Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-rvbq7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-10T08:25:54.222Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Julia Marlowe: An Actress Caught Between Traditions

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 October 2010

Patty S. Derrick
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Julia Marlowe's career, 1887–1924, came at an awkward point in the history of the American theatre, a transitional period when old traditions were fading and new ones had not yet been established. During her thirty years as an actress, a heterogeneous mixture of plays was seen on the American stage: Shakespeare and other old classics, emotional dramas adapted from the French and German, melodramas old and new, early attempts at realism, problem plays. Most strikingly innovative in this period were the dramas of Ibsen, Shaw, and O'Neill (his early plays), which questioned conventional values and often presented a disturbing view of human life and relationships. The range of plays was varied for performers, and the acting styles employed by the actors revealed a comparable diversity. According to Garff Wilson's classification, players like Helena Modjeska performed in the classic style characterized by grace, symmetry, and poetic grandeur; Clara Morris and Fanny Davenport perfected a highly emotional style, both specialists in the art of stage weeping; Otis Skinner abandoned the classics of Shakespeare and Restoration drama and became famous in sentimental comedy and romantic costume drama such as Kismet; Ada Rehan and Viola Allen, part of the “sisterhood of sweetness and light,” achieved popularity as actresses of the “personality school”; Richard Mansfield, a thoroughly transitional figure, clung to the classics in his repertoire but also produced and performed in the modern plays of Shaw and Ibsen; Minnie Maddern Fiske championed the works of Ibsen and a style of acting called the school of psychological naturalism.

Type
Research Article
Information
Theatre Survey , Volume 32 , Issue 1 , May 1991 , pp. 85 - 105
Copyright
Copyright © American Society for Theatre Research 1991

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Wilson, Garff B., Three Hundred Years of American Drama and Theatre, 2d ed. (Englevroood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1982), 163–78, 201–206.Google Scholar

2 The same distinctions were not necessarily made by Julia Marlowe's contemporaries, of course; “romantic” and “classic” actors, for example, would have had certain characteristics in common when compared to “naturalistic” ones.

3 Wilson, 170.

4 Wilson, 202.

5 Hewitt, Bernard, Theatre U.S.A., 1668–1957 (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1959), 220.Google Scholar

6 Hewitt, 227.

7 Hewitt, 250.

8 Russell, Charles Edward, Julia Marlowe: Her Life and Art (New York: D. Apppleton, 1926), 37.Google Scholar

9 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 203, 37.Google Scholar

10 Sothern, Edward H., Julia Marlowe's Story, ed. Downey, Fairfax (New York: Rinehart, 1954), 118.Google Scholar

11 Sothern, 115.

12 New York Times, 2 October 1927.

13 Sothern, 99–100.

14 Marlowe, Julia, “The Essentials of Stage Success,” Theatre (December 1901), 14–15.Google Scholar

15 Wilson, 175, 202.

16 Wagenknecht, Edward, Seven Daughters of the Theater (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1966), 125.Google Scholar

17 Marlowe's method was a departure from the conventional acting style of her younger days, but it was not unprecedented. Macready had earlier done the same although he, like Marlowe, familiarized himself with other actors’ arrangements and business. As part of her lengthy preparation for a role, Marlowe read every commentary available and reviewed the stage history of the play, but then she would begin anew with an earlier text.

18 Wagenknecht, 122.

19 Marlowe, , “Essentials,” 14.Google Scholar

20 Sothern, 82.

21 Marlowe, , “Essentials,” 14.Google Scholar

22 Marlowe, , “Essentials,” 14.Google Scholar

23 Marlowe, Julia, “The Eloquence of Silence,” Green Book Magasine 9 (March 1913), 393.Google Scholar

24 Marlowe, , “Eloquence,” 394.Google Scholar

25 Sothem, 103–104.

26 Sothern, 104.

27 Marlowe, , “Essentials,” 15.Google Scholar

28 Russell, Charles Edward, “A Notable Achievement: Miss Marlowe and Mr. Sothern in Shakespeare,” Critic (December 1904), 529.Google Scholar

29 Sothern, 199.

30 Sothern, 216–17.

31 New York limes, 7 October 1919.

32 New York Times, 6 November 1923.

33 Beckerman, Bernard and Siegman, Howard, eds., On Stage (New York: Quadrangle, 1973), xxv–xxvii.Google Scholar

34 Sothern, 165.

35 Marlowe, Julia, “Reminiscences of an Actress,” Philharmonie (July 1901), 146–47.Google Scholar

36 Sothern, 164.

37 Wagenknecht, 22.

38 Marlowe, , “Reminiscences,” 148.Google Scholar

39 Wagenknecht, 127.

40 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 365.Google Scholar

41 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 366–67.Google Scholar

42 Sothern, 152–53.

43 Sothern, 194; Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 365, 670.Google Scholar

44 Winter, William, Vagrant Memories: Being Further Recollections of Other Days (New York: George H. Doran, 1915), 469.Google Scholar

45 Winter, William, “The Art of Julia Marlowe,” Century (June 1915), 215.Google Scholar

46 Marlowe, , “Reminiscences,” 143.Google Scholar

47 Russell, , JuUa Marlowe, 171.Google Scholar

48 Sothern, 186.

49 New York Times, 30 October 1923.

50 Barry, John, Julia Marlowe (Boston: R. G. Badger, 1899), 44–45.Google Scholar

51 Sogliuzzo, Richard A., “E H. Sothern and Julia Marlowe on the Art of Acting,” Theatre Survey 11 (1970), 192.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

52 Marlowe, , “Reminiscences,” 141.Google Scholar

53 Firkins, Oscar, “Sothern-Marlowe—An Estimate,” Theatre (October 1923), 121, ix.Google Scholar

54 Firkins, ix.

55 Russell, , “Dramatic Achievement,” 531.Google Scholar

56 Jones, Edward T., Jones, Janet Wilson, and Bayers, Paul S., eds., Notable American Women 1607–1950: A Biographical Dictionary, 3 vols. (Cambridge, MA: Belknap, 1971), 499.Google Scholar

57 New York Tunes 22 November 1921.

58 New York Times 22 November 1921.

59 Sothern, 224.

60 Mordden, Ethan, The American Theatre (New York: Oxford University Press, 1981), 81.Google Scholar

61 Atkinson, Brooks, Broadway (New York: Macmillan, 1970), 198Google Scholar; Atkinson, Brooks and Hirshfield, Albert, The lively Years: 1920–1973 (New York: Association, 1973), 5.Google Scholar

62 Sothern, 223–24.

63 Downey, Fairfax, éd., Julia Marlowe's Story by Sothern, E. H. (New York: Rinehart, 1954), 233–34.Google Scholar

64 Shattuck, Charles, Shakespeare on the American Stage: From Booth and Barrea to Sothern and Marlowe (Washington, DCFolger Shakespeare Library, 1987), 256.Google Scholar

65 Shattuck, 257.

66 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 171.Google Scholar

67 All of the following citations from Cymbeline arc taken from Julia Marlowe's promptbook, New York Public Library.

68 New York Times, 3 October 1923.

69 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 529.Google Scholar

70 Sothern, 222–23.

71 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 531.Google Scholar

72 New York Tunes, 3 October 1923.

73 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 199.Google Scholar

74 Russell, , Julia Marlowe, 199.Google Scholar

75 Mantle, Burns, ed., The Best Plays of 1923–24 (Boston: Small, Maynard, 1924), 5.Google Scholar

76 Duerr, Edwin, The Length and Depth of Acting (New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1962), 394.Google Scholar

77 Winter, , Vagrant Memories, 448.Google Scholar