Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-5g6vh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-28T04:47:59.669Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Arghun Aqa: Mongol Bureaucrat

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2022

George Lane
George Lane*
Affiliation:
The School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The question of who ran the Mongol Empire has long challenged historians, and various theories have emerged and retreated in answer to this problem. As far as the question of who ran the Persian part of the empire the answer has been made more elusive by the nature of the sources. Though excellent primary source material for this period abounds, for the most part it is written by the bureaucrats of the Il-Khanate themselves, most of whom were Persian. Very little Mongol material survives. It is this lack of Mongolian material that has prompted historians to speculate that perhaps none ever existed and thus that “the Mongols were happy to leave the tedious minutiae of government to those best qualified to cope with them.” In the case of Persia “those best qualified to cope” meant the traditional bureaucratic classes, and such individual luminaries as ᶜAta Malik Juvaini and Rashid al-Din and families such as the Qazvinis and Simnanis spring to mind.

Type
Articles
Information
Iranian Studies , Volume 32 , Issue 4 , Fall 1999 , pp. 459 - 482
Copyright
Copyright © Association For Iranian Studies, Inc 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. See Morgan, David, “Mongol or Persian: The Government of Il-Khanid Iran,” Harvard Middle-Eastern and Islamic Review 3 (1996): 1–2Google Scholar, 62-76; see also Aubin, Jean, “Emirs, Mongols et Viziers Persans dans les Remous de l'Acculturation”, Studia Iranica. 15 (1995)Google Scholar.

2. Morgan, “Mongol or Persian”, 64.

3. Onon, Urgunge, The History and Life of Chinggis Khan (Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1990)Google Scholar.

4. Spuler, Bertold, Die Mongolen in Iran (Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1985), 238–40.Google Scholar

5. ᶜAta-Malik Juvaini, Genghis Khan: The History of the World-Conqueror trans. Boyle, J. A. (Manchester, 1997)Google Scholar (henceforth Juvaini/Boyle), 505.

6. Hamadani, Rashid al-Din Fazl Allah, Jāmiᶜ al-tavārīkh, ed. Rawshan, Muhammad and Musavi, Mustafa, eds. (Tehran, 1373/1994)Google Scholar (henceforth Rashid al-Din), 103, 607.

7. On Korguz's career see Juvaini/Boyle, 489-505 and ᶜAta Malik Juvaini, Tārīkhi jahān-gushā, ed. Qazvini, M., 2 vols. (London, 1916) (henceforth Juvaini/Qazvini), 2, 225–242Google Scholar.

8. For a discussion of the differences in meaning of basqaq, shahna, etc. see Ostrowski, Donald, “The tamma and the dual-administrative structure of the Mongol Empire,” Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 61/2 (1998): 262–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9. See Jean Aubin, “Emirs Mongols”, 14-15 and Sayf ibn Muhammad ibn Ya'qub al-Harawi,) Tārīkh-nāmah-i Harāt, ed. Zubayr al-Ṣiddiqi, Muhammd (Calcutta, 1944), 128Google Scholar.

10. Juvaini/Boyle, 502-3; Rashid al-Din, 682, claims that Chaghatai's widow complained to Ogedei, who he states was still alive, who then ordered Korkuz's execution: “The Qa'an ordered that they should arrest him and fill his mouth with dirt until he should die.”

11. Juvaini/Boyle, 507.

12. See Allsen, T. T., Mongol Imperialism: The Policies of the Great Qan Möngke in China, Russia, and the Islamic Lands (Berkeley, 1987), 176–77Google Scholar. This conclusion is based on silver coins struck c1244-5 in Transcaucasia with the quoted Turkic inscription, without reference to a qa'an written in Arabic script and stamped on the reverse side from the Muslim formula.

13. Ibid., 545, 280.

14. Juvaini/Boyle, 526.

15. See Jackson, Peter, “The Dissolution of the Mongol Empire,” Central Asiatic Journal 32 (1978): 216Google Scholar

16. Aubin, “Emirs Mongol”, 15.

17. Juvaini/Boyle, 529, 530.

18. Ibid., 508. Boyle in Cambridge History of Iran, vol. 4, 337 assumes that Juvaini exaggerates Sharaf al-Din's evil nature.

