No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
An ancient and industrious place: visual geographies and urban identity in a Danish provincial town, c. 1780–1915
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 06 May 2019
Abstract
Through the example of Danish provincial town, Odense, the article explores the role of visual culture in the construction and transformation of nineteenth-century provincial identities and placemaking in an industrial town. It demonstrates that while representations may follow certain aesthetic conventions of urban imagery and ideas of urban prestige, they both reflect and contribute to the construction and reproduction of a specific local, imagined geography; an imagined geography where initially history and nature and as time progresses signs of industriousness and in particular an infrastructure of civic culture merges into a narrative of an ancient and industrious place.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019
Footnotes
†
The author would like to acknowledge the Research Board of the Danish Ministry of Culture, which funded the research project ‘Imagined geographies, social identities and urban transformation, Odense 1536–1915’ of which this article is part. The author wishes to thank Per Seesko for his invaluable input on the older materials. Moreover, I thank the peer reviewers for their valuable input.
References
1 Bang, H., Rundt i Landet (Viborg, 2003), 77Google Scholar. All quotes in Danish are translated by the author.
2 Gunn, S., The Public Culture of the Victorian Middle Class. Ritual and Authority in the English Industrial City 1840–1914 (Manchester, 2000), 36–7Google Scholar.
3 Otter, C., ‘Making liberalism durable’, Social History, 27 (2002), 1–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Joyce, P., The Rule of Freedom (London, 2003)Google Scholar; Ealham, C., ‘An imagined geography: ideology, urban space, and protest in the creation of Barcelona's “Chinatown”, c. 1835–1936’, International Review of Social History, 50 (2005), 373–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lützen, K., Byen Tæmmes (Copenhagen, 1998)Google Scholar; J. Toftgaard, Citydannelse, butiksstrøg og byidealer: dannelsen af centrale byrum i Odense samt Aarhus og Aalborg 1870–1970’, University of Southern Denmark Ph.D. thesis, 2012; M. Thelle, ‘København 1900: Rådhuspladsen som laboratorium for den moderne bys offentlige rum 1880–1914’, University of Copenhagen Ph.D. thesis, 2013.
4 Stobart, J., ‘Identity, competition and place promotion in the Five Towns’, Urban History, 30 (2003), 163–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Stobart, J., ‘Building an urban identity. Cultural space and civic boosterism in a “new” industrial town: Burslem, 1761–1911’, Social History, 29 (2004), 485–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gunn, The Public Culture; Sweet, R., The Writing of Urban Histories in Eighteenth-Century England (Oxford, 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Arnold, D., Re-presenting the Metropolis: Architecture, Urban Experience and Social Life in London 1800–1840 (Cambridge, 2000)Google Scholar; Arscott, C., ‘The representation of the city in the visual arts’, in Daunton, M. (ed.), The Cambridge Urban History of Britain, vol. III (Cambridge, 2001), 809–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Robinson, A., Imagining London 1770–1900 (London, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Nead, L., Victorian Babylon: People, Streets and Images in Nineteenth-Century London (London, 2011)Google Scholar; McKellar, E., Landscapes of London: The City, the Country and the Suburbs 1660–1840 (London, 2013)Google Scholar.
6 Layton-Jones, K., Beyond the Metropolis: The Changing Image of Urban Britain, 1780–1880 (Manchester, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Arscott, C., Pollock, G. and Wolff, J., ‘The partial view: the visual representation of the early nineteenth-century city’, in Wolff, J. and Seed, J. (eds.), The Culture of Capital: Art, Power and the Nineteenth-Century Middle Class (Manchester, 1988), 191–233Google Scholar. Other examples include Arscott, C., ‘Victorian development and images of the past’, in Shaw, C. and Chase, M. (eds.), The Imagined Past: History and Nostalgia (Manchester, 1989), 47–67Google Scholar; Tomann, J., Geschichtskultur im Strukturwandel. Öffentliche Geschichte in Katowice nach 1989 (Oldenbourgh, 2017)Google Scholar; Behringer, W. and Roeck, B. (eds.), Das Bild der Stadt in der Neuzeit 1400–1800 (Munich, 1999)Google Scholar; Günther, L., Die Bildhafte Repräsentation Deutscher Städte (Cologne, 2009)Google Scholar.
7 Nevers, J., Det produktive samfund (Odense, 2013), ch. 1Google Scholar. Also Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis, 1–3.
8 Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis; Arscott, Pollock and Wolff, ‘The partial view’.
9 Boje, P., ‘Fortællingen om, hvorfor Danmark blev rigt – og hvorfor ikke rigere’, in Fossat, S.B., Glenthøj, R. and Martinsen, L.K. (eds.), Konfliktzonen Danmark (Copenhagen, 2018), 180–97Google Scholar. Examples of the master narrative can be found in Jespersen, K.J.V, A History of Denmark (Basingstoke, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Nordstrom, B.J., Scandinavia since 1500 (Minneapolis, 2000), 237–9Google Scholar.
10 Kuisma, M., ‘Industrial expansion’, in The Cambridge History of Scandinavia, vol. II (Cambridge, 2016), 742–69, 767CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
11 Boje, ‘Fortællingen om’; Jørgensen, C. and Pedersen, M. (eds.), Industrial Heritage in Denmark (Aarhus, 2014), 11–18Google Scholar.
12 Abildgaard, H. and Bak, A. (eds.), Industriens billeder (Gylling, 2007)Google Scholar.
13 See e.g. Scavenius, B. and Michaëlis, B.T., Danmarks billeder: litterære landskaber og maleriske motiver (Copenhagen, 2018)Google Scholar; Hvidberg, G. et al. , Aftenlandet: motiver og stemninger i dansk landskabsmaleri omkring år 1800 (Odense, 2011)Google Scholar; Gunnarsson, T., Nordic Landscape Painting in the Nineteenth Century (New Haven, 1998)Google Scholar.
14 See e.g. Petersen, A.R., Storbyens billeder – fra industrialisme til informationsalder (Copenhagen, 2002)Google Scholar; Zerlang, M., Bylivets kunst. København som metropol og miniature (Copenhagen, 2002)Google Scholar; Scavenius, B. and Michaëlis, B.T., Bybilleder. Kunsternes og forfatternes København (Copenhagen, 2016)Google Scholar; Weisner, A., Groβstadtbild und nordische Moderne. Untersuchungen zur Groβstadtdarstellung in der skandinavischen Malerei von 1870 bis 1920 (Kiel, 2012)Google Scholar.
15 Abildgaard and Bak (eds.), Industriens billeder, 34–52, 76–103.
16 For a similar argument in a Danish context, see Toftgaard, Citydannelse.
17 Sweet, The Writing of Urban Histories.
18 In writing on the early depictions of Odense, I am deeply indebted to Per Seesko and his mapping of these.
19 Braun, G. and Hogenberg, F., Cities of the world (Cologne, 2017 [1617])Google Scholar.
20 Møller, P.G. and Porsmose, E., Byen vokser (Odense, 1988), 15Google Scholar.
21 Guldberg, J., ‘Sansning, fantasi og konvention: det topografiske element i landskabsmaleriet’, Bol og by, 1 (1997), 60–98, at 67–9Google Scholar.
22 Jørgensen, O., Otonium (Odense, 1981), 66, 88Google Scholar.
23 Petersen, E. Ladewig et al. , De fede år. Odense 1559–1660 (Odense, 1984), 332ffGoogle Scholar.
24 Canute was king 1042–86 and during a rebellion murdered in the church of Sct. Alban, where he was buried. After being canonized around 1100 his body was moved to the new cathedral, which became the centre of his cult until the Danish reformation in 1536.
25 Guldberg, ‘Sansning, fantasi og konvention’. On city prospects in general, see Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis, ch 1.
26 Autobiography of Herberstein [1516], in Fontes rerum austriacarum. Österreischische Geschichtsquellen, vol. I (Graz, 1969), 95; von Steblau, E.L., in Schottin, R. (ed.), Tagebuch des Erich Lassota von Steblau (Halle, 1866), 189–91Google Scholar; Maar, V. (ed.), Holger Jacobæus’ Rejsebog (1671–1692) (Copenhagen, 1910), 32Google Scholar; Major [1794], ‘Udtog af Joh. Dan. Majors reise i Norden’, in Suhm, P.F. (ed.), Nye Samlinger til den danske historie, vol. III (Copenhagen, 1794), 125–32, at 128Google Scholar.
27 Resen, P.H., Atlas Danicus IV, Fyn (Odense, 1984), 87–124Google Scholar; Fussing, H., ‘Fyens Antiquiteter’, Aarbog for Historisk Samfund for Odense og Assens Amter, 21 (1933), 387–98Google Scholar.
28 Pontoppidan, E., Den Danske Atlas (Copenhagen 1968 [1767])Google Scholar.
29 Olwig, K.R., ‘The Jutland Cipher’, in Jones, M. and Olwig, K.R., Nordic Landscapes (Chicago, 2008), 12–51, at 20Google Scholar.
30 Royal Library Copenhagen, Niels von Haven, unpublished manuscript. Von Haven comments that the image is more likely a pope, announcing the allegiance of the town during the papal schism of 1378.
31 Sweet, The Writing of Urban Histories; Jensen, Møller (ed.), Fynske Antikvarer. Lærdom, fortid og fortolkninger 1550–1850 (Odense, 2008)Google Scholar.
32 Marryat, H., A Residence in Jutland, the Danish Isles, and Copenhagen (London, 1860)Google Scholar.
33 On the role of the green in city prospects, see Layton-Jones, K., ‘A commanding view: public parks and the Liverpool prospect, 1722–1870’, Cultural and Social History, 10 (2015), 47–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
34 An uncompleted sketch from 1835 by Hanck features the motive from the opposite viewpoint, the church obscured by buildings.
35 On ‘taking in’ the town, see e.g. Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis, 30–1; Kenny, N., The Feel of the City. Experience of Urban Transformation (Toronto, 2014), ch. 2CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
36 See Borsay, P., ‘Nature, the past and the English town: a counter-cultural essay’, Urban History, 44 (2017), 27–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sweet, The Writing of Urban Histories, 139–49.
37 Marryat, A Residence in Jutland, 245.
38 Molesworth, R., An Account of Denmark as it Was in the Year 1692 (London, 1694)Google Scholar; Barton, H.A., Northern Arcadia. Foreign Travelers in Scandinavia, 1765–1815 (Carbondale, 1998), 172–5Google Scholar.
39 Ibid., 252, 255.
40 Illustreret Tidende, 24 May 1863.
41 See e.g. Clausen, S.H., Odense og Omegn, en lexikalsk Beskrivelse (Odense, 1863), 61Google Scholar.
42 Fionia. Ugeblad for underholdende Læsning, 23, 7 June 1863.
43 Similar cases of competing perspectives can be found in Edinburgh, where the physical distance between the old and the new town made it possible to give quite different visual versions of the cityscape. Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis, 103–4.
44 Clausen, Odense og Omegn, 53.
45 Engelstoft, C.T., Odense Byes Historie (Odense, 1880), 478Google Scholar.
46 Fyens Stiftstidende, 9 Oct., 11. Oct., 25 Dec. 1838.
47 Harnow, H., ‘Den fynske industris fader – M.P. Allerup og det danske industrimøde i Odense 1858’, in Fynske Minder (Odense, 2000), 23–46Google Scholar.
48 Fyens Stiftstidende, 29 Jun. 1891.
49 Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis, 93–7, 125–8. See also Arscott, Pollock and Wolff, ‘The partial view’.
50 Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis, 24–5.
51 See Arscott, Pollock and Wolff, ‘The partial view’, 208.
52 Abildgaard and Bak (eds.), Industriens billeder, 20–33.
53 Odense prospects by Heiden from 1847.
54 Another example is the prospect Udsigt fra Allerups Maskinværksted 1864. On the blend of industry and nature, see Layton-Jones, ‘A commanding view’, 45–52; Arscott, Pollock and Wolff, ‘The partial view’, 214–17.
55 Lauritzen, J., Odense og nærmeste Omegn i Billeder (Odense, 1874), 63Google Scholar.
56 Malmgren, N., Danmarks industrielle Etablissementer i Billeder med Tekst (Copenhagen, 1887)Google Scholar.
57 See Abildgaard and Bak (eds.), Industriens billeder, 22–5.
58 See Layton-Jones, K., ‘The synthesis of town and trade: visualizing provincial urban identity, 1800–1858’, Urban History, 35 (2008), 72–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar, for a detailed study of provincial urban identity as expressed in advertisements.
59 Ridter, J.L., Odense, 30 Tegninger (Odense, 1891)Google Scholar.
60 See Malmgren, N., Danmarks Industrielle Etablissementer (Copenhagen, 1887)Google Scholar.
61 Layton-Jones, Beyond the Metropolis, 93–7, 125–8. See also Arscott, Pollock and Wolff, ‘The partial view’.
62 See Kortbek, H., ‘Udviklingen af havnen i åbyen Odense’, in Frandsen, J.N. and Toftgaard, J. (eds.), Odense i forvandling: drømme og virkelighed (Odense, 2013), 231–65Google Scholar.
63 On this shift in imagery, see Arscott, Pollock and Wolff, ‘The partial view’; Gunn, The Public Culture, 52–3.
64 On the importance of civic culture in place identities, see e.g. Stobart, ‘Building an urban identity’.
65 Nevers, Det produktive samfund, 51.
66 Clausen, C.C., Odense og Omegn. Danmarks Byer og Deres Mænd VI (Copenhagen, 1900), 1Google Scholar.
67 Officiel Fører under den 18. Danske Landmandsforsamling i Odense 1900 (Odense, 1900)Google Scholar.
68 Illustreret Tidende, 23 Sep. 1894, 664.
69 Bang, Rundt i Landet, 75.
70 Edwards, B. and Jenkins, P. (eds.), Edinburgh. The Making of a Capital City (Edinburgh, 2005)Google Scholar; Madgin, R. and Rodger, R., ‘Inspiring capital? Deconstructing myths and reconstructing urban environments, Edinburgh, 1860–2010’, Urban History, 40 (2013), 507–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
71 Fyns Social-Demokrat, 12 Aug. 1898.
72 C.C. Clausen, Odense og Omegn, 35–6.
73 Nordahl, A., Odense Turistguide – Odense og Omegn (Odense, 1920); Odense i Dag (Odense, 1941)Google Scholar.
74 C.C. Clausen, Odense og Omegn; Dannebrog, 10 Jul. 1898.
75 Of the Atheneum as preferred sight, see also Galschiøt, M., Danmark i Skildringer og Billeder af danske Forfattere og Kunstnere, 1887–93 (Copenhagen, 1893)Google Scholar; A. Steenbuch, ‘Den gamle by’, Illustreret Tidende, 4 Aug. 1899, 532. Aarhus had its Atheneum from 1840.
76 Andersen, M., Odense By (Aarhus, 1915), 22Google Scholar. The same basic narrative is found in Galschiøt, Danmark i Skildringer.
77 Kruuse, J., Min lykkelige barndom (Copenhagen, 1966), 39Google Scholar.
78 Engelstoft, Odense Byes Historie, 475, 480, 482.
79 See Petersen, J.A.S. et al. , Byens Ansigt: Historien om Odense Rådhus 1480–2012 (Odense, 2012), 24–36Google Scholar.
80 Toftgaard, Citydannelse, 140.
81 Sweet, The Writing of Urban Histories, ch. 6, esp. 274–5.
82 Stobart, ‘Identity, competition and place promotion’; Stobart, ‘Building an urban identity’.
83 On this new paradigm of mobility, see Toftgaard, Citydannelse, 195–259, esp. 228–34.