No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Extract
I start this review, which focuses for the most part on publications on Hellenistic philosophy, with a survey of some recent studies on Stoicism. René Brouwer's The Stoic Sage introduces itself as ‘an attempt to bring the early Stoic notions of the sage and wisdom to the fore again’ (1). ‘Again’ alludes to the fact that those notions, which attracted considerable philosophical and scholarly interest at various stages since antiquity, have not received sufficient attention in recent times (specialists in the area will judge the merits of this assessment). The book is divided into four chapters, dealing respectively with the Stoic definitions of wisdom; the ancient puzzles surrounding the nature and very possibility of the change from ‘folly’ to ‘wisdom’; the controversial question of whether the Stoics themselves believed they had achieved the ideal of perfect wisdom; and the intellectual, Socratic background against which the Stoics developed their notion of wisdom. Chapters 2, 3, and 4 contain, in expanded and revised form, material published by Brouwer in self-contained essays between 2002 and 2008. Chapter 1, with its analysis of the Stoic definitions of wisdom as ‘knowledge of human and divine matters’ and ‘fitting expertise’, is fundamental to set the stage for the more focused inquiries of the rest of the book. From this point of view, it succeeds only partially. It helpfully covers a reasonable amount of ground, but because of Brouwer's choice to focus exclusively on the Stoic definitions of wisdom (sophia) at this stage, and not, say, on the descriptions of the Stoic wise man (sophos: Brouwer's preferred translation ‘sage’ hides the etymological connection), it also problematically leaves some fundamental aspects untouched. I was especially surprised not to see the key notion of infallibility discussed at all in this context, despite the fact that Brouwer correctly clarifies that Stoic wisdom is not to be interpreted as a form of omniscience (33–4). This ultimately springs from an insufficiently detailed analysis of the Stoics’ notions of katalēpsis (which Brouwer translates as ‘cognition’, without ever explaining its distinctive status), and then, in turn, of epistēmē and technē, and their Stoic definitions (see also the puzzling reference to ‘weak cognitions’ on p. 62). (I only note here that Paolo Togni's 2010 monograph Conoscenza e virtù nella dialettica stoica examines much more extensively and systematically the psychological and epistemological ground which needs to be covered by a discussion of Stoic sophia.) The attempt to map exhaustively the three key terms of the first definition – knowledge, human and divine – into the three parts of Stoic philosophy, respectively logic, ethics, and physics, is ingenious but too crude and ultimately unconvincing, since logic had for the Stoics its own separate subject matter (not to be identified with ‘human and divine matters’, and not even with knowledge itself, pace Brouwer), and ethics and physics can themselves be described as forms of knowledge. The interconnected nature of Stoic philosophy, which is helpfully emphasized throughout the book, need not be mirrored in the very definition of wisdom. From a broader methodological point of view, the attempt to reconstruct an early Stoic theory of wisdom constantly clashes with the nature of our evidence, and although in several cases Brouwer does carefully justify why a certain late source can be taken to bear witness to such an early theory, in other cases the reader is left to wonder whether such a justification could be given (for example, in the case of some passages from Seneca). There is still much worth pondering in Brouwer's insightful analyses in Chapters 2–4, although one is left to wonder how much added value has been generated by integrating this previously published material into a single monograph.
- Type
- Subject Reviews
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Classical Association 2015
References
1 The Stoic Sage. The Early Stoics on Wisdom, Sagehood and Socrates. By René Brouwer. Cambridge Classical Studies. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2014. Pp. x + 230. 1 b/w illustration. Hardback £60, ISBN: 978-1-107-02421-2.
2 Conoscenza e virtù nella dialettica stoica. By Paolo Togni. Naples, Bibliopolis, 2010. Pp. 305. Paperback €30, ISBN: 978-88-7088-599-6.
3 Plato and the Stoics. Edited by A. G. Long. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2013. Pp. x + 199. Hardback £55, ISBN: 978-1-107-04059-5.
4 Naturalistic Psychology in Galen and Stoicism. By Christopher Gill. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2010. Pp. xv + 396. Hardback £87, ISBN: 978-0-19-955679-3.
5 The Hellenistic Stoa. Political Thought and Action. By Andrew Erskine. Second edition. London, Bristol Classical Press, 2011. Pp. xv + 233. Paperback £25, ISBN: 978-1-8539-9747-1.
6 Studies in Stoicism. By P. A. Brunt. Edited by Miriam Griffin and Alison Samuels, with the assistance of Michael Crawford. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2013. Pp. vi + 521. Hardback £120, ISBN: 978-0-19-969585-0.
7 Marcus Aurelius. Meditations. With Selected Correspondence. Translated by Robin Hard, with an Introduction and Notes by Christopher Gill. Oxford World's Classics. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011. Pp. xxxii + 176. Paperback £7.99, ISBN: 978-0-19-957320-2.
8 A Written Republic. Cicero's Philosophical Politics. By Yelena Baraz. Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press, 2012. Pp. xi + 252. Hardback £32.95, ISBN: 978-0-691-15332-2.
9 Cicero on Politics and the Limits of Reason. The Republic and Laws. By Jed W. Atkins. Cambridge Classical Studies. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2013. Pp. xiv + 270. Hardback £60, ISBN: 978-1-107-04358-9.
10 Cicero's Ideal Statesman in Theory and Practice. By Jonathan Zarecki. London and New York, Bloomsbury, 2014. Pp. xi + 212. Hardback £60, ISBN: 978-1-78093-295-8.
11 Epicuro. By Francesco Verde. Rome, Carocci, 2013. Pp. 276. Paperback €22, ISBN: 978-88-430-7110-4.
12 Épicurisme et scepticisme. Edited by Stéphane Marchand and Francesco Verde. Roma, Sapienza Università Editrice, 2013. Pp. xii + 189. Paperback €17, ISBN: 978-88-98533-10-7.
13 Epicurus and the Epicurean Tradition. Edited by Jeffrey Fish and Kirk R. Sanders. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2011. Pp. xi + 267. Hardback £59.99, ISBN: 978-0-521-19478-5.
14 The Invention and Gendering of Epicurus. By Pamela Gordon. Ann Arbor, MI, University of Michigan Press, 2012. Pp. viii + 222. Hardback £56.95, ISBN: 978-0-472-11808-3.
15 Plutarch Against Colotes. A Lesson in History of Philosophy. By Eleni Kechagia. Oxford Classical Monographs. Oxford and New York, Oxford University Press, 2011. Pp. xvii + 359. Hardback £78, ISBN: 978-0-19-959723-9.
16 <http://aitia.revues.org/591>, accessed 5 May 2015.
17 L’Adversus Colotem di Plutarco. Storia di una polemica filosofica. By Aurora Corti. Leuven, Leuven University Press, 2014. Pp. 326. Hardback €79, ISBN: 978-94-6270-009-3.
18 Philodemus. On Property Management. Translated with an Introduction and Notes by Voula Tsouna. Writings from the Greco-Roman World 33. Atlanta, GA, Society of Biblical Literature, 2012. Pp. xlv + 125. Paperback £15.99, ISBN: 978-1-58983-667-9.
19 Aenesidemus of Cnossus. Testimonia. By Roberto Polito. Cambridge Classical Texts and Commentaries. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2014. Pp. vii + 395. Hardback £75, ISBN: 978-0-521-19025-1.
20 Strategies of Argument. Edited by Mi-Kyoung Lee. New York, Oxford University Press, 2014. Pp. xvii + 399. Hardback £64, ISBN: 978-0-19-989047-7.
21 E.g. Dorothea Frede (2006, reviewed in G&R 2007), Myles Burnyeat (2007), Anthony Long (2010, reviewed in G&R 2013), Michael Frede (2011, reviewed in G&R 2013), Jonathan Barnes (2011), Julia Annas (2012, reviewed in G&R 2013), Christopher Rowe (2013), and Malcolm Schofield (2013).
22 Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy. Edited by Brad Inwood. Oxford, Oxford University Press. Volumes XLIV (Summer 2013; hardback £55, ISBN: 978-0-19-967788-7; paperback £22.99, ISBN: 978-0-19-967789-4), XLV (Winter 2013; hardback £55, ISBN: 978-0-19-967943-0; paperback £25, ISBN: 978-0-19-967944-7), XLVI (Summer 2014; hardback £55, ISBN: 978-0-19-871292-3; paperback £22.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-871293-0), and XLVII (Winter 2014; hardback £55, ISBN: 978-0-19-872271-7; paperback £22.50, ISBN: 978-0-19-872272-4).
23 Proof, Knowledge and Scepticism. Essays in Ancient Philosophy III. By Jonathan Barnes. Edited by Maddalena Bonelli. Oxford, Clarendon Press, 2014. Pp. xii + 703. Hardback £85, ISBN: 978-0-19-957753-8.