No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Croatian Homeland War Memorial Museums – Exhibiting Urbicides and Concentration Camps
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 19 January 2024
Abstract
Recently opened memorial museums and exhibitions in Croatia museumize the “Homeland War” of 1991 to 1995. This article examines the four major institutions, the Museum of the Homeland War in Karlovac as well as three sites in Vukovar: The Memorial Center for the Homeland War, the Memorial Hospital and the Ovčara Memorial Home. This first systematic site analysis compares 1) the overall narratives; 2) how enemy images from World War II are reactivated to demonize “the other”; 3) how women are represented in these war exhibitions; and 4) the topics that are left out. I argue that while there is still no national museum that includes war developments in all of the country, the two big institutions, the Museum in Karlovac and the Center in Vukovar, focus on the “defenders,” as the Croatian fighters are called – while in Karlovac strikingly marginalizing and at the Center completely omitting civilians. War here means (male) soldiers and weapons, while the other two institutions portray individual victims without discussing their biographies. In all sites, Serbs are depicted with reference to World War II: as Chetniks, running “concentration camps” who committed either “urbicide and culturocide” or a “holocaust” against Croats.
- Type
- Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Association for the Study of Nationalities
References
Alon, Nahi, and Omer, Haim. 2005. The Psychology of Demonization Promoting Acceptance and Reducing Conflict. Mahwah: Routledge.Google Scholar
Apor, Péter. 2014. “Museums of Civilization, Museums of State, Museums of Identity. National Museums in Europe, 1918–2000.” In National Museums and Nation-Building in Europe 1750–2010: Mobilization and Legitimacy, Continuity and Change, edited by Aronsson, Peter and Elgenius, Gabriella, 33–65. London/New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aronsson, Peter, and Elgenius, Gabriella. 2014. “Introduction: Making Museums and Nations.” In National Museums and Nation-Building in Europe 1750–2010: Mobilization and Legitimacy, Continuity and Change, edited by Aronsson, Peter and Elgenius, Gabriella, 1–9. London/New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Banjeglav, Tamara. 2012. “Sjećanje na rat ili rat sjećanja? Promjene u politikama sjećanja u Hrvatskoj od 1990. godine do danas” [War Memory or War on Memory? Changes in Memory Politics in Croatia from 1990 until Today]. In Re:vizija prošlosti. Politike sjećanja u Bosni i Hercegovini, Hrvatskoj i Srbiji od 1990. godine [Re:Visions of the Past. Memory Politics in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia and Serbia since 1990], edited by Karačić, Darko, Banjeglav, Tamara, and Govedarica, Nataša, 91–162. Sarajevo: ACIPS and Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung.Google Scholar
Banjeglav, Tamara. 2019. “Filling voids with memories: commemorative rituals and the memorial landscape in postwar Vukovar.” In Framing the Nation and Collective Identities. Political Rituals and Cultural Memory of the Twentieth-Century Traumas in Croatia, edited by Vjeran Pavlaković and Davor Pauković, 194–208. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Bernhard, Michael, and Kubik, Jan. 2014. “Roundtable Discord. The Contested Legacy of 1989 in Poland.” In Twenty Years After Communism. The Politics of Memory and Commemoration, edited by Bernhard, Michael and Kubik, Jan, 60–84. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Biro, Štefan. 2007. “Bolnička logistika u sustavu ratne bolnice Vukovar 1991 godine” [Hospital Logistics in the Vukovar War Hospital System in 1991]. In Vukovarska bolnica 1991 [Vukovar Hospital 1991], edited by Biro, Štefan, 179–188. Vukovar: Opća bolnica Vukovar.Google Scholar
