Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Editors' preface
- Contributors
- The historical background: the past 25 years since the Mental Health Act of 1959
- The social and medical consequences of recent legal reforms of mental health law in the USA: the criminalization of mental disorder
- The recent Mental Health Act in the United Kingdom: issues and perspectives
- Medical and social consequences of the Italian Psychiatric Care Act of 1978
- Lessons for the future drawn from United States legislation and experience
- Recent developments in relation to mental health and the law in the Federal Republic of Germany
- Psychopathy and dangerousness
- Dangerousness in social perspective
- Psychiatric explanations as excuses
- Detention of patients: administrative problems facing Mental Health Review Tribunals
- Developments in forensic psychiatry services in the National Health Service
- The role of psychiatry in prisons and ‘the right to punishment’
- Human rights in mental health
- Changes in mental health legislation as indicators of changing values and policies
- The Danish experience: one model of psychiatric testimony to courts of law
- A postscript on the discussions at the Cambridge Conference on Society, Psychiatry and the Law
Lessons for the future drawn from United States legislation and experience
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 August 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Editors' preface
- Contributors
- The historical background: the past 25 years since the Mental Health Act of 1959
- The social and medical consequences of recent legal reforms of mental health law in the USA: the criminalization of mental disorder
- The recent Mental Health Act in the United Kingdom: issues and perspectives
- Medical and social consequences of the Italian Psychiatric Care Act of 1978
- Lessons for the future drawn from United States legislation and experience
- Recent developments in relation to mental health and the law in the Federal Republic of Germany
- Psychopathy and dangerousness
- Dangerousness in social perspective
- Psychiatric explanations as excuses
- Detention of patients: administrative problems facing Mental Health Review Tribunals
- Developments in forensic psychiatry services in the National Health Service
- The role of psychiatry in prisons and ‘the right to punishment’
- Human rights in mental health
- Changes in mental health legislation as indicators of changing values and policies
- The Danish experience: one model of psychiatric testimony to courts of law
- A postscript on the discussions at the Cambridge Conference on Society, Psychiatry and the Law
Summary
Forensic psychiatry developed largely in relation to lawyers’ efforts to save their clients from a death sentence and involved proving ‘facts’ about insanity, intent, competence, and the like. It spread to include other facts, such as paternity, the cause of death, and a broad range of data relevant to assessing the presence or extent of malpractice. As all clinicians know, however, what is defined as malpractice has mushroomed in recent years and the umbrella of forensic psychiatry now embraces a considerably larger area than it did even a decade ago.
The essentials of classic forensic psychiatry were the assessment and treatment of those who had been statutorily labeled as dangerous, the protection of the public, and the protection of the rights of patients (including their right to treatment). In a technological society such as ours, however, the roles of medical professionals have become increasingly intertwined with those of legal professionals, for scientific advances in medicine relate more and more to the quality of life and the fundamental rights of individuals, and they raise questions about the effects of interventions in the lives of today's patients on tomorrow's society (Harrison, 1983). At the present time, the phrase ‘health law’ is used to emphasize the expanded interface between medicine and the law and the substantial body of law that now governs the relations between health care providers, professionals, third-party payers, and patients (Stromberg, 1983).
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Psychiatry, Human Rights and the Law , pp. 43 - 57Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1985