Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-x4r87 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T00:55:59.636Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A New Wave of Research on Civilizational Politics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 January 2021

Henry E. Hale Open the ORCID record for Henry E. Hale [Opens in a new window]  and
Marlene Laruelle
Henry E. Hale*
Affiliation:
George Washington University, Washington DC, USA
Marlene Laruelle
Affiliation:
George Washington University, Washington DC, USA
*
*Corresponding author. Email: hhale@gwu.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

A new wave of scholarship has made major advances in how we understand the politics of civilizational identity by drawing powerfully from conceptual tools developed over the years to study other forms of identity. What unites this wave is treating civilizations not as distinctive “things” that might “clash” but as meaningful social imaginings. This growing body of work is far from monolithic, generating alternative theories that should structure scholarly debate going forward. Central issues include whether civilizational identity is primarily elite led or mass driven, whether it inherently involves conflictual human impulses, what the role of religion and values are in driving it, what its relationship is to nationalism, and how similarly we can expect the countries and people who share civilizational identity to behave. We also find emerging debates on what this newly conceptualized civilizational identity explains in contemporary world politics. Social scientists are now only beginning to apply important tools of social science to this question, with even public opinion research in its infancy. Early findings suggest civilizational identity may be shaping not only elite foreign policy making but also patterns of domestic politics, including the recent rise of populism and levels of democracy and authoritarianism more generally.

Keywords

civilizationsidentityinternational relationspopulismauthoritarianism
Type
State of the Field
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 49 , Issue 4: Special Issue on 1918 and the Ambiguities of “Old-New Europe” , July 2021 , pp. 597 - 608
Check for updates
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Association for the Study of Nationalities

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

This is an updated version of the original article. For details please see the notice at https://doi.org/10.1017/nps.2021.18.

References

Acharya, Amitay. 2020. “The Myth of the ‘Civilization State’: Rising Powers and the Cultural Challenge to World Order.” Ethics and International Affairs 34 (2): 139–156.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anderson, Benedict. 1991. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Ang, Ien, and Stratton, Jon. 1995. “The Singapore Way of Multiculturalism: Western Concepts/Asian Cultures.” Sojourn: Journal of Social Issues in Southeast Asia 10 (1): 65–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Avksent’ev, Viktor A., and Aksiumov, Boris V.. 2012. “A Portfolio of the Identities of Young People of the South of Russia Under the Conditions of Civilizational Choice.” Russian Education and Society 54 (1): 71–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bilgin, Pinar. 2012. “Civilisation, Dialogue, Security: The Challenge of Post-Secularism and the Limits of Civilisational Dialogue.” Review of International Studies 38 (5): 1099–1115.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Braudel, Fernand. 1995. A History of Civilizations. English translation by Mayne, Richard. New York: Penguin.Google Scholar
Breznau, Nate, Kelley, Jonathan, Lykes, Valerie A., and Evans, M. D. R.. 2011. “A Clash of Civilizations? Preferences for Religious Political Leaders in 86 Nations.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 50 (4): 671–691.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers. 2004. Ethnicity without Groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers. 2017a. “Between Nationalism and Civilizationism: The European Populist Moment in Comparative Perspective.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 40 (8): 1191–1226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers. 2017b. “The New Language of European Populism.” Foreign Affairs, December 6. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/europe/2017-12-06/new-language-european-populism.Google Scholar
Christian, David, and McNeill, William H.. 2011. Maps of Time: An Introduction to Big History. Berkeley, Calif London: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
De Bary, Theodore. 2000. Asian Values and Human Rights: A Confucian Communitarian Perspective. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Diamond, Jared M. 1999. Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.Google Scholar
Eriksson, Johan, and Norman, Ludvig. 2011. “Political utilisation of scholarly ideas: the ‘clash of civilisations’ vs. ‘Soft Power’ in US foreign policy.” Review of International Studies 37, 417–436.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ferguson, Niall. 2012. Civilization: The West and the Rest. New York: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Fernandez-Armesto, Felipe. 2002. Civilizations: Culture, Ambition, and the Transformation of Nature. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Flannery, Kent V. 1972. “The Cultural Evolution of Civilizations.” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 3: 399–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, Jonathan. 2001. “Two Civilizations and Ethnic Conflict: Islam and the West.” Journal of Peace Research 38 (4): 459–472.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, Jonathan. 2002. “Ethnic Minorities and the Clash of Civilizations: A Quantitative Analysis of Huntington’s Thesis.” British Journal of Political Science; Cambridge 32 (July): 415–434.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, Jonathan. 2019. “Civilizational Clash or Balderdash? The Causes of Religious Discrimination in Western and European Christian-Majority Democracies,” The Review of Faith & International Affairs, 17:1, 34–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Freeman, Michael. 1998. “Human Rights, Asian Values, and the Clash of Civilizations,” Issues & Studies 34, no. 10, 48–78.Google Scholar
Hale, Henry E. 2004. “Explaining Ethnicity.” Comparative Political Studies 37 (4): 458–485. doi:10.1177/0010414003262906.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hale, Henry E. 2008. The Foundations of Ethnic Politics: Separatism of States and Nations in Eurasia and the World. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hale, Henry E. 2014. “Civilizations Reframed: Towards a Theoretical Upgrade for a Stalled Paradigm.” Journal of Civilization Studies / Medeniyet Araştırmaları Dergisi 1 (1): 5–23.Google Scholar
Hale, Henry E. 2019. “A Surprising Connection between Civilizational Identity and Succession Expectations among Russian Elites.” Post-Soviet Affairs 35 (5–6). Routledge: 406–421.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hale, Henry, and Laruelle, Marlene. 2020. “Rethinking Civilizational Identity from the Bottom Up: A Case Study of Russia and a Research Agenda,” Nationalities Papers 48, no. 3: 585–602.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Martin, and Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus. 2008. “Introduction: Civilizations and International Relations Theory.” In Civilizational Identity: The Production and Reproduction of “Civilizations” in International Relations, edited by Hall, Martin and Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus, 1–12. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
Haynes, Jeffrey. 2017. “Donald Trump, ‘Judeo-Christian Values,’ and the ‘Clash of Civilizations.’” Review of Faith & International Affairs 15 (3). Routledge: 66–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haynes, Jeffrey. 2019a. “Introduction: The ‘Clash of Civilizations’ and Relations between the West and the Muslim World.” The Review of Faith & International Affairs 17 (1). Routledge: 1–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haynes, Jeffrey. 2019b. “From Huntington to Trump: Twenty-Five Years of the ‘Clash of Civilizations.’” The Review of Faith & International Affairs 17 (1). Routledge: 11–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henderson, Errol A., and Tucker, Richard. 2001. “Clear and Present Strangers: The Clash of Civilizations and International Conflict.” International Studies Quarterly 45 (2): 317–338.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huntington, Samuel P. 1990. Collision of Civilizations? Translated by David, Nahum Ben. Shalem Publication, Kam, Efraim. Jerusalem.Google Scholar
Huntington, Samuel P. 1993. “The Clash of Civilizations?” Foreign Affairs 72 (3): 22–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huntington, Samuel P. 1996. The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus. 2006. Civilizing the Enemy: German Reconstruction and the Invention of the West. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus. 2010. “How to Think About Civilizations.” In Civilizations in World Politics: Plural and Pluralist Perspectives, edited by Katzenstein, Peter J., 176–200. NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Kaczmarska, Katarzyna. 2016. “‘But in Asia We Too Are Europeans’: Russia’s Multifaceted Engagement with the Standard of Civilisation.” International Relations 30.4: 432–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kahneman, Daniel. 2011. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York, NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.Google Scholar
Katzenstein, Peter J., ed. 2010. Civilizations in World Politics: Plural and Pluralist Perspectives. NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Katzenstein, Peter J., and Weygandt, Nicole. 2017. “Mapping Eurasia in an Open World: How the Insularity of Russia’s Geopolitical and Civilizational Approaches Limits Its Foreign Policies.” Perspectives on Politics 15 (2): 428–442.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kaya, Ayhan, and Tecmen, Ayşe. 2019. “Europe versus Islam? Right-Wing Populist Discourse and the Construction of a Civilizational Identity.” The Review of Faith & International Affairs 17.1: 49–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kumar, Krishan. 2014. “The Return of Civilization—and of Arnold Toynbee?” Comparative Studies in Society and History 56 (4). Cambridge University Press: 815–843.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laruelle, Marlene, 2010. “The Ideological Shift On The Russian Radical Right: From Demonizing The West To Fear Of Migrants,” Problems of Post-Communism 57, no. 6: 19–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laruelle, Marlene, 2016. “Russia as an anti-liberal European civilization,” in Kolstø, Pål and Blakkisrud, Helge, eds., The New Russian Nationalism: Between Imperial and Ethnic (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press), 275–297.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laruelle, Marlene. 2017. “Putin’s Regime and the Ideological Market: A Difficult Balancing Game,” Carnegie Papers, March.Google Scholar
Laruelle, Marlene, 2019. “Mirror Games? Ideological Resonances between Russian and U.S. Radical Conservatism,” in Suslov, Mikhail, Uzlaner, Dmitry, eds, Contemporary Russian Conservatism. Problems, Paradoxes, and Perspectives (Leiden: Brill), 177–203.Google Scholar
Linde, Fabian. 2016. “The Civilizational Turn in Russian Political Discourse: From Pan-Europeanism to Civilizational Distinctiveness.” The Russian Review 75 (4): 604–625.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Malinova, Olga. 2020. “‘Nation’ and ‘Civilization’ as Templates for Russian Identity Construction: A Historical Overview.” In Russia as Civilization: Ideological Discourses in Politics, Media and Academia, edited by Kåre Johan, Mjør and Turoma, Sanna. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Mjør, Kåre Johan, and Turoma, Sanna, eds. 2020. Russia as Civilization: Ideological Discourses in Politics, Media and Academia. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Morris, Ian. 2011. Why the West Rules--for Now: The Patterns of History, and What They Reveal About the Future. New York: Picador.Google Scholar
Neumayer, Eric, and Plümper, Thomas. 2009. “International Terrorism and the Clash of Civilizations.” British Journal of Political Science 39 (4): 711–734.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicolaidis, Kalypso, Vergerio, Claire, Onar, Nora Fisher, and Viehoff, Juri. 2014. “From Metropolis to Microcosmos: The EU’s New Standards of Civilisation.” Millennium 42.3: 718–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
O’Hagan, Jacinta. 2008. “Discourses of Civilizational Identity.” In Civilizational Identity: The Production and Reproduction of “Civilizations” in International Relations, edited by Hall, Martin and Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus, 15–32. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
O’Loughlin, John, and Talbot, Paul. 2005. “Where in the World Is Russia? Geopolitical Perceptions and Preferences of Ordinary Russians.” Eurasian Geography and Economics 46 (1): 23–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
O’Loughlin, John, Toal, Gerard, and Kolosov, Vladimir. 2005. “Russian Geopolitical Culture in the Post-9/11 Era: The Masks of Proteus Revisited.” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 30 (3): 322–335.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ortmann, Stephan; Thompson, Mark R. 2018. “Introduction: The ‘Singapore model’ and China’s Neo-Authoritarian Dream”. The China Quarterly 236, 930–945.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Orzi, Davide, ed. 2018. The ‘Clash of Civilizations’ 25 Years On: A Multidisciplinary Appraisal. Bristol, UK: E-International Relations. https://www.e-ir.info/publication/the-clash-of-civilizations-25-years-on-a-multidisciplinary-appraisal/.Google Scholar
Pagden, Anthony. 2008. Worlds at War: The 2,500-Year Struggle Between East and West. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
Pantin, V.I. 2010. “The Political and Civilizational Self-Identity of Contemporary Russian Society in a Global Context.” Russian Social Science Review 51 (1): 4–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pasamonik, Barbara. 2019. “Cultural Barbarism in Relation to Women? Huntington’s Theory and the German Case of Mass Sexual Assaults on New Year’s Eve 2015,” The Review of Faith & International Affairs, 17:1, 89–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Qadir, Shahid. 1998. “Civilisational Clashes: Surveying the Fault-Lines.” Third World Quarterly 19 (1): 149–152.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rivera, Sharon Werning. 2016. “Is Russia Too Unique to Learn from Abroad? Elite Views on Foreign Borrowing and the West, 1993-2012.” Sravnitel’naia Politika i Geopolitika / Comparative Politics and Geopolitics 1 (22): 31–40.Google Scholar
Rivera, Sharon Werning, and Bryan, James D.. 2019. “Understanding the Sources of Anti-Americanism in the Russian Elite.” Post-Soviet Affairs 35 (5–6). Routledge: 376–392.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rivera, Sharon, and Zimmerman, William. 2019. “Introduction: New Directions in Survey Research on Russian Elites.” Post-Soviet Affairs 35 (5–6). Routledge: 359–364.Google Scholar
Russett, Bruce M., Oneal, John R., and Cox, Michaelene. 2000. “Clash of Civilizations, or Realism and Liberalism Déjà Vu? Some Evidence.” Journal of Peace Research 37 (5): 583–608.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stepanova, Elena. 2015. “‘The Spiritual and Moral Foundation of Civilization in Every Nation for Thousands of Years’: The Traditional Values Discourse in Russia.” Politics, Religion & Ideology 16 (2–3). Routledge: 119–136.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Subramaniam, Surain. 2010. “The Asian Values Debate: Implications for the Spread of Liberal Democracy.” Asian Affairs: An American Review, 27, no. 1: 19–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsygankov, Andrei P. 2003. “The Irony of Western Ideas in a Multicultural World: Russians’ Intellectual Engagement with the ‘End of History’ and ‘Clash of Civilizations.’” International Studies Review 5 (1): 53–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsygankov, Andrei. 2014. “Contested Identity and Foreign Policy: Interpreting Russia’s International Choices.” International Studies Perspectives 15, 19–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsygankov, Andrei P. 2016. “Crafting the State-Civilization Vladimir Putin’s Turn to Distinct Values.” Problems of Post-Communism 63 (3): 146–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Verkhovsky, Alexander, and Pain, Emil. 2012. “Civilizational Nationalism: The Russian Version of the ‘Social Path.’ ” Russian Politics & Law 50 (5): 52–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1984. The Politics of the World-Economy: The States, the Movements, and the Civilizations. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Wetzel, Christian. 2011. “The Asian Values Thesis Revisited: Evidence from the World Values Surveys.” Japanese Journal of Political Science 12 (1): 1–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yilmaz, Eylem, and Bilgin, Pinar. 2005. “Constructing Turkey’s ‘Western’ Identity during the Cold War: Discourses of the Intellectuals of Statecraft.” International Journal 61 (1): 39–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zevelev, Igor. 2009. “Russia’s Future: Nation or Civilization?” Russia in Global Affairs 4 (October/December). https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/articles/russias-future-nation-or-civilization. (Accessed November 11, 2020.)Google Scholar
Zimmerman, William. 2002. The Russian People and Foreign Policy: Russian Elite and Mass Perspectives, 1993–2000. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar