No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
A merger of equals: The political economy of the World Bank’s early contacts with China
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 October 2023
Abstract
This article assesses the initial contacts between the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and the World Bank during the early 1980s, following China’s admission to the institution in 1980. In the late 1970s, the PRC launched a new phase of economic reforms aimed at re-modelling its economic outlook. Collaboration with multilateral economic institutions such as the World Bank was a key part of its “opening up” strategy. By drawing on newly available records from World Bank archives, the article reveals how the Bank’s approach to China's economic development was tailored to meet Beijing’s specific economic conditions and needs, and welcomed gradualism as the best path for China's reform strategy. At times of free market triumphalism and heavy structural adjustment towards developing countries, the China case, the article stresses, shows a World Bank behaving not quite in line with what many would expect. Therefore, the article provides not only an account of a bilateral relationship but offers a new perspective and reflection of the history of the international political economy of the early 1980s.
- Type
- Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
References
1 Mr Clausen’s Interview with Chairman Deng Xiaoping, 26 May 1983, FINSU-Financial Adviser, IBRD, China 1981-1986, World Bank Archives, Washington, DC (hereafter cited as WBA), 3.
2 ‘GDP per Capita (current US$) – China’: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=CN; ‘China GDP 1960-2022’ https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/CHN/china/gdp-gross-domestic-product.
3 Joseph Fewsmith, Dilemmas of Reform in China: Political Conflict and Economic Debate (London and New York: Routledge, 1994), 123-48; Barry Naughton, Growing Out of the Plan: Chinese Economic Reform 1978-1993 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 173-99; Yan Sun, The Chinese Reassessment of Socialism, 1976-1992 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995), 85-121.
4 Isabella Weber, How China Escaped Shock Therapy: The Market Reform Debate (London and New York: Routledge, 2021); Julian Gewirtz, Unlikely Partners: Chinese Reformers, Western Economists, and the Making of Global China, 1976-1992 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2017); Harold K. Jacobson and Michel Oksenberg, China’s Participation in the IMF, the World Bank, and GATT: Toward a Global Economic Order (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, 1990); Pieter Bottelier, ‘China and the World Bank: How a Partnership was Built’, Journal of Contemporary China 16, no. 51 (2007): 239-58. For oral histories, see ‘Transcript of Interview with Edwin R. Lim’, 30-31 October 2002, Washington, DC, The World Bank Group, Oral History Program: http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/344281468157786211/pdf/790750TRN0Lim000October030031002002.pdf and ‘Transcript of Oral History Interview with Caio-Koch Weser’, 21 December 1992, World Bank History Project, Brookings Institution: https://oralhistory.worldbank.org/transcripts/transcript-oral-history-interview-caio-koch-weser-held-december-21-1992; Edwin Lim, ‘Learning and Working with the Giants’, in At the Frontiers of Development: Reflections from the World Bank, ed. Indermit S. Gill and Todd Pugatch (Washington, DC: The World Bank Group, 2005), 94-107.
5 Gewirtz, Unlikely Partners, 180.
6 David Harvey, A Brief History of Neoliberalism (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), 120.
7 Adam Tooze, ‘China in 1983, a miracle waiting to happen? The World Bank’s first report on Socialist Economic Development’: https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/adam-toozes-chartbook-28-china-in.
8 Naughton, Growing Out of the Plan, 63.
9 Country Program Paper, China, December 24, 1981, FINSU-Financial Adviser, IBRD, China 1981-1986, WBA, 8.
10 Patrick Sharma, Robert McNamara’s Other War: The World Bank and International Development (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2017), 140.
11 Mr Stern’s Meeting with Vice Premier Gu Mu in Beijing, 8 March 1982, Memorandum from Caio Koch-Weser to Files, 25 March 1982, China, Trips, 1982 19 April – 1 May, Background Materials, World Bank Memoranda, 1980-1982, Geopolitical Files, Box I99, Folder 1, McNamara Papers, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC (hereafter LOC), 2.
12 Sarah Babb, Behind the Developments Banks: Washington Politics, World Poverty, and the Wealth of Nations (Chicago and London: Chicago University Press, 2009), 70-99; Ngaire Woods, The Globalizers: The IMF, the World Bank, and Their Borrowers (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2006), 39-64.
13 Sara Lorenzini, Global Development: A Cold War History (Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2019), 164; Sarah Babb and Alexander Kentikelenis, ‘Markets Everywhere: The Washington Consensus and the Sociology of Global Institutional Changes, Annual Review of Sociology 47 (2021): 525.
14 Eric Helleiner, ‘The Life and Times of Embedded Liberalism: Legacies and Innovations since Bretton
Woods’, Review of International Political Economy 26, no. 6 (2019): 1127.
15 Paul Mosley, Jane Harrigan, and John Toye, Aid and Power: The World Bank and Policy-based Lending. Volume 1. Analysis and Policy Proposal, 2nd ed. (New York: Routledge, 1995), 24.
16 On the lost decade, see Lorenzini, Global Development, 160-9; H.W. Singer, ‘The 1980s: A Lost Decade – Development in Reverse?’, in Growth and External Debt Management, ed. H.W. Singer and Soumitra Sharma (New York: Palgrave MacMillan, 1989), 46-59; for the East Asian successes, see Robert Wade, Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asia Industrialization, 2nd ed. (Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2004).
17 Richard Drayton and David Mortadel, ‘Discussion: The Futures of Global History’, Journal of Global History 13, no. 1 (2018): 1-21.
18 Jeremy Adelman, ‘What is Global History Now?’, Aeon, 2 March 2017.
19 Drayton and Mortadel, ‘Discussions’, 9.
20 Ibid. 8.
21 Adelman, ‘What is Global History Now?’.
22 Drayton and Mortadel, ‘Discussions’, 10.
23 On China at the Bretton Woods conference, see Michael Franczak ‘“Asia” at Bretton Woods: India, China and Australasia in Comparative Perspective’, in Global Perspectives on the Bretton Woods Conference and the Post-War Order, ed. Giles Scott Smith and Simon J. Rofe (London: Palgrave MacMillan, 2017) 111-29; for the earlier approaches of the 1970s see Eric Helleiner and Bessma Momani, ‘The Hidden Story of China and the IMF’, in The Great Wall of Money: Power and Politics in China’s International Monetary Relations, ed. Eric Helleiner and Jonathan Kirshner (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2014), 62-5; for the late 1970s acceleration see Pieter Bottelier, Economic Policy Making in China (1949-2016): The Role of Economists (London and New York: Routledge, 2018), 72-84; see also Doak Barnett, China’s Economy in Global Perspective (Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution, 1981), 191, 236-7.
24 Rebecca Karl, Mao Zedong and China in the Twentieth-Century World: A Concise History (Durham and London: Duke University Press, 2010), 150-1.
25 ‘Bank/IMF membership of the People’s Republic of China,’ Memorandum from M.P. Benjenk to Memorandum for the Record, Robert McNamara Papers, Country File, China, 1973-1979, Box I-25, Folder 5, McNamara Papers, LOC, 2.
26 ‘Transcript of Interview with Caio Koch-Weser’, 2.
27 Bottelier, ‘China and the World Bank: How a Partnership was Built’, 242.
28 US-China Economic Relations, Summary of Conclusions of a Presidential Review Committee Meeting, Washington, 27 March 1980, 4.30-5.45pm, Foreign Relations of the United States, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC (hereafter cited as FRUS), Volume XIII, China, Document No. 305, 1103-4.
29 PRC Entry into the IMF/IBRD, Memorandum from the President’s Deputy Assistant for National Security Affairs (Aaron) to President Carter, Washington, April 2, 1980, FRUS, 1977-1980, Volume XIII, China, Document No. 306, 1104-5.
30 Stephen Roach, Unbalanced: The Codependency of America and China (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2014).
31 Odd Arne Westad, Restless Empire: China and the World Since 1750 (New York: Basic Books, 2012), 373-5.
32 Sharma, Robert McNamara’s Other War, 158-9.
33 Final Meeting, 14 April 1980, sub-section of Meetings of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and World Bank Delegations, 10-14 April 1980, at the State Guest House, Beijing, Geopolitical File, China Trips, 1982 19 April – 1 May, Background Material, World Bank Memoranda, 1980-1982, Box I99, Folder 1, McNamara Papers, LOC, 11.
34 Meeting with Vice Premier Deng Xiaoping, Beijing, 15 April 1980, Geopolitical File, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 1.
35 World Bank China records pre-1980 are still classified, preventing a fuller account of what happened before then.
36 Knapp as cited in Sharma, Robert McNamara’s Other War, 152; McNamara shared China’s preoccupation over Soviet expansion in Asia. See Meeting with Vice Minister of Foreign Affairs, Zhang Wenjin, 12 April 1980, Geopolitical File, China Trips, McNamara Papers, 2.
37 Devesh Kapur, John P. Lewis, and Richard Webb, The World Bank: Its First Half Century, Volume 1: History (Washington, DC: Brookings Institutions Press, 1997), 549-50.
38 Final Meeting, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 11.
39 Data is taken from https://data.worldbank.org/country/china.
40 Kapur, The World Bank, 24, 258.
41 Babb, Behind the Development Banks, 50.
42 Meeting on Bank Operation Program, Policies and Procedures, 12 April 1980, Geopolitical Files, China, Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 7.
43 Country Program Paper, WBA, 9.
44 Kapur, The World Bank, 244.
45 Sharma, Robert McNamara’s Other War, 143.
46 Kapur, The World Bank, 981.
47 ‘Meeting on Bank Operation Program’, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 8; see also Gewirtz, Unlikely Partners, 75.
48 Robin Broad, ‘Research, Knowledge, and the Art of “Paradigm Maintenance”: The World Bank’s Development Economics Vice-Presidency (DEC)’, Review of International Political Economy 13, no. 3 (August 2006): 392.
49 Meeting on Bank Operation Program, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 7; on the successful negotiation see Sharma, Robert McNamara’s Other War, 158.
50 Harold James, International Monetary Cooperation Since Bretton Woods (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996), 347-51.
51 In order to be eligible for IDA funds, GDP per capita had to be lower than $400; see Kapur, The World Bank, 1154-5.
52 ‘Transcript of oral history interview with J. Burke Knapp’, held on 22 October 1990, 26 June 1991, 24 and 25 September 24 1992, and 10 October 1995, World Bank oral history program, 101: https://oralhistory.worldbank.org/transcripts/transcript-oral-history-interview-j-burke-knapp-held-october-22-1990-june-26-1991.
53 Country Program Paper, WBA, 9.
54 Kapur, The World Bank, 44-5.
55 Caio Koch Weser, ‘How it All Began; China Resuming Membership in the World Bank,’ in At the Front Line: Reflections on the Bank’s Work with China Over Forty Years, 1980-2020. 40 years of Partnership, World Bank Group, 23: https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/643531627030598596/pdf/At-the-Front-Line-Reflections-on-the-Bank-s-Work-with-China-over-Forty-Years-1980-2020.pdf.
56 Branko Milanovic, ‘How China Escaped, and Eastern Europe Was Felled by, the Volcker Shock’: http://glineq.blogspot.com/2021/06/.
57 Katherine Marshall, The World Bank: From Reconstruction to Development to Equity (London and New York: Routledge, 2008) 48.
58 Meeting on Bank Operation Program, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 8.
59 On NIEO see the special issue ‘Toward a History of the New International Economic Order’, Humanity 6, no. 1 (spring 2015); on the rise and fall of development economics, see Paul Krugman, ‘The Rise and Fall of Development Economics’, in Development, Geography, and Economic Theory, ed. Paul Krugman (Cambridge, MA and London: MIT Press, 1995), 1-31.
60 Lorenzini, Global Development, 156-7; ‘Declaration on the Establishment of a New International Economic Order’, Resolution Adopted by the UN General Assembly, 1 May 1974: http://www.un-documents.net/s6r3201.htm
61 Samuel Moyn, Not Enough. Human Rights in An Unequal World (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2018), 139.
62 Lorenzini, Global Development, 154-9.
63 China Country Program Paper, WBA 9.
64 Gewirtz, Unlikely Partners, 35-6.
65 Naughton, Growing Out of the Plan, 65-70, 74-6; Ezra Vogel, Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2011), 424-30.
66 Frederick C. Teiwes and Warren Sun, ‘China’s Economic Reorientation After the Third Plenum: Conflict Surrounding “Chen Yun’s” Readjustment Program, 1979–80’, The China Journal 70 (July 2013): 167-8.
67 Weber, How China Escaped Shock Therapy, 104.
68 Meeting with Vice Premier Gu Mu, Beijing, April 13, 1980, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, Box I 99, McNamara Papers, LOC, 1.
69 Human Resource Development and Employment, Development Performance and Issues, Economic Brief/1, attached to People’s Republic of China, Briefing Material Mr. McNamara, Prepared in March, 1980, Country Files: China- Correspondence 01, WBA, 1.
70 Dwight Perkins and Shahid Yusuf, Rural Development in China (Baltimore and London: John Hopkins University Press, 1984), 139-40.
71 Xin Meng and Robert Gregory, ‘Exploring the Impact of Interrupted Education on Earnings: The Educational Cost of the Chinese Cultural Revolution’, Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit Institute for the Study of Labor, Discussion Paper No. 2548, January 2007: http://ftp.iza.org/dp2548.pdf.
72 Weaver, Hypocrisy Trap, 76.
73 Kapur, The World Bank, 292.
74 Human Resource Development and Employment, Country Files: China- Correspondence 01, WBA, 1.
75 Naughton, Growing Out of the Plan, 52-3.
76 Weber, How China Escaped Shock Therapy, 90; Justin Yifu Lin, Demystifying the Chinese Economy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011), 6; Martin Ravallion, ‘Poverty In China Since 1950: A Counterfactual Perspective’, National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 28370, January 2021: 1-2: https://www.nber.org/papers/w28370.
77 Meeting with Vice-Premier Deng Xiaoping, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 2.
78 Julian Gewirtz, Never Turn Back. China and the Forbidden Story of the 1980s (Cambridge, MA, and London: Harvard University Press, 2022), 75.
79 Teiwes and Sun, ‘China’s Economic Re-Orientation’, 178-9.
80 For Deng’s stress on relying on China’s own strengths, see Meeting with Vice-Premier Deng Xiaoping, McNamara Papers, LOC, 2.
81 Martin Raiser, ‘Lesson for Whom, From Whom? The Transition from Socialism in China and Eastern Europe Compared’, Kiel Working Paper, No. 630, May 1994: 9, Kiel Institute of World Economics, Kiel.
82 Country Program Paper, WBA, 8,9.
83 James, International Monetary Cooperation Since Bretton Woods, 407.
84 China, Country Program Paper, WBA, 8.
85 Kapur, The World Bank, 517.
86 Mosley, Harrigan, and Toye Aid and Power, 43-4.
87 Babb, Behind the Development Banks, 50.
88 Kapur, The World Bank, 297.
89 A. Aydin Cecen, A. Suut Dogruel, and Fatma Dogruel, ‘Economic Growth and Structural Change in Turkey 1960-1988’, International Journal of Middle East Studies 26, no. 1 (February 1994): 38-9, 44-6.
90 Francisco H.G. Ferreira and Louise C. Keely, ‘The World Bank and Structural Adjustment: Lessons from the 1980s’, in The World Bank: Structure and Policies, ed. Christopher L. Gilbert and David Vines (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000), 162.
91 Mosley, Harrigan, and Toye, Aid and Power, 22.
92 Country Program Paper, WBA, 11.
93 Ibid., 12.
94 Meeting with Vice Premier Gu Mu, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 4.
95 Ziyang Zhao, The Collected Works of Zhao Ziyang (1980-1989), Vol. 1 (1980-1982), ed. editorial group of The Collected Works of Zhao Ziyang (Hong Kong: Chinese University Press, 2016), 48-51.
96 Chen Yun, Chen Yun Wenxuan [Selected Works of Chen Yun], Volume III, (Beijing: Renmin Chubanshe, 1995), 100.
97 James, International Monetary Cooperation Since Bretton Woods, 551.
98 Mosley, Harrigan, and Toye, Aid and Power, 78.
99 Country Program Paper, WBA, 17.
100 Recent Changes in Economic Policy’ sub section of ‘CHINA-Recent Developments, Memorandum from Shahid Husain to Robert McNamara, January 9, 1981, Country Files: China-Correspondence 02, WBA, 4.
101 Mu Gu, Gu Mu Hui Yi Lu [Autograph of Gu Mu] (Beijing: Central Party Literature Press, 2009), 314-16.
102 Meeting with Vice Premier Gu Mu, Geopolitical Files, China Trips, McNamara Papers, LOC, 6; Jacobson and Oksenberg, China’s Participation in the IMF, 111.
103 China—Mr. Husain’s meeting with Vice-Premier Gu Mu, Beijing, 24 July 1980, Memorandum from Caio-Koch-Weser to FILES, 11 August 1980, Country Files: China-Correspondence 01, WBA, 5, 4.
104 Sharma, Robert McNamara’s Other War, 144-5.
105 Jacobson and Oksenberg, China’s Participation in the IMF, 111-12.
106 Bottelier, ‘China and the World Bank’, 243-4.
107 Teiwes and Sun, ‘China’s Economic Re-Orientation’, 182, 184-5.
108 CHINA-Mission Report and Recommendation, Memorandum from Shahid Husain to Robert McNamara, July 27, 1980, Country Files, China, Correspondence 01, WBA, 5.
109 Country Program Paper, WBA, 7, 8.
110 Economic Mission to China, General Wrap Up Meeting, 12/11/80, attachment to ‘CHINA-Recent Developments,’ Country Files: China-Correspondence 02, WBA, 8.
111 Ezra Vogel, Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China, 430.
112 Mr Husain’s meeting with Vice Premier Zhao Ziyang, Beijing, July 16, 1980, Memorandum from Caio Koch- Weser to Files, July 29, 1980, Country Files: China-Correspondence 01, WBA, 1-2.
113 Bottelier, ‘China and the World Bank’, 244.
114 CHINA-Recent Developments, WBA, 3.
115 CHINA-Mission Report and Recommendation, WBA, 3-4.
116 Loren Brandt and Thomas G. Rawski, ‘China’s Great Economic Transformation’, in China’s Great Economic Transformation, ed. Loren Brandt and Thomas G. Rawski (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008), 6.
117 Mr Clausen’s Interview with Premier Zhao Ziyang, IBDR, FINSU-Financial Adviser, China-1981-1986, WBA, 7.
118 Mr Clausen’s Interview with Chairman Deng Xiaoping, WBA, 6, 7.
119 Kapur, The World Bank, 26.
120 Ibid, 338-9, 511-12.
121 Babb, Behind the Development Banks, 106-8; Weaver, The Hypocrisy Trap, 76.
122 ‘United States Participation in the Multilateral Development Banks in the 1980s’, Department of the Treasury (Washington, DC, February 1982), 1, 7.
123 Yasheng Huang, Capitalism with Chinese Characteristics. Entrepreneurship and the State (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008), 53.
124 Kapur, The World Bank, 332.
125 Sergey Radchenko, Unwanted Visionaries. The Soviet Failure in Asia at the End of the Cold War (New York: Oxford University Press, 2014), 4.
126 ‘Planning Considerations for US-China Policy,’ Paper Prepared in the Policy Planning Staff, undated, attached to ‘Some differing thoughts on our emerging China strategy’, Information Memorandum From the Director of the Policy Planning Staff (Wolfowitz) to Secretary of State Shultz, Washington, 22 September 1982, FRUS, 1981-1988, Volume 1, Foundations of Foreign Policy, Document 118, 450.
127 Babb, Behind the Development Banks, 111.
128 Gewirtz, Unlikely Partners, 115.
129 Naughton, Growing Out of the Plan, 134.
130 CHINA—Mr. Clausen’s Meeting with Vice-Prime Minister of Finance Li Peng, Washington, 26 April 1983, Memorandum from Caio Koch-Weser to Files, May 5, 1983, Country Files: China-Correspondence 03, WBA, 1-2.
131 Weser, ‘How It All Began’, 23-4.
132 Briefing Note: Meeting with Premier Zhao Ziyang, Wednesday, January 11, 1984, at 11:45, Madison Hotel, Memorandum from Attila Karaosmanoglu to Clausen, January 9, 1984, Country Files: China-Correspondence 03, WBA, 2. For data see also Babb, Behind the Development Banks, 111.
133 ‘The World Bank Group in China: Facts and Figures, 1980-2020’, The World Bank Office, Beijing, July 2020’, 1-1: https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/777941604392304764-0070022020/original/ffs2020en.pdf.
134 Kapur, The World Bank, 25.
135 Mr. Clausen’s meeting with Premier Zhao Ziyang, Washington, 11 January 1984, Memorandum from Caio Koch-Weser to Files, 11 January 1984, Country Files: China-Correspondence 03, WBA, 1.
136 Huang, Capitalism with Chinese Characteristics, 53.
137 Mark Mazower, Governing the World: The History of an Idea (Penguin: London, 2012), 317.
138 William Easterly, The Tyranny of Experts: Economists, Dictators, and the Forgotten Rights of the Poor (New York: Basic Books, 2014).