Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Foreword, by Eric E. Bergsten
- Contributors
- PART ONE INTRODUCTION
- PART TWO CISG–UNIDROIT Principles comparative editorials
- Art. 6 CISG–UP, by Bojidara Borisova [Bulgaria]
- Art. 7 CISG–UP, by Ulrich Magnus [Germany]
- Art. 8 CISG–UP, by Joseph M. Perillo [U.S.A.]
- Art. 9 CISG–UP, by Jorge Oviedo Alban [Colombia]
- Art. 10 CISG–UP, by Allison E. Butler [U.S.A.]
- Art. 11 CISG–UP, by Chantal Niggemann [Germany]
- Art. 13 CISG–UP, by Andrea Charters [U.S.A.]
- Art. 14 CISG–UP, by Jorge Oviedo Alban [Colombia]
- Art. 16 CISG–UP, by Andrea Vincze [Hungary]
- Art. 17 CISG–UP, by Stephen Smith [U.S.A.]
- Art. 18 CISG–UP, by Jorge Oviedo Alban [Colombia]
- Art. 20 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 21 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 22 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 24 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 25 CISG–UP, by Robert Koch [Germany]
- Arts. 26/39 CISG–UP–PECL, by Camilla Baasch Andersen [Denmark]
- Art. 27 CISG–UP–PECL, by Chengwei Liu [China]
- Arts. 28, 46, 62 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 29 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 35 CISG–UP–PECL, by René Franz Henschel [Denmark]
- Art. 37 CISG–UP, by Bertram Keller [Germany]
- Arts. 47/49 CISG–UP, by Robert Koch [Germany]
- Art. 48 CISG–UP, by Chris Kee [Australia]
- Art. 55 CISG–UP, by Jumpita Ruangvichatron [Thailand]
- Arts. 63/64 CISG–UP, by Robert Koch [Germany]
- Arts. 71/72 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 74 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 75 CISG–UP, by Bojidara Borisova [Bulgaria]
- Art. 76 CISG–UP, by Bruno Zeller [Australia]
- Art. 77 CISG–UP, by Elisabeth Opie [Australia]
- Art. 78 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 79 CISG–UP, by Alejandro M. Garro [Argentina]
- Art. 80 CISG–UP, by Friederike Schäfer [Germany]
- Arts. 81/82 CISG–UP, by Florian Mohs [Switzerland]
- PART THREE CISG–PECL COMPARATIVE EDITORIALS
- Index
Art. 16 CISG–UP, by Andrea Vincze [Hungary]
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 October 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Foreword, by Eric E. Bergsten
- Contributors
- PART ONE INTRODUCTION
- PART TWO CISG–UNIDROIT Principles comparative editorials
- Art. 6 CISG–UP, by Bojidara Borisova [Bulgaria]
- Art. 7 CISG–UP, by Ulrich Magnus [Germany]
- Art. 8 CISG–UP, by Joseph M. Perillo [U.S.A.]
- Art. 9 CISG–UP, by Jorge Oviedo Alban [Colombia]
- Art. 10 CISG–UP, by Allison E. Butler [U.S.A.]
- Art. 11 CISG–UP, by Chantal Niggemann [Germany]
- Art. 13 CISG–UP, by Andrea Charters [U.S.A.]
- Art. 14 CISG–UP, by Jorge Oviedo Alban [Colombia]
- Art. 16 CISG–UP, by Andrea Vincze [Hungary]
- Art. 17 CISG–UP, by Stephen Smith [U.S.A.]
- Art. 18 CISG–UP, by Jorge Oviedo Alban [Colombia]
- Art. 20 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 21 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 22 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 24 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 25 CISG–UP, by Robert Koch [Germany]
- Arts. 26/39 CISG–UP–PECL, by Camilla Baasch Andersen [Denmark]
- Art. 27 CISG–UP–PECL, by Chengwei Liu [China]
- Arts. 28, 46, 62 CISG–UP, by John Felemegas [Australia]
- Art. 29 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 35 CISG–UP–PECL, by René Franz Henschel [Denmark]
- Art. 37 CISG–UP, by Bertram Keller [Germany]
- Arts. 47/49 CISG–UP, by Robert Koch [Germany]
- Art. 48 CISG–UP, by Chris Kee [Australia]
- Art. 55 CISG–UP, by Jumpita Ruangvichatron [Thailand]
- Arts. 63/64 CISG–UP, by Robert Koch [Germany]
- Arts. 71/72 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 74 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 75 CISG–UP, by Bojidara Borisova [Bulgaria]
- Art. 76 CISG–UP, by Bruno Zeller [Australia]
- Art. 77 CISG–UP, by Elisabeth Opie [Australia]
- Art. 78 CISG–UP, by Sieg Eiselen [South Africa]
- Art. 79 CISG–UP, by Alejandro M. Garro [Argentina]
- Art. 80 CISG–UP, by Friederike Schäfer [Germany]
- Arts. 81/82 CISG–UP, by Florian Mohs [Switzerland]
- PART THREE CISG–PECL COMPARATIVE EDITORIALS
- Index
Summary
INTRODUCTION TO THE ISSUE OF IRREVOCABILITY OF OFFERS
a. Article 16 CISG dealing with the revocation of an offer is a rather controversial provision of the Convention. Most of the difficulties derive from the different interpretative approaches of civil law and common law regarding the revocability of offers. Although the drafters of the CISG provision were determined to create a compromise solution reflecting the approaches of the two systems, the practical application of Article 16 CISG still reflects several ambiguities of interpretation.
b. Before examining whether the Official Comments to Article 2.4 of the UNIDROIT Principles may be used to help interpret Article 16 CISG, this chapter examines different approaches of civil and common law in interpreting revocation of the offer.
c. In civil law systems a contract is concluded only if the acceptance reaches the offeror. Before that, the offeror impliedly gives the offeree a reasonable time to consider the offer, during which time the offer is irrevocable unless otherwise indicated by the offeror. If the offer states a time limit for acceptance, the offer is usually irrevocable, and if it does not, the offer is irrevocable for a reasonable period.
d. In common law systems, however, the contract is concluded as soon as the offeree dispatches the acceptance. Prior to that point in time, the offer is revocable at any time, even if it must be accepted within a time period. This may sometimes also be the case even if the offeror expressly states that the offer is irrevocable.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2007