Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-jwnkl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T05:19:01.349Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

11 - The development of Vegetian influence

from Part III - The legacy: the De re militari in medieval military thought and practice

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 October 2011

Christopher Allmand
Affiliation:
University of Liverpool
Get access

Summary

Introduction

The transmission of ideas expressed by Vegetius, ideas which, on his admission, were not necessarily his own, was achieved through the use of the written word: the copying of his text, whether in whole or in parts (excerpts); the making of translations; and, most interesting of all, the way his ideas were reflected in those of others as they discussed matters of war, government, even religious practice. Many types of people, soldiers, rulers, even clergy, were to have an interest in what Vegetius had written.

It is one thing to see ideas proposed by or attributed to Vegetius reflected in written works. It is quite another, and a much more difficult one to pinpoint or to analyse, to say precisely how such ideas either influenced or, at least, came to be reflected in military or other forms of action. In brief, what practical influence did the teachings of the man called ‘el sabio’ or ‘der meister’ have upon the way war was conducted in the Middle Ages? Although we can say that the De re militari had influence at an intellectual level, how far did that influence extend to the way things were actually done? While ‘the hope that Roman warfare could be studied and then imitated was a common simplification among humanists’, was Vegetius’ legacy in any sense practical?

Type
Chapter
Information
The De Re Militari of Vegetius
The Reception, Transmission and Legacy of a Roman Text in the Middle Ages
, pp. 251 - 348
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print publication year: 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Hoeffner, E. 1921
Piaget, A.Le chapel des fleurs de lis” par Philippe de VitriRomania 1898CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgess, G. S.The theme of chivalry in Medioevo romanzo 1989 359Google Scholar
Phillpotts, C.The French plan of battle during the Agincourt campaign’ [1415]EHR 1984 59CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Verbruggen, J. F.Un plan de bataille du duc de Bourgogne (14 septembre 1417) et la tactique de l’époqueRevue internationale d'histoire militaire 1959 443Google Scholar
Maravall, J. A.Ejercito y estado en el RenacimientoRevista de estudos politicos 1961 129Google Scholar
Fortescue, Sir JohnDe laudibus legum AnglieChrimes, S. B.Cambridge 1942 137Google Scholar
Scaglione, A.Knights at court. Courtliness, chivalry and courtesy from Ottonian Germany to the Italian RenaissanceBerkeley, Los Angeles and Oxford 1991 69Google Scholar
Fowler, K. A.Medieval mercenaries. I. The great companiesOxford and Malden, MA 2001Google Scholar
Lassabatère, T.Théorie et éthique de la guerre dans l’œuvre d’Eustache DeschampsLa guerre, la violence et les gens au moyen âge. I. Guerre de violenceContamine, P.Guyotjeannin, O.Paris 1996 41Google Scholar
Contamine, P.Guerre, état et société à la fin du moyen âge. Études sur les armées des rois de France, 1337–1494Paris and The Hague 1972 197CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allmand, C. T.Armstrong, C. A. J. 1982
Keen, M. H.The laws of war in the late Middle AgesLondon and Toronto 1965 68Google Scholar
Nederman, C. J. 2002
Ashmole, E.The institution, laws & ceremonies of the most noble Order of the GarterLondon 1672 158Google Scholar
Chartier, AlainLe quadrilogue invectifDroz, E.Paris 1950 55Google Scholar
Allmand, C.Changing views of the soldier in late medieval FranceGuerre et société en France, en Angleterre et en Bourgogne, XIVe–XVe siècleContamine, P.Giry-Deloison, C.Keen, M. H.Lille 1991 182Google Scholar
Synan, E. ASt Thomas Aquinas and the profession of armsMedieval studies 1988 425Google Scholar
Keauper, R. W.War, justice and public order. England and France in the later Middle AgesOxford 1988Google Scholar
Noble, P.Military leadership in the Old French epicReading around the epicAiles, M.Bennett, P. E.Pratt, K.London 1998 186Google Scholar
Autrand, F.Charles V, le SageParis 1994 578Google Scholar
Kempshall, M. S.The common good in late medieval political thoughtOxford 1999 126CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spiegel, G. M.Moral imagination and the rise of the bureaucratic state: images of government in the , Chantilly, MS 869Journal of Medieval and Renaissance studies 1988 157Google Scholar
Eschenbach, Wolfram vonWillehalmHarmondsworth 1984Google Scholar
Jones, M. H.The depiction of battle in Wolfram von Eschenbach's The ideals and practice of medieval knighthood IIHarper-Bill, C.Harvey, R.Woodbridge and Wolfeboro 1988 46Google Scholar
Complainte sur la bataille de Poitiersde Beaurepaire, C.BEC 1851 257CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dembowski, P. F.Chivalry, ideal and real, in the narrative poetry of Jean FroissartMedievalia et humanistica 1986 7Google Scholar
Saint-Hilaire, Queux de 1878
Wright, N. A. R.The of Honoré Bouvet and the laws of warWar, literature and politics in the late Middle AgesAllmand, C. T.Liverpool 1976 28Google Scholar
Kaeuper, R. W.Kennedy, E. 1996
Pons, N. 1990
Potter, D.Chivalry and professionalism in French armies of the RenaissanceThe chivalric ethos and the development of military professionalismTrim, D. J. B.Leiden and Boston 2003Google Scholar
Harding, A.Medieval law and the foundations of the stateOxford 2002CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morillo, S.The sword of justice: war and state formation in comparative perspectiveJMMH 2006 1Google Scholar
García, L. R.Types of armies: early modern SpainWar and competition between statesContamine, P.Oxford 2000 43Google Scholar
Agrait, N.Castilian military reform under the reign of Alfonso XIJMMH 2005 88Google Scholar
Mallett, M.Trim,
Watanabe, M.The political ideas of Nicholas of Cusa, with special reference to hisGeneva 1963 136Google Scholar
Contamine, P.L’armée de Philippe AugusteLa France de Philippe Auguste. Le temps des mutationsBautier, R.-H.Paris 1982 577Google Scholar
Strayer, J. R.Defense of the realm amd royal power in FranceStudi in onore di Gino LazattoMilan 1949 289Google Scholar
StrayerThe reign of Philip the FairPrinceton 1980 374Google Scholar
Pons, N.Goullet, M. 2001
F. A. IsambertA. J. L. Jourdan and Monsieur DecrusyRecueil général des anciennes lois françaises depuis l'an 420 jusqu’à la Révolution de 1789Paris 1822 59Google Scholar
Solon, P. D.Popular response to standing military forces in fifteenth-century FranceStudies in the Renaissance 1972 108Google Scholar
Major, J. R.Representative institutions in Renaissance France, 1421–1559Madison 1960 99Google Scholar
Lewis, P. S.Later medieval France. The polityLondon 1968 101CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, M. C. E.L’armée bretonne, 1449–1491: structures et carrièresLa France de la fin du XVe siècle: renouveau et apogéeChevalier, B.Contamine, P.Paris 1985 147CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pryor, J. H.Logistics of warfare in the age of the crusadesAldershot and Burlington, VT 2006 279Google Scholar
PiagetLe chapel des fleurs de lisUeber eine Handschrift des Nicolaus von CuesKlein, J.Berlin 1866 39Google Scholar
Vale, M. G. A.Sir John Fastolf's “Report” of 1435: a new interpretation reconsideredNottingham Medieval Studies 1973 78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hale, J. R.War and society in Renaissance Europe, 1450–1620London 1985 159Google Scholar
Bartusis, M. C.The late Byzantine army. Arms and society, 1204–1453Philadelphia 1992 247Google Scholar
Haldon, J.Military service, military lands and the status of soldiers: current problems and interpretationsDumbarton Oaks Papers 1993 42Google Scholar
Storey, R.The Tower of London and the Royal Armouries Yearbook 1998 176Google Scholar
Harari, Y. N.Strategy and supply in fourteenth-century Western European invasion campaignsJournal of Military History 2000 297CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Curry, A.Agincourt. A new historyLondon 2005Google Scholar
Allmand, C.Keen, M.History and the literature of war: the of William WorcesterWar, government and power in late medieval FranceAllmand, C. T.Liverpool 2000 92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luttwak, E. N.Logistics and the aristocratic idea of warFeeding Mars. Logistics in western warfare from the Middle Ages to the presentLynn, J. A.Boulder, San Francisco and Oxford 1993 3Google Scholar
Gillingham, J.The Wars of the Roses. Peace and conflict in fifteenth-century EnglandLondon 1981 35Google Scholar
Armstrong, C. A. J. 1969
Contamine, P.The war literature of the late Middle Ages: the treatises of Robert de Balsac and Béraud Stuart, lord of AubignyWar, literature and politics in the late Middle AgesAllmand, C. T.Liverpool 1976 121Google Scholar
Rogers, C. J.The Vegetian “Science of warfare” in the Middle AgesJMMH 2002 1Google Scholar
Morillo, S.Battle seeking: the contexts and limits of Vegetian strategyJMMH 2002 22Google Scholar
Ayton, A.Knights and warhorses. Military service and the English aristocracy under Edward IIIWoodbridge 1994 36Google Scholar
Oman, C.History of the art of war in the Middle AgesLondon 1924 201Google Scholar
Hewitt, H. J.The Black Prince's expedition of 1355–1357Manchester 1958Google Scholar
AllmandThe Hundred Years War. England and France at war, c.1300–c.1450Cambridge 2001 54Google Scholar
Savy, N.The of John Chandos and Robert Knolles: early March to early June, 1369JMMH 2009 38Google Scholar
Gillingham, J.Up with orthodoxy!” In defense of Vegetian warfareJMMH 2004 152Google Scholar
2000
Jal, A.Archéologie navaleParis 1840 289Google Scholar
Paviot, J.Contamine, P.L’art de la guerre selon Philippe de Clèves, seigneur de Ravenstein (1456–1528): innovation ou tradition?Bijdragen en mededelingen betreffende de Geschiedenis der Nederlanden 1980 363Google Scholar
Mott, L. V.The battle of Malta, 1283: prelude to a disasterThe circle of war in the Middle AgesKagay, D. J.Villalon, L. J. A.Woodbridge 1999 149Google Scholar
Rose, S.Medieval naval warfare, 1000–1500London and New York 2002 6Google Scholar
Hartig, O. 1917
Patch, H. R.The goddess Fortuna in medieval literatureCambridge, Mass. 1927 107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huntington, S. P.The soldier and the state. The theory and practice of civil–military relationsCambridge, Mass. 1957 11Google Scholar
Feld, M. D.The structure of violence. Armed forces in social systemsBeverley Hills and London 1977 19Google Scholar
de Comminges, E. 1976
Balsat, Robert deLa nef des princes et des bataillesLyons 1502 lviivvGoogle Scholar
Diamantberger, M. 1925 rv
Anglo, S.Vegetius's “De re militari”: the triumph of mediocrityThe Antiquaries Journal 2002 247CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richardot, P.La tradition moderne du de Végèce (XVe–XVIIIe siècles)Hommages à Carl Deroux. V. Christianisme et moyen âge, néo-latin et survivance de la latinitéDefosse, P.Brussels 2003 537Google Scholar

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure coreplatform@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

Available formats
×