19. paiza, p'ai-tse = tablet of authority in wood, silver or gold sometimes bearing a tiger or gerfalcon depending on rank. See Morgan, David, The Mongols (Oxford, 1986), 105–7Google Scholar.

20. Yarligh = royal order or licence.

21. Juvaini/Boyle, 509.

22. Ibid., 539.

23. See “In the Service of the Khan,” ed. de Rachewiltz, Igor et al. (Wiesbaden, 1993), 122–7Google Scholar. Mahmud Yalavach and his descendants were among the most prominent of the non-Mongol functionaries governing the sedentary sections of the Mongol Empire. He was a Turkish-speaking Khwarazmian and was a merchant employed by Chingiz Khan as an intermediate with the Khwarazmshah. He is held to have been the architect of the qobchur tax system which eventually became the model for Arghun Aqa's regime in the west.

24. Juvaini/Boyle, 544.

25. Ibid., 511.

26. Eljigitei had been dispatched by Guyuk to subdue the west. See Jackson, Dissolution, 200, 215.

27. Juvaini/Boyle 512.

28. Cited in Allsen, Mongol Imperialism, 107. Yuan Shih, the official history of the Yuan dynasty, was compiled in 1369 on the orders of newly founded Ming dynasty. See Allsen, 11-12.

29. Juvaini/Boyle, 9-11.

30. Ibid., 152.

31. Reid, James J., “The Je'un-i Qurban Oirat Clan in the Fourteenth Century,” Journal of Asian History (1984): 191Google Scholar.

32. Rashid al-Din, 980; Juvaini/Boyle 522, 614-5.

33. Juvaini/Boyle, 516.

34. Ibid., 517.

35. See Morgan, David, “Ḳūbčūr”, Encyclopedia of Islam 5, 299–300Google Scholar and Lambton, Ann, Continuity and Change in Medieval Persia (London: I. B. Tauris, 1988), 199–202Google Scholar.

36. Juvaini/Boyle, 517.

37. Ibid., 598-602; Rashid al-Din, 842-4; Boyle, J. A., trans., The Successors of Genghis Khan (New York & London, 1971), 218–20Google Scholar.

38. Juvaini/Boyle, 34; See also Vladimir Minorsky, “Naṣir al-Din Tusi on Finance” in idem, Iranica: Twenty Articles (Tehran: University of Tehran, 1964), 72–3Google Scholar, where Chingiz Khan's dislike for certain kinds of taxes is cited. (The text of Tusi's treatise was published by Radawi, M., ed., Majmūᶜah-yi rasā˒il-i Khwājah Naṣīr al-Dīn Ṭūṣī [Tehran: University of Tehran], 1957Google Scholar).

39. Cited in Allsen, 104, n. 91.

40. Juvaini/Boyle, 108, n. 31.

41. Ibid., 515-16, 605.

42. Ibid., 514, 521.

43. Kirakos, Kirakos Ganjakets'i's History of Armenia, trans. Bedrosian, Robert (New York, 1986) (henceforth Kirakos), 299Google Scholar.

44. See Sayfi, 175.

45. Grigor of Akanc, History of the Nations of Archers, trans. Blake, Robert P. and Frye, Richard N. (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1954) (henceforth Grigor), 325Google Scholar.

46. Kirakos, 299.

47. Allsen, Mongol Imperialism, 112-3.

48. For an explanation of the apparent discrepancies in dating the censuses between the various sources see Allsen, 132-3.

49. Minorsky, “Naṣir al-Din Tusi on Finance” 70, 77-8.

50. Juvaini/Boyle, 519.

51. Ibid.

52. Ibid., 521.

53. Allsen, Mongol Imperialism, 123.

54. Juvaini/Boyle, 33-4.

55. Grigor, 75.

56. Ibid, 57.

57. Kolbas, Judith, Mongol Money: The role of Tabriz from Chingiz Khan to Uljaytu (PhD diss., New York University, 1992), 194–95Google Scholar.

