Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-17T19:28:59.996Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Iconoclasm in Roman Britain?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2011

Ben Croxford
Ben Croxford
Affiliation:
University of Durham, bc256@cam.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Studies of the presence of Christianity in Roman Britain occasionally utilise a form of ‘negative evidence’: the destruction of pagan images. That this destruction is iconoclasm carried out by Christians is too readily assumed. Christian iconoclastic attacks did occur elsewhere in the Roman Empire, the question is whether we have been uncritical in automatically applying such evidence to the damaged Romano-British images. The apparent preference for certain parts of statuary, coupled with the occurrence of pieces in deposits that would, under any other circumstances, be regarded as ‘votive’ or ‘ritual’, suggests that these images may have been broken for reasons other than that of straightforward ‘destruction’. It is possible that some of these images may instead have been deliberately fragmented, with the resulting pieces retaining meaning and receiving special treatment and deposition. The aim of this paper is to question the validity of interpretations that suggest iconoclasm and to put forward an explanation based upon the theories of fragmentation as an alternative explanatory framework. By examining the high proportion of certain ‘body parts’ in the archaeological record, the contexts in which these occur, and the possible differing treatment of statuary of different materials and sizes, it is hoped to demonstrate that iconoclasm cannot account for all of the instances of image ‘destruction’ in Roman Britain.

Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 34 , November 2003 , pp. 81 - 95
Copyright
Copyright © Ben Croxford 2003. Exclusive Licence to Publish: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Bradley, R. 1990: The Passage of Arms, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Brewer, R.J. 1986: Corpus Signor?m Imperii Romani, Great Britain Vol. 1 fase. 5. Wales, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Brown, P. 1981: The Cult of the Saints, its Rise and Function in Latin Christianity, LondonGoogle Scholar
Chapman, J. 2000: Fragmentation in Archaeology, LondonGoogle Scholar
Clarke, S. 1997: ‘Abandonment, rubbish disposal and “special” deposits at Newstead’, in Meadows, K., Lemke, C. and Heron, J. (eds), TRAC 96, Oxford, 73–81Google Scholar
Coulston, J.C., and Phillips, E.J. 1988: Corpus Signorum Imperii Romani, Great Britain Vol.1 fase 6. Hadrian's Wall West of the North Tyne, and Carlisle, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Cunliffe, B., and Fulford, M.G. 1982: Corpus Signor?m Imperil Romani, Great Britain Vol.1 fase. 2. Bath and the Rest of Wessex, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Eaton, T. 2000: Plundering the Past: Roman Stonework in Medieval Britain, StroudGoogle Scholar
Fulford, M. 2001: ‘Links with the past: pervasive “ritual” behaviour in Roman Britain’, Britannia 32, 199–218CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Green, M. 1976: A Corpus of Religions Material from the Civilian Areas of Roman Britain, British Archaeological Reports 24, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Green, M. 1978: A Corpus of Small Cult-Objects from the Military Areas of Roman Britain, British Archaeological Reports 52, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henig, M. 1984: Religion in Roman Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
Henig, M. 1993a: ‘Votive objects: images and inscriptions’, in Woodward, A. and Leach, P., The Uley Shrines, English Heritage Archaeological Report 17, London, 89Google Scholar
Henig, M. 1993b: Corpus Signorum Imperil Romani, Great Britain Vol. 1 fase. 7. Roman Sculpture from the Cotswold Region: with Devon and Cornwall, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Huskinson, J. 1994: Corpus Signorum Imperil Romani, Great Britain Vol. 1 fase. 8. Roman Sculpture from Eastern England, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Keppie, L.J.F., and Arnold, B.J. 1984: Corpus Signorum Imperii Romani, Great Britain Vol. 1 fase. 4. Scotland, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Lindgren, C. 1980: Classical Art Forms and Celtic Mutations: Figurai Art in Roman Britain, Park Ridge, NJGoogle Scholar
Marsden, P. 1980: Roman London, LondonGoogle Scholar
Mawer, C.F. 1995: Evidence for Christianity in Roman Britain, British Archaeological Reports 242, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Merrifield, R. 1965: The Roman City of London, LondonGoogle Scholar
Merrifield, R. 1977: ‘Art and religion in Roman London: an inquest on the sculptures of Londinium’, in Munby, J. and Henig, M. (eds), Roman Life and Art in Britain ii, British Archaeological Reports 41, Oxford, 375–406Google Scholar
Merrifield, R. 1987: The Archaeology of Ritual and Magic, LondonGoogle Scholar
Merrifield, R. 1995: ‘Roman metalwork from the Walbrook — rubbish, ritual or redundancy?’, Trans. London and Middlesex Arch. Soc. 46, 27–44Google Scholar
Phillips, E.J. 1977: Corpus Signorum Imperii Romani, Great Britain Vol. 1 fase. 1. Corbridge, Hadrian's Wall East of the North Tyne, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Rawes, B. 1984: ‘The Romano-British site on the Portway, near Gloucester’, Trans. Bristol and Gloucestershire Arch. Soc. 102, 23–72Google Scholar
Ross, A. 1967: Pagan Celtic Britain: Studies in Iconography and Tradition, LondonGoogle Scholar
Shepherd, J. 1998: The Temple of Mithras, London, English Heritage Archaeological Report 12, LondonGoogle Scholar
Stewart, P. 1999: ‘The destruction of statues in late antiquity’, in Miles, R. (ed.), Constructing Identities in Late Antiquity, London, 159–89Google Scholar
Toynbee, J.M.C. 1986: The Roman Art Treasures from the Temple of Mithras, London and Middlesex Arch. Soc. Special paper 7, LondonGoogle Scholar
Watts, L., and Leach, P. 1996: Henley Wood, Temples and Cemetery, CBA Research Report 99, YorkGoogle Scholar
Willis, S. 1997: ‘Samian: beyond dating’, in Meadows, K., Lemke, C. and Heron, J. (eds), TRAC 96, Oxford, 38–54Google Scholar
Wilmott, T. 1991: Excavations in the Middle Walbrook Valley: City of London, 1927–1960, LondonGoogle Scholar
Woodward, A., and Leach, P. 1993: The Uley Shrines, English Heritage Archaeological Report 17, LondonGoogle Scholar