Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-lrf7s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-28T13:38:59.617Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Ideology and Its Ethics: Maria Da̧browska's Jewish (and Polish) Problem

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 January 2017

Rachel Feldhay Brenner
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article is part of a project that examines Polish writers' diaristic responses to the Warsaw ghetto and to the Holocaust in general. Rachel Feldhay Brenner examines Maria Da̧browska's response in the context of her prewar attitude to Polish Jews, which was shaped by her nationalistic ideology of Poland's messianic position among the nations. Although Da̧browska publicly denounced Endecja and its antisemitism, in private she cultivated a powerful sense of ressentiment toward the Jews, seeing Jews as outsiders who stood in the way of Poland realizing its special mission. This attitude persisted during the Holocaust and explains Da̧browska's emotional disengagement in the face of Jewish extermination. In the postwar years, her resentment became more pronounced, as even Jewish suffering in the Holocaust became an object of competition and envy. Da̧browska's response to the Holocaust offers a poignant example of the impact of ideological beliefs on emotional and ethical aspects of human interaction.

Type
Articles
Information
Slavic Review , Volume 70 , Issue 2 , Summer 2011 , pp. 399 - 421
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Slavic, East European, and Eurasian Studies. 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. See Engel, David, “On Reconciling the Histories of Two Chosen People,” AmericanHistorical Review 114, no. 4 (October 2009): 914–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2. Jan Blońiski, “Biedni Polacy patrza na getto,” Tygodnik Powszechny, 11 January 1987. The title is a paraphrase of Czeslaw Milosz's famous poem “A Poor Christian Looks at the Ghetto,” which he wrote in 1943 at the time of the ghetto uprising. The persona in the poem, who calls himself “a Jew of the New Testament,” accuses himself of not fulfilling the moral obligation to help the Jews who perished in the ghetto. See Nathan, Leonard and Quinn, Arthur, The Poet's Work: An Introduction to Czesiaw Miłosz (Cambridge, Mass., 1991), 17–18 Google Scholar.

3. See, among others, Polonsky, Antony, ed., “My Brother's Keeper?” Recent Polish Debateson the Holocaust (New York, 1990)Google Scholar; Steinlauf, Michael C., Bondage to the Dead: Poland and the Memory of the Holocaust (Syracuse, 1997)Google Scholar; Zimmerman, Joshua D., ed., Contested Memories:Poles and Jews during the Holocaust and Its Aftermath (New Brunswick, N.J., 2003)Google Scholar; Cherry, Robert and Orla-Bukowska, Annamaria, eds., Rethinking Poles and Jews: Troubled Past, Future (Lanham, Md., 2007)Google Scholar; Glowacka, Dorota and Zylińska, Joanna, Imaginary Neighbors: MediatingPolish-Jewish Relations after the Holocaust (Lincoln, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4. See, for instance, Steinlauf, Bondage to the Dead, esp. 89-121 (“Memory Reconstructed“).

5. See, for instance, Shapiro, Robert Moses, ed., Holocaust Chronicles: Individualizing theHolocaust through Diaries and Other Contemporaneous Personal Accounts (Hoboken, N.J., 1999)Google Scholar; Leociak, Jacek, Text in the Face of Destruction: Accounts from the Warsaw Ghetto Reconsidered, trans. Harris, Emma (Warsaw, 2004)Google Scholar; Zapruder, Alexandra, Salvaged Pages: Young Writers’ Diaries of the Holocaust (New Haven, 2002)Google Scholar; Vice, Sue, Children Writing the Holocaust (New York, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Garbarini, Alexandra, Numbered Days: Diaries and the Holocaust (New Haven, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6. For documentation by non-Jews, see Tych, Feliks and Tych, Lucyna, “Świadkowie Shoah: Zagtady Zaglada Zydów w polskich pamietnikach i wspomnieniach,” in Tych, Feliks, Dlugi Cien Zagtady: Szkice Historyane (Warsaw, 1999), 9–55 Google Scholar. I am indebted to Mrs. Lucyna Tych for her archival research into non-Jewish documents, which was gready helpful to my work. For die minimal attention paid to the individuals whose diaries I consult, see Jan Tomasz Gross, “Two Memoirs from the Edge of Destruction,” in Shapiro, ed., HolocaustChronicles, 225. Gross juxtaposes the diary of Maria Dąbrowska, whom he brands an antisemite, and the diary of Dr. Zygmunt Klukowski, which he considers proof of the Polish population's awareness of the Holocaust. Magdalena M. Opalski, “The Holocaust in the Diaries of Zofia Nalkowska, Maria Dąbrowska, andjaroslaw Iwaszkiewicz,” in Shapiro, ed., Holocaust Chronicles, 231-40, claims that these diaries present evidence of prevailing Polish detachment from the fate of the Jewish people. In Brodzka-Wald, Alina, Krawczynska, Dorota, and Leociak, jacek, eds., Literaturapolska wobeczagtady (Warsaw, 2000)Google Scholar, Hanna Kirchner, “Holocaust w dziennikach Zofii Nalkowskiej i Marii Dabrowskiej” accuses Opalski of intentional misreading and claims that the diaries of Nalkowska and Dąbrowska evince identification with die Jews and die desire to help the victims. These studies continue the patterns of the contested memories about Polish attitudes toward Jews during the Holocaust.

7. Nalkowska burned part of her diaries when she heard the Gestapo in die neighboring apartment.

8. The discussion of Dąbrowska's fictional work does not lie within the scope of this article. Let me just note that her literary writing combined patriotic love for Poland with universal moral values. Her prewar career started with the novel Ludzie stamtad (1926); the acclaimed Noce i dnie (1932-34) followed. Dąbrowska novels are grounded in Polish rural and small-town life, and her literary style combined Romanticism and realism. For a discussion of her work, see, for instance, Folejewski, Zbigniew, Maria Dąbrowska (New York, 1967), 20–23 Google Scholar.

9. Tadeusz, Drewnowski, Wyproiuadzka źczyśćća:Burzliwe życie pośmiertne Marii Dabrowskiej (Warsaw, 2006), 6 Google Scholar: “Slonimski kept declaring that nobody since Stefan Zeromski had such moral authority.” Slonimski was of Jewish origin.

10. Polacy o Żydach: Zbiór artykułów z przedruku (Warsaw, 1937).

11. Drewnowski, Tadeusz, Rzect russowska: O pisarstwie Marii Dabrowskiej (Kraków, 1981), 29 Google Scholar.

12. Drewnowski, Wyprowadzka z czyśćća, 5.

13. I was unable to obtain a copy of the publication in the United States. My quotations are taken from the full text sent to me by Dr. Slawomir Buryla with Drewnowski's permission. I thank them both for their kind cooperation.

14. Biblioteka Narodowa, Muzeum Literatury (BN/ML), CD no. 8, vol. 14, 8.XII.1955- 31.XII.1956.

15. Drewnowski, Wyprowadzka z czyśćća, 29.

16. Ibid., 184.

17. Ibid., 186-87.

18. Mencwel, Andrzej, “Dąbrowska wobec Stalinizmu,” Twórczość 53, no. 8 (621) (August 1997): 82 Google Scholar.

19. Borkowska, Grazyna, Maria Dąbrowska i Stanislaw Stempowski (Kraków, 1999), 114–15Google Scholar.

20. Drewnowski, Wyprowadzka z czyśćća, 184.

21. Gross, “Two Memoirs from the Edge of Destruction,” 224.

22. See 14 November 1940 in BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 9, rekopis, zeszyt 13.VI.1940- 18.XI.1940. See 22 April 1943, 26 April 1943, 27 April 1943, and 12 May 1943 in BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 9, zeszyt 2.IV.1943-1.IX.1943.

23. I realize that the concept of nationalism exceeds the component of ethnicity as defined by cultural features such as language and religion. The distinction between ethnicity and race also presents problems, as Eriksen, Thomas Hylland claims: “ethnicity can assume many forms, and since ethnic ideologies tend to stress common descent among their members, the distinction between race and ethnicity is a problematic one.” Eriksen, Ethnicity and Nationalism: Anthropological Perspectives, 2d ed. (London, 1993), 5 Google Scholar. This is certainly true of Polish Jews in the context of Polish nationalism, in which prejudicial perception blended the cultural and religious uniqueness of the Jews with the supposed distinctiveness of the hereditary characteristics of their “race.” My use of the terms nationalism and ethnicity with relation to Gentile-Polish and Polish-Jewish contacts includes the components of religion and racism.

24. Drewnowski, Rzea. russowska, 42-48. The Filaret motto was “a free human being in free Poland.“

25. Ibid., 47.

26. Ibid., 48.

27. Ibid., 50.

28. Abramowski, Edward, Filozofia spolecina: Wybr Wyborpism (Warsaw, 1965) 209.Google Scholar See also Drewnowski, Rzecz russowska, 53-57.

29. Dąbrowska, Maria, Zycie i dzieto Edwarda Abramowskiego (Warsaw, 1925)Google Scholar.

30. Dąbrowska, Maria, “O czlowieku pracowitym i czlowieku spolecznym,” Zaranie, 1913, no. 17, quoted in Drewnowski, Rzecz russowska, 72 Google Scholar.

31. Dąbrowska, Życie i dzido Ediuarda Abramowskiego, 30.

32. Drewnowski, Rzecz russowska, 46.

33. Ibid., 46-47.

34. Mickiewicz quoted in Janion, Maria and Żmigrodzka, Maria, Romantyzm i historia (Warsaw, 1978), 52 Google Scholar. On the issue of “Universal Brotherhood,” see Walicki, Andrzej, Philosophyand Romantic Nationalism: The Case of Poland (Oxford, 1982), 249 Google Scholar.

35. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 2, 11.XI.1917-31.XII.1927.

36. In my forthcoming article, “Warsaw Polish Writers and Their Wartime Diaries: The Case of Jaroslaw Iwaszkiewicz,” I discuss the prevailing desire of Polish men and women of letters to “Europeanize” Poland. European culture was undeniably their unsurpassed model. The independence of the Polish state raised hopes among the Polish intelligentsia that Poland would become an equal contributor to European culture. See, for instance, Drobniak, Piotr, Jedność i roinorodność: Europa w tworaości Jaroslawa Iwaszkiewiaa (Wroclaw, 2000)Google Scholar.

37. The Polish Minority Treaty, signed in 1919 at the Versailles Peace conference, promised to protect the rights of all minorities in the Polish state. The Constitution of the Polish Republic of 17 March 1921 reconfirmed the spirit of the treaty, guaranteeing freedom of conscience and religion to all Polish citizens as well as equal rights regardless of religious denomination.

38. See, for instance, Paczkowski, Andrzej, “Introduction: Twenty Years of Independence,“ The Spring Will Be Ours: Poland and the Poles from Occupation to Freedom, trans. Cave, Jane (University Park, 2003), 21–23 Google Scholar.

39. See Steinlauf, Bondage to theDead, 12-16.

40. Pieńkowski, Stanislaw, “Dwa pytania,” Rozwój, 9 May 1926 Google Scholar.

41. Dmowski, Roman [Goj], “My a hitleryzm,” Rozwój, 7 November 1932 Google Scholar, quoted in Rudnicki, Szymon, Równi ale niezupetnie (Warsaw, 2008), 101 Google Scholar.

42. See, for instance, Paczkowski, The Spring Will Be Ours, 17.

43. I am referring to Andrzej Walicki's distinction between “political” pluralistic nationalism, the product of western Enlightenment thinking that promoted humanitarian ideals and progressive democratic sovereignty, and “cultural” linguistic nationalism that promoted “a closed and monolithic society with [an] authoritarian government.” Walicki, , The Enlightenment and the Birth of Modern Nationhood: Polish Political Thought from Noble Republicanismto Tadeusz Kosciuszko, trans. Harris, Emma (Notre Dame, 1989), 2, 5 Google Scholar.

44. Steinlauf, Bondage to the Dead, 16-17.

45. For a discussion of Polish antisemitism in the interwar period, see, for instance, Gutman, Yisrael, “Polish Antisemitism between the Wars: An Overview,” in Gutman, Yisrael, Mendelsohn, Ezra, Reinharz, Jehuda, and Shmeruk, Chone, eds., The Jews of Poland betweenTwo World Wars (Hanover, 1989), 97–109 Google Scholar; Emanuel Melzer, “Antisemitism in the Last Years of the Second Republic,” in Gutman, Mendelsohn, Reinharz, and Shmeruk, eds., The Jewsof Poland between Two World Wars, 126-41; and Rudnicki, Równi, ale niezupetnie.

46. Scheler, Max, Ressentiment, trans. Coser, Lewis B. and Holdheim, William W. (Milwaukee, 2007), 25, 29, 30 Google Scholar. Emphasis in the original.

47. Dąbrowska, Maria, “Doroczny wstyd,” Dziennik Popularity, 24 November 1936, no. 43, p. 3 Google Scholar.

48. The “bench ghetto” involved relegating Jewish students to specially assigned back seats in lecture halls.

49. For an extensive historical survey of the campaign against Jewish students, see “Od numerous clausus do numerous nullus,” in Rudnicki, Równi, ale niezupeinie, 135-56.

50. See Polacy o Żydach.

51. “Her words,” claims Rudnicki, “[which] reflected the opinions and the position of the best part of the Polish intelligentsia, gave moral support to the beaten [Jewish students]. Rudnicki, Rowni, ale niezupeinie, 150. See also Libera, Zdzislaw, Maria Dąbrowska (Warsaw, 1975), 76–77 Google Scholar.

52. Entry for 4 November 1936, BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 9, 26.IX.1934-31.XII.1936.

53. See, for instance, Drewnowski, Rzecz russowska, 70.

54. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 9, 26.IX.1934-31.XII.1936.

55. Dąbrowska, “Doroczny wstyd,” 3.

56. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 5, 1.I.1937-7.IX.1939.

57. A right-wing literary-art weekly (1931-1939) that became radical, Prosto z Mostu was considered the main nationalistic publication featuring antisemitic articles. Stanislaw Piasecki began editing it in 1935.

58. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 5, 1.I.1937-7.IX.1939. Emphasis in the original.

59. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 5,1.I.1937-7.IX.1939.

60. Ibid.

61. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 5, 1.I.1937-7.IX.1939. Stach [Stanislaw] Stempowski, Dąbrowska's partner and mentor, was an open-minded intellectual and an enlightened individual. It seems that he urged Dąbrowska to confront publicly the antisemiuc incidents at the universities. See Borkowska, Maria Dąbrowska, 17—19, 105-6.

62. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 5,1.I.1937-7.IX.1939.

63. Iwaszkiewiczowie, Anna andjaroslaw, Listy 1922-1926, ed. Bojanowska, Malgorzata and Cieślak, Ewa (Warsaw, 1998), 195, 180, 205 Google Scholar.

64. Iwaszkiewicz, Jaroslaw, Notatki 1939-1945, ed. Zawada, Andrzej (Wroclaw, 1991)Google Scholar.

65. See, for instance, Iwaszkiewicz's, Jaroslaw recollections of his prewar and postwar Jewish friends, Julian Tuwim, Jan Lechon, Antoni Slonimski, and Arnold Szyfman, in AlejaPrzyjacidi (Warsaw, 1984)Google Scholar.

66. See Fein's, Helen notion that most Poles did not regard the Jews as part of “their universe of obligation.” Fein, Accounting/or Genocide: National Responses andjeioish Victimizationduring the Holocaust (Chicago, 1979), 33 Google Scholar.

67. Rudnicki, Adolf, “Wielki Stefan Konecki,” Żywe i martwe morze (Warsaw, 1956), 5 8– 89 Google Scholar. I am grateful to a reviewer of my article for directing my attention to this story.

68. Borkowska, Maria Dąbrowska, 113-14.

69. Entry for 19 January 1939, BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 5, 1.I.1937-7.IX.1939.

70. Entry for 2 June 1944, BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 10, rekopis, zeszyt 2.IX.1943.

71. BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 9, zeszyt 2.IV.1943-1.IX.1943.

72. Dąbrowska, Maria, “Mialo śie ku switaniu,” A teraz wypijmy … : Opowiadania (Warsaw, 1981), 179 Google Scholar.

73. Dąbrowska, Maria, Przygody atowieka myślQcego (Warsaw, 1972), 394–413 Google Scholar.

74. BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 9, zeszyt2.IV.1943-l.IX.1944, s. 551-82.

75. BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 10, rekopis, zeszyt 2.IX.1943-5.X.1945.

76. For Warsaw deprivations, see, for instance, Lucas, Richard C., The Forgotten Holocaust:The Poles under German Occupation 1939-1944, 2d ed. (New York, 2001), 30 Google Scholar. The moral disintegration of the Polish population was recorded in the war diaries of Iwaszkiewicz and Wylezyńska.

77. Ibid., 10-12.

78. See, for instance,Jerzy Andrzewski's Wielki Tydzień (1945), a short novel he wrote during the ghetto uprising in 1943 in which the Poles persecute the Jews in hiding but also engage in crimes against fellow Poles. While the novel provides a broad spectrum of responses to the Jews, such as Christian pity and courageous assistance to the ghetto fighters, the story indicts the widespread moral disintegration within Polish society.

79. Gross, Jan T., Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz. An Essay in HistoricalInterpretation (New York, 2006), 5 Google Scholar.

80. BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 10, zeszyt 2.IX.1943-5.X.1945.

81. See, for instance, Grabowski, Jan, “Ja lego zyda znam!” Szantaiowanie Zydoiv iv Warszawie,1939-1943 (Warsaw, 2004)Google Scholar.

82. On die right-wing press, see Szapiro, Pawel, Wojna zydowsko-niemiecka: Polskaprasakonspiracyjna 1943-1944 o powslaniu w getcie Warszawy (London, 1992)Google Scholar. On Poles’ preoccupation with dieir own fate, see, for instance, Polonsky, Antony, “Beyond Condemnation: Apologetics and Apologies: On die Complexity of Polish Behavior toward the Jews during the Second World War,” in Frankel, Jonathan, ed., TheFate of the European Jews, 1939-1945 (Oxford, 1997), 190–224 Google Scholar.

83. Biblioteka Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego (BUW), BN/ML, CD no. 9, zeszyt 63, 17.XI.1959-2.III.1960.

84. See Jan Gross's appreciation of the Polish organization of the struggle against the German invader. Gross, Fear, 5-6.

85. The question of which of the parties suffered more is a consistent feature of Polish-Jewish debates. A survey of this issue can be found in Zimmerman, Joshua, “Introduction: Changing Perceptions in the Historiography of Polish-Jewish Relations during the Second World War,” in Zimmerman, , ed., Contested Memories, 1–19 Google Scholar.

86. BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 10, rekopis, zeszyt 31.1.1947-16.VI.1947.

87. Drewnowski, Wyprowadzka z czyśćća, 189.

88. 20 July 1960, Muzeum Literackie, Warsaw, Dziat Rekopisów inw. 4608.

89. Tel Aviv, 20 November 1960, Muzeum Literackie, Warsaw, Dzial Rekopisow inw. 4608.

90. BUW, BN/ML, CD no. 9, zeszyt 74, 11.IV1960-13.V.1960, s. 1320-1361-19.V1II. 1960.

91. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 10, 7.VH.1950-1.IV195].

92. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 13, 2.I.1954-5.XII.1955.

93. BN/ML, CD no. 4, vol. 10, rekopis, zeszyt 31.1.1947-16.VI.1947, s. 864-84.

94. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 8, 5.XII.1948-17.XI.1949.

95. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 9, 18.XI.1949-7.VII.1950.

96. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 14, 8.XII.1955-31.XII.1956.

97. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 7, 26.XII.1947-5.XII. 1948.

98. BN/ML, CD no. 8, vol. 7, 26.XII.1947-5.XII.1948.