58. Kirakos, 205.

59. According to Juvaini, Buqa was appointed basqāq along with Juvaini's father as ṣāḥib-dīwān by Arghun Aqa over the lands of Azerbaijan, Georgia, Rum etc. Juvaini/Boyle, 508, Qazvini, ii, 245.

60. Kirakos, 260-1.

61. Frik, V., V, Collection of Verses, (Yerevan, 1937), 165Google Scholar, cited in Galstyan, A.G., “The Conquest of Armenia by the Mongol Armies,” The Armenian Review, 23/4 (1975): 108Google Scholar; cf. Hairapetian, Srbouhi, A History of Armenian Literature (New York: Caravan Books, 1995) 373–383Google Scholar.

62. Kirakos, 267.

63. See the Syrian historian and cleric Hebraeus, Bar, The Chronography of Gregory Abû'l-Faraj, ed. and trans., Budge, E.A.W. (London, 1932)Google Scholar; also Lane, George, “An account of Bar Hebraeus Abu al-Faraj and his relations with the Mongols of Persia,” Hugoye: Journal of Syriac Studies, 2/2Google Scholar available on the World Wide Web at ≪http://syrcom.cua.edu/Hugoye/Vol2No2HV2N2Glane.html≫.

64. See Allen, History of the Georgian People (London, 1932), 104, 115Google Scholar. Awag was of the family of Sargis Mkhargrdzeli, an aznauri (honoured and decorated mercenary) of Kurdish origin, who was raised by the Georgian King Giorgi. The three princes of this house had been the first to make accommodation with the Mongols to safeguard their vast landholdings which stretched from Ani to Somkheti. The family of Mkhargrdzelis were Armenian by religion; Allen History, 115.

65. Kirakos, 268.

66. Ibid.

67. The same destruction as had occurred in 1243.

68. The Historical Compilation of Vardan Arewelc'i, (henceforth Vardan) trans. Thomson, Robert, (Washington, D.C., 1989)Google Scholar, Dumbarton Oaks Papers no. 43.

69. Grigor, 321.

70. Ibid.

71. Juvaini/Boyle, 507-8.

72. See Boyle's note concerning this date, ibid., 510, n. 10.

73. Ibid., 510.

74. Sayfi, 172

75. Ibid., 170. It is not clear if this first 50,000 dinars is the same gift as the one given during the visit to Tus or another.

76. Ibid., 172; Isfazari, Mu'in al-Din Muhammad Zamchi, Rawżat al-jannāt fī awṣāf madīnat-i Harāt (Tehran, 1338/1959), vol. 1, 411Google Scholar; Shihab al-Din ᶜAbd Allah Sharaf Shirazi “Wassaf,” Tajziyat al-amṣār wa tazjiyat al-aᶜṣār (Tārīkh-i Waṣṣāf), ed. Isfahani, M.M. (henceforth Wassaf) (Tehran, 1338/1959), 81Google Scholar; for an abridged version see ᶜA. M., Ayati ed., Taḥrīr-i tārīkh-i Waṣṣāf (Tehran, 1346/1967) (henceforth Ayati), 48Google Scholar.

77. Allsen, 71.

78. Kirakos, 300.

79. Ibid, 299-300, g 362-3

80. Histoire de la Georgie, 550.

81. Ibid; see also Bedrosian, Robert, trans., The Turco-Mongol Invasion and the Lords of Armenia in the 13th-14th Centuries (New York, 1985), 123Google Scholar.

82. See Kolbas, Judith, Mongol Money, 266Google Scholar; Jackson, “Dissolution”, 212, 220Google Scholar; al-Din Juzjani, Minhaj, Tabaqat-i Nasirl, ed. Habibi, cAbd al-Hayy (Tehran, 1363/1984), 176Google Scholar; Ṭabaqāt-i Nāṣirī, ed. and trans., Raverty, H.G. (London, 1881), 1172Google Scholar.

83. Histoire de la Georgie, 551-2 (Bedrosian trans., 124, n. 196).

84. Kirakos, 300.

85. Bedrosian, The Turco-Mongol Invasion, 285-6, citing Step'annos Orbelean,; Orbelean, Step'annos, Histoire de la Siounie, trans. Brosset, M. (St. Petersbourg, 1864), 230–31Google Scholar.

86. Bedrosian, The Turco-Mongol Invasion, 286; Histoire de la Georgie, 552.

87. Kirakos, 296.

88. Ibid.

89. Step'annos Orbelean, Histoire de la Sioune, 232.

90. Ibid., 230.

91. Ibid., 233.

92. Ibid., 236.

93. Juvaini/Boyle, 523.

94. Ibid., 524.

95. Allen, History of the Georgian People, 115.

96. Kirakos 225-6.

97. See Bedrosian, The Turco-Mongol Invasions, 197.

98. Ibid. 196; Histoire de la Georgie, 529-30.

99. Allen, 116-7. On Hajji Aziz see Histoire de la Georgie, 561-65.

100. Kirakos, 325-30.

101. Vardan, 218.

102. Ibid.

103. Ibid.

104. Kirakos, 327.

105. Histoire de la Georgie, 563.

106. Rashid al-Din, 1061.

107. William of Rubruck's description of Arghun Aqa in idem, The Mission of Friar William of Rubruck,. eds., Jackson, Peter and Morgan, David (London, 1990), 263Google Scholar.

108. anon., Tārīkh-i Shāhī-i Qarā Khiṭā˒ī, ed. Ibrahim Bastani Parizi, M. (Tehran, 2535/1976-77), 156Google Scholar.

109. Ibid., 156.

110. Rashid al-Din, 74.

111. Jackson, Peter, “Arḡūn Āqā,” Encyclopaedia Iranica, 2, 402 citing KirakosGoogle Scholar; see also Rashid al-Din, 879-80, 881-885 on the relationship between Hulegu, Algu, and Ariq Boke.

112. For a new interpretation of the role of Qaidu see Biran, Michal, Qaidu and the Rise of the Independent Mongol State (London: Curzon, 1997)Google Scholar.

113. Rashid al-Din, 1071-72.

114. Sayfi, 310; Rashid al-Din, 1072; al-Din Khwandamir, Ghiyas, Ḥabīb al-siyar fī akhbār afrād al-bashar, ed. Dabir Siyaqi, M. (Tehran, 1353/1974), vol. 3, 85Google Scholar; idem, Habibu's-Siyar trans., Thackston, W. M., Tome 3, (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University, 1994), 49Google Scholar; Wassaf, 71; Ayati, 41.

115. Rashid al-Din, 1078.

116. Ibid., 1079, 1101.

117. Ibid., 1083. Khwandamir, 3, 85-86.

118. Rashid al-Din, 1084.

119. Ibid., 1086-87; Wassaf, 74; Ayati, 42-43.

120. Wassaf, 75.

121. Rashid al-Din, 1088.

122. Cited in Sayfi, 330. Baraq is reported as having returned to Bukhara, where he converted to Islam and took the name Sultan Ghiyath al-Din before suffering a paralysing stroke. In the Year of the Goat, 1270, he went to Qaidu Khan where he was given a poisoned drink that killed him. See Khwandamir, 3: 83, 87; Thackston translation, 47, 49; Ayati, 44; Wassaf, 76.

123. Histoire de la Georgie, 591; Peter Jackson “Arghun Aqa” citing A.G. Galstyn

124. See Vladimir Minorsky, Iranica, Tehran, 1964, 299-305.

125. Ibid., 299, 303.

126. Ibid., 301, 304.

127. Ibid., 301, 305.

128. See Aubin, Jean, “Emirs, Mongol,” 59Google Scholar.

129. Wassaf, 313; Ayati, 190.