Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-gq7q9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T10:44:40.525Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The “Railroad Scheme” of Massachusetts

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 February 2011

Edward C. Kirkland
Edward C. Kirkland
Affiliation:
Bowdoin College
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

By the 1820's, New England was in ferment. Unitarianism had shattered the old religious orthodoxy and, while the Dedham case provided a material dowry for the new religion, the sermons of William Ellery Channing furnished a theology and creed. In politics the dogmas of regional Federalism were weakened and soon Daniel Webster was to celebrate the virtues of an embracing nationalism which Pickering and his fellow conspirators of an earlier period would have found incomprehensible. Along the Merrimack were arising the cotton-mill towns, symbols of a new industrialism. An old order was giving way to a new. Once begun, change accelerated and touched one by one the institutions and ideas of the region. Of the economic factors that gave momentum to this transformation, the railroad was the most important. For it was the railroad that after 1830 tied New England into the nation. No longer was it to be a fringe of Hanseatic ports communicating with the rest of the world and with America by sea; it was to become a section in a developing nation. When Emerson wrote of Massachusetts, “From 1790 to 1820, there was not a book, a speech, a conversation, or a thought in the State,” he should have added that there was not a railroad. For the railroad, even though it may not have opened wider prospects, at least revealed different ones.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Economic History , Volume 5 , Issue 2 , November 1945 , pp. 145 - 171
Copyright
Copyright © The Economic History Association 1945

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Emerson, E. W. and Forbes, W. E., eds., Journals of Ralph Waldo Emerson (Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1909–1914), VIII, 339.Google Scholar

2 Levi Lincoln, Governor's Message, January 7, 1829, Resolves of the General Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court, Commencing May, 1828, and Ending June, 1831 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1831), pp. 81–82Google Scholar; Hale, Nathan, Remarks on the Practicability and Expediency of Establishing a Rail Road on One or More Routes from Boston to the Connecticut River (Boston: William L. Lewis, 1827), pp. 59–60.Google Scholar

3 Hale, ibid., pp. 56,59, 62–63; idem, Remarks on the Practicability and Expediency of Rail Roads from Boston to the Hudson River and from Boston to Providence (Boston: Boston Daily Advertiser, 1829), pp. 24–31Google Scholar; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence. Submitted to the General Court, January: 6, 1820 (Boston: Boston Daily Advertiser, 1829), pp. 30–35.Google Scholar

4 Report of the Commissioners, Appointed under the Act of April 15, 1828, relative to the Construction of a Rail-Road from the City of Boston to the Hudson River, [New York] Senate Document, 1829, no. 113 (Albany: E. Croswell, 1829), pp. 54, 59–62; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 27–30.

5 William S. Prentiss to James F. Baldwin, February 16, 1829, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVI; Report of the Commissioners of the State of Massachusetts, on the Routes of Canals from Boston Harbour, to Connecticut and Hudson Rivers (Boston: True and Greene, 1826), pp. 167–74.Google Scholar

6 Derby, Elias H., “Progress of Railroads in Massachusetts,” The Merchants’ Magazine and Commercial Review, XIV (1846), 30Google Scholar; Hale, Remarks on the Practicability and Expediency of Rail Roads from Boston to the Hudson River and from Boston to Providence, p. iv.

7 Vose, George L., A Sketch of the Life and Works of Loammi Baldwin, Civil Engineer. Read before the Boston Society of Civil Engineers. Sept. 16, 1885 (Boston: George H. Ellis, 1885), p. 3.Google Scholar

8 Report of the Commissioners of the State of Massachusetts on the Routes of Canàls from Boston Harbour.

9 Adams, C. D. Jr, “The Canal and Railroad Enterprise of Boston,” The Memorial History of Boston, Including Suffolk County, Massachusetts, 1630–1830 (Boston: James R. Osgood and Company, 1881), IV, 115.Google Scholar

10 Stuart, Charles B., Lives and Works of Civil and Military Engineers of America (New York: D. Van Nostrand, 1871), pp. 122–23Google Scholar; Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court, Beginning May, 1825, and Ending March, 1828 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1828), pp. 329–34.Google Scholar

11 Gridley Bryant to James F. Baldwin, January 21, 1828, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVI; Hale, Remarks on the Practicability and Expediency of Establishing a Rail Road on One or More Routes from Boston to the Connecticut River, pp. 3–8; Report of Board of Commissioners for the Survey of One or More Routes for a Railway from Boston to Albany (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1828), pp. 28–29.Google Scholar