Blažuc, Vedrana. 2018. Aspekti razvoja turističkog proizvoda memorijalnog turizma istočne Hrvatske [Aspects of the Development of the Touristic Product Memorial Tourism in Eastern Croatia], MA Thesis, Međimurje University in Čakovac.Google Scholar
Bosanac, Vesna. 2007. “Suradnja ratne bolnice Vukovar s ostalim relevantnim institucijama za obranu grada Vukovara” [Cooperation of the Vukovar War Hospital with Other Relevant City of Vukovar’s Defense Institutions]. In Vukovarska bolnica 1991 [Vukovar Hospital 1991], edited by Biro, Štefan, 104–107. Vukovar: Opća bolnica Vukovar.Google Scholar
Bounia, Alexandra, and Stylianou-Lambert, Theopisti. 2013. “War Museums and Photography.” In Does War Belong in Museums? The Representation of Violence in Exhibitions, edited by Muchitsch, Wolfgang, 155–172. Bielefeld: transcript.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Božić, Hrvojka, ed. 2012. Karlovački muzejski prostor za budućnost. Projekt rekonstrukcije zgrade California unutar bivšeg vojnog kompleksa Turanj – Karlovac [The Karlovac Museum Space for the Future. Reconstruction Project of the California Building Within the Former Turanj Military Complex]. Karlovac: Gradski muzej Karlovac.Google Scholar
Brink, Cornelia, and Wegerer, Jonas. 2012. “Wie kommt die Gewalt ins Bild. Über den Zusammenhang von Gewaltakt, fotografischer Aufnahme und Bildwirkungen” [How does Violence Enter the Picture. About the Relationship of the Violent Act, the Photograph and the Effects of the Image]. Fotogeschichte 125: 5–14.Google Scholar
Calic, Marie-Janine. 2018. “Nach Jugoslawien hat der Geschichtsrevisionismus in seinen Nachfolgestaaten Konjunktur” [After Yugoslavia Historical Revisionism is Rising in its Successor States]. Journal of Modern European History 16 (2): 169–174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clark, Janine Natalya. 2012. “Reconciliation through Remembrance? War Memorials and the Victims of Vukovar.” The International Journal of Transitional Justice 7 (1): 116–135.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Čulić, Mariko. 1999. Tuđman: anatomija neprosvijećenog apsolutizma [Tuđman: Anatomy of Unenlightened Absolutism]. Split: Feral Tribune.Google Scholar
Dannehl, Karin. 2017. “Object biographies. From production to consumption.” History and Material Culture. A Student’s Guide to Approaching Alternative Sources, edited by Harvey, Karen, 171–186. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diner, Dan. 2007. Gegenläufige Gedächtnisse. Über Geltung und Wirkung des Holocaust [Antidromic Memories. Abut the Validity and Effect of the Holocaust]. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.Google Scholar
Eckel, Jan, and Moisel, Claudia, ed. 2008. Universalisierung des Holocaust? Erinnerungskultur und Geschichtspolitik in internationaler Perspektive [Universalization of the Holocaust? Memory Culture and Politics of History in International Perspective]. Göttingen: Wallstein.Google Scholar
Emedi, Vladimir. 2007. “Liječnik u koncentracijskom logoru Stajićevo” [A Doctor at the Stajićevo Concentration Camp]. Vukovarska bolnica 1991 [Vukovar Hospital 1991], edited by Štefan Biro, 216–219. Vukovar: Opća bolnica Vukovar.Google Scholar
Filipović, Vladimir. 2019. “Na rubu službene kulture sjećanja: slučaj vukovarskog kirurga dr. Mladena Ivankovića” [At the Fringes of Official Memory Culture: The Case of the Vukovar Surgeon Dr Mladen Ivanković]. Tragovi 2 (2): 101–119.Google Scholar
GS. 2021. “Vukovar: Ružica Markobašić, trudnica ubijena na Ovčari, i njezin nerođeni sin dobili su kip” [Vukovar: Ružica Markobašić, a Pregnant Woman Killed at Ovčara, and Her Unborn Son Got a Statue]. Narod.hr, November 17, 2021. https://narod.hr/kultura/vukovar-ruzica-markobasic-trudnica-ubijena-na-ovcari-i-njezin-nerodeni-sin-dobili-su-kip.Google Scholar
Halovanić, Dubravko. 2006. “Muzejska zbirka naoružanja Domovinskog rata na Turnju” [Museum Collection of Weaponry from the Homeland War in Turanj]. Svjetlo 1 (2): 201–212.Google Scholar
Hina. 2010. “Vukovarska bolnica od Tadića dobila 25 dokumenata, samo četiri su vrlo važna” [Vukovar Hospital Got 25 Documents from Tadić, Only Four Are Very Important]. Dnevno.hr, November 10, 2010. https://web.archive.org/web/20110319201600/http://www.dnevno.hr/vijesti/hrvatska/vukovarska_bolnica_od_tadica_dobila_25_dokumenata_samo_cetiri_su_vrlo_vazna/156876.html.Google Scholar
Hina. 2021. “Umro arhitekt Željko Kovačić (1951–2021).” [Architect Željko Kovačić Passed Away]. Glas Istre, August 15, 2021.Google Scholar
Höpken, Wolfgang. 1999. “Vergangenheitspolitik im sozialistischen Vielvölkerstaat 1944–1991.” [Politics of the Past in the Socialist Multiethnic State 1944–1991]. In Umkämpfte Vergangenheit. Geschichtsbilder, Erinnerung und Vergangenheitspolitik im internationalen Vergleich [Contested Past. Images of History, Memory and Politics of the Past in International Comparison], edited by Bock, Petra and Wolfrum, Edgar, 210–243. Göttingen: Brill.Google Scholar
Hrženjak, Juraj. 2002. Rušenje antifašističkih spomenika u Hrvatskoj 1990-2000 [The Destruction of Antifascist Monuments in Croatia 1990–2000]. Zagreb: Savez antifašističkih boraca Hrvatske.Google Scholar
ICTY. 2010. Judgement Summary: Review Judgement Summary for Veselin Šljivančanin. December 8, 2010.Google Scholar
Jäger, Siegfried. 2004. Kritische Diskursanalyse. Eine Einführung [Critical Discourse Analysis. An Introduction]. Münster: Unrast.Google Scholar
Jaeger, Stephan. 2020. The Second World War in the Twenty-First-Century Museum: From Narrative, Memory, and Experience to Experientiality. Berlin: De Gruyter.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jambrešić-Kirin, Renata. 2006. “Politička sjećanja na Drugi svjetski rat u doba medijske reprodukcije socijalističke kulture” [Memory Politics Regarding World War II in the Era of Media Reproduction of Socialist Culture]. In Devijacije i promašaji: Etnografija domaćeg socijalizma [Deviations and Failures: Ethnography of Domestic Socialism], edited by Feldman, Lada Čale and Prica, Ines, 149–177. Zagreb: Institut za etnologiju i folkloristiku.Google Scholar
Kasapović, Mirjana. 2001. “Demokratska konsolidacija i izborna politika u Hrvatskoj 1990–2000” [Democratic Consolidation and Electoral Policy in Croatia 1990–2000]. In Hrvatska politika 1990–2000. [Croatian Politics 1990–2000], edited by Kasapović, Mirjana, 15–40. Zagreb: Fakultet političkih znanosti.Google Scholar
Katz, Dovid. 2016. “Is Eastern European ‘Double Genocide’ Revisionism Reaching Museums?” Dapim: Studies on the Holocaust 30 (3): 191–220.Google Scholar
Keller, Reiner. 2011. “The Sociology of Knowledge Approach to Discourse.” Human Studies 1: 43–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Križić Roban, Sandra. 2010. “Vrijeme spomenika. Skulpturalni, arhitektonski, urbanistički i drugi načini obilježavanja Domovinskog rata” [Monuments Time. Sculptural, Architectonic and Other Ways of Commemorating the Homeland War]. Radovi Instituta za povijest umjetnosti 34: 225–240.Google Scholar
Kuljić, Todor. 2010. Umkämpfte Vergangenheiten: Die Kultur der Erinnerung im postjugoslawischen Raum [Conflicted Pasts. Memory Culture in the Post-Yugoslav Space]. Berlin: Verbrecher Verlag.Google Scholar
Kurka, Bruna. 2022. “Materijalna baština Domovinskog rata kao osnova za ravoj memorijalnog turizma” [Material Heritage of the Homeland War as a Basis for the Development of Memorial Tourism], MA thesis, University of Pula.Google Scholar
Levy, Daniel, and Sznaider, Natan. 2007. Erinnerung im globalen Zeitalter: Der Holocaust [Memory in the Global Era: The Holocaust]. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.Google Scholar
MacDonald, David Bruce. 2002. Balkan holocausts? Serbian and Croatian victim-centred propaganda and the war in Yugoslavia. Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
MacDonald, Sharon. 2003. “ Museums, National, Postnational and Transcultural Identities.” Museum and Society 1 (1): 1–16.Google Scholar
Messner, Elena, and Pirker, Peter. 2021. Kriege gehören ins Museum! Aber wie? [Wars Belong into a Museum! But How?]. Vienna: Edition Atelier.Google Scholar
Mihalić, Anamarija. 2022. Utjecaj digitalnih sadržaja na iskustvo posjetitelja na primjeru Muzeja Domovinskog rata Karlovac-Turanj [The Influence of Digital Content on the Visitors’ Experience at the Example of the Museum of the Homeland War Karlovac-Turanj]. MA thesis, University of Zagreb.Google Scholar
Milic, Nela. 2022. “Belgrade’s Protest Museum: Digital Memorialisation as Continuing the Event.” In The Memorial Museum in the Digital Age, edited by Walden, Victoria Grace, 247–282. Falmer, Sussex: REFRAME Books.Google Scholar
Mrvica Madarac, Sandra. 2020. “Memorial Tourism in the City of Vukovar.” In Economic and Social Development, edited by Tsiring, Diana, 332–341. Chelyabinsk: Chelyabinsk State University.Google Scholar
Muchitsch, Wolfgang. 2013. Does War Belong in Museums? The Representation of Violence in Exhibitions. Bielefeld: transcript.Google Scholar
Muttenthaler, Roswitha, and Wonisch, Regina. 2006. Gesten des Zeigens. Zur Repräsentation von Gender und Race in Ausstellungen [Gestures of Showing. Representation of Gender and Race in Exhibitions]. Bielefeld: transcript.Google Scholar
Naef, Patrick. 2013. “‘Souvenirs’ from Vukovar: Tourism and Memory within the Post-Yugoslav Region.” Via 3, http://journals.openedition.org/viatourism/1019.Google Scholar
Paul, Gerhard. 2013. BilderMACHT. Studien zur Visual History des 20. und 21. Jahrhunderts [ImagePOWER. Studies in Visual History of the 20th and 21st Century]. Göttingen: Wallstein.Google Scholar
Pieken, Gorch. 2013. “Contents and Space: New Concept and New Building of the Militärhistorisches Museum of the Bundes.” In Does War Belong in Museums? The Representation of Violence in Exhibitions, edited by Muchitsch, Wolfgang, 63–82. Bielefeld: transcript.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Radonić, Ljiljana, ed. 2020. The Holocaust/Genocide Template in Eastern Europe. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Radonić, Ljiljana. 2010. Krieg um die Erinnerung. Kroatische Vergangenheitspolitik zwischen Revisionismus und europäischen Standards [War on Memory. Croatian Politics of the Past Between Revisionism and European Standards]. Frankfurt: Campus.Google Scholar
Radonić, Ljiljana. 2021. Der Zweite Weltkrieg in postsozialistischen Gedenkmuseen. Geschichtspolitik zwischen der “Anrufung Europas” und dem Fokus auf “unser” Leid [World War II in Postsocialist Memorial Museums. Politics of History between the “Invocation of Europe” and the Focus on “Our” Suffering]. Berlin: De Gruyter.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rehak, Danijel, and Barinić, Nenad. 2007. Ovčara – Krik u noći [Ovčara – A Scream at Night]. Vukovar: Hrvatsko društvo logoraša srpskih koncentracijskih logora.Google Scholar
Schellenberg, Renata. 2016. Commemorating conflict. Models of Remembrance in Postwar Croatia. Oxford: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Schellenberg, Renata. 2017. “Commemorative War Museums in 1990s post-war Croatia.” The Museum Review 2 (1), https://themuseumreviewjournal.wordpress.com/2017/08/31/tmr_vol2no1_schellenberg/.Google Scholar
Sodaro, Amy. 2018. Exhibiting Atrocity: Memorial Museums and the Politics of Past Violence. Newark: Rutgers University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sommer-Sieghart, Monika. 2010. “Historische Ausstellungen als ‘contested space’” [Historical Exhibitions as ‘Contested Space’]. In Schauplatz Kultur – Zentraleuropa [Locale Culture – Central Europe], edited by Feichtinger, Johannes et al., 159–166. Innsbruck: Studienverlag.Google Scholar
Spring, Kelly A. 2019. “The Battle of the Land and the Kitchen Front: Twenty-First-Century Museum Representations of Second World War British Food Rationing and Gender Roles.” Historical Geography 47: 37–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stjepanović, Ružica. 2012. “Karlovački muzejski prostor za budućnost” [The Karlovac Museum Space for the Future]. In Karlovački muzejski prostor za budućnost. Projekt rekonstrukcije zgrade California [The Karlovac Museum Space for the Future. Reconstruction Project of the California Building Within the Former Turanj Military Complex], edited by Božić, Hrvojka, 8–9. Karlovac: Gradski muzej Karlovac.Google Scholar
Subotić, Jelena. 2019. Yellow Star, Red Star. Holocaust Remembrance after Communism. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Šuligoj, Metod, and Rudan, Elena. 2022. “Media-generated characteristics of Homeland War-related commemorations in Croatia.” Memory Studies, online first: 1–18.Google Scholar
Sundhaussen, Holm. 2004. “Jugoslawien und seine Nachfolgestaaten” [Yugoslavia and Its Successor States]. In Mythen der Nationen. 1945 – Arena der Erinnerung [Myths of Nations. 1945 – Arena of Memory], edited by Flacke, Monika, 375–384. Mainz: Deutsches Historisches Museum.Google Scholar
Taber, Nancy, and Grover, Ashley. 2021. “Leveraging, militarising, and stereotyping civilians for the war effort: pedagogies of gender in war museums in Canada, England, and Europe.” International Journal of Lifelong Education 40 (3): 268–280.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tuđman, Franjo. 2004. Bespuća povijesne zbiljnosti [The Pathlessness of Historical Reality]. Zagreb: Matica hrvatske.Google Scholar
Vlada Republike Hrvatske. 2006. “Potpredsjednica Vlade na otvaranju Spomen-doma Ovčara” [Vice-President of the Government at the Opening of the Ovčara Memorial Home]. November 20, 2006. https://vlada.gov.hr/vijesti/potpredsjednica-vlade-na-otvaranju-spomen-doma-ovcara/11883.Google Scholar
Walden, Victoria Grace. 2022. “The Memorial Museum in the Digital Age.” In The Memorial Museum in the Digital Age, edited by Walden, Victoria Grace, 20–51. Falmer, Sussex: REFRAME Books.Google Scholar
Williams, Paul. 2007. Memorial Museums. The Global Rush to Commemorate Atrocities. Oxford: Berg Publishers.Google Scholar
Winter, Jay. 2013. “Museums and the Representation of War.” In Does War Belong in Museums? The Representation of Violence in Exhibitions, edited by Muchitsch, Wolfgang, 21–37. Bielefeld: transcript.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Žanić, Mateo. 2008. “Konstrukcija poslijeratnog prostora: Simbolička izgradnja Vukovara” [The Construction of Postwar Space: The Symbolic Building of Vukovar]. Polemos XI (22): 29–50.Google Scholar
Žanić, Mateo, Kufrin, Krešimir, and Živić, Dražen. 2017. “Kultura i sjećanje na rat: Vukovarska bitka i njezini društveni odjeci” [Culture and War Memory: The Battle of Vukovar and Its Reverberations in Society]. Migracijske i etničke teme 31 (2): 245–270.Google Scholar
Zerubavel, Eviatar. 2006. The Elephant in the Room Silence and Denial in Everyday Life. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar