;40:512515.
31. Moore, G, Muzlay, M, Wilson, P. The type, level and distribution of microorganisms within the ward environment: a zonal analysis of an intensive care unit and a gastrointestinal surgical ward. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2013;34:500506.
32. Vickery, K, Deva, A, Jacombs, A, Allan, J, Valente, P, Gosbell, IB. Presence of biofilm containing viable multi-resistant organisms despite terminal cleaning on clinical surfaces in an intensive care unit. J Hosp Infect 2012;80:5255.
33. Galvin, S, Dolan, A, Cahill, O, Daniels, S, Humphreys, H. Microbial monitoring of the hospital environment: why and how? J Hosp Infect 2012;82:143151.
34. Whiteley, GS, Derry, C, Glasbey, T. Failure analysis in the identification of synergies between cleaning monitoring methods. Am J Infect Control 2015;43:147153.

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed