Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-75dct Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-08T00:15:00.424Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Philosophy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 September 2013

Extract

The interest in Presocratic philosophy, and the scholarly output on it, have been rising again in the last few years. I start this review with a sample of recent publications in the area. It is easy to expect that Daniel Graham's collection of The Texts of Early Greek Philosophy, in two volumes, will become a popular tool for the study of Presocratic philosophy (for some qualifications on this expectation see below). The sourcebook aims to present ‘the complete fragments and a generous selection of testimonies’ for the major early Greek philosophers. English translations (all by Graham himself) are set opposite to Greek and Latin texts (with slim textual notes identifying substantive textual variants), with succinct introductions for each philosopher, and brief commentaries and basic bibliographies following the texts. The Diels-Kranz (hereafter DK) collection is the starting point for this sourcebook, but Graham is quite selective in his shortlist of those who deserve a place in his sourcebook: out of ninety DK sections, he includes only nineteen philosophers (Thales, Anaximander, Anaximenes, Xenophanes, Heraclitus, Parmenides, Zeno of Elea, Anaxagoras, Empedocles, Diogenes of Apollonia, Melissus, Philolaus, Leucippus, Democritus, Protagoras, Gorgias, Antiphon, Prodicus, and Pythagoras, the last being relegated to an appendix) and two anonymous texts, the Anonymus Iamblichi and the Dissoi Logoi. Although the sourcebook includes some fragments and testimonies that did not appear in DK (e.g. the Strasbourg papyrus for Empedocles), and only a selection of the testimonies included there, the major difference in terms of the material included for the selected philosophers is the order in which fragments and testimonies are presented. The fragments are incorporated within the context of the broader testimonies containing them (and signalled in bold), rather than listed separately, as in DK; the numbering of fragments and testimonies does not correspond to DK, but the DK numbers are given in addition, and volume 2 includes a list of concordances (besides an index of sources, an index of other passages quoted by Graham in his end-of-chapter commentaries, and a short general index of names and topics). Graham's choice is definitely a healthy step forward from DK's largely artificial strategy of separating fragments and testimonies into two different sections; one might wonder whether the decision to signal in bold words, phrases, sentences, and sections that supposedly count as original fragments within the broader context in which they occur is still too heavily indebted to the DK model. For each author the texts are organized in four main sections: life, works, philosophy, and reception, with the philosophy section typically structured into thematic subsections. Of course the strengths and shortcomings of a monumental work such as Graham's can be fully appreciated only over time, once you use it repeatedly in your teaching and research. I have mentioned Graham's approach to the distinction between fragments and testimonies: some sustained methodological discussion, and explanation of the criteria guiding the distinction, would have been welcome. Unavoidably some readers will find Graham's shortlist of philosophers and selection of texts unsatisfactory and too narrow: some qualms about notable exclusions – such as Solon, Alcmaeon, Archytas, Pherecydes, the Orphics, and the Derveni author – have already been voiced (for example, by Jason Rheins in his review in Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews). As far as I could see, the translations are reliable, and the short introductions, commentaries, and bibliographies provide just enough information for readers to contextualize the authors and texts within the philosophical tradition (less so within the broader archaic Greek cultural and literary tradition), and appreciate some of the key exegetical and philosophical issues that they raise. Just enough, and this brings me to what I find to be the less convincing aspect of such an enterprise as Graham's. His collection will certainly be of some use as an accessible reference tool for advanced students and researchers, but its selectivity will prevent it from becoming a research tool in its own right, and standard editions of individual Presocratics will remain the first port of call (for example, the second edition of Coxon's The Fragments of Parmenides, reviewed below). At the same time, the breadth of the material that it contains, coupled with the relative thinness of the apparatus of introductions and commentaries, does not make The Texts of Early Greek Philosophy the kind of introductory sourcebook that could be used on its own in an introductory undergraduate course on ancient philosophy, or on the Presocratics. It is difficult to imagine lecturers of such courses prescribing to their students more than a small fraction of the material offered by Graham; and those students will still need to use standard introductions to Presocratic philosophy such as Kirk–Raven–Schofield, Barnes, McKirahan, or Warren to make real sense of the evidence presented by Graham, placing it within a unified narrative about the nature and development of early Greek philosophy. From this point of view, Graham's collection risks falling into no man's land from the point of view of its readership: it is neither a ground-breaking, research-shaping tool such as, for example, Long and Sedley's collection on The Hellenistic Philosophers has been for three decades now, nor an introductory textbook easily accessible (for both sheer bulk and price) to undergraduate students. That said, Graham's work still deserves a place in all university libraries and on the shelves of ancient philosophy scholars.

Type
Subject Reviews
Copyright
Copyright © The Classical Association 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The Texts of Early Greek Philosophy. The Complete Fragments and Selected Testimonies of the Major Presocratics. By Graham, Daniel W.. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2010. Pp. xiv + 1020Google Scholar. Hardback £116, ISBN: 978-0-521-84591-5; paperback £62, ISBN: 978-0-521-60842-8.

2 Die sieben Weisen. Leben, Lehren und Legenden. By Engels, Johannes. Munich, Beck, 2010. Pp. 127Google Scholar. 1 map, 10 illustrations. Paperback €8.95, ISBN: 978-3-406-58785-6.

3 Gli inizi della filosofia. In Grecia. By Sassi, Maria Michela. Turin, Bollati Boringhieri, 2009. Pp. 307Google Scholar. Paperback €19, ISBN: 978-88-339-1974-4.

4 Introduction to Presocratics. A Thematic Approach to Early Greek Philosophy with Key Readings. By Stamatellos, Giannis. Malden, MA, Oxford, and Chichester, Wiley-Blackwell, 2012. Pp. xiv + 162Google Scholar. 1 map. Hardback £50, ISBN: 978-0-470-65502-3; paperback £19.99, ISBN: 978-0-470-655503-0.

5 Early Greek Thought. Before the Dawn. By Luchte, James. Continuum Studies in Ancient Philosophy. London and New York, Continuum, 2011. Pp. xvii + 197Google Scholar. Hardback £65, ISBN: 978-1-4411-4661-8.

6 The Fragments of Parmenides. A Critical Text with Introduction and Translation, the Ancient Testimonia and Commentary. By Coxon, A. H.. Second edition. Edited with new translations by McKirahan, Richard and a new preface by Malcolm Schofield. Las Vegas, NV, Zurich, and Athens, Parmenides Publishing, 2009. Pp. xiv + 461Google Scholar. Paperback £52.50, ISBN: 978-1-930972-67-4.

7 Parmenides and To Eon. Reconsidering Muthos and Logos. By Wilkinson, Lisa Atwood. Continuum Studies in Ancient Philosophy. London and New York, Continuum, 2009. Pp. 156Google Scholar. Hardback £65, ISBN: 978-1-8470-6245-1.

8 Parmenides and Presocratic Philosophy. By Palmer, John. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2009. Pp. xii + 428.CrossRefGoogle Scholar Hardback £70, ISBN: 978-0-19-956790-4; paperback £25, ISBN: 978-0-19-966469-6.

9 Definition in Greek Philosophy. Edited by Charles, David. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2010. Pp. x + 556CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Hardback £63, ISBN: 978-0-19-956445-3.

10 Explorations in Ancient and Modern Philosophy. Volume I. By Burnyeat, M. F.. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2012. Pp. x + 382Google Scholar. Hardback £75, ISBN: 978-0-521-75072-1. Explorations in Ancient and Modern Philosophy. Volume II. By Burnyeat, M. F.. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2012. Pp. x + 356Google Scholar. Hardback £75, ISBN: 978-0-521-75073-8. Also available as a set: hardback £135, ISBN: 978-1-107-40006-1.

11 A complete list of Burnyeat's publications until 2007 can be found in the splendid Scott, D. (ed.), Maieusis. Essays in Ancient Philosophy in Honour of Myles Burnyeat (Oxford, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Castagnoli, L., Ancient Self-refutation. The Logic and History of the Self-refutation Argument from Democritus to Augustine (Cambridge, 2010)Google Scholar.

13 Method and Metaphysics. Essays in Ancient Philosophy I. By Barnes, Jonathan. Edited by Bonelli, Maddalena. Oxford, Clarendon Press, 2011. Pp. xi + 621Google Scholar. Hardback £62.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-957751-4.

14 Logical Matters. Essays in Ancient Philosophy II. By Barnes, Jonathan. Edited by Bonelli, Maddalena. Oxford, Clarendon Press, 2012. Pp. xv + 796Google Scholar. Hardback £85, ISBN: 978-0-19-957752-1.

15 A Free Will. Origins of the Notion in Ancient Thought. By Frede, Michael. Edited by Long, A. A., with a foreword by David Sedley. Berkeley, CA, Los Angeles, CA, and London, University of California Press, 2011. Pp. xiv + 206Google Scholar. Hardback £41.95, ISBN: 978-0-520-26848-7; paperback £19.95, ISBN: 978-0-520-27266-8.

16 Bobzien, S., ‘The Inadvertent Birth and Late Conception of the Free-will Problem’, Phronesis 43 (1998), 133–75CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Essays in Memory of Michael Frede. Edited by Allen, James, Eyjόlfur Kjalar Emilsson, Wolfgang-Rainer Mann, and Benjamin MorisonGoogle Scholar. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy, Vol. XL, Summer 2011. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011. Pp. viii + 420Google Scholar. Hardback £65, ISBN: 978-0-19-960965-9; Paperback £27.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-960966-6.

18 Ancient Models of Mind. Studies in Human and Divine Rationality. Edited by Nightingale, Andrea and Sedley, David. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2010. Pp. ix + 250CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Hardback £58, ISBN: 978-0-521-11355-7.

19 Virtue and Happiness. Essays in Honour of Julia Annas. Edited by Kamtekar, Rachana. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy, Supplementary Volume 2012. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2012. Pp. x + 351CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Hardback £57.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-964604-3; paperback £24, ISBN: 978-0-19-964605-0.

20 Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy. Edited by Inwood, Brad. Oxford, Oxford University Press. Vol. XXXVII, Winter 2009Google Scholar, hardback £62.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-957556-5, paperback £27, ISBN: 978-0-19-957557-2. Vol. XXXVIII, Summer 2010, hardback £65, ISBN: 978-0-19-958680-6, paperback £27.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-958681-3. Vol. XXXIX, Winter 2010, hardback £63, ISBN: 978-0-19-959711-6; paperback £26, ISBN: 978-0-19-959712-3. Vol. XLI, Winter 2011, hardback £52.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-969861-5, paperback £24, ISBN: 978-0-19-969862-2. Vol. XLII, Summer 2012, hardback £52.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-964438-4, paperback £24, ISBN: 978-0-19-964439-1. Vol. XLIII, Winter 2012, hardback £50, ISBN: 978-0-19-966616-4, paperback £22.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-966617-1.