Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-c654p Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-29T05:27:45.479Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Bishop as Pastor and Solitary: Bede and the Spiritual Authority of the Monk-Bishop

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 February 2009

Simon J. Coates
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

‘One is always aware of Bede's Church as an institution of men and women, meetings and buildings, and especially as a bishops' Church.’ With this comment, J. M. Wallace-Hadrill directed attention to a fundamental aspect of Bede's world which requires further examination. From early childhood until his death, Bede was and remained a monk. He had entered the monasterium of Wearmouth and Jarrow at the age of seven and was to remain in it all his life. Although he was ordained to the priesthood by John of Beverley he never advanced to episcopal office. Despite the fact that he was nurtured in a world of reflective scholarship at Wearmouth and Jarrow it is now less common for historians to view Bede as ‘a lonely intellectual locked in an elite minority community’ and a scholar who lived out his life away from the events of the outside world. He perceived that world and the clergy who occupied it, however, through monastic eyes. Since Bede is, and indeed should be, seen as a representative and guardian of a monastic culture heavily influenced by Benedictine spirituality his views concerning the episcopate have not been analysed to the same extent as his views concerning monasticism. This is somewhat surprising since Bede himself perceived a clear link between the episcopal and monastic lives and was deeply concerned with the early Anglo-Saxon Church as an episcopally governed institution. The purpose of this article is to examine Bede's exploration of the manner in which individual bishops came personally to define their prestige, power and authority. This involves an investigation of their continued attachment to ascetic traditions once they had been elevated to the episcopate and an examination of the models applying ascetic sanctity to an episcopal context which Bede inherited from his predecessors in the late antique and early Christian world.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 47 , Issue 4 , October 1996 , pp. 601 - 619
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Wallace-Hadrill, J. M., Bede's ecclesiastical history of the English people: a historical commentary, Oxford 1988, p. xxviiiGoogle Scholar.

2 Bede, , HE v. 24Google Scholar. Bede commented upon his elevation to the priesthood in Opera homiletica ed. Hurst, D., CCSL cxxii. 84Google Scholar: ‘quotquot per gradum sacerdotalem ad dispensanda illius sumus sacramenta promoti’. Alcuin suggests that Bede entered the monastic life as an oblate, having been made to enter it by the ‘loving concern’ of his parents: Alcuin, , The bishops, kings and saints of York, ed. and trans. Godman, Peter, Oxford 1982, 102–3, lines 1294–5Google Scholar.

3 John, E., review of Goffart, Walter, The narrators of barbarian history, Princeton 1988Google Scholar, in Catholic Historical Review lxxv (1989), 130Google Scholar; cf. Thacker, A. T., ‘Bede's ideal of reform’, in Wormald, P., Collins, R. and Bullough, D. (eds), Ideal and reality in Frankish and Anglo-Saxon society, Oxford 1983, 130Google Scholar.

4 Van Der Walt, A. G. P., ‘Reflections of the Benedictine Rule in Bede's Homiliary’, this JOURNAL xxxvii (1986), 367–76Google Scholar; Bonner, G., ‘The Christian life in the thought of the Venerable Bede’, Durham University Journal lxiii ns xxxii (1970), 39–55Google Scholar. Other scholars have been more cautious and point out that despite the prominent place held by the Benedictine Rule at Wearmouth-Jarrow it was probably not followed exclusively: Mayr-Harting, H., The Venerable Bede, the Rule of St Benedict and social class, Jarrow Lecture 1976Google Scholar; Blair, P. Hunter, The world of Bede, 2nd edn, Cambridge 1990, 199CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Regula magistri 83, ed. de Vogüé, A., SC cvi, Paris 1964, 342–7Google Scholar.

6 Regula Sancti Benedicti 60, 62, ed. de Vogüé, A. and Neufville, J., SC clxxxii, Paris 1971–1972, 634–6, 640–2Google Scholar.

7 Thacker, A. T., ‘Monks, preaching and pastoral care in early Anglo-Saxon England’, in Blair, John and Sharpe, Richard (eds), Pastoral care before the parish, Leicester 1992, 153Google Scholar.

8 Thacker, , ‘Bede's ideal of reform’, 140–6Google Scholar; Campbell, J., Essays in Anglo-Saxon history, London 1986, 37–9Google Scholar; Kendall, C. B., ‘Imitation and the Venerable Bede's Historia ecclesiastica’, in King, M. H. and Stevens, W. M. (eds), Saints, scholars and heroes: studies in medieval culture in honour of Charles W. Jones, Collegeville, Minn. 1979, i. 169–71Google Scholar.

9 Holder, A. G., ‘Bede and the tradition of patristic exegesis’, Anglican Theological Review lxxii (1990), 406Google Scholar; Bonner, G., ‘Bede and medieval civilization’, Anglo-Saxon England ii (1973), 78Google Scholar.

10 Congar, Yves, L'ecclésiologie du haut moyen âge, Paris 1968Google Scholar; Carroll, M. T. A., The Venerable Bede, his spiritual teachings, Washington 1946, ch. iiGoogle Scholar; Olsen, G. W., ‘From Bede to the Anglo-Saxon presence in the Carolingian empire’, Settimane di studio del Centro italiano di studi sull'alto medioevo xxxii (1984), 305–82Google Scholar.

11 Carroll, , The Venerable Bede, his spiritual teachings, 68Google Scholar; Bede, , In primam partem Samuhelis libri III, ed. Hurst, D., CCSL cxix. 61, 63Google Scholar; In Ezram et Neemiam, ed. Hurst, D., CCSL cxixa. 248Google Scholar; In Lucam, ed. Hurst, D., CCSL cxx. 37–8Google Scholar; In Genesim, ed. Jones, C. W., CCSL cxviii. 186Google Scholar.

12 Congar, , L'ecclésiologie, 92Google Scholar.

13 Wallace-Hadrill, , Historical commentary, pp. xxvii–xxviiiGoogle Scholar.

14 Bede, , In Ezram et Neemiam, 262Google Scholar; In Genesim, 162, 157; Markus, R. A., Saeculum: history and society in the theology of Saint Augustine, Cambridge 1970, ch. viiGoogle Scholar.

15 Bede, , De templo, ed. Hurst, D., CCSL cxixa. 147Google Scholar.

16 Idem, In Ezra et Neemiam, 357.

17 Bonner, ‘Bede and medieval civilization’, passim; Ray, R., ‘What do we know about Bede's commentaries?’, Recherches de théologie ancienne et médiévale xlix (1982), 5–20 at p. 12Google Scholar.

18 Bede, , In Ezram et Neemiam, 237Google Scholar.

19 Idem, In Genesim, 103–4.

20 Idem, In Lucam, 224.

21 Ibid; De tabernaculo, ed. Hurst, D., CCSL cxixa. 15–25Google Scholar.

22 Mayr-Harting, , The Venerable Bede, the Rule of St Benedict and social class, 1Google Scholar.

23 Augustine, , De civitate Dei xix. 19, ed. Dombart, B. and Kalb, A., CCSL xlix. 686Google Scholar.

24 Markus, R. A., The end of ancient Christianity, Cambridge 1990, 160Google Scholar.

25 Cassian, , Conlationes, xviii. 5. 2–3, ed. Petschenig, M., CSEL xiii. 510–11Google Scholar: ‘hi autem quibus adhuc apostolicus inerat feruor, memores illius pristinae perfectionis, discedentes a civitatibus suis illorumqe consortio, qui sibi vel ecclesiae dei remissioris uitae neglegentiam licitam esse credebant, in locis suburbanis ac secretioribus conmanere et ea, quae ab apostolis per universum corpus ecclesiae generaliter meminerant instituta, priuatim ac peculiariter exercere coeperunt’.

26 Athanasius, , Vita Antonii, Latin trans, by Evagrius, , PL lxxiii. 125–70Google Scholar; English trans. Gregg, R. C., Athanasius, , The Life of Antony and the letter to Marcellinus, New York-London 1980Google Scholar; Jerome, , Vita Pauli, PL xxiii. 17–30Google Scholar.

27 Athanasius, , Vita Antonii 82–4, pp. 90–2Google Scholar.

28 Ibid. 85, p. 93.

29 Salvian, , De gubernatione Dei iii. 9. 44, ed. Pauly, F., CSEL viii. 57Google Scholar; Olsen, G. W., ‘Reform after the pattern of the primitive Church in the thought of Salvian of Marseille’, Catholic Historical Review lxviii (1982), 1–12Google Scholar.

30 Rousseau, P., Ascetics, authority and the Church in the age of Jerome and Cassian, Oxford 1978, 143–65Google Scholar; Stancliffe, C., Saint Martin and his hagiographer, Oxford 1983Google Scholar; Van Dam, R., ‘Images of Saint Martin in late Roman and early Merovingian Gaul’, Viator xix (1988), 1–27Google Scholar, and Saints and their miracles in late antique Gaul, Princeton 1993Google Scholar.

31 Severus, Sulpicius, Vita Martini 6–7, 10, ed. Fontaine, J., SC cxxxiii. 264–9, 272–5Google Scholar.

32 Ibid. 10, SC cxxxiii. 272–5.

33 Ibid. 10–11, 13, SC cxxxiii. 272–7, 280–3; Severus, Sulpicius, Dialogi 11. 4, ed. Halm, C., CSEL i. 184–5Google Scholar.

34 Vitat sanctorum Hiberniae, ed. Plummer, C., Oxford 1910, ii. 96–106 at p. 98Google Scholar. The Life is late but it is possible that it was transcribed in a collection of vitae between 750 and 850: Sharpe, R., Medieval Irish Saints' Lives: an introduction to the Vitae sanctorum Hiberniae, Oxford 1991, 71, 76, 299, 315–18, 329–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar. The heavily monastic structure of the early Irish Church as outlined in Ryan, J., Irish monasticism, Dublin 1931Google Scholar, has recently been reassessed and it has been stressed that the role of the episcopate, as well as monks, should be emphasised: Sharpe, R., ‘Some problems concerning the organisation of the Church in early medieval Ireland’, Peritia iii (1984), 230–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and ‘Churches and communities in early medieval Ireland: towards a pastoral model’, in Pastoral care before the parish, 81–109.

35 Charles-Edwards, T. M.. ‘The social background to Irish peregrinatio’, Celtica xi (1976), 43–59Google Scholar; Hughes, K., ‘The changing theory and practice of Irish pilgrimage’, this JOURNAL xi (1960), 143–5Google Scholar.

36 Sancti Columbani Opera, ed. Walker, G. S. M., Scriptores Latini Hiberniae, ii, Dublin 1957, 122–81Google Scholar; Jonas, , Vita Columbani i. 8, ed. Krusch, B., MGH SS rer. Mer. iv. 74–5Google Scholar.

37 Vita Columbani i. 8–12, 27, ibid. iv. 74–8, 101–4.

38 Vita Fursei, ed. B. Krusch, ibid. iv. 434–40.

39 Markus, , The end of ancient Christianity, 175Google Scholar. See further idem, Saeculum, passim; Brown, P., Augustine of Hippo, London 1967, 136–45Google Scholar; Zumkeller, A., Augustine's ideal of the religious life, trans. Colledge, E., New York 1986, 154Google Scholar; Van Oort, J., Jerusalem and Babylon: a study into Augustine's City of God and the sources of his doctrine of the two cities, Leiden 1991Google Scholar.

40 Ladner, G. B., The idea of reform, 2nd edn, New York 1967, 378–424Google Scholar; Lawless, G., Augustine of Hippo and his monastic rule, Oxford 1987Google Scholar; Brockwell, C. W., ‘Augustine's ideal of monastic community: a paradigm for his doctrine of the Church’, Augustinian Studies viii (1977), 91–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

41 Possidius, , Vita Augustini 24, ed. Weiskotten, H. T., Princeton 1919Google Scholar, trans. Hoare, F. H., in The western fathers, London 1954, 223Google Scholar.

42 Ibid. 5, 22–5, 30, pp. 198–9, 220–5, 232–42.

43 Stancliffe, C., ‘Cuthbert and the polarity between pastor and solitary’, in Bonner, G., Stancliffe, C. and Rollason, D. (eds), Saint Cuthbert, his cult and his community, Woodbridge 1989 37Google Scholar. See further Rousseau, P., ‘Cassian, contemplation and the coenobitic Life’, this JOURNAL xxvi (1975), 113–26Google Scholar.

44 Cassian, , Conlationes, Praef, i. 4, CSEL xiii. 4Google Scholar.

45 Ibid. i. 8. 14–16.

46 Ibid. xix. 3. 2. 536. ‘sed quia degustata eius puritas sollicitudine interdum carnalium rerum interpolata sordebat, recurrere ad coenobium commodius uisum est, ut et promptior adrepti propositi planioris consummatio consequeretur et minus de praesumptae sublimioris professionis humilitate periculum’.

47 Ibid. xvi. 6. 442–5.

48 Rousseau, , Ascetics, authority and the Church, 169–239Google Scholar; Markus, , The end of ancient Christianity, 181–211Google Scholar.

49 Prinz, F., Frühes Mönchtum im Frankenreich, Munich-Vienna 1965, 47–87Google Scholar.

50 Hilary, of Arles, , Vita Honorali 16, ed. Cavallin, S., in Vitae sanctorum Honorati et Hilarii, Lund 1952, 60Google Scholar.

51 Ibid. 17–18, 28. 61–2, 69.

52 Vita Caesarii i. 11, 15–16, 20, 37; ii. 42, ed. B. Krusch, MGH SS rer. Mer. iii. 461–4, 471, 498. For further discussion of Caesarius of Aries see Klingshirn, W. E., Caesarius of Aries: the making of a Christian community in late antique Gaul, Cambridge 1994Google Scholar.

53 On Pomerius' career as a priest see Riché, Pierre, Education and culture in the barbarian west, sixth through eighth centuries, trans. Contreni, J. J., Columbia, SC 1976, 32Google Scholar.

54 Pomerius, Julianus, De vita contemplativa, i. 12, PL lix. 427–8Google Scholar: ‘Ad activam vitam pertinet inter humana proficere, et rebelles corporis motus rationis imperio temperare; ad contemplativam supra humana desiderio perfectionis ascendere, et indesinenter augendis virtutibus incubare. Habet activa profectum, contemplativa fastigium. Haec facit hominem sanctum, ilia perfectum’.

55 Butler, C., Western mysticism, London 1922, 195–241Google Scholar; Dagens, C., Saint Grégoire le Grand: culture et expérience chrétiennes, Paris 1977, 135–63Google Scholar; Fontaine, J., ‘Un fondateur de l'Europe: Grégoire le Grand (590–604)’, Helmantica xxxiv (1983), 171–89Google Scholar.

56 Gregory, the Great, Homiliae in Ezechielem, ed. Adriaen, M., CCSL cxlii. 235–6Google Scholar.

57 Idem, Liber regulae pastoralis ii. 5, PL lxxvii. 32. ‘Sit rector singulis compassione proximus, prae cunctis contemplatione suspensus, ut et per pietatis viscera in se infirmitatem caeterorum transferat, et per speculationis altitudinem semetipsum quoque invisibilia appetendo transcendat, ne aut alta petens proximorum infirma despiciat, aut informis proximorum congruens, appetere alta derelinquat’.

58 Ibid. ii. 3. 28; ii. 5. 32–3.

59 Gregory, the Great, Homiliae in Ezechielem, 152, 174, 183–4Google Scholar; Moralia in Iob 1. 20. 28, CCSL cxliii. 40.

60 Ibid. 31. 51. 102, CCSL cxliiib. 1620–1; 6. 37. 56–61, CCSL cxliii. 325–31; 28. 13. 33, CCSL cxliiib, 1420–1; 31. 25. 49, CCSL cxliiib. 1584–5; 30. 2. 8, CCSL cxliiib, 1495–6; Homiliae in Ezechielem, 229–30.

61 Bede, , Opera homiletica, i. 9, ed. Hurst, D., CCSL cxxii. 64–5Google Scholar.

62 Stancliffe, ‘Cuthbert and the polarity between pastor and solitary’, passim.

63 VCA, i. 1.

64 Ibid.

65 Stancliffe, , ‘Cuthbert and the polarity between pastor an d solitary’, 32Google Scholar.

66 VCA iv. ii.

67 Ibid. ii. 1, 3.

68 Thacker, A. T., ‘Lindisfarne and the origins of the cult of St Cuthbert’, in Bonner, , Stancliffe, and Rollason, , St Cuthbert, his cult and his community, 111Google Scholar. A further parallel is with the Dialogues of Gregory the Great.

69 VCA i. 2; iv. 1; Picard, J.-M., ‘Structural patterns in early Hiberno-Latin hagiography’, Peritia iv (1985), 75Google Scholar.

70 VCA ii. 7; Severus, Sulpicius, Vita Martini 14, SC cxxxii. 282–5Google Scholar.

71 VCA iv. 6; Severus, Sulpicius, Dialogi ii. 4, CSEL i. 184–5Google Scholar.

72 VCA iv. 1; Vita Martini 10, SC cxxxiii. 272–5.

73 VCA ii. 6; iv. 5; Vita Martini 7–8, 22, SC cxxxiii. 266–71, 300–3.

74 VCA iv. 1, 9, 11; Vita Martini 10, SC cxxxviii. 272–5.

75 Adomnán, , Vita Columbae, iii. 12, trans. Sharpe, R., Harmondsworth 1995, 214–15Google Scholar.

76 Stancliffe, , ‘Cuthbert and the polarity between pastor and solitary’, 22–3Google Scholar; Bullough, D. A., ‘Columba, Adomnán and the achievement of Iona’, Scottish Historical Review xliii (1964), 110–30Google Scholar; xliv (1965) 17–33.

77 Ibid. 130.

78 Picard, , ‘Structural patterns in early Hiberno-Latin hagiography’, 75Google Scholar.

79 VCA iv. 8; Vita Columbae i. 7–15, 43, 49. 118–123, 145–7, 151–2.

80 VCA ii. 3; Vita Columbae iii. 16. 217–19.

81 VCA ii. 3, 5; iii. 5; Vita Columbae ii. 19, 21, 26–9; iii. 23. 168–9, 170, 175–8 225–34.

82 Ibid. iii. 18. 219–20.

83 Ibid. ii. 17, 20–3, 25, 33. 167, 169–73, 174–55 181–2; Stancliffe, C., ‘The miracle stories in seventh-century Irish saints' lives’, in Fontaine, J. and Hillgarth, J. N. (eds), Le septième siècle: changements et continuités; the seventh century: change and continuity, London 1992, 87–115Google Scholar.

84 Severus, Sulpicius, Dialogi i. 13–14Google Scholar; ii. 9, CSEL i. 164–7, 190–1, 190–1; VCA, i. 6; ii. 3, 5; iii. 5; Vita Columbani i. 7–8, 15, 17, 22, 27, MGH SS rer. Mer. iv. 73–5, 80–1, 83–5, 95–7, 101–4.

85 Ibid. i. 8–9, 12, 17, 27, MGH SS rer. Mer. iv. 74–5, 78, 83–5, 101–4.

86 Ibid. i. 18–22, 24, 27–9, MGH SS rer. Mer. iv. 86–97, 98–9, 101–8.

87 Vita Amandi i. 5, 8, 13, 16, 18–20, 22, 26, ed. Krusch, B., MGH SRM v. 433–4, 436, 439–40, 442–5, 449Google Scholar.

88 The Calendar of Saint Willibrord from MS Paris lat. 10837, ed. Wilson, H. A. (Henry Bradshaw Society lv, 1918), 4–16, 21, 24, 27Google Scholar.

89 Lapidge, M., ‘Bede's metrical Vita S. Cuthberti’ in Bonner, , Stancliffe, and Rollason, , St Cuthbert, his cult and his community, 77–93Google Scholar; VCM 21. 100, lines 582–5.

90 Ibid. prologue, 57.

91 Godman, P., ‘The Anglo-Latin opus geminatum from Aldhelm to Alcuin’, Medium Aevum 1 (1982), 215–29Google Scholar.

92 Lapidge, , ‘Bede's metrical Vita S. Cuthberti’, 83–5Google Scholar.

93 Paulinus, of Périgueux, , De Vita S. Martini, ed. Petschenig, M., CSEL xvi. 17–159Google Scholar; Fortunatus, Venantius, Vita S. Martini, MGH Auct. Ant. iv. 1, 293–370Google Scholar.

94 Van Dam, , ‘Images of St Martin’, 5–12Google Scholar.

95 VCM 21. 98, line 587; Paulinus, of Périgueux, , De Vita S. Martini ii. 35, line 21Google Scholar.

96 VCM 7, 74; Severus, Sulpicius, Vita Martini 21, SC cxxxiii. 298–301Google Scholar; Paulinus, of Périgueux, , De Vita S. Martini, iii. 68–9, lines 144–51Google Scholar; Fortunatus, Venantius, Vita S. Martini ii. 318, line 122Google Scholar; iii. 343, lines 409–13.

97 Thacker, , ‘Bede's ideal of reform’, 134–42Google Scholar.

98 Wallace-Hadrill, , Historical commentary, 170Google Scholar.

99 VCP 39.

100 Ibid. 22.

101 Ibid. 9.

102 Ibid. 16; Stancliffe, , ‘Cuthbert and the polarity between pastor and solitary’, 32–3Google Scholar.

103 VCP 16.

104 Ibid. 17–22.

105 Gregory, the Great, Dialogues ii, ed. de Vogüé, A., SC cclx. 126–248Google Scholar; Thacker, , ‘Bede's ideal of reform’, 135Google Scholar.

106 VCP 26–35.

107 HE iv. 27–32.

108 Ibid. iii. 5, 17.

109 Vita Caesarii i. 7, 13–14, MGH iii. SS rer. Mer. 459–62.

110 HE iii. 5.

111 Ibid. iii. 16–17.

112 Ibid. iii. 5, 15.

113 Ibid. iv. 29–30; VCP 40, 42.

114 HE iv. 3.

115 Severus, Sulpicius, Vita Martini 10, SC cxxxiii. 272–5Google Scholar; Stancliffe, , St Martin, 24Google Scholar.

116 HE v. 2.

117 Ibid. iv. 1–2.