No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Killing in ‘the good old Irish fashion’? Irish revolutionary violence in context
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 August 2020
Abstract
In comparison to many parts of post-war Europe, Ireland's wars between 1919 and 1923 were not as lethal as they might have been. This article addresses some of the possible reasons why, reasons that were quite specific to the immediate Anglo-Irish context but reasons that may also have been due to broader transnational understandings of what it was to be a soldier, what it was to fight at that time. But while comparative fatality rates may leave Ireland somewhat overshadowed, this article considers what Ireland's wars still share with other conflicts and looks at some of the dimensions of Irish violence that were, irrespective of numbers killed, still fundamentally the same as violence experienced in other periods and places. Tackling some of the challenges of contemporary comparisons, the article suggests other possible comparisons ranging far beyond the inter-war period that may prove more fruitful, and asks whether the nature of violence shapes our perceptions of a conflict far more than fatality rates do.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2020
References
1 Christie, Agatha, A murder is announced (London, 1950), p. 70Google Scholar.
2 Ambler, Eric, Uncommon danger (London, 1937)Google Scholar.
3 Chandler, Raymond, The big sleep (3rd ed., London, 2000), p. 8Google Scholar.
4 O'Hegarty, P. S., The victory of Sinn Féin (2nd ed., Dublin, 1998), p. 122Google Scholar; Flanagan, Frances, Remembering the revolution: dissent, culture and nationalism in the Irish Free State (Oxford, 2015), p. 21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Ireland Today, iii, no. 2 (Feb. 1938), p. 186.
6 Niall Whelehan, ‘Playing with scales: transnational history and modern Ireland’ in idem (ed.), Transnational perspectives on modern Irish history (Abingdon, 2015), p. 15.
7 Fearghal McGarry, ‘Revolution, 1916–1923’ in Thomas Bartlett (ed.), The Cambridge history of Ireland, iv: 1880 to the present (Cambridge, 2018), p. 258; Charles Townshend, The republic: the fight for Irish independence (London, 2013), p. 452.
8 Pertti Haapala and Marko Tikka, ‘Revolution, civil war, and terror in Finland in 1918’ in Robert Gerwarth and John Horne (eds), War in peace: paramilitary violence in Europe after the Great War (Oxford, 2012), p. 72; Robert Gerwarth, The vanquished: why the First World War failed to end, 1917–1923 (London, 2016), pp 114, 139; ‘The correlates of war project’ (http://correlatesofwar.org/data-sets/downloadable-files/the-new-cow-war-data-1816-2007-v4-0/cow-wars) (11 Aug. 2019); Eunan O'Halpin, ‘Counting terror: Bloody Sunday and the dead of the Irish Revolution’ in David Fitzpatrick (ed.), Terror in Ireland, 1916–1923 (Dublin, 2012), p. 152; McGarry, ‘Revolution’, p. 291.
9 David Fitzpatrick, ‘The geography of the war of independence’ in John Crowley, Donal Ó Drisceoil, Mike Murphy and John Borgonovo (eds), Atlas of the Irish Revolution (Cork, 2017), p. 541; Ian d'Alton, ‘“A vestigial population”? Perspectives on southern Irish Protestants in the twentieth century’ in Éire-Ireland, xliv, nos 3 & 4 (Fall/Winter 2009), p. 26; Bill Kissane, The politics of the Irish Civil War (Oxford, 2005); T. K. Wilson, Frontiers of violence: conflict and identity in Ulster and Upper Silesia, 1918–1922 (Oxford, 2010).
10 Stathis N. Kalyvas, ‘The paradox of terrorism in civil war’ in Journal of Ethics, viii, no. 1 (Mar. 2004), p. 101.
11 O'Hegarty, The victory of Sinn Féin, p. 91.
12 Carolyn Conley, Melancholy accidents: the meaning of violence in post-Famine Ireland (Oxford, 1999), p. 142; Ian O'Donnell, ‘Lethal violence in Ireland, 1841–2003: famine, celibacy and parental pacification’ in British Journal of Criminology, xlv, no. 5 (Sept. 2005), pp 671–95.
13 Fitzpatrick, ‘The geography of the War of Independence’, pp 536, 540.
14 Ariane Chebel d'Apppollonia, ‘The contemporary repertoire of contentious identity politics and religious conflicts in France’ in French History, xxxiii, no. 2 (June 2019), pp 278–95.
15 Charles Tilly and Sidney Tarrow, Contentious politics (Oxford, 2007).
16 Nevil Macready, Annals of an active life (2 vols, London, 1924), ii, 509.
17 Penny Roberts, ‘French historians and collective violence’ in History and Theory, lvi, no. 4 (Dec. 2017), pp 60–75.
18 Natalie Zemon Davis, ‘The rites of violence: religious riot in sixteenth-century France’ in Past & Present, no. 59 (May 1973), p. 82; Eunan O'Halpin, ‘Problematic killing during the War of Independence and its aftermath: civilian spies and informers’ in James Kelly and Mary Ann Lyons (eds), Death and dying in Ireland, Britain and Europe: historical perspectives (Sallins, 2013), p. 339.
19 Natalie Zemon Davis, Fiction in the archives (Cambridge, 1988), p. 28.
20 Alain Corbin, The village of cannibals (2nd ed., Cambridge, MA, 1992), p. 45; Peter Hart, The I.R.A. and its enemies: violence and community in Cork, 1916–1923 (Oxford, 1998), pp 293–315.
21 Court of inquiry in lieu of inquest, Michael O'Keeffe, 2 May 1921 (T.N.A., WO 35/157b).
22 Zemon Davis, ‘The rites of violence’, p. 85; Hart, The I.R.A. and its enemies, p. 309.
23 Court of inquiry in lieu of inquest, William Charters, 28 Jan. 1921 (T.N.A., WO 35/147a).
24 Irish Times, 16 June 1921.
25 Kalyvas, ‘The paradox of terrorism’, pp 99–101.
26 Zemon Davis, ‘The rites of violence’, p. 53; D. M. G. Sutherland, ‘Justice and murder: massacres in the provinces, Versailles, Meaux and Reims in 1792’ in Past & Present, no. 222 (Feb. 2014), pp 131–2, 153.
27 Court of inquiry in lieu of inquest, Frank Sullivan, 4 July 1921 (T.N.A., WO 35/159b).
28 Corbin, The village of cannibals, p. 1; Richard Cobb, Death in Paris (Oxford, 1978), p. 90; Stathis N. Kalyvas, The logic of violence in civil war (Cambridge, 2006); idem, ‘The ontology of “political violence”: action and identity in civil wars’ in Perspectives on Politics, i, no. 3 (Sept. 2003), pp 478–80.
29 Zemon Davis, ‘The rites of violence’, p. 90; Kalyvas, ‘The ontology of “political violence”’, pp 476–81; idem, The logic of violence, p. 1.
30 Roger Howell, cited in Kalyvas, ‘The ontology of “political violence”’, p. 478.
31 Siniša Malešević, ‘Is nationalism intrinsically violent?’ in Nationalism and Ethnic Politics, xix, no. 1 (2013), p. 32.
32 Kalyvas, ‘The ontology of “political violence”’, p. 480.
33 Jonathan Spencer, cited in Kalyvas, ‘The ontology of “political violence”’, p. 479.
34 Ibid., p. 480.
35 Ibid., p. 482.
36 J. R. W. Goulden statement (M.A.I., B.M.H., W.S. 1340).
37 J. S. Wilkinson, unpublished memoir (Imperial War Museum (I.W.M.), 88/56/1); Kalyvas, ‘The paradox of terrorism’, p. 109.
38 Kalyvas, ‘The paradox of terrorism’, p. 109; Joice M. Nankiville and Sydney Loch, Ireland in travail (London, 1922), p. 127; Douglas Wimberley, unpublished memoir (I.W.M., PP/MCR/182); E. M. Ransford, unpublished memoir (I.W.M., 80/29/1).
39 Pension application, James Norton, 5 Aug. 1937 (M.A.I., M.S.P.C., MSP34REF4136).
40 Statement of James Norton, 15 Mar. 1939 (M.A.I., M.S.P.C., MSP34REF4136).
41 Ibid.
42 Report by J. Fitzgerald, 7 Mar. 1935 (M.A.I., M.S.P.C., MSP34REF4136); John B. Fitzgerald, solicitor, to the Department of Defence, confirming Norton's date of death as 15 Dec. 1974, 26 May 1975 (ibid.).
43 Raphaëlle Branche and Jim House, ‘Silences on state violence during the Algerian war of independence: France and Algeria, 1962–2007’ in Efrat Ben-Ze'ev, Ruth Ginio and Jay Winter (eds), Shadows of war: a social history of silence in the twentieth century (Cambridge, 2010), p. 124; Charles Dalton, Ernie O'Malley notebooks (U.C.D.A., P17b/122(22)); Harry Colley, Ernie O'Malley notebooks (U.C.D.A., P17b/97(5)).
44 Efrat Ben-Ze'ev, ‘Imposed silences and self-censorship: Palmach soldiers remember 1948’ in Ben-Ze'ev, Ginio & Winter (eds), Shadows of war, p. 181.
45 Quoted in Diarmaid Ferriter, ‘In such deadly earnest’ in Dublin Review, no. 12 (autumn 2003), p. 42.
46 Samuel Hynes, The soldiers’ tale: bearing witness to modern war (London, 1998), p. 100.
47 Pension application, Joseph Dolan (M.A.I., M.S.P.C., 24SP1400).
48 Reference for Dolan by Daniel McDonnell, 28 Nov. 1924 (ibid.); secretary of the Department of Local Government and Public Health to Army Finance Officer, 24 Sept. 1926 (M.A.I., M.S.P.C., W24C12).
49 Pension application, Joseph Dolan (M.A.I., M.S.P.C., W24C12).
50 Alvin Jackson, ‘Widening the fight for Ireland's freedom: revolutionary nationalism in its global contexts’ in Victorian Studies, liv, no. 1 (autumn 2001), p. 106.
51 Ibid.
52 Fitzpatrick, ‘The geography of the War of Independence’, p. 542.
53 Padraic Colum, The road round Ireland (New York, 1927), p. 25.
54 On land and revolution see Fergus Campbell, Land and revolution: nationalist politics in the west of Ireland, 1891–1921 (Oxford, 2005); Timothy G. McMahon, ‘“The land for the people”: the Irish Revolution as a revolution of rising expectations’ in Michael de Nie and Sean Farrell (eds), Power and popular culture in modern Ireland (Dublin, 2010), pp 172–92.
55 Gerwarth, The vanquished, pp 150–1; Jeffery Dixon and Meredith Sarkees, Guide to intra-state wars: an examination of civil wars, 1816–2014 (London, 2016), p. 297.
56 Robert Gerwarth and Heinz-Gerhard Haupt, ‘Internationalising historical research on terrorist movements in twentieth-century Europe’ in European Review of History, xiv, no. 3 (Sept. 2007), pp 277, 280; Robert Gerwarth and John Horne, ‘Paramilitarism in Europe after the Great War’ in Gerwarth & Horne (eds), War in peace, p. 3; Martin Conway and Robert Gerwarth, ‘Revolution and counter-revolution’ in Donald Bloxham and Robert Gerwarth (eds), Political violence in twentieth-century Europe (Cambridge, 2011), p. 143.
57 Gerwarth & Horne, ‘Paramilitarism in Europe’, p. 4.
58 Conway & Gerwarth, ‘Revolution and counter-revolution’, p. 144.
59 Martin Pugh, We danced all night: a social history of Britain between the wars (London, 2008), pp 117–18.
60 Manchester Guardian, Feb.–July 1921.
61 Keith Jeffery, ‘The road to Asia, and the Grafton Hotel, Dublin: Ireland in the “British world”’ in I.H.S., xxxvi, no. 142 (Nov. 2008), pp 243–56.
62 Wilson diary, 10 May 1920 (I.W.M., HHW1/35/5).
63 Unsigned to ‘Mr Stewart’, 11 Jan. 1922 (B.L., India Office, IOR:L/MIL/7/806); Wilson diary, 31 Mar. 1920 (I.W.M., HHW1/35/3).
64 E. M. Ransford, unpublished memoir (I.W.M., 80/29/1); ‘Note of conversation’, 30 Apr. 1920 (T.N.A., CAB 23/21/23/20A).
65 Wilson diary, 14 Feb. 1920 (I.W.M., HHW1/35/2).
66 Montgomery to Percival, 14 Oct. 1923 (I.W.M., Percival collection, P18 4/1).
67 Duff, Douglas V., Sword for hire (London, 1934), p. 77Google Scholar.
68 Wilson diary, 11 May 1920 (I.W.M., HHW1/35/5).
69 Duff, Sword for hire, pp 78–9.
70 ‘Ernest Lycett – a memoir’ (I.W.M., 08/43/1).
71 McGarry, ‘Revolution’, p. 283; F. A. S. Clarke, unpublished memoir (Liddell Hart Centre for Military Archives, King's College London, 1/6 1968).
72 Interview with J. M. Rymer-Jones, n.d. (I.W.M., 10699).
73 G. W. Albin, unpublished memoir (I.W.M., PP/MCR/192).
74 ‘To members of the IRA’, July 1921 (T.N.A., CO 904/168).
75 Silvestri, Michael, ‘The bomb, Bhadralok, Bhagavad Gita, and Dan Breen: terrorism in Bengal and its relation to the European experience’ in Terrorism and Political Violence, xxi, no. 1 (2009), pp 1–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
76 ‘Steps to be taken in the event of the termination of the truce with Ireland’, Oct. 1921 (T.N.A., WO 141/55).
77 Rawlinson to Eddie (Lord Derby), 16 Aug. 1921 (B.L., EUR D605, Rawlinson papers, ff 33–4).
78 ‘The reign of terror in Ireland and Egypt’ (1919) (New York Public Library, Maloney papers, 7.13).
79 Lord Liverpool to Lord Buxton, 2 June 1921 (B.L., Buxton papers, MS 87070).
80 Lord Derby to Rawlinson, 14 Sept. 1921 (B.L., EUR D605, Rawlinson papers, f. 44).
81 Suilleabháin, Micheál Ó, Where mountainy men have sown (Tralee, 1965), pp 55–6Google Scholar; Statement by Matt Smyth (Monaghan County Museum (M.C.M.), 1986:2A3).
82 Seamus Robinson to an taoiseach, n.d. (N.A.I., TSCH/S9240).
83 Statement by Johnnie McKenna (M.C.M., 1986:4A1-2); statement by Tom Carragher (M.C.M., 1986:6C9).
84 Court of inquiry in lieu of inquest, Thomas Byrne, 8 Apr. 1921 (T.N.A., WO 35/147a).
85 Statement by Patrick Woods (M.C.M., 1986:2D8).
86 Townshend, The republic, p. 452.
87 Stuart Carroll, ‘The rights of violence’ in Past & Present, supplement 7 (2012), p. 139.
88 Thompson, E. P., ‘The moral economy of the English crowd in the eighteenth century’ in Past & Present, no. 50 (Feb. 1971), p. 112CrossRefGoogle Scholar.