1 Haley, John O., ‘Criminal justice in Japan’ (review), Journal of Japanese Studies 18(2) (1992), 552.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 Beer, in Kodansha encyclopedia of Japan (Tokyo, 1983)Google Scholar, in article on ‘Legal System’, 380Google Scholar; Y. Suzuki, ibid., article on ‘Crime’, 45.

3 See Kodansha's, Japan: an illustrated encyclopedia (Tokyo, 1993), vol. i, 256.Google Scholar

4 Suzuki, , ‘Crime’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 44.Google Scholar

5 Bayley, David H., ‘Police, crime and the community in Japan’ in De Vos, George ed., Institutions for change in Japanese society (Institute of East Asian Studies, University of California, Berkeley, Research Papers, 9) (Berkeley, 1982), 179.Google Scholar

6 Wigmore, John Henry ed., Law and justice in Tokugawa Japan (Tokyo, 1969), vol. i, 43.Google Scholar

7 Bayley, , ‘Police, crime and the community’, 179.Google Scholar

8 Beardsley, Richard K., Hall, John W. and Ward, Robert E., Village Japan (Chicago, 1959), 390.Google Scholar

9 See, for instance, Ames, Walter L., Police and community in Japan (Berkeley, 1981), ch. 6.Google Scholar

10 Smith, Robert J., Japanese society: tradition, self and the social order (Cambridge, 1983), 126.Google Scholar

11 Bayley, , ‘Police, crime and the community’, 188.Google Scholar

12 Ibid., 182.

13 Suzuki, ‘Crime’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 46.Google Scholar

14 Haley, John O., ‘Sheathing the sword of justice in Japan: an essay on law without sanctions’, Journal of Japanese Studies 8(2) (1982), 273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

15 Bayley, , ‘Police, crime and the community’, 182.Google Scholar

16 Suzuki, Y., ‘Prisons’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 249.Google Scholar The figure for 1989 is 51,658, almost identical to that for 1980 given the rise in population, according to Japan: an illustrated encyclopedia, vol. ii, 1230.Google Scholar

17 Bayley, , ‘Police, crime and the community’, 182.Google Scholar

18 Ibid., 180.

19 Ibid., 182; Haley, , ‘Sheathing the sword’, 270.Google Scholar

20 Bayley, , ‘Police, crime and the community’, 182.Google Scholar

21 Haley, John Owen, ‘The myth of the reluctant litigant’, Journal of Japanese Studies 4(2) (1978), 362.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

22 Tanabe, K., in Mehren, Arthur Taylor von ed., Law in Japan: the legal order in a changing society (Cambridge, Mass., 1963), 85.Google Scholar

23 Maki, J. M., ‘Judicial system’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 81.Google Scholar

24 Haley, , ‘Reluctant litigant’, 368.Google Scholar

25 Watanabe, T., ‘Lawyers’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 371.Google Scholar

26 Haley, , ‘Sheathing the sword’, 274.Google Scholar

27 Ibid., 273.

28 Haley, , ‘Reluctant litigant’, 386.Google Scholar

29 Haley, , ‘Reluctant litigant’, 389.Google Scholar Smith disputes this interpretation, but only on general grounds (Smith, , Japanese society, 44).Google Scholar Of course, it is impossible to prove, but those I talked to in Japan about this matter suggested that if there were many more courts and judges and hence justice was speeded up, this might possibly double the litigation rates. If this reasonable guess is approximately right, even such a doubling would not bring the level anywhere near that in most industrial countries.

30 Bayley, , ‘Police, crime and the community’, 183–4.Google Scholar

31 Ratclifle, C. T., ‘Dispute resolution’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 117.Google Scholar

32 Suzuki, , ‘Crime’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 46.Google Scholar

33 Haley, , ‘Sheathing the sword’, 276.Google Scholar

34 Haley, , ‘Criminal justice’, 555.Google Scholar

35 de Montesquieu, Baron, The spirit of the laws, Hafner edn (New York, 1949), trans. Nugent, Thomas, i, 233–4.Google Scholar

36 Smith, Thomas, The agrarian origins of modern Japan (Stanford, 1959), 60.Google Scholar

37 Wigmore, ed., Law and justice, i, 22.Google Scholar

38 Sansom, G. B., Japan: a short cultural history, revised edn (New York, 1962), 427.Google Scholar

39 I thank Professor Yon Nakanishi of Tokyo for his description of this feature of modern Japan.

40 Manners and customs of the Japanese in the nineteenth century: from the accounts of Dutch residents in Japan and… Dr. Philipp Franz von Siebold, Tuttle edn, (Tokyo, 1973), 154.Google Scholar

41 Haley, , ‘Criminal justice’, 555.Google Scholar

42 Smith, Robert J., Japanese society, 56.Google Scholar

43 Longford, Joseph H., Japan of the Japanese, 2nd edn (London, 1915), 195.Google Scholar

44 Haley, , ‘Sheathing the sword’, 269.Google Scholar

45 Tanaka, Hideo ed., The Japanese legal system: introductory cases and materials (Tokyo, 1976), 316.Google Scholar

46 Haley, , ‘Sheathing the sword’, 270.Google Scholar

47 George, B. J., ‘Criminal procedure’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 50.Google Scholar

48 Foucault, Michel, Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison (London, 1977).Google Scholar

49 Suzuki, , ‘Prisons’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 249.Google Scholar

50 Hendry, Joy, Understanding Japanese society (London, 1987), 189.Google Scholar

51 Hirano, R. in Mehren, von ed., Law in Japan, 290.Google Scholar

52 Haley's, ‘Criminal justice’, 555.Google Scholar

53 Quoted in Sansom, , Japan, 427.Google Scholar

54 All quoted in Watanabe, Shoichi, The peasant soul of Japan (London, 1989), 86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

55 Tanaka, ed., Japanese legal system, 303.Google Scholar

56 Matsumoto, Michiro, The unspoken way: Haragei, silence in Japanese business and society (Tokyo, 1988).Google Scholar

57 Beardsley, , Village Japan, 392–3.Google Scholar

58 Henderson, Dan F. and Anderson, James L., ‘Japanese law: a profile’, in Tiedemann, Arthur E. ed., An introduction to Japanese civilization (Columbia, 1974), 577.Google Scholar

59 Smith, Robert J., Japanese society, 39.Google Scholar

60 Ibid., 40.

61 ‘Japanese law’, 588.Google Scholar

62 Obuchi, Tetsuya, ‘Role of the court in the process of informal dispute resolution in Japan’, Law in Japan 20(74) (1987), 77.Google Scholar

63 Henderson, and Anderson, , ‘Japanese law’, 587.Google Scholar

64 Tanaka, ed., Japanese legal system, 306, 307.Google Scholar

65 Wigmore, ed., Law and justice, vol. i, 43.Google Scholar

66 See Takayanagi, K., ‘A century of innovation: the development of Japanese law, 1868–1961’, in Mehren, von ed., Law in Japan, 39.Google Scholar

67 Obuchi, , ‘Role of the court’, 100.Google Scholar

68 For a description of nemawashi and of the ringi system of stamps of approval, see for example Matsumoto, , Unspoken way, 127, 121.Google Scholar

69 Sansom, , Japan, 158.Google Scholar For a more detailed account using this framework, see Ryavec, C. A., ‘Legal system: history of Japanese law’ in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 376.Google Scholar

70 Sansom, , Japan, 284.Google Scholar

71 Quoted by Takayanagi, in von Mehren, ed., Law in Japan, 23.Google Scholar

72 Haley, , ‘Consensual governance’ in Kumon, Shumpei and Rosovsky, Henry eds., The political economy of Japan, iii: Cultural and social dynamics (Stanford, 1992), 45.Google Scholar

73 Wigmore, ed., Law and justice, i, xxii.Google Scholar

74 Sansom, , Japan, 302–3.Google Scholar

75 Ryavec, , ‘Legal system’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 376.Google Scholar

76 Henderson, Dan Fenno, ‘The evolution of Tokugawa law’ in Hall, John W. and Jansen, Marius B. eds., Studies in the institutional history of early modern Japan (New Jersey, 1968), 204.Google Scholar

77 Mass, Jeffrey P., ‘The origins of Kamakura justice’ in Journal of Japanese Studies 3(2) (1977), 322.CrossRefGoogle Scholar For documentary evidence, see the same author's Lordship and inheritance in early medieval Japan (Stanford, 1989).Google Scholar

78 Mass, , ‘Kamakura justice’, 301.Google Scholar

79 Mass, Jeffrey P., ‘The Kamakura bakufu’, in Yamamura, Kozo ed., The Cambridge history of Japan, iii: Medieval Japan (Cambridge, 1990), 75.Google Scholar

80 Mass, , ‘Kamakura justice’, 313.Google Scholar

81 Ibid., 320.

82 Ibid., 321.

83 Mass, , ‘Kamakura bakufu’, 75.Google Scholar

84 Ryavec, , ‘Legal systems’, in Kodansha Encyclopedia, 377.Google Scholar

85 Ibid., 377.

86 Mass, , ‘Kamakura bakufu’, 76.Google Scholar

87 Mass, , ‘Kamakura justice’, 320–1.Google Scholar

88 Mass, , ‘Kamakura bakufu’, 79.Google Scholar

89 Ibid., 78.

90 Sansom, , Japan, 426.Google Scholar

91 Ibid., 459.

92 Wigmore, ed., Law and justice, i, 3.Google Scholar

93 Henderson, , ‘The evolution of Tokugawa law’, 204.Google Scholar

94 Henderson, Dan Fenno, ‘“Contracts” in Tokugawa villages’, Journal of Japanese Studies 1(1) (1974), 72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

95 Duus, Peter, Feudalism in Japan, 2nd edn (New York, 1976), 98.Google Scholar

96 Haley, , ‘Reluctant litigant’, 371.Google Scholar

97 Henderson, , ‘“Contracts”’, 68.Google Scholar

98 Ibid., 62.

99 Ibid., 68.

100 Haley, , ‘Sheathing the sword’, 277.Google Scholar

101 Henderson, , ‘The evolution of Tokugawa law’, 208.Google Scholar

102 Haley, , ‘Consensual governance’, 45.Google Scholar

103 Quoted in ibid., 46.

104 For a comparison of the Japanese and English kinship systems, see Macfarlane, Alan, ‘On individualism’, Proceedings of the British Academy 82 (1993), 171–99.Google Scholar

105 Ratcliffe, C. T., ‘Dispute settlement’, Kodansha Encyclopedia, 177.Google Scholar

106 Baker, J. H., An introduction to English legal history, 2nd edn (London, 1979), 28.Google Scholar

107 Smith, Robert J., Japanese society, 38.Google Scholar

108 Hendry, , Japanese society, 199.Google Scholar