Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-xm8r8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-26T18:51:59.013Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Small parks, big designs: reconstructed Tokyo's new green spaces, 1923–1931

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 June 2019

Janet Borland Open the ORCID record for Janet Borland [Opens in a new window]
Janet Borland*
Affiliation:
Department of Japanese Studies, Room 5.01, Run Run Shaw Tower, Centennial Campus, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong
*
*Corresponding author. Email: borland@hku.hk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores the genesis of small parks in Tokyo following the 1923 Great Kantō Earthquake. It sheds new light on an example of innovative urban design and post-disaster reconstruction, and highlights the growing place that children occupied in the minds of bureaucrats and urban planners. The small parks were designed for children first and foremost. Originally conceived as a means to increase space for school children to play and exercise, all 52 parks were strategically located beside primary schools. As the state's goals of social management expanded, however, officials increasingly recognized the potential to use small parks as sites of rest and guided recreation, as well as emergency refuge. A history of Tokyo's small parks thus offers a window in to the growing understanding about the relationship between the built environment, health and society in inter-war Japan.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 47 , Issue 1 , February 2020 , pp. 106 - 125
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

†

I would like to thank Charles Schencking and three anonymous readers for their helpful comments and suggestions. Research for this article was supported by the Hong Kong Research Grants Council General Research Fund [Project ID: 740413].

References

1 Sueda, M., Jidō Kōen (Children's Parks) (Tokyo, 1942), 58Google Scholar.

2 Maejima, Y., Toshi to Midori: Inoshita Kiyoshi Chosakushū (Cities and Green: Collection of Writings by Inoshita Kiyoshi) (Tokyo, 1973), 77Google Scholar.

3 Cranz, G., The Politics of Park Design: A History of Urban America (Cambridge, 1982)Google Scholar; Wilson, W.H., The City Beautiful Movement (Baltimore, 1989)Google Scholar; Young, T., Building San Francisco's Parks, 1850–1930 (Baltimore, 2004)Google Scholar; Rosenzweig, R. and Blackmar, E., The Park and the People: A History of Central Park (Ithaca, NY, 1992)Google Scholar; Clark, P. (ed.), The European City and Green Space: London, Stockholm, Helsinki and St. Petersburg, 1850–2000 (Aldershot, 2006)Google Scholar.

4 Waley, P., ‘Parks and landmarks: planning the eastern capital along western lines’, Journal of Historical Geography, 31 (2005), 1–16CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Havens, T., Parkscapes: Green Spaces in Modern Japan (Honolulu, 2011), 85–91Google Scholar.

6 Koshizawa, A., Tokyo no Toshi Keikaku (Tokyo's City Planning) (Tokyo, 1991), 78–83Google Scholar. See also Schencking, J.C., The Great Kantō Earthquake and the Chimera of National Reconstruction in Japan (New York, 2013), 288–90Google Scholar; Weisenfeld, G., Imaging Disaster: Tokyo and the Visual Culture of Japan's Great Earthquake of 1923 (Berkeley, 2012), 231Google Scholar.

7 Tokyoshi, , Dai Nijūkyūkai Tokyoshi Tōkei Nenpyō (29th Annual Statistics of the City of Tokyo) (Tokyo, 1933), 40–5Google Scholar.

8 Ambaras, D., Bad Youth: Juvenile Delinquency and the Politics of Everyday Life in Modern Japan (Berkeley, 2006)Google Scholar; Garon, S., Molding Japanese Minds: The State in Everyday Life (Princeton, NJ, 1997)Google Scholar; Hastings, S.A., Neighborhood and Nation in Tokyo, 1905–1937 (Pittsburgh, 1995)Google Scholar.

9 Hein, C., ‘Resilient Tokyo: disaster and transformation in the Japanese city’, in Vale, L.J. and Campanella, T.J. (eds.), The Resilient City: How Modern Cities Recover from Disaster (Oxford, 2005), 213Google Scholar.

10 Waley, ‘Parks and landmarks’, 11.

11 Tokyoshi, , Dai Nijukkai Tokyoshi Tōkei Nenpyō (20th Annual Statistics of the City of Tokyo) (Tokyo, 1924)Google Scholar; on building material, see 802; on fires, see 420–1; on road width, see 800–1.

12 Tokyoshi, , Tokyo Shisei Yōran (Outline of Tokyo Municipal Government) (Tokyo, 1922), 8, 13–14Google Scholar.

13 Tokyoshi, Dai Nijukkai Tokyoshi Tōkei Nenpyō, 34–5.

14 On usable area of parks, see Murataka, M., Tokyoshi no Kaizō (The Reconstruction of Tokyo) (Tokyo, 1922), 19–20Google Scholar; Tokyoshi, , Tokyoshi Kōen Gaikan (Outline of Tokyo's Parks) (Tokyo, 1923), 66–70Google Scholar. For area occupied by temples and shrines, see Tokyoshi, Dai Nijukkai Tokyoshi Tōkei Nenpyō, 34–5.

15 Tokyoshi, Dai Nijukkai Tokyoshi Tōkei Nenpyō, 18–35; on factories, see 572–3.

16 Kikuchi, S., ‘Teito fukkō jigyō to shakai seisaku’ (Imperial capital reconstruction project and social policy), Shakai Seisaku Jihō, 13 (1924), 208Google Scholar.

17 Beard, C.A., The Administration and Politics of Tokyo: A Survey and Opinions (New York, 1923), 177Google Scholar.

18 Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kōen Gaikan, 66–70.

19 Borland, J., ‘Voices of vulnerability and resilience: children and their recollections in post-earthquake Tokyo’, Japanese Studies, 36 (2016), 307CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On population statistics as of 31 Dec. 1922, see Dai Nijukkai Tokyoshi Tōkei Nenpyō, 133, 150, 169, 172–7.

20 Jones, M., Children as Treasures: Childhood and the Middle Class in Early Twentieth-Century Japan (Cambridge, MA, 2010), 248–310CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Mine, Y., Gendai Shōgakkō no Kenchiku to Setsubi (The Architecture and Facilities of Present-day Primary Schools) (Tokyo, 1925), 14–15Google Scholar.

22 On the collected writings of Inoshita, see Maejima, Toshi to Midori. For a summary of his publications and career, see end pages, 1–14.

23 Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kōen Gaikan, 1; Murataka, Tokyoshi no Kaizō, 129–30.

24 Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kōen Gaikan, 67.

25 In 1921, as mayor of Tokyo, Gotō Shinpei wanted to build 60 new parks at a cost of 20 million yen over 15 years as part of his ambitious ‘800 million yen plan’. Gotō faced fierce political and financial resistance and the plan never materialized. See Schencking, J.C., ‘Catastrophe, opportunism, contestation: the fractured politics of reconstructing Tokyo following the Great Kantō Earthquake of 1923’, Modern Asian Studies, 40 (2006), 845–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Scott, J.C., Seeing like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed (New Haven, 1998), 91Google Scholar.

27 Schencking, The Great Kantō Earthquake and the Chimera of National Reconstruction in Japan, 153–86.

28 ‘Kore kara no shinkōen wa chiisaku shinrinshiki ni’ (New parks should be small and like forests), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 4 Nov. 1923, evening edition, 2.

29 ‘Kengisho (Proposal)’, Teien, 5 (1923), frontispiece; ‘Kōen goshū o arata ni secchi seyo’ (Establish five new types of parks), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 9 Nov. 1923, 2.

30 Ōya, R., ‘Teito fukkō to kōen’ (Imperial capital reconstruction and parks), Toshi Kōron, 7 (1924), 15–20Google Scholar. Charles A. Beard visited Tokyo in 1922 and Japanese urban planners would have been familiar with his recommendation that an ideal city should have a park within easy walking distance or 0.4 kilometres from every home. Beard, The Administration and Politics of Tokyo, 177–8.

31 Miyajima, M., ‘Toshi eiseijō no shomondai’ (Various problems with urban hygiene), Toshi mondai, 1 (1925), 7–8Google Scholar.

32 Ichikawa, G., ‘Daisai no kyōkun’ (Lessons from this great disaster), Kyōiku Jiron, 1382 (1923), 5Google Scholar; Higuchi, C., ‘Kōka na keiken o anka ni suru ni tsutomeyō’ (Let's turn this costly experience into a cheap one), in Kyōikukai, Teikoku (ed.), Shinsai to Kyōiku (The Earthquake and Education) (Tokyo, 1924), 372–3Google Scholar.

33 Yoshida, K., Kyōiku no beikoku (Education America) (Tokyo, 1918), 125–6Google Scholar.

34 Yoshida, K., Sekai ni okeru saikin no kyōiku shichō (Recent Trends in Education around the World) (Matsue, 1923), 140Google Scholar.

35 ‘Dainanakai teikoku rengō kyōiku kaigi’ (7th imperial education conference), Teikoku Kyōiku, 497 (1923), 104.

36 For details on the post-disaster contestation and parliamentary debates about the reconstruction budget, see Schencking, The Great Kantō Earthquake and the Chimera of National Reconstruction in Japan, 186–225.

37 Sasaki, K., ‘Shinsaigo no Tokyoshi shōgakkō kyōiku no fukkō ni tsuite’ (About the reconstruction of Tokyo's primary school education following the earthquake), Kyōiku Jiron, 1391 (1924), 6–10Google Scholar.

38 Budget and construction details were issued in Home Ministry Notification no. 424 on 4 Jul. 1924. Sōmubu, Tokyoshi Fukkō, Tokyoshi Teito Fukkō Jigyō Gaiyō (Outline of Activities for the Imperial Capital's Reconstruction) (Tokyo, 1925), 119Google Scholar.

39 , Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kyōiku Fukkōshi (History of the Reconstruction of Education in Tokyo) (Tokyo, 1930), 334Google Scholar; Inoshita, K., ‘Shōkōen no shisetsu to sono tokushoku’ (Special features of small parks), Toshi mondai, 10 (1930), 238Google Scholar.

40 ‘Tokushi keikaku iinkai’ (Special committee for city planning), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 23 May 1924, 3.

41 The Diet passed the 1919 City Planning Law as a means to regulate urban planning in cities nationwide. As André Sorensen points out, the law was largely in response to Tokyo's unruly growth over the past decade. On the history and development of urban planning in Japan, as well as the practice of land readjustment, see Sorensen, André, The Making of Urban Japan: Cities and Planning from Edo to the Twenty-First Century (New York, 2005)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hein, Carola, ‘Shaping Tokyo: land development and planning practice in the early modern Japanese metropolis’, Journal of Urban History, 36 (2010), 447–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42 Schencking, The Great Kantō Earthquake and the Chimera of National Reconstruction in Japan, 266.

43 ‘Kukaku seiri mondō’ (Questions and answers about land readjustment), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 28 May 1924, 6. The newspaper published the ‘Land readjustment Q&A’ daily column from 9 Apr. until 7 Jul. 1924.

44 ‘Shinai ni dekiru shōkōen’ (Small parks to be built in the city), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 28 May 1924, 7.

45 Kyōkai, Fukkō Chōsa (ed.), Teito Fukkōshi (History of the Imperial Capital Reconstruction) (Tokyo, 1930), vol. II, 960–5Google Scholar.

46 Other expenses included plants (¥212,250), civil engineering (¥231,500), construction of facilities such as toilets and resting places (¥376,250), and planning and supervision (¥180,000). Tokyoshi Fukkō Sōmubu, Tokyoshi Teito Fukkō Jigyō Gaiyō, 124.

47 , Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi shokuinroku (Record of City of Tokyo Employees) (Tokyo, 1928), 42–3Google Scholar.

48 Inoshita, K., ‘Tokyo fukkō kōen wa kōen shijō ichi epokku o tsukuru mono de aru’ (Tokyo's reconstructed parks mark a new epoch in park history), Toshi Kōron, 14 (1931), 52–3Google Scholar.

49 Calculations are based on figures contained in Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kyōiku Fukkōshi, 341–3.

50 For details of the size of school sports grounds, see , Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kyōiku Shisetsu Fukkō Zushū (An Illustrated Collection of Tokyo's Reconstructed Education Facilities) (Tokyo, 1932), 347–51Google Scholar. For a table of all the parks built adjacent to primary schools in Tokyo and the relevant statistics, see Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kyōiku Fukkōshi, 341–2; also Inoshita, ‘Shōkōen no shisetsu to sono tokushoku’, 251–6.

51 Inoshita, ‘Shōkōen no shisetsu to sono tokushoku’, 239.

52 Office, Tokyo Municipal, Education in Tokyo (Tokyo, 1937), 92–3Google Scholar. On similar efforts to promote children's health in inter-war England and France, see Pomfret, D., ‘The city of evil and the great outdoors: the modern health movement and the urban young, 1918–40’, Urban History, 28 (2001), 405–27CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

53 Yasuhiro, Takada, ‘Toshi kōen ni taisuru ichi yōkyū: kōen to shakai kyōiku’ (One requirement for city parks: parks and social education), Toshi Kōron, 14 (1931), 47Google Scholar.

54 Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kyōiku Fukkōshi, 334.

55 Inoshita, ‘Shōkōen no shisetsu to sono tokushoku’, 243–6.

56 Tokyo Municipal Office, Education in Tokyo, 79–80.

57 Jones, Children as Treasures, 277.

58 ‘Tokai no kensō kara kodomo o sukuu shin undō’ (New movement to rescue children from hustle and bustle of the city), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 4 Feb. 1929, 7.

59 Tokyoshi, Dai Nijūkyūkai Tokyoshi Tōkei Nenpyō, 788–9.

60 Nishida, F., ‘Keisatsukan no me ni eijiru kōen no shujusō’ (Various phases of parks as seen through the eyes of a police officer), Toshi Kōron, 14 (1931), 247–8Google Scholar.

61 Sueda, Jidō Kōen, 63, 65–6, 76.

62 For a calendar of seasonal events and festivals at different parks, see Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kōen Gaikan, 81–6.

63 Inoshita, K., ‘Kōen no genjitsuka’ (Realization of parks), Toshi Mondai, 1 (1925), 25Google Scholar. Inoshita published his views on park design, complete with photographs of overseas parks in Inoshita, K., Kōen no Sekkei (Park Design) (Tokyo, 1928)Google Scholar.

64 Tokyo Municipal Office, Education in Tokyo, 214.

65 ‘Rajio: kodomo no kōen, Inoshita Kiyoshi’ (Radio: Children's Parks, by Inoshita Kiyoshi), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 29 Oct. 1926, 12.

66 Kashiwagi, H., ‘On rationalization and the national lifestyle: Japanese design of the 1920s and 1930s’, in Tipton, E. and Clark, J. (eds.), Being Modern in Japan, Culture and Society from the 1920s to the 1930s (Honolulu, 2000), 61–74Google Scholar; Sand, J., House and Home in Modern Japan: Architecture, Domestic Space, and Bourgeois Culture, 1880–1930 (Harvard, 2003), 181–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

67 Local community groups, such as the Sakurada Park Support Group in Shiba ward, donated flag poles to parks. They were not part of the original design.

68 Tokyo Shiyakusho, Nan’ō Kōen Annai (Guide to Nan’ō Park) (Tokyo, undated).

69 For other examples of how the state used welfare programmes, religious organizations, the regulation of prostitution, and women's groups to manage society on a daily basis, see Garon, Molding Japanese Minds.

70 Fukyūkai, Nihon Tōkei (ed.), Teito Fukkō Jigyō Taikan (Survey of the Imperial Capital Reconstruction Project), vol. II (Tokyo, 1930)Google Scholar, section 18, 34.

71 Wilson, The City Beautiful Movement, 1.

72 Boyer, P., Urban Masses and Moral Order in America, 1820–1920 (Cambridge, 1978)Google Scholar.

73 Office, Tokyo Municipal, The Reconstruction of Tokyo (Tokyo, 1933), 293Google Scholar.

74 Tokyoshi, Tokyoshi Kyōiku Fukkōshi, 335.

75 For example Hammer, J., Yokohama Burning: The Deadly 1923 Earthquake and Fire that Helped Forge the Path to World War II (New York, 2006)Google Scholar.

76 Havens, Parkscapes, 90.

77 ‘Yamanote nijūkasho ni shōkōen shinsetsu’ (Twenty new small parks for yamanote), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 15 Sep. 1932, 11; ‘Zokuzoku tsukuru shōkōen, akisasenai setsubi o shite Inoshita Tokyoshi kōen kachō dan’ (Keep building small parks with facilities that attract people, speech by Tokyo's park director Inoshita), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 10 Dec. 1935, 5.

78 ‘Eiyo no hyōshōsha, nidome no hyōshō Inoshita Kiyoshi kachō’ (Park director Inoshita is publicly recognized for the second time), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 27 Sep. 1933, 3.

79 ‘Hogaraka ni hataraku josei no shinshokuba (15)’ (Smiling brightly as they work, women in a new work place (15)), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 26 Jan. 1935, 7.

80 ‘Nakayoku asobō yo’ (Let's play well together), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 25 Oct. 1936, evening, 3; ‘35 kasho ni bakudan no mokei, kaku shōkōen ni ichi jōkei’ (Model bombs in 35 locations, a spectacle in small parks), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 13 Nov. 1936, evening edition, 3.

81 ‘Teito shōkōen ni “nōjō”’ (Small parks as ‘farms’ in the imperial capital), Tokyo Asahi Shinbun, 6 Feb. 1941, evening edition, 2.