Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Perspectives on Glyphosate Resistance

  • Laura D. Bradshaw (a1), Stephen R. Padgette (a1), Steven L. Kimball (a1) and Barbara H. Wells (a1)

Abstract

The lack of evolution of weed resistance to the herbicide glyphosate has been considered from several perspectives. Few plant species are inherently resistant to glyphosate. Furthermore, the long history of extensive use of the herbicide has resulted in no verified instances of weeds evolving resistance under field situations. Unique properties of glyphosate such as its mode of action, metabolism, chemical structure and lack of residual activity in soil may explain this observation. Selection for glyphosate resistance of crops using intense whole plant and cell/tissue culture techniques, including mutagenesis, has had only limited success and is unlikely to be duplicated under normal field conditions. Information obtained in the development of glyphosate-resistant crops suggests that target-site alterations that decrease the herbicidal activity of glyphosate also may lead to reduced survival of a weed. In addition, the complex manipulations that were required for the development of glyphosate-resistant crops are unlikely to be duplicated in nature to evolve glyphosate-resistant weeds.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Amrhein, N., Deus, B., Gehrke, P., and Steinrücken, H. C. 1980. The site of the inhibition of the shikimate pathway by glyphosate, Plant Physiol. 65:830834.
Amrhein, N., Hollander-Czytko, H., Johanning, D., Schulz, A., Smart, C. C., and Steinrücken, H. C. 1987. Overproduction of 5-enolypyruvyl-shikimate-3-phosphate synthase in glyphosate-tolerant plant cell cultures. p. 119133 in Liss, Alan R., pub. Plant Tissue and Cell Culture. New York.
Anderson, K. S., and Johnson, K. A. 1990. Kinetic and structural analysis of enzyme intermediates: lessons from EPSP synthase. Chem. Rev. 90:11311149.
Anderson, K. S., Sikorski, J. A., and Johnson, K. A. 1988. Evaluation of 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase substrate and inhibitor binding by stopped-flow and equilibrium fluorescence measurements. Biochemistry 27:16041610.
Barry, G., Kishore, G., Padgette, S., Taylor, M., Kolacz, K., Weldon, M., Re, D., Eichholtz, D., Fincher, K., and Hallas, L. 1992. p. 139145 in Singh, B. K., Flores, H. E., and Shannon, J. C., eds. Biosynthesis and Molecular Recognition of Amino Acids in Plants. Am. Soc. Plant Physiol. Rockville, MD.
Bently, R., 1990. The shikimate pathway-A metabolic tree with many branches. p. 307384 in Fasman, G. D., ed. Critical Reviews in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, v. 25. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
Boerboom, C. M., Wyse, D. L., and Somers, D. A. 1990. Mechanism of glyphosate tolerance in birdsfoot trefoil (Lotus corniculatus). Weed Sci. 38:463467.
Boocock, M. R., and Coggins, J. R. 1983. Kinetics of 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase inhibition by glyphosate. Fed. Eur. Biochem. Soc. Lett. 154:127133.
Burnet, M.W.M., Hildebrand, O. B., Holtum, J.A.M., and Powles, S. B. 1991. Amitrole, triazine, substituted urea, and metribuzin resistance in a biotype of rigid ryegrass (Lolium rigidum). Weed Sci. 39:317323.
Carlisle, S. M., and Trevors, J. T. 1988. Glyphoste in the environment. Water, Air Soil Pollut. 39:409420.
Comai, L., Sen, L., and Stalker, D. M. 1983. An altered aroA gene product confers resistance to the herbicide glyphosate. Science 221:370371.
Comai, L. D., Facciotti, D., Hiatt, W. R., Thompson, G., Rose, R. E., and Stalker, D. M. 1985. Expression in plants of a mutant aroA gene from Salmonella typhimurium confers tolerance to glyphosate. Nature 317:741744.
Conard, S. G., and Radosevich, S. R. 1979. Ecological fitness of Senecio vulgaris and Amman/hits retroflexus biotypes susceptible or resistant to atrazine. J. Appl. Ecol. 16:171177.
Cotterman, J. C., and Saari, L. L. 1992. Rapid metabolic inactivation is the basis for cross-resistance to chlorsulfuron in diclofop-methyl-resistant rigid ryegrass (Lolium rigidum) biotype sr4/84. Pestic. Biochem. Physiol. 43:182192.
Coupland, D., 1985. Metabolism of glyphosate in plants. p. 2534 in Grossbard, E., and Atkinson, D., eds. The Herbicide Glyphosate. Butterworth and Company, Ltd., London.
DeGennaro, F. P., and Weller, S. C. 1984. Differential susceptibility of field bindweed (Convolvulus arvensis) biotypes to glyphosate. Weed Sci. 32:472476.
della-Cioppa, G., Bauer, S. C., Klein, B. K., Shah, D. M., Fraley, R. T., and Kishore, G. 1986. Translocation of the precursor of 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase into chloroplasts of higher plants in vitro . Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 83:68736877.
della-Cioppa, G., and Kishore, G. M. 1988. Import of a precursor protein into chloroplasts is inhibited by the herbicide glyphosate. Eur. Mol. Biol. Organ. J. 7:12991305.
Duke, S.O., 1988. Glyphosate. p. 3:1–70 in Kearney, P. C. and Kaufman, D. D., eds. Herbicides: Chemistry, Degradation and Mode of Action. Dekker, New York.
Duke, S. O., Christy, A. L., Hess, F. D., and Holt, J. S. 1991. Herbicide-resistant crops. Comments From Counc. Agric. Sci. Technol. p. 128.
Duncan, C. N., and Weller, S. C. 1987. Heritability of glyphosate susceptibility among biotypes of field bindweed. J. of Heed. 78:257260.
Dyer, W. E., 1994. Resistance to glyphosate. p. 229241 in Powles, S. B. and Holtum, J.A.M., eds. Herbicide Resistance in Plants. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
Fillatti, J. J., Kiser, J., Rose, R., and Comai, L. 1987. Efficient transfer of a glyphosate tolerance gene into tomato using a binary Agrobacterium tumefaciens vector. Bio-Technology 5:726730.
Fraley, R. T., Kishore, G., Gasser, C. S., Padgette, S., Horsch, R., Rogers, S., della-Cioppa, G., and Shah, D. 1987. Genetically-engineered herbicide tolerance-technical and commercial considerations. Proc. Br. Crop Prot. Conf. 463471.
Franz, J. E., Mao, J. K., and Sikorski, J. A. 1993. Glyphosate's molecular mode of action: A review of glyphosate and EPSPS biochemistry. Am. Chem. Soc. Monogr. 13:187.
Fuerst, E. P., and Vaughn, K. C. 1990. Mechanism of paraquat resistance. Weed Technol. 4:150156.
Goodman, R. M., 1987. Future potential, problems, and practicalities of herbicide-tolerant crops from genetic engineering. Weed Sci. 35 (Suppl. 1):2831.
Gossett, B. J., Murdock, E. C., and Toler, J. E. 1992. Dinitroaniline-resistant Palmer amaranth (Amaranthus palmeri). Proc. South. Weed Sci. Soc. 45:90.
Gressel, J., 1993. Evolution of herbicide resistance in weeds: causes, prevention. and ameliorative management. p. 173188 in Malik, R. K., ed. Integrated Weed Management for Sustainable Agriuclture, v. 1. Proc. Int. Symp. Indian Society of Weed Science, Hisar.
Gressel, J., 1992. Genetically-engineered herbicide-resistant crops-a moral imperative for world food production. Agro-Food-Industry Hi-Tech. Nov–Dec:37.
Gressel, J., and Segel, L. S. 1990. Modelling the effectiveness of herbicide rotations and mixtures as strategies to delay or preclude resistance. Weed Technol. 4:186198.
Gronwald, J. W., Anderson, R. N., and Yee, C. 1989. Atrazine resistance in velvetleaf (Abutilon threophrasti) due to enhanced atrazine detoxification. Pestic. Biochem. Physiol. 34:149163.
Grossbard, E., and Atkinson, D. 1985. The Herbicide Glyphosate. Butterworth and Company, Ltd., London. 490 p.
Gruys, K. J., Walker, M. C., and Sikorski, J. A. 1992. Substrate synergism and the steady-state kinetic reaction mechanism for EPSP synthase from E. coli . Biochemistry 31:55345544.
Gruys, K. J., Marzabadi, M. R., Pansegrau, P. D., and Sikorski, J. A. 1993. Steady-state kinetic evaluation of the reverse reaction for Escherichia coli 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 304:345351.
Hallas, L. E., Hahn, E. M., and Korndorfer, C. 1988. Characterization of microbial traits associated with glyphosate biodegradation in industrial activated sludge. J. Industrial Microbiol. 3:377385.
Harper, J. L., 1956. The evolution of weeds in relation to the resistance to herbicides. Proc. 3rd Br. Weed Control Conf. 1:179188.
Hartnett, M. E., Chui, C. F., Mauvais, C. J., McDevitt, R. E., Knowlton, S., Smith, J. K., Falco, S. C., and Mazur, B. J. 1990. Herbicide-resistant plants carrying mutated acetolactate synthase genes. p. 459473 in Green, M. B., LeBaron, H. M., and Moberg, W. K., eds. Managing Resistance to Agrochemicals: From Fundamental Research to Practical Strategies. Am. Chem. Soc. Symp. Ser. No. 421, ACS Books, Washington, DC.
Haughn, G. W., and Somerville, C. 1986. Sulfonylurea-resistant mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana . Mol. Gen. Genet. 204:430434.
Haughn, G., Smith, J., Mazur, B., and Somerville, C. R. 1988. An Arabidopsis acetolactate synthase gene in tobacco confers resistance to sulfonylurea herbicides. Mol. Gen. Genet. 211:266271.
Haughn, G. W., and Somerville, C. R. 1990. A mutation causing imidazolinone resistance maps to the csr1 locus of Arabidopsis thaliana . Plant Physiol. 92:10811085.
Haughn, G. W., and Somerville, C. R. 1987. Selection for herbicide resistance at the whole plant level. p. 98108 in Lebaron, H., Mumma, R. O., Honeycutt, R. C., and Duesing, J. H., eds. Applications of Biotechnology to Agricultural Chemistry. American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C.
Heap, I. M., 1991. Resistance to herbicides in annual ryegrass (Lolium rigidum) in Australia. p. 5766 in Casely, J. C., Cussans, G. W., Atkins, R. K., eds. Herbicide Resistance in Weeds. Butterworth-Heinemann, Ltd., Oxford, U.K.
Heap, I., and Knight, R. 1986. The occurrence of herbicide cross-resistance in a population of annual ryegrass, Lolium rigidum, resistant to the herbicide diclofop-methyl. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 37:149156.
Hinchee, M. A., Connor-Ward, D. V., Newell, C. A., McDonnell, R. E., Sato, S. J., Gasser, C. S., Ficchoff, D. A., Re, D. B., Fraley, R. T., and Horsch, R. B. 1988. Production of transgenic soybean plants using Agrobacterium-mediated DNA transfer. Bio-Technology 6:915921.
Hirschberg, J. A., Bleeker, A., Kyle, D. J., Mcintosh, L., and Arntzen, C. J. 1984. The molecular basis of triazine-herbicide resistance in higher-plant chloroplasts. Z. Naturforsch. 39c:412420.
Holt, J. S. 1992. History of identification of herbicide-resistant weeds. Weed Technol. 6:615620.
Holt, J. S., and LeBaron, H. M. 1990. Significance and distribution of herbicide resistance. Weed Technol. 4:141149.
Holt, J. S., Powles, S. B., and Holtum, J.A.M. 1993. Mechanisms and agronomic aspects of herbicide resistance. Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Biol. 44:203229.
Holt, J. S., and Radosevich, S. R. 1983. Differential growth of two common groundsel (Senecio vulgaris) biotypes. Weed Sci. 31:112115.
Horsch, R. B., Fraley, R. T., Rogers, S. G., Klee, H. J., Fry, J., W. Hinchee, M. A., and Shah, D. S. 1988. Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer to plants; engineering tolerance to glyphosate. Iowa State J. Res. 62:487502.
Jacob, G. S., Garbow, J. R., Hallas, L. E., Kimack, N. M., Kishore, G. M., and Schaefer, J. 1988. Metabolism of glyphosate in Pseudomonas sp. strain LBr. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54:29532958.
Johnston, D. T., Van Wijk, A.J.P., and Kilpatrick, D. 1989. Selection for tolerance to glyphosate in fine-leaved Festuca species. Proc. 6th Int. Turgrass Res. Conf. p. 103105.
Johnston, D. T., and Faulkner, J. S. 1991. Herbicide resistance in the Graminaceae—A plant breeder's view. p. 319330 in Caseley, J. C., Cussans, G. W. and Atkin, R. K., eds. Herbicide Resistant Weeds and Crops. Butterworth-Heinemann Ltd., Oxford, U.K.
Kishore, G. M., and Shah, D. M. 1988. Amino acid biosynthesis inhibitors as herbicides. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 57:627663.
Kishore, G. M., Brundage, L., Kolk, K., Padgette, S. R., Rochester, D., Huynh, Q. K., and della-Cioppa, G. 1986. Isolation, purification, and characterization of a glyphosate-tolerant mutant E. coli EPSP synthase. Proc. Fed. Am. Soc. Exp. Biol. 45:1506.
Komoba, D., Gennity, I., and Sandermann, H. 1992. Plant metabolism of herbicides with C-P bonds: glyphosate. Pestic. Biochem. Physiol. 43:8594.
LeBaron, H. M., and Gressel, J. 1982. Herbicide Resistance in Plants. John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York. 401 p.
LeBaron, H. M., 1991. Distribution and seriousness of herbicide resistant weed infestations worldwide. p. 1513 in Caseley, J. C., Cussans, G. W., and Atkins, R. K., eds. Herbicide Resistance in Weeds and Crops. Butterworth-Heinemann Ltd., Oxford, U.K.
Lee, K. Y., Townsend, J., Tepperman, J., Black, M., Chui, C. F., Mazur, B., Dunsmuir, P., and Bedbrook, J. 1988. The molecular basis of sulfonylurea herbicide resistance in tobacco. Eur. Mol. Biol. Organ. J. 7:12411248.
Loux, M. M., Liebl, R. A., and Hymowitz, T. 1987. Examination of wild perennial Glycine species for glyphosate tolerance. Soybean Genet. Newsl. 14:268271.
Malik, J., Barry, G., and Kishore, G. 1989. The herbicide glyphosate. BioFactors 2(1):1725.
Mallory-Smith, C. A., Thill, D. C., and Dial, M. J. 1990. Identification of sulfonylurea herbicide-resistant prickly lettuce (Lactuca serriola). Weed Technol. 4:163168.
Marshall, G., Kirkwood, R. C. and Martin, D. J. 1987. Studies on the mode of action of asulam, aminotriazole and glyphosate in Equisetum arvense L. II. The metabolism of [14C]asulam, [14C]aminotriazole and [14C]glyphosate. Pestic. Sci. 18:6577.
Moss, S. R., 1990. Herbicide resistance in slender foxtail (Alopecurus myosuroides). Weed Sci. 38:492–196.
Moss, S. R., and Rubin, B. 1993. Herbicide-resistant weeds: a worldwide perspective. J. Agric. Sci. 120:141148.
Mousdale, P. M., and Coggins, J. R. 1985. Subcellular localization of the common shikimate pathway enzymes in Pisum sativum . Planta 163:241249.
Nafziger, E. M., Wildholm, J. M., Steinrücken, H. C., and Killmer, J. L. 1984. Selection and characterization of a carrot cell line tolerant to glyphosate. Plant Physiol. 76:571574.
Nomura, N. S., and Hilton, H. W. 1977. The adsorption and degradation of glyphosate in five Hawaiian sugarcane soils. Weed Res. 17:113121.
Padgette, S. R., Re, D. B., Barry, G. F., Eichholtz, D. E., Delannay, X., Fuchs, R. L., Kishore, G. M., and Fraley, R. T. 1996. New weed control opportunities: Development of soybeans with a Roundup Ready™ gene. p. 5384 in Duke, S. O., ed. Herbicide-Resistant Crops: Agricultural, Economic, Environmental, Regulatory, and Technological Aspects. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
Padgette, S. R., della-Cioppa, G., Shah, D. M., Fraley, R. T., and Kishore, G. M. 1989. Selective herbicide tolerance through protein engineering. p. 441476 in Schell, J. and Vasil, I., eds. Cell Culture and Somatic Cell Genetics of Plants, Vol. 6. Academic Press, New York.
Padgette, S. R., Re, D. B., Gasser, C. S., Eichholtz, D. A., Frazier, R. B., Hironaka, C. M., Levine, E. B., Shah, D. M., Fraley, R. T., and Kishore, G. M. 1991. Site-directed mutagenesis of a conserved region of the 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase active site. J. Biol. Chem. 266:2236422369.
Pfister, K., and Arntzen, C.J. 1979. The mode of action of photosystem H-specific inhibitors in herbicide-resistant weed biotypes. Z. Naturforsch. 34c:9961009.
Pipke, R., and Amrhein, N. 1988. Degradation of the phosphonate herbicide glyphosate by Arthrobacter atrocyaneus ATCC 13752. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54:12931296.
Powles, S. B., and Howat, P. D. 1990. Herbicide-resistant weeds in Australia. Weed Technol. 4:178185.
Powles, S. B., Tucker, E. S., and Morgan, T. R. 1989. A capeweed (Arctotheca calendula) biotype in Australia resistant to bipyridyl herbicides. Weed Sci. 37:6062.
Pratley, J., Baines, B., Eberbach, P., Incerti, M., and Broster, J. 1996. Glyphosate resistance in annual ryegrass. Proc. Eleventh Ann. Conf. Grassld. Soc. NSW. 122.
Primiani, M. M., Cotterman, J. C., and Saari, L. L. 1990. Resistance of kochia (Kochia scoparia) to sulfonylurea and imidazolinone herbicides. Weed Technol. 4:169172.
Radosevich, S. R., and Holt, J. S. 1982. Physiological responses and fitness in susceptible and resistant weed biotypes to triazine herbicides. p. 163183 in LeBaron, J. M. and Gressel, J., eds. Herbicide Resistance in Plants. John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York.
Re, D. B., Padgette, S. R., Delannay, X., Kolacz, K. H., Nida, D. L., Peschke, V. M., Derting, C. W., Rogers, S. G., Edwards, J. W., Barry, G. F., and Biest, N. A. 1993, Petition of Determination of Nonregulated Status: Soybeans with a Roundup Ready™ Gene. Submitted to the United States Department of Agriculture, 09, 1993.
Rueppel, M. L., Brightwell, B. B., Schaefer, J., and Marvel, J. T. 1977. Metabolism and degradation of glyphosate in soil and water. J. Agric. Food Chem. 25:517528.
Ruff, T., Eichholtz, D., Re, D., Padgette, S., and Kishore, G. 1991. Effects of amino acid substitutions on glyphosate tolerance and activity of EPSPS. Plant Physiol. 96 (Suppl):94.
Saari, L. L., Cotterman, J. C., and Primiani, M. M. 1990. Mechanism of sulfonylurea herbicide resistance in the broadleaf weed, Kochia scoparia. Plant Physiol. 93:5561.
Schulz, A., Wengenmayer, F., and Goodman, H. M. 1990. Genetic engineering of herbicide resistance in higher plants. Grit. Rev. Plant Sci. 9(1):115.
Sellin, C., Forlani, G., Dubois, J., Nielsen, E., and Vasseur, J. 1992. Glyphosate tolerance in Cichorium intybus L. var. Magdebourg. Plant Sci. 85:223231.
Shah, D. M., Horsch, R. B., Klee, H. J., Kishore, G. M., Winter, J. A., Tumer, N. E., Hironaka, C. M., Sanders, P. R., Gasser, C. S., Aykent, S. A., Siegel, N. R., Rogers, S. G., and Fraley, R. T. 1986. Engineering herbicide tolerance in transgenic plants. Science 233:478481.
Shaner, D. L., 1991. Mechanisms of resistance to acetolactate synthase/acetohydroxyacid sythase inhibitors. p. 187191 in Caseley, J. C., Cussans, G. W., and Atkins, R. K., eds. Herbicide Resistance in Weeds and Crops. Butterworth-Heinemann, Ltd., Oxford.
Shyr, Y. J., Hepburn, A. G., and Wildholm, J. M. 1992. Glyphosate selected amplification of the 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase gene in cultured carrot cells. Mol. Gen. Genet. 232:377382.
Singer, S. R., and McDaniel, C. N. 1985. Selection of glyphosate-tolerant tobacco calli and the expression of this tolerance in regenerated plants. Plant Physiol. 78:411416.
Smith, E. A., and Oehme, E. W. 1992. The biological activity of glyphosate to plants and animals: A literature review. Vet. Hum. Toxicol. 34:531543.
Smith, C. M., Pratt, D., and Thompson, G. A. 1986. Increased 5-enolpyruvylshikimic acid 3-phosphate synthase activity in a glyphosate-tolerant variant strain of tomato cells. Plant Cell Rep. 5:298301.
Stalker, D. M., Hiatt, W. R., and Comai, L. 1985. A single amino acid substitution in the enzyme 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase confers resistance to the herbicide glyphosate. J. Biol. Chem. 260:47244728.
Steinrücken, H., and Amrhein, N. 1980. The herbicide glyphosate is a potent inhibitor of 5-enolpyruvylshikimic acid-3-phosphate synthase. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 94:12071212.
Steinrücken, H. C., Schulz, A., Amrhein, N., Porter, C. A., and Fraley, R. 1986. Overproduction of 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase in a glyphosate-tolerant Petunia hybrida cell line. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 224:169178.
Subramanian, M. V., Loney-Gallant, V., Dias, J. M., and Mireles, L. C. 1991. Acetolactate synthase inhibiting herbicides bind to the regulatory site. Plant Physiol. 96:310313.
Sunby, C., Chow, W. S., and Anderson, J. M. 1993. Effects on photosystem II function, photoinhibition, and plant performance of the spontaneous mutation of serine-264 in the photosystem II reaction center D1 protein in triazine-resistant Brassica napus L. Plant Physiol. 103:105113.
Thompson, G. A., Hiatt, W. R., Gacciotti, D., Stalker, D. M., and Comai, L. 1987. Expression in plants of a bacterial gene coding for glyphosate resistance. Weed Sci. 35 (Suppl. 1):1923.
Torstensson, L., 1985. Behavior of glyphosate in soils and its degradation. p. 137150 in Grossbard, E. and Atkinson, D., eds. The Herbicide Glyphosate. Butterworth and Company, Ltd., London.
Tucker, E. S., and Powles, S. B. 1991. A biotype of hare barley (Hordeum leporinum) resistant to paraquat and diquat. Weed Sci. 39:159162.
Uotila, M., Gullner, G., and Kömives, T. 1995. Induction of glutathione S-transferase activity and glutathione level in plants exposed to glyphosate. Physiol. Plant. 93:689694.
Wang, Y., Jones, J. D., Weller, S. C., and Goldsbrough, P. B. 1991. Expression and stability of amplified genes encoding 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase in glyphosate-tolerant tobacco cells. Plant Mol. Biol. 17:11271138.
Weed Science Society of America. 1989. Glyphosate. p. 146149 in Herbicide Handbook of the Weed Science Society of America, 6th ed., Champaign, IL.

Keywords

Perspectives on Glyphosate Resistance

  • Laura D. Bradshaw (a1), Stephen R. Padgette (a1), Steven L. Kimball (a1) and Barbara H. Wells (a1)

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed