Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-17T18:03:11.721Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

What Is It like to Feel Another's Pain?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2022

Frédérique de Vignemont  and
Pierre Jacob
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We offer an account of empathetic pain that preserves the distinctions among standard pain, contagious pain, empathetic pain, sympathy for pain, and standard pain ascription. Vicarious experiences of both contagious and empathetic pain resemble to some extent experiences of standard pain. But there are also crucial dissimilarities. As neuroscientific results show, standard pain involves a sensorimotor and an affective component. According to our account, contagious pain consists in imagining the former, whereas empathetic pain consists in imagining the latter. We further argue that awareness of another's standard pain is part of empathetic pain, but empathetic awareness of another's standard pain differs from believing that another is in standard pain.

Type
Research Article
Information
Philosophy of Science , Volume 79 , Issue 2 , April 2012 , pp. 295 - 316
Copyright
Copyright © The Philosophy of Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

‡

Earlier versions of this article were presented at the conference on Self and Other in Social Neuroscience and Philosophy of Mind in Alghero (Sardinia), at the Mind and Language seminar at the Department of Philosophy at New York University, and at the Philosophy Department of the Central European University in Budapest. We are grateful to the reactions of audiences there and particularly to Ned Block, Tim Crane, Kati Farkas, Alvin Goldman, Christophe Heintz, and Jesse Prinz for their comments. We also wish to acknowledge the support of a grant from the French Ministry of Research (ANR-BLAN SOCODEV). We dedicate this article to the French cognitive neuroscientist Marc Jeannerod, who died on July 1, 2011.

References

Adolphs, Ralph, Tranel, Daniel, Damasio, Hanna, and Damasio, Antonio. 1994. “Impaired Recognition of Emotion in Facial Expressions following Bilateral Damage to the Amygdale.” Nature 372:669–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Armstrong, David. 1962. Bodily Sensations. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Avenanti, Alessio, Bueti, Domenica, Galati, Gaspare, and Aglioti, Salvatore. 2005. “Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Highlights the Sensorimotor Side of Empathy for Pain.” Nature Neuroscience 87:955–60.Google Scholar
Avenanti, Alessio, Minio-Paluello, Ilaria, Bufalari, Ilaria, and Aglioti, Salvatore. 2006. “Stimulus-Driven Modulation of Motor-Evoked Potentials during Observation of Others’ Pain.” Neuroimage 321:316–24.Google Scholar
Avenanti, Alessio, Minio-Paluello, Ilaria, Sforza, Anna, and Aglioti, Salvatore. 2009. “Freezing or Escaping? Opposite Modulations of Empathic Reactivity to the Pain of Others.” Cortex 45 (9): 1072–77.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Aydede, Murat, ed. 2006. Pain: New Essays on Its Nature and the Methodology of Its Study. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Aydede, Murat. 2009. “Pain.” In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Zalta, Edward N.. Stanford, CA: Stanford University. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pain/.Google Scholar
Baron-Cohen, Simon, and Wheelwright, Sarah. 2004. “The Empathy Quotient: An Investigation of Adults with Asperger Syndrome or High Functioning Autism, and Normal Sex Differences.” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 342:163–75.Google Scholar
Batson, C. Daniel 2009. “These Things Called Empathy: Eight Related but Distinct Phenomena.” In The Social Neuroscience of Empathy, ed. Decety, J. and Ickles, W., 3–15. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bird, Geoffrey, Silani, Giorgia, Brindley, Rachel, White, Sarah, Frith, Uta, and Singer, Tania. 2010. “Empathic Brain Responses in Insula Are Modulated by Levels of Alexithymia but Not Autism.” Brain 133 (5): 1515–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blakemore, Sarah-Jayne, Bristow, Davina, Bird, Geoffrey, Frith, Chris, and Ward, James. 2005. “Somatosensory Activations during the Observation of Touch and a Case of Vision-Touch Synaesthesia.” Brain 128:1571–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Botvinick, Matthew, Jhab, Amishi, Bylsmaa, Lauren, Fabian, Sara, Solomon, Patricia, and Prkachin, Kenneth. 2005. “Viewing Facial Expressions of Pain Engages Cortical Areas Involved in the Direct Experience of Pain.” Neuroimage 251:312–19.Google Scholar
Bufalari, Ilaria, Aprile, Taryn, Avenanti, Alessio, Russo, Francesco Di, and Aglioti, Salvatore. 2007. “Empathy for Pain and Touch in the Human Somatosensory Cortex.” Cerebral Cortex 17 (11): 2553–61.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Calder, Andrew, Keane, Jill, Manes, Facundo, Antoun, Nagui, and Young, Andrew W.. 2000. “Impaired Recognition and Experience of Disgust following Brain Injury.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 3:1077–78.Google ScholarPubMed
Carruthers, Peter. 2006. “Why Pretend?” In The Architecture of the Imagination, ed. Nichols, S., 89–109. Oxford: Clarendon.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cheng, Yawei, Lin, Ching-Po, Liu, Ho-Ling, Hsu, Yuan-Yu, Lim, Kun-Eng, Hung, Daisy, and Decety, Jean. 2007. “Expertise Modulates the Perception of Pain in Others.” Current Biology 1719:1708–13.Google Scholar
Cheng, Yawei, Yang, Chia-Yen, Lin, Ching-Po, Lee, Po-Lei, and Decety, Jean. 2008. “The Perception of Pain in Others Suppresses Somatosensory Oscillations: A Magnetoencephalography Study.” Neuroimage 40 (4): 1833–40.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Currie, Gregory. 1995. “Visual Imagery as the Simulation of Vision.” Mind and Language 10 (1–2): 25–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Currie, Gregory, and Ravenscroft, Ian. 1997. “Mental Simulation and Motor Imagery.” Philosophy of Science 64 (1): 161–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Currie, Gregory, and Ravenscroft, Ian. 2002. Recreative Minds. Oxford: Clarendon.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dantziger, Nicolas, Faillenot, Isabelle, and Peyron, Roland. 2009. “Can We Share a Pain We Never Felt? Neural Correlates of Empathy in Patients with Congenital Insensitivity to Pain.” Neuron 61:203–12.Google Scholar
Dewall, Nathan, MacDonald, Geoff, Webster, Gregory, Masten, Carrie, Baumeister, Roy, Powell, Caitlin, Combs, David, Schurtz, David, Stillman, Tyler, Tice, Dianne, and Eisenberger, Naomi. 2010. “Tylenol Reduces Social Pain: Behavioral and Neural Evidence.” Psychological Science 21 (7): 931–37.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Eisenberger, Naomi, Lieberman, Matthew, and Williams, Kipling. 2003. “Does Rejection Hurt? An FMRI Study of Social Exclusion.” Science 302:290–92.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Freedberg, David, and Gallese, Vittorio. 2007. “Motion, Emotion and Empathy in Esthetic Experience.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 11:197–203.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Gallese, Vittorio. 2001. “The ‘Shared Manifold’ Hypothesis: From Mirror Neurons to Empathy.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 8 (5–7): 33–50.Google Scholar
Goldman, Alvin. 1992. “Empathy, Mind, and Morals.” Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association 66 (3): 17–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldman, Alvin. 2006a. “Imagination and Simulation in Audience Responses to Fiction.” In The Architecture of the Imagination, ed. S. Nichols. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Goldman, Alvin. 2006b. Simulating Minds, the Philosophy, Psychology and Neuroscience of Mindreading. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hardcastle, Victoria. 1999. The Myth of Pain. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoffman, Martin. 2000. Empathy and Moral Development: Implications for Caring and Justice. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
IASP (International Association for the Study of Pain). 1986. “Pain Terms: A List with Definitions and Notes on Pain.” Pain 3 (Suppl.): 216–21.Google Scholar
Jackson, Philip, Brunet, Eric, Meltzoff, Andrew, and Decety, Jean. 2006. “Empathy Examined through the Neural Mechanisms Involved in Imagining How I Feel versus How You Feel Pain.” Neuropsychologia 445:752–61.Google Scholar
Jackson, Philip, Meltzoff, Andrew, and Decety, Jean. 2005. “How Do We Perceive the Pain of Others? A Window into the Neural Processes Involved in Empathy.” Neuroimage 24:771–79.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jacob, Pierre. 2011. “The Direct-Perception Model of Empathy: A Critique.” Review of Philosophy and Psychology 2 (3): 519–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jacob, Pierre, and Vignemont, Frederique de. Forthcoming. “Vicarious Pain: Imagination, Mirroring or Perception?” In Perception and Its Modalities, ed. Biggs, Stephen, Strokes, Dustin, and Matthen, Mohan. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Jeannerod, Marc. 1994. “The Representing Brain: Neural Correlates of Motor Intention and Imagery.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 17:187–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keysers, Christian, Wicker, Bruno, Gazzola, Valeria, Anton, Jean-Luc, Fogassi, Leonardo, and Gallese, Vittorio. 2004. “A Touching Sight: SII/PV Activation during the Observation and Experience of Touch.” Neuron 42:335–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lamm, Claus, Batson, Daniel, and Decety, Jean. 2007. “The Neural Substrate of Human Empathy: Effects of Perspective-Taking and Cognitive Appraisal.” Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 191:42–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lamm, Claus, and Decety, Jean. 2008. “Is the Extrastriate Body Area (EBA) Sensitive to the Perception of Pain in Others?” Cerebral Cortex 18 (10): 2369–73.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lamm, Claus, Meltzoff, Andrew, and Decety, Jean. 2010. “How Do We Empathize with Someone Who Is Not like Us? A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study.” Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 22:362–76.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lamm, Claus, Nusbaum, Howard, Meltzoff, Andrew, and Decety, Jean. 2007. “What Are You Feeling? Using Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging to Assess the Modulation of Sensory and Affective Responses during Empathy for Pain.” PLoS One 212:e1292.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McGinn, Colin. 2004. Mindsight. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Nichols, Shaun. 2004. Review of Recreative Minds, by G. Currie and I. Ravenscroft. Mind 113:329–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ogino, Yuichi, Nemoto, Hidenori, Inui, Koji, Saito, Shigeru, Kakigi, Ryusuke, and Goto, Fumio. 2007. “Inner Experience of Pain: Imagination of Pain While Viewing Images Showing Painful Events Forms Subjective Pain Representation in Human Brain.” Cerebral Cortex 17:1139–46.Google ScholarPubMed
O'shaughnessy, Brian. 1980. The Will: Dual Aspect Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Rizzolatti, Giacomo, and Craighero, Laila. 2005. “Mirror Neuron: A Neurological Approach to Empathy.” In Neurobiology of Human Value, ed. Changeux, J.-P. et al. Berlin: Springer.Google Scholar
Singer, Tania, and Lamm, Claus. 2009. “The Social Neuroscience of Empathy.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1156:81–89.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Singer, Tania, Seymour, Ben, O’Doherty, John, Kaube, Holger, Dolan, Ray, and Frith, Chris. 2004. “Empathy for Pain Involves the Affective but Not Sensory Components of Pain.” Science 303:1157–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Singer, Tania, Seymour, Ben, O’Doherty, John, Stephan, Klaas, Dolan, Ray, and Frith, Chris. 2006. “Empathic Neural Responses Are Modulated by the Perceived Fairness of Others.” Nature 439:466–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sober, Eliott, and Wilson, David. 1998. Unto Others. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Stueber, Karsten. 2008. “Empathy.” In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Zalta, Edward N.. Stanford, CA: Stanford University. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/empathy.Google Scholar
Vignemont, Frederique de, and Singer, Tania. 2006. “The Empathic Brain: How, When and Why.” Trends in Cognitive Science 10 (10): 435–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wicker, Bruno, Keysers, Christian, Plailly, Jane, Royet, Jean-Pierre, Gallese, Vittorio, and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 2003. “Both of Us Disgusted in My Insula: The Common Neural Basis of Seeing and Feeling Disgust.” Neuron 40:655–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wispé, Lauren. 1986. “The Distinction between Sympathy and Empathy: To Call Forth a Concept, a Word Is Needed.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 50 (2): 314–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zahavi, Dan. 2008. “Simulation, Projection and Empathy.” Consciousness and Cognition 17:514–22.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed