Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The scale of it all: postcanine tooth size, the taxon-level effect, and the universality of Gould's scaling law

  • Lynn E. Copes (a1) and Gary T. Schwartz (a2)

Abstract

In a seminal paper in 1975, Gould proposed that postcanine occlusal area (PCOA) should scale metabolically (0.75) with body mass across mammals. By regressing PCOA against skull length in a small sample of large-bodied herbivorous mammals, Gould provided some marginal support for this hypothesis, which he then extrapolated as a universal scaling law for Mammalia. Since then, many studies have sought to confirm this scaling relationship within a single order and have found equivocal support for Gould's assertion. In part, this may be related to the use of proxies for both PCOA and body mass, small sample sizes, or the influence of a “taxon-level effect,” rendering Gould's scaling “universal” problematic.

Our goal was to test the universality of Gould's prediction and the impact of the taxon-level effect on regressions of tooth size on body mass in a large extant mammalian sample (683 species spanning 14 orders). We tested for the presence of two types of taxon-level effect that may influence the acceptance or rejection of hypothesized scaling coefficients. The hypotheses of both metabolic and isometric scaling can be rejected in Mammalia, but not in all sub-groups therein. The level of data aggregation also influences the interpretation of the scaling relationship. Because the scaling relationship of tooth size to body mass is highly dependent on both the taxonomic level of analysis and the mathematical methods used to organize the data, paleontologists attempting to retrodict body mass from fossilized dental remains must be aware of the effect that sample composition may have on their results.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Agrawal, A. A. 2004. The metabolic theory of ecology. Ecology 85:17901791.
Aiello, L., and Wood, B. 1994. Cranial variables as predictors of hominine body mass. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 95:409426.
Allen, A., Brown, J., and Gillooly, J. 2002. Global biodiversity, biochemical kinetics, and the energetic-equivalence rule. Science 297:15451548.
Anapol, F., and Lee, S. 1994. Morphological adaptation to diet in platyrrhine primates. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 94:239261.
Anapol, F., Turner, T., Mott, C., and Jolly, C. 2005. Comparative postcranial body shape and locomotion in Chlorocebus aethiops and Cercopithecus mitis . American Journal of Physical Anthropology 127:231239.
Anderson, J., Rahn, H., and Prange, H. 1979. Scaling of supportive tissue mass. Quarterly Review of Biology 54:139148.
Biewener, A. 2005. Biomechanical consequences of scaling. Journal of Experimental Biology 208:16651676.
Biknevicius, A., and Ruff, C. 1992. Structure of the mandibular corpus and its relationship to feeding behaviors in extant carnivorans. Journal of Zoology 228:478507.
Blondel, J. 1987. From biogeography to life history theory: a multithematic approach illustrated by the biogeography of vertebrates. Journal of Biogeography 14:405422.
Boekschoten, G., and Sondaar, P. 1972. The Pleistocene of the Katharo Basin (Crete) and its hippopotamus. Bijdragen tot de Diekunde 36:1744.
Brown, J., and Nicoletto, P. 1991. Spatial scaling of species composition: body masses of North American land mammals. American Naturalist 138:14781512.
Brown, J., Marquet, P., and Taper, M. 1993. Evolution of body size: consequences of an energetic definition of fitness. American Naturalist 142:573584.
Brown, J., Gillooly, J., Allen, A., Savage, V., and West, G. 2004. Toward a metabolic theory of ecology. Ecology 85:17711789.
Brown, P., Sutikna, T., Morwood, M., Soejono, R., Jatmiko, E. Saptomo, and Due, R. 2004. A new small-bodied hominin from the Late Pleistocene of Flores, Indonesia. Nature 431:10551061.
Cheverud, J., Dow, M. M., and Leutenegger, W. 1985. The quantitative assessment of phylogenetic constraints in comparative analyses: sexual dimorphism in body weight among primates. Evolution 396:13351351.
Churchfield, S. 1996. Ecology of very small terrestrial mammals. Symposia of the Zoological Society of London 69:259276.
Conroy, G. C. 1987. Problems of body-weight estimation in fossil primates. International Journal of Primatology 82:115137.
Corruccini, R., and Henderson, A. 1978. Multivariate dental allometry in primates. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 48:205208.
Cottingham, K., and Zens, M. 2004. Metabolic rate opens a grand vista on ecology. Ecology 85:18051807.
Creighton, G. 1980. Static allometry of mammalian teeth and the correlation of tooth size and body size in contemporary mammals. Journal of Zoology London 191:435443.
Cuozzo, F. P. 2001. Craniodental body mass estimators in the dwarf bushbaby (Galagoides). American Journal of Physical Anthropology 1152:187190.
Damuth, J. D. 1990. Problems in estimating body masses of archaic ungulates using dental measurements. Pp. 229254 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Damuth, J. D., and MacFadden, B. J., eds. 1990. Body size in mammalian paleobiology: estimation and biological implications. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Dayan, T., Wool, D., and Simberloff, D. 2002. Variation and covariation of skulls and teeth: modern carnivores and the interpretation of fossil mammals. Paleobiology 28:508526.
Eisenberg, J. F. 1990. The behavioral/ecological significance of body size in the Mammalia. Pp. 2538 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Enquist, B., Economo, E., Huxman, T., Allen, A., Ignace, D., and Gillooly, J. 2003. Scaling metabolism from organisms to ecosystems. Nature 423:639642.
Fa, J. E., and Purvis, A. 1997. Body size, diet and population density in Afrotropical forest mammals: a comparison with neotropical species. Journal of Animal Ecology 66:98112.
Feldman, H. A., and McMahon, T. 1983. The 3/4 mass exponent for energy metabolism is not a statistical artifact. Respiration Physiology 52:149163.
Felsenstein, J. 1985. Phylogenies and the comparative method. American Naturalist 125:115.
Fleagle, J. G. 1985. Size and adaptation in primates. Pp. 119 in Jungers, W. L., ed. Size and scaling in primate biology. Plenum, New York.
Fooden, J. 1990. The bear macaque, Macaca arctoides: a systematic review. Journal of Human Evolution 19:607686.
Fortelius, M. 1985. Ungulate cheek teeth: developmental, functional, and evolutionary interrelations. Acta Zoologica Fennica 190:176.
Fortelius, M. 1990. Problems with using fossil teeth to estimate body sizes of extinct mammals. Pp. 207228 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Garland, T. 1992. Rate tests for phenotypic evolution using phylogenetically independent contrasts. American Naturalist 140:509519.
Garland, T., Midford, P., and Ives, A. 1999. An introduction to phylogenetically based statistical methods, with a new method for confidence intervals on ancestral values. American Zoologist 39:374388.
Garland, T., and Ives, A. 2000. Using the past to predict the present: confidence intervals for regression equations in phylogenetic comparative methods. American Naturalist 155:346364.
Garland, T., Bennett, A., and Rezende, E. L. 2005. Phylogenetic approaches in comparative physiology. Journal of Experimental Biology 2086:30153035.
Garn, S., Lewis, A., and Kerewsky, R. 1968. The magnitude and implications of the relationship between tooth size and body size. Archives of Oral Biology 13:128131.
Gingerich, P. 1974. Size variability of the teeth in living mammals and the diagnosis of closely related sympatric fossil species. Journal of Paleontology 48:895903.
Gingerich, P. 1977. Correlation of tooth size and body size in living hominoid primates, with a note on relative brain size in Aegyptopithecus and Proconsul . American Journal of Physical Anthropology 47:395398.
Gingerich, P. D., and Smith, B. H. 1985. Allometric scaling in the dentition of primates and insectivores. Pp. 257272 in Jungers, W. L., ed. Size and scaling in primate biology. Plenum, New York.
Gingerich, P., Smith, B. H., and Rosenberg, K. 1982. Allometric scaling in the dentition of primates and prediction of body weight from tooth size in fossils. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 58:81100.
Goldstein, S., Post, D., and Melnick, D. 1978. An analysis of cercopithcoid odontometrics. 1. The scaling of the maxillary dentition. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 49:517532.
Gould, S. 1975. On the scaling of tooth size in mammals. American Zoologist 15:351362.
Grand, T. I. 1990. The functional anatomy of body mass. Pp. 3948 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Harestad, A., and Bunnel, F. 1979. Home range and body weight—a reevaluation. Ecology 60:389402.
Harvey, P. H., Pagel, M., and Rees, J. 1991. Mammalian metabolism and life histories. American Naturalist 137:556566.
Hastings, I. 1996. The genetics and physiology of size reduction in mice. Symposia of the Zoological Society of London 69:129142.
Henderson, A., and Corruccini, R. 1976. Relationship between tooth size and body size in American blacks. Journal of Dental Research 55:9496.
Herring, S. 1985. Morphological correlates of masticatory patterns in peccaries and pigs. Journal of Mammalogy 66:603617.
Hershkovitz, P. 1970. Notes on Tertiary platyrrhine monkeys and description of a new genus from the Late Miocene of Colombia. Folia Primatologica 12:137.
Heusner, A. 1982. Energy metabolism and body size. 1. Is the 0.75 mass exponent of Kleiber's equation a statistical artifact? Respiratory Physiology 48:112.
Hill, A. 1950. The dimensions of animals and their muscular dynamics. Science Progress 38:209230.
Iwaniuk, A., Pellis, S., and Whishaw, I. 2000. The relative importance of body size, phylogeny, locomotion, and diet in the evolution of forelimb dexterity in fissiped carnivores (Carnivora). Canadian Journal of Zoology 78:11101125.
Janis, C. 1979. Mastication in the hyrax and its relevance to ungulate dental evolution. Paleobiology 5:5059.
Janis, C. 1986. An estimation of tooth volume and hypsodonty indices in ungulate mammals, and the correlation of these factors with dietary preferences. Mémoires du Museum d'Histoire Naturelle de Paris 53:367387.
Janis, C. 1990a. Correlation of cranial and dental variables with body size in ungulates and macropodoids. Pp. 255300 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Janis, C. 1990b. Correlation of cranial and dental variables with dietary preferences in mammals: a comparison of macropodoids and ungulates. Memoirs of the Queensland Museum 28:249266.
Johanson, D. 1974. Some metric aspects of the permanent and deciduous dentition of the pygmy chimpanzee (Pan paniscus) . American Journal of Physical Anthropology 41:3948.
Kanazawa, E., and Rosenberger, A. 1989. Interspecific allometry of the mandible, dental arch, and molar area in anthropoid primates: functional morphology of masticatory components. Primates 30:543560.
Kappeler, P. 1996. Causes and consequences of life-history variation among strepsirhine primates. American Naturalist 148:868891.
Kaspari, M. 2004. Using the metabolic theory of ecology to predict global patterns of abundance. Ecology 85:18001802.
Kay, R. 1975. Reply to “Allometry and early hominids.” Science 189:63.
Kay, R. 1994. “Giant” tamarin from the Miocene of Colombia. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 95:333353.
Kieser, J. A. 1990. Allometric relations of tooth size. Pp. 112125 in Human adult odontometrics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Kieser, J., and Groeneveld, H. 1990. Static intraspecific allometry of the dentition in Otolemur crassicaudatus . Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 98:295306.
Kieser, J., and Groeneveld, H. 1991. Craniodental allometry in the African wild cat, Felis lybica . Journal of Mammalogy 72:578582.
Kleiber, M. 1932. Body size and metabolism. Hilgardia 61:315353.
Kleiber, M. 1947. Body size and metabolic rate. Physiology Reviews 27:511541.
Koehl, M. A. R., and Wolcott, B. 2004. Can function at the organismal level explain ecological patterns? Ecology 85:18081810.
Kozlowski, J., and Konarzewski, M. 2004. Is West, Brown and Enquist's model of allometric scaling mathematically correct and biologically relevant? Functional Ecology 18:283289.
Legendre, S., and Roth, C. 1988. Correlation of carnassial tooth size and body weight in recent carnivores (Mammalia). Historical Biology 1:8598.
Leigh, S., Shah, N., and Buchanan, L. 2003. Ontogeny and phylogeny in papionin primates. Journal of Human Evolution 45:285316.
Leutenegger, W. 1982. Scaling of sexual dimorphism in body weight and canine size in primates. Folia Primatologica 37:163176.
Marquet, P., Labra, F., and Maurer, B. 2004. Metabolic ecology: linking individuals to ecosystems. Ecology 85:17941796.
Matsumoto, H. 1926. Contribution to the knowledge of the fossil Hyracoidea of the Fayûm, Egypt, with description of several new species. Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 61:253350.
McHenry, H. 1984. Relative cheek-tooth size in Australopithecus . American Journal of Physical Anthropology 64:297306.
McHenry, H., and Berger, L. 1998. Body proportions of Australopithecus afarensis and A. africanus and the origin of the genus Homo . Journal of Human Evolution 35:122.
McMahon, T. 1973. Size and shape in biology. Science 179:12011204.
McNab, B. 1988. Complications inherent in scaling the basal rate of metabolism in mammals. Quarterly Review of Biology 63:2554.
McNab, B. 1990. The physiological significance of body size. Pp. 1124 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
McNab, B. 2003. Metabolism: ecology shapes bird bioenergetics. Nature 426:620621.
Niven, J., and Scharlemann, J. 2005. Do insect metabolic rates at rest and during flight scale with body mass? Biology Letters 1:346349.
Pagel, M., and Harvey, P. 1988. The taxon-level problem in the evolution of mammalian brain size: facts and artifacts. American Naturalist 132:344359.
Pagel, M., and Harvey, P. 1989. Taxonomic differences in the scaling of brain on body weight among mammals. Science 244:15891593.
Palkovacs, E. 2003. Explaining adaptive shifts in body size on islands: a life history approach. Oikos 103:3744.
Pan, R., and Oxnard, C. 2001. Metrical dental analysis on golden monkey (Rhinopithecus roxellana). Primates 42:7589.
Pan, R., Peng, Y., Ye, Z., and Yu, F. 1993. Sexual dimorphism of skull and dentition in Phayre's leaf monkey (Presbytis phayrei). Folia Primatologica 60:230236.
Perzigian, A. 1981. Allometric analysis of dental variation in a human population. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 54:341345.
Pilbeam, D., and Gould, S. 1974. Size and scaling in human evolution. Science 186:892901.
Pirie, C. 1978. Allometric scaling in the postcanine dentition with reference to primate diets. Primates 19:583591.
Plavcan, J. M. 1990. Sexual dimorphism in the dentition of extant anthropoid primates. Ph.D. dissertation. Duke University, Durham, N.C.
Plavcan, J., and Gomez, A. 1990. Phyletic dwarfing and dental scaling in Callitrichines. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 81:282 [abstract].
Plavcan, J., and Gomez, A. 1993. Relative tooth size and dwarfing in callitrichines. Journal of Human Evolution 25:241245.
Polly, P. 1998. Variability in mammalian dentitions: size-related bias in the coefficient of variation. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 64:8399.
Popowics, T. 2003. Postcanine dental form in the Mustelidae and Viverridae (Carnivora: Mammalia). Journal of Morphology 256:322341.
Prange, H., Anderson, J., and Rahn, H. 1979. Scaling of skeletal mass to body mass in birds and mammals. American Naturalist 113:103122.
Prothero, D., and Sereno, P. 1982. Allometry and paleoecology of medial Miocene dwarf rhinoceroses from the Texas Gulf Coast Plain. Paleobiology 8:1630.
Rosenberger, A. L. 1979. Phylogeny, evolution and classification of New World monkeys (Platyrrhini, Primates). Ph.D. dissertation. City University of New York, New York.
Rosenberger, A. L. 1992. Evolution of feeding niches in New World monkeys. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 88:525562.
Rosenberger, A., and Strier, K. 1989. Adaptive radiation of the ateline primates. Journal of Human Evolution 18:717750.
Ross, C. 1992. Basal metabolic rate, body weight and diet in primates: an evaluation of the evidence. Folia Primatologica 58:723.
Roth, V. L. 1990. Insular dwarf elephants: a case study in body mass estimation and ecological significance. Pp. 151180 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Rubin, C., and Lanyon, L. 1984. Dynamic strain similarity in vertebrates; an alternative to allometric limb bone scaling. Journal of Theoretical Biology 107:321327.
Sacher, G. A. 1959. Relation of lifespan to brain weight and body weight in mammals. Pp. 115141 in Wolstenholme, G. E. W., ed. Ciba Foundation Colloquium on Aging, Vol. 1.
Schmidt-Nielsen, K. 1970. Energy metabolism, body size, and problems of scaling. Federation Proceedings 29:15241532.
Schuman, E. 1954. Metric and morphologic variations in the dentition of the Liberian chimpanzee: comparisons with anthropoid and human dentitions. Human Biology 26:239268.
Schwartz, G. T., Rasmussen, D. T., and Smith, R. J. 1995. Body-size diversity and community structure of fossil hyracoids. Journal of Mammalogy 76:10881099.
Scott, K. M. 1990. Postcranial dimensions of ungulates as predictors of body mass. Pp. 301336 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Shea, B., and Gomez, A. 1988. Tooth scaling and evolutionary dwarfism: an investigation of allometry in human pygmies. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 77:117132.
Silva, M., and Downing, J. A. 1995. CRC handbook of mammalian body masses. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Fla.
Smith, R. J. 1981. On the definition of variables in studies of primate dental allometry. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 55:323329.
Smith, R. J. 1983. The mandibular corpus of female primates: taxonomic, dietary, and allometric correlates of interspecific variations in size and shape. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 61:315330.
Smith, R. J. 1993. Categories of allometry: body size versus biomechanics. Journal of Human Evolution 24:173182.
Smith, R. J. 1996. Biology and body size in human evolution: statistical inference misapplied. Current Anthropology 37:451481.
Smith, R. J. 2009. Use and misuse of the reduced major axis for line-fitting. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 140:476486.
Smith, R. J., and Cheverud, J. 2002. Scaling of sexual dimorphism in body mass: a phylogenetic analysis of Rensch's Rule in Primates. International Journal of Primatology 23:10951135.
Speakman, J. 1996. Energetics and the evolution of body size in small terrestrial mammals. Symposia of the Zoological Society of London 69:6381.
Speakman, J., Selman, C., McLaren, J., and Harper, E. 2002. Living fast, dying when? The link between aging and energetics. Journal of Nutrition 132:15831597.
Stahl, W. 1967. Scaling of respiratory variables in mammals. Journal of Applied Physiology 22:453460.
Strait, S. 1993. Differences in occlusal morphology and molar size in frugivores and faunivores. Journal of Human Evolution 25:471484.
Swindler, D. R. 2002. Primate Dentition: an introduction to the teeth of non-human primates. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Swindler, D. R., and Sirianni, J. 1975. Tooth and body size correlations in Macaca nemestrina . Journal of Dental Research 54:695.
Taylor, C., Caldwell, S., and Rowntree, V. 1972. Running up and down hills: some consequences of size. Science 178:10961097.
Taylor, C. R., Schmidt-Nielsen, K., and Raab, J. 1970. Scaling of energetic cost of running to body size in mammals. American Journal of Physiology 219:11041107.
Taylor, C., Heglund, N., and Maloiy, G. 1982. Energetics and mechanics of terrestrial locomotion. I. Metabolic energy consumption as a function of speed and body size in birds and mammals. Journal of Experimental Biology 97:121.
Thorington, R., and Heaney, L. 1981. Body proportions and gliding adaptations of flying squirrels (Petauristinae). Journal of Mammalogy 62:101113.
Tilman, D., Hillerislambers, J., Harpole, S., Dybzinski, R., Fargione, J., Clark, C., and Lehman, C. 2004. Does metabolic theory apply to community ecology? It's a matter of scale. Ecology 85:17971799.
Tornow, M., Ford, S., Garber, P., and de la Sauerbrunn, E. 2006. Dentition of moustached tamarins (Saguinus mystax mystax) from Padre Isla, Peru, Part 1. Quantitative variation. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 130:352363.
Umminger, B. 1975. Body size and whole blood sugar concentrations in mammals. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 50A:455458.
van Valkenburgh, B. 1990. Skeletal and dental predictors of body mass in carnivores. Pp. 181205 in Damuth, and MacFadden, 1990.
Vinyard, C. J., and Hanna, J. 2005. Molar scaling in strepsirrhine primates. Journal of Human Evolution 49:241269.
Wang, D.-H., Pei, Y.-X., Yang, J.-C., and Wang, Z.-W. 2003. Digestive tract morphology and food habits in six species of rodents. Folia Zoologica 52:5155.
Warton, D., Wright, I., Falster, D., and Westoby, M. 2006. Bivariate line-fitting methods for allometry. Biological Reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 81:259291.
Webster, A., Gittleman, J., and Purvis, A. 2004. The life history legacy of evolutionary body size change in carnivores. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 17:296407.
Weiss, E. 2006. Osteoarthritis and body mass. Journal of Archaeological Science 33:690695.
West, G., Brown, J., and Enquist, B. 1997. A general model for the origin of allometric scaling laws in biology. Science 276:122126.
West, G., Brown, J., and Enquist, B. 1999. The fourth dimension of life: fractal geometry and allometric scaling of organisms. Science 284:16771679.
West, G., Woodruff, W., and Brown, J. 2002. Allometric scaling of metabolic rate from molecules and mitochondria to cells and mammals. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 99:24732478.
West, G., Savage, V., Gillooly, J., Enquist, B., Woodruff, W., and Brown, J. 2003. Physiology: why does metabolic rate scale with body size? Nature 421:713714.
Wood, B. 1979. An analysis of tooth and body size relationships in five primate taxa. Folia Primatologica 31:187211.
Yamashita, N. 1998. Molar morphology and variation in two Malagasy lemur families (Lemuridae and Indriidae). Journal of Human Evolution 35:137162.
Zingeser, M. 1967. Odontometric characters of the howler monkey (Alouatta caraya). Journal of Dental Research 46:975978.
Type Description Title
EXCEL
Supplementary materials

Copes and Schwartz supplementary material
Appendices

 Excel (90 KB)
90 KB

The scale of it all: postcanine tooth size, the taxon-level effect, and the universality of Gould's scaling law

  • Lynn E. Copes (a1) and Gary T. Schwartz (a2)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed