Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-dnltx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T20:50:07.300Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Stakeholder Orientation and the Cost of Debt: Evidence from State-Level Adoption of Constituency Statutes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 August 2020

Huasheng Gao Open the ORCID record for Huasheng Gao [Opens in a new window] ,
Kai Li Open the ORCID record for Kai Li [Opens in a new window]  and
Yujing Ma Open the ORCID record for Yujing Ma [Opens in a new window]
Huasheng Gao
Affiliation:
Fudan University Fanhai International School of Financehuashenggao@fudan.edu.cn
Kai Li*
Affiliation:
University of British Columbia Sauder School of Business
Yujing Ma
Affiliation:
Hong Kong Polytechnic University School of Accounting and Financeyujingma@connect.polyu.hk
*
kai.li@sauder.ubc.ca (corresponding author)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We examine the causal effect of stakeholder orientation on firms’ cost of debt. Our test exploits the staggered state-level adoption of constituency statutes, which allows directors to consider stakeholders’ interests when making business decisions. We find a significant drop in loan spreads for firms incorporated in states that adopted such statutes relative to firms incorporated elsewhere. We further show that constituency statutes reduce the cost of debt through the channels of mitigating conflicts of interest between residual and fixed claimants and between holders of liquid claims and holders of illiquid claims, limiting legal liability and lowering takeover threats.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis , Volume 56 , Issue 6 , September 2021 , pp. 1908 - 1944
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

We are grateful for helpful comments from Rajesh Aggarwal, Rui Albuquerque, Aziz Alimov, Andrea Buffa, Utpal Bhattacharya, Murray Carlson, Ling Cen, Sandra Chamberlain, Chun Chang, Shaq Chi, Wan-Chien Chiu, François Derrien, Bernard Dumas, Lorenzo Garlappi, Edith Ginglinger, Sergei Glebkin, Will Gornall, Mark Grinblatt, Jarrad Harford, Mark Huson, Chuanyang Hwang, Yeejin Jang, Jon Karpoff, Youngsoo Kim, Karthik Krishnan, Ali Lazrak, Angie Low, Xiaoxia Lou, Guangli Lu, Evgeny Lyandres, Peter Mackay, Paul Malatesta (the editor), Massimo Massa, Egor Matveyev, Vikas Mehrotra, Randall Morck, Kasper Nielsen, Hernan Ortiz-Molina, Clemens Otto, Dino Palazzo, Joël Peress, Edward Podolski, Jeff Pontiff, Lynnette Purda, Sahil Raina, David Reeb, Jon Reuter, Lukas Roth, Zacharias Sautner, Katherine Schipper, Elena Simintzi, Phil Strahan, Günter Strobl, Sheridan Titman, Chishen Wei, John Wei, Lucy White, Michael Wittry (the referee), Hong Yan, Alminas Zaldokas, and Kuncheng Zheng; seminar participants at Boston College, Boston University, the Frankfurt School of Finance and Management, HEC Paris, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST), Hong Kong Polytechnic University, INSEAD, Nanyang Technological University, National University of Singapore, Northeastern University, Paris Dauphine University, Shanghai Advanced Institute of Finance, the University of Alberta, and the University of British Columbia; and conference participants at the 2017 Financial Management Association (FMA) Asia/Pacific Conference, the 2017 China International Conference in Finance, and the 2017 Northern Finance Association conference. Gao acknowledges financial support from Shanghai Pujiang Program (Reference Number: 18PJC007), the Program for Professor of Special Appointment (Eastern Scholar) at Shanghai Institutions of Higher Learning (Reference Number: TP2018001), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Reference Number: 71973029). Li acknowledges financial support from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC; Grant Number: 435-2013-0023). All errors are our own.

References

Aboody, D., and Lev, B.. “Information Asymmetry, R&D, and Insider Gains.” Journal of Finance, 55 (2000), 2747–2766.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Acharya, V. V.; Baghai, R.; and Subramanian, K.. “Wrongful Discharge Laws and Innovation.” Review of Financial Studies, 27 (2014), 301–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Acharya, V. V.; Bharath, S. T.; and Srinivasan, A.. “Does Industry-Wide Distress Affect Defaulted Firms? Evidence from Creditor Recoveries.” Journal of Financial Economics, 85 (2007), 787–821.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Adams, E. S., and Matheson, J. H.. “A Statutory Model for Corporate Constituency Concerns.” Emory Law Journal, 49 (2000), 1085–1135.Google Scholar
Altman, E. “Financial Ratios Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy.” Journal of Finance, 23 (1968), 589–609.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atanassov, J. “Do Hostile Takeovers Stifle Innovation? Evidence from Antitakeover Legislation and Corporate Patenting.” Journal of Finance, 68 (2013), 1097–1131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Attig, N.; Ghoul, S. E.; Guedhami, O.; and Suh, J.. “Corporate Social Responsibility and Credit Ratings.” Journal of Business Ethics, 117 (2013), 679–694.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bae, K., and Goyal, V. K.. “Creditor Rights, Enforcement and Bank Loans.” Journal of Finance, 64 (2009), 823–860.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bae, K.; Kang, J.; and Wang, J.. “Employee Treatment and Firm Leverage: A Test of the Stakeholder Theory of Capital Structure.” Journal of Financial Economics, 100 (2011), 130–153.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bainbridge, S. “Interpreting Nonshareholder Constituency Statutes.” Pepperdine Law Review, 19 (1992), 991–1025.Google Scholar
Barzuza, M. “The State of State Antitakeover Law.” Virginia Law Review, 95 (2009), 1973–2052.Google Scholar
Bebchuk, L. A., and Ferrell, A.. “Federalism and Corporate Law: The Race to Protect Managers from Takeovers.” Columbia Law Review, 99 (1999), 1168–1199.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Becker, B., and Strömberg, P.. “Fiduciary Duties and Equity-Debtholder Conflicts.” Review of Financial Studies, 25 (2012), 1931–1969.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bennett, B.; Milbourn, T. T.; and Wang, Z.. “Corporate Investment under the Cloud of Litigation.” Working Paper, Ohio State University (2018).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berle, A. A. “Corporate Powers as Powers in Trust.” Harvard Law Review, 44 (1931), 1049–1074.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bertrand, M., and Mullainathan, S.. “Enjoying the Quiet Life? Corporate Governance and Managerial Preferences.” Journal of Political Economy, 111 (2003), 1043–1075.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bhide, A. “The Hidden Costs of Stock Market Liquidity.” Journal of Financial Economics, 34 (1993), 31–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bhojraj, S.; Hribar, P.; Picconi, M.; and McInnis, J.. “Making Sense of Cents: An Examination of Firms that Marginally Miss or Beat Analyst Forecasts.” Journal of Finance, 64 (2009), 2361–2388.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bushee, B. J. “The Influence of Institutional Investors on Myopic R&D Investment Behavior.” Accounting Review, 73 (1998), 305–333.Google Scholar
Bushee, B. J. “Do Institutional Investors Prefer Near‐Term Earnings over Long‐Run Value?” Contemporary Accounting Research, 18 (2001), 207–246.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cen, L.; Dasgupta, S.; Elkamhi, R.; and Pungaliya, R.. “Reputation and Loan Contract Terms: The Role of Principal Customers.” Review of Finance, 20 (2016), 501–533.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chae, J. “Trading Volume, Information Asymmetry, and Timing Information.” Journal of Finance, 60 (2005), 413–442.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chan, L.; Chen, K.; and Chen, T.. “The Effects of Firm-Initiated Clawback Provisions on Bank Loan Contracting.” Journal of Financial Economics, 110 (2013), 659–679.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chava, S.; Livdan, D.; and Purnanandam, A.. “Do Shareholder Rights Affect the Cost of Bank Loans?” Review of Financial Studies, 22 (2009), 2973–3004.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chava, S., and Roberts, M.. “How Does Financing Impact Investment? The Role of Debt Covenants.” Journal of Finance, 63 (2008), 2085–2121.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chen, H. J.; Kacperczyk, M.; and Ortiz-Molina, H.. “Do Nonfinancial Stakeholders Affect the Pricing of Risky Debt? Evidence from Unionized Workers.” Review of Finance, 16 (2012), 347–383.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cohen, D. A.; Dey, A.; and Lys, T. Z.. “Real and Accrual-Based Earnings Management in the Pre- and Post-Sarbanes–Oxley Periods.” Accounting Review, 83 (2008), 757–787.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Comment, R. G., and Schwert, G. W.. “Poison or Placebo? Evidence on the Deterrence and Wealth Effects of Modern Anti-Takeover Measures.” Journal of Financial Economics, 39 (1995), 3–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Costello, A., and Wittenberg-Moerman, R.. “The Impact of Financial Reporting Quality on Debt Contracting: Evidence from Internal Control Weakness Reports.” Journal of Accounting Research, 49 (2011), 97–136.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cremers, M.; Guernsey, S. B.; and Sepe, S. M.. “Stakeholder Orientation and Firm Value.” Working Paper, University of Notre Dame (2019).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cronqvist, H.; Heyman, F.; Nilsson, M.; Svaleryd, H.; and Vlachos, J.. “Do Entrenched Managers Pay Their Workers More?” Journal of Finance, 64 (2009), 309–339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dechow, P. M.; Kothari, S. P.; and Watts, R. L.. “The Relation between Earnings and Cash Flows.” Journal of Accounting and Economics, 25 (1998), 133–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deng, X.; Kang, J.; and Low, B. S.. “Corporate Social Responsibility and Stakeholder Value Maximization: Evidence from Mergers.” Journal of Financial Economics, 110 (2013), 87–109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dimitrov, V.; Palia, D.; and Tang, L.. “Impact of the Dodd–Frank Act on Credit Ratings.” Journal of Financial Economics, 115 (2015), 505–520.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dodd, E. M. “For Whom Are Corporate Managers Trustees?” Harvard Law Review, 45 (1932), 1145–1163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elhauge, E. “Sacrificing Corporate Profits in the Public Interest.” New York University Law Review, 80 (2005), 733–869.Google Scholar
Faleye, O.; Mehrotra, V.; and Morck, R.. “When Labor Has a Voice in Corporate Governance.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 41 (2006), 489–510.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fama, E. F. “Contract Costs and Financing Decisions.” Journal of Business, 63 (1990), S71–S91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flammer, C. “Competing for Government Procurement Contracts: The Role of Corporate Social Responsibility.” Strategic Management Journal, 39 (2018), 1299–1324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flammer, C.; Hong, B.; and Minor, D.. “Corporate Governance and the Rise of Integrating Corporate Social Responsibility Criteria in Executive Compensation: Effectiveness and Implications for Firm Outcomes.” Strategic Management Journal, 40 (2019), 1097–1122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flammer, C., and Kacperczyk, A.. “The Impact of Stakeholder Orientation on Innovation: Evidence from a Natural Experiment.” Management Science, 62 (2016), 1982–2001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Francis, B.; Hasan, I.; Huang, Y.; and Sharma, Z.. “Do Banks Value Innovation? Evidence from US Firms.” Financial Management, 41 (2012), 159–185.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Francis, B.; Hasan, I.; John, K.; and Waisman, M.. “The Effect of State Antitakeover Laws on the Firm’s Bondholders.” Journal of Financial Economics, 96 (2010), 127–154.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frankel, R. M.; Johnson, M. F.; and Nelson, K. K.. “The Relation between Auditors’ Fees for Nonaudit Services and Earnings Management.” Accounting Review, 77 (2002), 71–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Freeman, R. E. Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Marshfield, MA: Pitman (1984).Google Scholar
Gao, H.; Harford, J.; and Li, K.. “CEO Turnover–Performance Sensitivity in Private Firms.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 52 (2017), 583–611.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geczy, C.; Jeffers, J. S.; Musto, D. K.; and Tucker, A. M.. “Institutional Investing When Shareholders Are Not Supreme.” Harvard Business Law Review, 5 (2015), 73–139.Google Scholar
Godfrey, P.; Merrill, C.; and Hansen, J.. “The Relationship between Corporate Social Responsibility and Shareholder Value: An Empirical Test of the Risk Management Hypothesis.” Strategic Management Journal, 30 (2009), 425–445.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gormley, T. A., and Matsa, D. A.. “Common Errors: How to (and Not to) Control for Unobserved Heterogeneity.” Review of Financial Studies, 27 (2014), 617–661.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gormley, T. A., and Matsa, D. A.. “Playing It Safe? Managerial Preferences, Risk, and Agency Conflicts.” Journal of Financial Economics, 122 (2016), 431–455.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goss, A., and Roberts, G.. “The Impact of Corporate Social Responsibility on the Cost of Bank Loans.” Journal of Banking and Finance, 35 (2011), 1794–1810.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Graham, J.; Li, S.; and Qiu, J.. “Corporate Misreporting and Bank Loan Contracting.” Journal of Financial Economics, 89 (2008), 44–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Griffin, D.; Guedhami, O.; Li, K.; and Lu, G.. “National Culture and the Value Implications of Corporate Social Responsibility.” Working Paper, University of British Columbia (2020).Google Scholar
Hall, B. H.; Jaffe, A. B.; and Trajtenberg, M.. “The NBER Patent Citation Data File: Lessons, Insights and Methodological Tools.” In Patents, Citations and Innovations: A Window on the Knowledge Economy, Jaffe, A. B. and Trajtenberg, M., eds. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press (2005).Google Scholar
Harford, J. “What Drives Merger Waves?” Journal of Financial Economics, 77 (2005), 529–560.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hasan, I.; Hoi, C. K.; Wu, Q.; and Zhang, H.. “Social Capital and Debt Contracting: Evidence from Bank Loans and Public Bonds.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 52 (2017), 1017–1047.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heath, D.; Ringgenberg, M.; Samadi, M.; and Werner, I. M.. “Reusing Natural Experiments.” Working Paper, University of Utah (2019).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hertzel, M. G., and Officer, M.. “Industry Contagion in Loan Spreads.” Journal of Financial Economics, 103 (2012), 493–506.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Imbens, G., and Wooldridge, J.. “Recent Developments in the Econometrics of Program Evaluation.” Journal of Economic Literature, 47 (2009), 5–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jensen, M. “Value Maximization, Stakeholder Theory, and the Corporate Objective Function.” European Financial Management, 7 (2001), 297–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jensen, M., and Meckling, W.. “Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure.” Journal of Financial Economics, 3 (1976), 305–360.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, J. J. “Earnings Management during Import Relief Investigations.” Journal of Accounting Research, 29 (1991), 193–228.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kale, J., and Shahrur, H.. “Corporate Capital Structure and the Characteristics of Suppliers and Customers.” Journal of Financial Economics, 83 (2007), 321–365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Karpoff, J. M.; Schonlau, R.; and Wehrly, E.. “Which Antitakeover Provisions Matter?” Working Paper, University of Washington (2019).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Karpoff, J. M., and Wittry, M. D.. “Institutional and Legal Context in Natural Experiments: The Case of State Antitakeover Laws.” Journal of Finance, 73 (2018), 657–714.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, I., and Skinner, D. J.. “Measuring Securities Litigation Risk.” Journal of Accounting and Economics, 53 (2012), 290–310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, J.; Song, B.; and Zhang, L.. “Internal Control Weakness and Bank Loan Contracting: Evidence from SOX Section 404 Disclosures.” Accounting Review, 86 (2011), 1157–1188.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Klock, M. S.; Mansi, S. A.; and Maxwell, W. F.. “Does Corporate Governance Matter to Bondholders?” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 40 (2005), 693–719.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Koh, P.; Qian, C.; and Wang, H.. “Firm Litigation Risk and the Insurance Value of Corporate Social Performance.” Strategic Management Journal, 35 (2014), 1464–1482.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leung, W. S.; Song, W.; and Chen, J.. “Does Bank Stakeholder Orientation Enhance Financial Stability?” Journal of Corporate Finance, 56 (2019), 38–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Loughran, T., and McDonald, B.. “When Is a Liability Not a Liability? Textual Analysis, Dictionaries, and 10-Ks.” Journal of Finance, 66 (2011), 35–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luoma, P., and Goodstein, J.. “Stakeholders and Corporate Boards: Institutional Influences on Board Composition and Structure.” Academy of Management Journal, 42 (1999), 553–563.Google Scholar
MacKinnon, J. G., and Webb, M. D.. “Randomization Inference for Difference-in-Differences with Few Treated Clusters.” Journal of Econometrics (2020), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2020.04.024.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merton, R. “On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: The Risk Structure of Interest Rates.” Journal of Finance, 29 (1974), 449–470.Google Scholar
Myers, S. “Determinants of Corporate Borrowing.” Journal of Financial Economics, 5 (1977), 147–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Myers, S. “Financing of Corporations.” In Handbook of the Economics of Finance, Vol. 1, Constantinides, G. M., Harris, M., and Stulz, R. M., eds. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier (2003).Google Scholar
Nguyen, P.; Kecskés, A.; and Mansi, S.. “Does Corporate Social Responsibility Create Shareholder Value? The Importance of Long-Term Investors.” Journal of Banking and Finance, 112 (2020), 105217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Opler, T. C., and Titman, S.. “Financial Distress and Corporate Performance.” Journal of Finance, 49 (1994), 1015–1040.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Orts, E. “Beyond Shareholders: Interpreting Corporate Constituency Statutes.” George Washington Law Review, 61 (1992), 14–135.Google Scholar
Pagano, M., and Volpin, P.. “Managers, Workers, and Corporate Control.” Journal of Finance, 60 (2005), 841–868.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pontiff, J.; Shleifer, A.; and Weisbach, M.. “Reversions of Excess Pension Assets after Takeovers.” RAND Journal of Economics, 21 (1990), 600–613.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Qian, J., and Strahan, P. E.. “How Laws and Institutions Shape Financial Contracts: The Case of Bank Loans.” Journal of Finance, 62 (2007), 2803–2834.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Radhakrishnan, S.; Wang, K.; and Wang, Z.. “Stakeholder Orientation and Accounting Conservatism: Evidence from a Natural Experiment.” Working Paper No. 3042901, University of Alberta School of Business (2018).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rauh, J. D. “Investment and Financing Constraints: Evidence from the Funding of Corporate Pension Plans.” Journal of Finance, 61 (2006), 33–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roberts, M. R., and Whited, T. M.. “Endogeneity in Empirical Corporate Finance.” In Handbook of the Economics of Finance, Vol. II, Constantinides, G. M., Harris, M., and Stulz, R. M., eds. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier (2013).Google Scholar
Santos, J., and Winton, A.. “Bank Loans, Bonds, and Information Monopolies across the Business Cycle.” Journal of Finance, 63 (2008), 1315–1359.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sharfman, M. P., and Fernando, C. S.. “Environmental Risk Management and the Cost of Capital.” Strategic Management Journal, 29 (2008), 569–592.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shleifer, A., and Summers, L. H.. “Breach of Trust in Hostile Takeovers, Corporate Takeovers: Causes and Consequences.” Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press (1988).Google Scholar
Spamann, H. “On Inference When Using State Corporate Laws for Identification.” Working Paper 1024, Harvard Law School (2019).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Springer, J. “Corporate Law and Constituency Statutes: Hollow Hopes and False Fears.” New York University Annual Survey of American Law, 85 (1999), 85–123.Google Scholar
Stein, J. C. “Takeover Threats and Managerial Myopia.” Journal of Political Economy, 96 (1988), 61–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stout, L. A. “New Thinking on ‘Shareholder Primacy.’” Accounting, Economics, and Law, 2 (2012), article 4.Google Scholar
Tirole, J. “Corporate Governance.” Econometric, 69 (2001), 1–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wittry, M. D. “(Debt) Overhang: Evidence from Resource Extraction.” Review of Financial Studies, forthcoming (2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Valta, P. “Competition and the Cost of Debt.” Journal of Financial Economics, 105 (2012), 661–682.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vassalou, M., and Xing, Y.. “Default Risk in Equity Returns.” Journal of Finance, 59 (2004), 831–868.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zingales, L. “In Search of New Foundations.” Journal of Finance, 55 (2000), 1623–1653.CrossRefGoogle Scholar