12 Charles B. Stuart, Lives and Works of Civil and Military Engineers of America, pp. 123–27.

13 Tredgold, Thomas, A Practical Treatise on Rail-Roads and Carriages, Shewing the Principles of Estimating Their Strength, Proportions, Expense, and Annual Produce, and the Conditions Which Render Them Effective, Economical, and Durable; with the Theory, Effect, and Expense of Steam Carriages, Stationary Engines, and Gas Machines (London: Printed for Josiah Taylor, 1825)Google Scholar; ibid (New York: E. Bliss and E. White, 1825); Wood, Nicholas, A Practical Treatise on Rail-Roads, and Interior Communication in General; with Original Experiments, and Tables of the Compârative Value of Canals and Rail-Roads (London: Printed for Knight and Lacey, 1825)Google Scholar; idem, A Practical Treatise on Rail-Roads and Interior Communication in General. Containing an Account of the Performance of the Different Locomotive Engines at and subsequent to the Liverpool Contest; Upwards of Two Hundred and Sixty Experiments; with Tables of the Comparative Value of Canals and Rail-Roads, and the Power of the Present Locomotive Engines (Philadelphia: Carey and Lea, 1832).Google Scholar

14 Proceedings of the Directors and Stockholders of the Boston and Worcester Railroad, MS, Harvard Business School Library, I, 147.

15 Elias H. Derby, The Merchants' Magazine and Commercial Review, XIV, 30; James F. Baldwin to Col. S. M. McKay, December 20,1827, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVI; The National Cyclopedia of American Biography (New York: James T. White and Company, 1893), III, 147; VI, 289.Google Scholar

16 Boston American Traveller, April 14, 1829; Massachusetts Rail Road Association, Constitution (Boston: 1829).Google Scholar

17 Card Catalogue of the members of the Massachusetts General Court, Massachusetts State Library.

18 Report of the Board of Commissioners for the Survey of One or More Routes for a Railway from Boston to Albany, p. 24; Hale, Remarks on the Practicability and Expediency of Establishing a Rail Road on One or More Routes to the Connecticut River, pp. 16–23.

19 Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 72–75; Hale, Remarks on the Practicability and Expediency of Establishing a Rail Road on One or More Routes from Boston to the Connecticut River, pp. 42–44.

20 Boston Courier, June 27, 1827, quoted in C. F. Adams, Jr., “The Canal and Railroad Enterprise of Boston,” The Memorial History of Boston, Including Suffolk County, Massachusetts, 1630–1830, IV, 122.

21 Levi Lincoln, Governor's Address, May 30, 1829, The Resolves of the General Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Passed at the Second Session of the General Court, Commencing May, 1825, and Ending June, 1831, pp. 166–73; Sedgwick, Theodore, Brief Remarks on the Rail Roads, Proposed in Massachusetts, By Berkshire (Stockbridge: Charles Webster, 1828), pp. 11–13Google Scholar; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 46–47.

22 William E. Prentiss to James F. Baldwin, February 16, 1829, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVI.

23 Resolves of the General Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court, Commencing May, 1824, and Ending March, 1828 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1828), pp. 479–80, 491–92, 589–90Google Scholar; Report of the Board of Commissioners of Internal Improvements in Relation to the Examination of Sundry Routes for a Railway from Boston to Providence. With a Memoir of the Survey (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1828)Google Scholar; Report of the Board of Commissioners for the Survey of One or More Routes for a Railway from Boston to Albany.

24 Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court, Beginning May, 1825, and Ending March, 1828, pp. 815–18; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 43–51.

25 Report of the Board of Commissioners, of Internal Improvements in Relation to the Examination of Sundry Routes for a Railway from Boston to Providence, pp. 9–16, 51–72; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 60–68.

26 Report of the Board of Commissioners for the Survey of One or More Routes for a Railway from Boston to Albany, pp. 9–23; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 14–18, 50–59.

27 Laws of the State of New York, Passed at Fifty-first Session (Albany: E. Croswell, 1829), pp. 258–59Google Scholar; Report of the Commissioners to aid the Railroad from Boston to the Hudson River, [New York] Senate Journal, 1829 (Albany: E. Croswell, 1829), pp. 235–41Google Scholar; Report of the Commissioners appointed under the Act of April 15, 1828, relative to the Construction of a Rail-Road from the City of Boston to the Hudson River, [New York] SenateDocument, 1829, no. 113 (Albany: E. Croswell, 1829), pp. 17–18, 51.Google Scholar

28 Report of the Committee of the House of Representatives, February 28, 1829, [Massachusetts] House Report, no. 42; Report of the Committee of the Senate, February 28, 1829, [Massachusetts] Senate Document, 1829, no. 24; House Journal, May 1828-March 1829, MS, Massachusetts State Library, pp. 302, 335, appendix; Senate Journal, May 1828-March 1829, MS, Massachusetts State Library, p. 454.

29 Levi Lincoln, Governor's Address, May 31, 1829, Resolves of the General Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.… Commencing May, 1826, and Ending June, 1831, pp. 166–73; Boston American Traveller, May 19, 1829; Boston Daily Advertiser, May 9, 1829.

30 Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court, Beginning May, 1828, and Ending March, 1831 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1831), pp. 412–38Google Scholar; An Act to Establish the Massachusetts Rail Road Corporations, [Massachusetts] House Document, 1829–1830, no. 4; House Journal, May 1828-March 1829, MS, Massachusetts State Library, p. 285; House Journal, May 1829-March 1830, MS, Massachusetts State Library, p. 229, appendix.

31 Report of James Hayward, January 7, 1830, on the Survey of a Rail Route between Boston and Lowell, [Massachusetts] Senate Document, 1829–30, no. 3; Report of the Committee on Railways and Canals on petition for a charter of the Boston and Lowell Railroad, [Massachusetts] Senate Document, 1829–30, no. 21; Remonstrance of the Proprietors of the Middlesex Canal against a Charter to the Boston and Lowell Railroad, [Massachusetts] House Document, 1829–30, no. 40.

32 Report of a Committee on the Boston and Lowell Rail Road (Boston: 1831.Google Scholar

33 Report of the Board of Commissioners of Internal Improvements in Relation to the Examination of Sundry Routes for a Railway from Boston to Providence, pp. 10–11, 42–50; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 63–67.

34 Report of the Board of Directors to the Stockholders of the Boston and Providence Rail-Road Company, Submitting the Report of Their Engineer with Plans and Profiles, Illustrative of the Surveys, and Estimates of the Cost of a Rail-Road from Boston to Providence, to Which are Annexed the Acts of Incorporation (Boston: J. E. Hinckley and Company, 1832), pp. 8–46Google Scholar; Annual Report of the Directors of the Boston and Providence Rail Road Corporation with That of the Agent and Engineer, January 2, 1833 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1833), pp. 15–32.Google Scholar

35 Charter of the Boston and Providence Railroad and Transportation Company, Passed by the General Assembly of Rhode-Island, at Their May Session, A. D. 1834 (Providence: William Simons, January 1834)Google Scholar; Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court, Beginning May, 1831, and Ending March, 1833 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1833), pp. 109–18.Google Scholar

36 Subscription Paper for the Boston and Worcester Railroad, February, 1831, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVII; Report of a Committee on the Petition of the City Council for Permission to Subscribe to a Railroad from Boston to the Western States, [Massachusetts] House Document, 1830–31, no. 54.

37 Report of the Board of Commissioners, for the Survey of One or More Routes for a Railway from Boston to Albany, pp. 16–23; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts, on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 14–18, 54–56.

38 Report of the Directors of the Boston and Worcester Rail-Road Corporation to the Stockholders, together with the Report of John M. Fessenden, Esq., Civil Engineer, and a Plan and Profile of the Location of the Rail Road (Boston: W. L. Lewis, 1832), pp. 4–5, 9–19, 22.Google Scholar

39 Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court of Massachusetts, Beginning May, 1828, and Ending March, 1831 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1831), pp. 494–501Google Scholar; Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Passed at the Several Sessions of the General Court of Massachusetts, Beginning May, 1831, and Ending March, 1833 (Boston: Dutton and Wentworth, 1833), pp. 109–18, 152–62Google Scholar; The General Laws of Massachusetts, from the Adoption of the Constitution to February, 1822 (Boston: Wells and Lilly and Cummings and Hilliard, 1823), I, 295–96Google Scholar; The General Laws of Massachusetts, From June. 1822, to June, 1831 (Boston: Hilliard, Gray, Little, and Wilkins, 1832), 138–39.Google Scholar

40 The Proprietors of Charles River Bridge in Equity v. the Proprietors of Warren Bridge et al., 23 Massachusetts (6 Pickering), 376–77, 392, 399; The Proprietors of Charles River Bridge v. The Proprietors of Warren Bridge et al., 24 Massachusetts (7 Pickering), 344–532; The Proprietors of the Charles River Bridge, Plaintiffs in Error, v. The Proprietors of the Warren Bridge, and others, 36 United States, 420–69; Boston and Lowell Railroad Corporation v. Salem and Lowell Railroad Company, and others, 68 Massachusetts (2 Grey), 1–42; The Contemplated Plan of the Franklin Rail Road Company to Commence with a Route through the Counties of Middlesex, Worcester, and Franklin, to the Line of Vermont; from Thence to Lake Champlain and to Lake Ontario, with Branches Convenient to Accommodate the Inhabitants of Massachusetts (Boston: John H. Eastburn, 1830), pp. 3–5Google Scholar; Elias H. Derby, The Merchants' Magazine and Commercial Review, XIV, 34–35.

41 Laws.… of Massachusetts.… Beginning May, 1828, and Ending March, 1831, pp. 494–500; Laws.… of Massachusetts.… Beginning May, 1831, and Ending March, 1833, pp. 110 ff., 153 ff., 280, 314, 454.

42 Laws.… Massachusetts.… Beginning May, 1828, and Ending March, 1831, p. 613; Adams, C. F. Jr, “Railroad Legislation,” The Merchants' Magazine and Commercial Review, LVII (1867), 341–42.Google Scholar

43 Report of the Board of Commissioners of Internal Improvements in Relation to the Examination of Sundry Routes for a Railway from Boston to Providence, pp. 18–31; Report of the Board of Directors of Internal Improvements of the State of Massachusetts on the Practicability and Expediency of a Rail-Road from Boston to the Hudson River, and from Boston to Providence, pp. 4–5, 16–17, 69–70.

44 Loammi Baldwin II to James F. Baldwin, March 17, 1831, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVI; P. T. Jackson to James F. Baldwin, April 1, 1831, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVII.

45 Description of the Boston and Lowell Railroad by James F. Baldwin (?), Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVII.

46 James F. Baldwin to Thomas I. Lobdell, March 2, 1836, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVII.

47 Cullum, George W., Biographical Register of the Officers and Graduates of the U. S. Military Academy at West Point, N. Y. From its Establishment in 1802, to 1890 with the Early History of the United States Military Academy (3d ed.; Boston and New York: Houghton, Mifflin and Company, 1891), III, 161–66, 328–29.Google Scholar

48 Report of the Directors of the Boston and Worcester Rail-Road Corporation to the Stockholders, together with the Report of John M. Fessenden, Esq., pp. 32–34.

49 Proceedings of the Directors and Stockholders of the Boston and Worcester Railroad, MS, Harvard Business School Library, I, 120–21.

50 Tanner, H. S., A Description of the Canals and Rail Roads of the United States, Comprehending Notices of all the Works of Internal Improvement throughout the Several States (New York: T. R. Tanner and J. Disturnell, 1840), p. 38Google Scholar; Second Annual Report of the Directors of the Boston and Worcester Railroad to the Massachusetts Legislature, February 5, 1834, pp. 9–10.

51 Report of the Board of Directors to the Stockholders of the Boston and Providence Rail-Road Company, Submitting the Report of Their Engineer. … and Estimates of the Cost of a Rail-Road from Boston to Providence, pp. 39–42; Annual Report of the Directors of the Boston and Providence Rail Road Corporation—January 2, 1833, p. 24; Tonner, p. 41.

52 Proceedings of the Directors of the Boston and Worcester Railroad, MS, Harvard Business School Library, I, 185–86.

53 Report of the Directors of the Boston and Worcester Rail Road, to the Stockholders, at Their Third Annual Meeting, June 2, 1834, p. 4; Proceedings of the Directors and Stockholders of the Boston and Worcester Railroad, MS, Harvard Business School Library, I, 190–91.

54 James F. Baldwin to Loammi Baldwin II, May 27,1835, Baldwin Papers, Harvard Business School Library, XXXVII.