Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2009
  • Online publication date: July 2009

4 - The contribution of criminal justice

Summary

INTRODUCTION

In dealing with its apartheid past, South Africa took the position: We need not punish the perpetrators, but we must know the truth. The resultant combination of a victim-centred truth commission with the granting of individual amnesties on the basis of full disclosure has been praised as an innovative alternative to the prosecutorial approach to past injustices.

This chapter seeks to analyse the contribution of the criminal justice system to the amnesty process. It argues that this contribution has at least three dimensions. The first of these is a limiting one: the amnesty process mirrored certain aspects of the criminal justice system and thereby, in a sense, reaffirmed the apartheid legal order. This may explain some of the shortcomings of the process. The second dimension is complementary: ongoing investigations and prosecutions of apartheid crimes uncovered information and provided an accountability mechanism running parallel to that constituted by the amnesty process. The third dimension is interactive. During the lifetime of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), the criminal justice system played a crucial role in making perpetrators come forward and apply for amnesty. This dimension remains important after the conclusion of the TRC's work, for the prosecution of those who did not seek, or were found not to qualify for, amnesty is essential to the integrity and credibility of the amnesty scheme.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Werle, Gerhard, ‘ “Without Truth, No Reconciliation”. The South African Rechtsstaat and the Apartheid Past’ (1996) 29 Verfassung und Recht in Übersee. Law and Politics in Africa, Asia and Latin America58.
Boraine, Alex, A Country Unmasked. Inside South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000)
Nerlich, Volker, Apartheidkriminalität vor Gericht. Der Beitrag der südafrikanischen Strafjustiz zur Aufarbeitung von Apartheidunrecht (Berlin: Berlin Verlag Arno Spitz, 2000).
Dugard, John, Human Rights and the South African Legal Order (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1978).
Slye, Ronald C., ‘Apartheid as a Crime Against Humanity: A Submission to the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission’ (1999) 20 Michigan Journal of International Law267
Werle, Gerhard, Principles of International Criminal Law (The Hague: TCM Asser Press, 2005)
Mamdani, Mahmood, ‘A Diminished Truth’ in James, Wilmot and Vijver, Linda (eds.), After the TRC: Reflections on Truth and Reconciliation in South Africa (Athens: Ohio University Press, 2001) 58
Teitel, Ruti G., Transitional Justice (New York: Oxford University Press, 2000)
Radbruch, Gustav, ‘Gesetzliches Unrecht und übergesetzliches Recht’ (1946) 1 Süddeutsche Juristenzeitung105
Pedain, Antje, ‘Was Amnesty a Lottery? An Empirical Study of the Decisions of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's Committee on Amnesty’ (2004) 121 South African Law Journal785
Sarkin, Jeremy, Carrots and Sticks: The TRC and the South African Amnesty Process (Antwerp: Intersentia, 2004)
du Bois-Pedain, Antje, Transitional Amnesty in South Africa (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007).
Varney, Howard and Klaaren, Jonathan, ‘A Second Bite at the Amnesty Cherry? Constitutional and Policy Issues Around Legislation for a Second Amnesty’ in Villa-Vicencio, Charles and Doxtader, Erik (eds.), The Provocations of Amnesty: Memory, Justice and Impunity (Claremont: David Philip, 2003) 265
Bekker, Peet M.et al., 3rd edn, Criminal Procedure Handbook (Kenwyn: Juta, 1998) at 50
Richings, F.G., ‘The Prosecutor's Discretion: A Plea for Circumspection’ (1977) 1 South African Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology143
Goldstone, Richard, For Humanity (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2000)
Pauw, Jacques, Into the Heart of Darkness. Confessions of Apartheid's Assassins (Johannesburg: Jonathan Ball, 1997)
Kock, Eugene and Gordin, Jeremy, A Long Night's Damage: Working for the Apartheid State (Saxonwold: Contra Press, 1998)
Coleman, Max (ed.), A Crime Against Humanity: Analysing the Repression of the Apartheid State (Cape Town: David Philip, 1998)
Varney, Howard and Sarkin, Jeremy, ‘Failing to Pierce the Hit Squad Veil: An Analysis of the Malan Trial’ (1997) 10 South African Journal of Criminal Justice141
Burger, Marléne and Gould, Chandé, Secrets and Lies. Wouter Basson and South Africa's Chemical and Biological Warfare Programme (Cape Town: Zebra Press, 2003).
Kutz, Florian, Amnestie für politische Straftäter in Südafrika. Von der Sharpeville-Amnestie bis zu den Verfahren der Wahrheits- und Versöhnungskommission (Berlin: Berlin Verlag Arno Spitz, 2001)
Rousseau, Nicky, ‘Prosecutions’, in Doxtader, Erik (ed.), Provoking Questions: An Assessment of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's Recommendations and their Implementation (Cape Town: Institute for Justice and Reconciliation, 2005)