Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-2lccl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T17:27:58.536Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Middle Class Factor in the Scottish Reformation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

W. Stanford Reid
W. Stanford Reid
Affiliation:
McGill University, Montreal
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

While studies of the Reformation on the Continent have long emphasized the importance and the influence of the middle class, the dominating figures in many accounts of this movement in Scotland have been the nobles and the preachers. The Lords of the Congregation, along with such ministers as Knox, Wynram, and Harlaw have usually received most of the credit—or blame, depending upon one's point of view—for what took place. While this may be accepted as natural, yet it must be remembered that the Scottish Reformation was neither Lutheran nor Anglican in its final form, but thoroughly Calvinistic. Although Calvinism was not the original moving force, by 1560 it was dominant. By analogy with the parallel movements on the Continent, it is hard to believe that such a development could have come from a purely feudal or princely origin. Following the example of the Reformation in Holland, for example, we are obliged to realize that another important factor was involved: the middle class. Neither the nobles nor the preachers give a complete answer to questions regarding the reason for, and the form of, the Scottish reform movement. True, they held an exceedingly important place in its history. Without the nobles the Reformation might never have taken place. Yet when all this is said, it would seem that if we are to have a proper understanding of the Scottish religious movement it is necessary to study the place held in it by the merchants and master craftsmen. These were the men who in no small way made the Reformation in Scotland possible, and enabled it for the next three hundred years to wield such an enormous influence on the life of the people.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 16 , Issue 3 , September 1947 , pp. 137 - 153
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1947

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Cf. Troeltsch, E., The Social Teachings of the Christian Churches (London, 1931)Google Scholar, passim; H, Fleming., The Reformation in Scotland (London, 1940)Google Scholar; and others for the difference in approach.

2 The conflict between James V and the Earl of Angus with the eventual defeat of the latter is a sign of the growing power of the crown during this period. Cf. Grant, I. F., The Social and Economic Development of Scotland before 1603 (Edinburgh, 1930), 186–218.Google Scholar

3 Ibid., 204–218, 350ff. The importance of the middle class in financing the government is shown in the relations of Robert Barton to James V. When Barton died the crown owed him 11,000 marks due for loans to the government. Fleming, D. Hay., ed., Register of the Secret Seal of Scotland (London, 1921), IIGoogle Scholar, no. 823.

4 Grant, op. cit., 202ff.; Paul, J. B., Accounts of the Lord High Treasurer of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1900), II, 23, 29, 32, 34, 37, 148ff.Google Scholar

5 MacKinnon, J., The Social and Industrial History of Scotland from earliest times to the Union (Glasgow, 1920), 85.Google Scholar

6 Davidson, J. and Gray, A., The Scottish Staple at Veere (London, 1909), pp. 107 ff.Google Scholar; Grant, op. cit., 339–341; Allen, C. F., Histoire de Danemark, trans. Beauvois, E. (Copenhagen, 1878), I, 273ff.Google Scholar; Burnett, G., MacKay, A.J.G., The Exchequer Rolls of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1893), XIV, cxxviii.Google Scholar

7 Grant, op. cit., 350ff.; Irons, J. C., Leith and its Antiquities (Edinburgh, n. d.)Google Scholar, chaps. xvi, xxi.

8 Cf. accounts of these two men in The Dictionary of National Biography.

9 Knox, J., History of Me Reformation of the Church in Scotland (Wodrow Society, 1846), I, 111f.Google Scholar; Hannay, R. K., Acts of the Lords of the Council in Public Affairs (Edinburgh, 1932), 96, 159.Google Scholar

10 Grant, op. cit., chapter viii; Irons, loc. cit.

11 Dunlop, A. I., Scots Abroad in the Fifteenth Century (Histbrical Association, 1942)Google Scholar, passiin; Burton, J. H., The Scot Abroad (Edinburgh, 1864)Google Scholar, passim.

12 Beveridge, E., The Burgh Records of Dunfermline (Edinburgh, 1917)Google Scholar, nos. 168, 270, 280, 298, 323; Brown, P. H., John Knox (London, 1895), I, 17ff.Google Scholar; Brown, P. H., George Buchanan (Edinburgh, 1890), 16ff.Google Scholar; M'Crie, T., Life of Andrew Melville (Edinburgh, 1824), I.Google Scholar

13 von Martin, A., The Sociology of the Renaissance (London, 1945), 15, 30ff.Google Scholar

14 The change in opinion is perhaps represented by Robert Barton who in 1514 wa strongly in favour of Albany, the representative of French interests, but who by 1524 had turned to support the English party. He seems to have been representative of many others. Brewer, J. S., ed., Letters and Papers of the Reign of Henry VIII (London, 1864), II; 1, no. 287; IV: 1, no. 943Google Scholar.

15 For the elergy's estimate of the state of the church see the statutes passed with regard to it in the Provincial Councils, 1549–1559. Patrick, D., ed. The Statutes of the Scottish Church (Scottish History Society, 1907), 84–192Google Scholar; Reid, W. S., “The Scottish Counter-Reformation before 1560,” Church History, XIV (1945), 104ff.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

16 Knox, op. cit., I, 217–219.

17 Calderwood, D., Historie of the Kirk of Scotland (Wodrow Society, 1842), I, 109.Google Scholar

18 Allen, op. cit., I, 280–305; Collins, W. E., “The Scandinavian North,” Cambridge Modern History (Cambridge, 1907), II, 609–618Google Scholar; Thomson, T., ed., The Acts of the Parliamemt of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1814), II, 295, 341–2Google Scholar; Calderwood, op. cit., I, 108–127; Knox, op. cit., I, appendix VI; Reid, W. S., “Lutheranism in the Scottish Reformation,” The Westminster Theological Journal (Philadelphia), VII (1945), 91ff.Google Scholar

19 The importance of the towns is revealed by the number of martyrs and exiles which they supplied. Cf.Knox, op. cit., I, 61, 125ff.; Wodrow, R., Collections upon the Lives of the Reformers of the Church of Scotland (Maitland Club, 1834), I, 5Google Scholar; Calderwood, op. cit., I, 108ff.; Donaldson, G., St. Andrews Fonnulare 1514–1546 (Stair Society, 1944), IIGoogle Scholar, no. 397; Hannay, B. K., “Letters of a Papal Legate in Scotland, 1543,” Scottish Historical Review XI (1914), 19, 21Google Scholar; Acts of Lds. of Co. in Pub, affairs, 372, 426; Fleming, D. H.Register of the Privy Seal of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1921), IIGoogle Scholar, nos. 1583, 2962, 2975; A Diurnal of Events within Scotland (Mainland Club, 1833), 18–19Google Scholar; Fittis, R. S., The Ecclesiastical Annals of Perth (Edinburgh, 1885), 66–7Google Scholar; Mitchell, A. F., The Gude and Godlie Ballatis (Scottish Text Society, 1897), xviiGoogle Scholar; Pitcairn, R., Ancient Criminal Trials in Scotland (Maitland Club, 1833), I: 1, 216*.Google Scholar

20 Calderwood, op. cit., I, 156; Lees, J. C., St. Giles, Edinburgh (Edinburgh, 1889), 106–114, 255–258.Google Scholar

21 Donaldson, op. cit., II, no. 367; Fleming, , Reformation in Scotland, 215ff.Google Scholar; Knox, op. cit., I, 98–100; M'Crie, T., Life of John Knox (Edinburgh, new edit.), 314 ff.Google Scholar; Anderson, C., Annals of the English Bible (London, 1862), 568–9, 497.Google Scholar

22 Cf. notes 19 and 21; Gau, J., The Richt Vay to the Kingdom of Hevine (S.T.S., 1888), xi–xxiiGoogle Scholar; M'Crie, , Knox, 323ff.Google Scholar; Fittis, op. cit., 54; Brown, , Buchanan, 84ff., 122ff.Google Scholar; Mitchell, Balltis, Introduction; Edgar, J., History of Early Education in Scotland (Edinburgh, 1883), 191–197.Google Scholar

23 Chambers, R., Biographical Dictioiary of Eminent Scotsmen (London, 1864), I, 41, 127Google Scholar; III, 449; IV, 1; Brown, , Knoz, 9Google Scholar; Buchanan, 7–10.

24 Fittis, op. cit., 66–8, 72, 88; Wodrow, op. cit., 5–7; Knox, op. cit., I, 45, 99ff.; Lorimer, P., The Precursors of Knox (Edinburgh, 1857), 199ff.Google Scholar; Brown, , Knox, I, 66Google Scholar; M'Crie, , Knox, 17Google Scholar; Calderwood, op. cit., I, 113, 144–192.

25 Reid, W. S., “The Lollard in Pre-reformation Scotiand,” Church History XI (1942), 3.Google Scholar

26 Knox, op.cit., I, 300–306, note 19.

27 Fittis, op. cit., 80, 244.

28 Patrick, Statutes, xcviiff.