Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-45l2p Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T20:59:02.270Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The language of tyranny in Cratinus, PCG 258*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2013

Maria Noussia
Maria Noussia
Affiliation:
University of Chieti
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

A mock theogony from Cratinus' Chirones seems straightforward and uncomplicated evidence of the jibes of the comic poets against Pericles. The source for this fragment, Plutarch's Life of Pericles, chapter 3, in fact connects it with the usual sallies of the archaia about the shape of Pericles' head. Yet, the fragment equally reflects the presence of contemporary opposition in Periclean Athens against the statesman. Plutarch simply covers the density of its allusion, which is something beyond the comic resource of attacking marked peculiarities of appearance of politically prominent individuals: the Homeric-style hapaxκεΦαληγερέταν alludes to the deformity of Pericles' head but also to his demagogic ability to assemble the masses in the so-called ‘language of the gods’.

Many questions are, however, posed when we attempt to account for the allegories or the analogies the passage establishes. As Hanow wondered back in 1830: verum quidΧρόνος πρεσβυγενήςad Periclem faciat, non reperio; quamquam certam quandam rem a Cratino spectatam arbitror. The main purpose of this paper, therefore, is to examine the fragment afresh, in the hope of showing that the source for the parody of this piece of Cratinus may be traced elsewhere than so far suggested, and that there is good reason for Stasis and Chronus fathering this sinister infant.

Type
Research Article
Information
Proceedings of the Cambridge Philological Society (Second Series) , Volume 49 , 2003 , pp. 74 - 88
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s). Published online by Cambridge University Press 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Amado Rodríguez, M. T. (1994) ‘Ομηροκρατινίζειν’, Minerva 8, 99–114.Google Scholar
Amado Rodríguez, M. T. (1997) ‘Crítics y elogio en los fragmentos de Cratino: algunos aspectos’, in Eire, A. López (ed.) Sociedad, político y literatura. comedia griega antigua. Adas del I congreso internacional Salamanca, noviembre 1996, Salamanca, 233–42.Google Scholar
Ameling, W. (1981) ‘Komödie und Politik zwischen Kratinos und Aristophanes: Das Beispiel Perikles’, QC 3, 383–424.Google Scholar
Arnott, W. G. (1996) Alexis, the fragments. A commentary, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Bona, G. (1988) ‘Per un'interpretazione di Cratino’, in Corsini, E. (ed.) La polis e il suo teatro, vol. 2, Padua, 181–211.Google Scholar
Brillante, C. (1991) ‘Crescita e apprendimento: l'educazione del giovane eroe’, QUCC n.s. 37, 7–28.Google Scholar
Brisson, L. (1997) ‘Chronos in column XII of the Derveni papyrus’, in Laks, A., Most, G. W. (eds.) Studies on the Derveni papyrus, Oxford, 149–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Catenacci, C. (1991) ‘Π τύραννος e i suoi strumenti: alcune metafore “tiranniche” nella Pitica II (vv. 72–96) di Pindaro’, QUCC n.s. 39, 85–95.Google Scholar
Catenacci, C. (1996) Il tiranno e l'eroe. Per un'archeologia del potere nella Grecia antica, Milan.Google Scholar
Ceccarelli, P. (1996) ‘L'Athènes de Périclès: un “pays de cocagne”? L'idéologie démocratique et Ι᾽αὐτόματος βίος dans la comédie ancienne’, QUCC n.s. 54, 109–59.Google Scholar
Cobet, C. G. (1840) Observationes criticae in Platonis comici reliquias, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
Cohen, B. (1991) ‘Perikles' portrait and the Riace Bronzes: new evidence for “schinocephaly”’, Hesperia 60, 465–502.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davies, J. K. (1971) Athenian propertied families 600–300 B.C., Oxford.Google Scholar
Davison, J. A. (1949) ‘The date of the Prometheia’, TAPA 80, 66–93.Google Scholar
Davison, J. A. (1966) ‘Aeschylus and Athenian politics 472–456’, in Badian, E. (ed.) Ancient society and institutions. Studies presented to Victor Ehrenberg, Oxford, 93–107.Google Scholar
De Martino, F., Vox, O. (1996) Lirica greca, Ban.Google Scholar
Detienne, M. (1992–1993) ‘Langue des dieux ou des dieux dans le langage’, AEHE (Ve sect.) 101, 219–22.Google Scholar
Dittenberger, W. (1897) Inscriptiones Phocidis, Locridis, Aetoliae, Acarnaniae, insularum maris Ionii, Berlin (IG 9.1).Google Scholar
Dunbar, N. (1995) Aristophanes, Birds, Oxford.Google Scholar
Edmonds, J. M. (1957) The fragments of Attic comedy after Meineke, Bergk, and Kock, Leiden.Google Scholar
Emperius, A. (1847) Opuscula philologica et historica, Göttingen.Google Scholar
Farioli, M. (1996) ‘Note sul lessico, lo stile e la struttura delle commedie di Cratino’, Aevum(ant) 9, 73–105.Google Scholar
Farioli, M. (2000) ‘Mito e satira politica nei Chironi di Cratino’, RFIC 128, 406–31.Google Scholar
Fileni, M. G. (1983) ‘Osservazioni sull'idea di tiranno nella cultura greca arcaica (Alc. frr. 70, 6–9; 129, 21–24 V.; Theogn. vv. 1179–1182)’, QUCC n.s. 14, 29–35.Google Scholar
Forrest, W. G. (1960) ‘Themistokles and Argos’, CQ n.s. 10, 221–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geissler, P. (1925) Chronologie der altattischen Komödie, Berlin.Google Scholar
Gentili, B., Prato, C. (eds.) (1988) Poetarum elegiacorum testimonia et fragmenta, vol. 1 (2nd. edn), Leipzig. (G-P2)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gomme, A. W. (1945–1981) A historical commentary on Thucydides, Oxford.Google Scholar
Grene, D., Lattimore, R. (1991) Aeschylus II: the Suppliant Maidens, the Persians, Seven against Thebes, Prometheus Bound, Chicago.Google Scholar
Griffith, M. (1983) Aeschylus. Prometheus Bound, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Hanow, R. (1830) Exercitationum criticarum in comicos Graecos liber primus, Halle.Google Scholar
Hegyi, D. (1965) ‘Notes on the origin of Greek tyrannis’, AAntHung 13, 303–18.Google Scholar
Hopkinson, N. (1984) ‘Rhea in Callimachus' Hymn to Zeus’, JHS 104, 176–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Janko, R. (1992) The Iliad: a commentary. Volume IV: books 13–16, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Kassel, R., Austin, C. (eds.) (1983—) Poetae comici graeci, Berlin and New York. (PCG)Google Scholar
Kirk, G. S. (1985) The Iliad: a commentary. Volume 1: books 1–4, Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kurke, L. (1990) ‘Pindar's sixth Pythian and the tradition of advice poetry’, TAPA 120, 85–107.Google Scholar
Lazzeroni, R. (1957) ‘Lingua degli dei e lingua degli uomini’, ASNP 26, 1–26.Google Scholar
Lucas, K. W. (1828) Specimen observationum in difficiliora quaedam Cratini veteris comici fragmenta, Bonn.Google Scholar
Luiselli, R. (1990) ‘Cratino, fr. 258,2 Kassel-Austin (= 240,1 Kock): Χρόνος ο Κρόνος?’, QUCC n.s. 36, 85–99.Google Scholar
Luppe, W. (1963) ‘Fragmente des Kratinos. Text und Kommentar’, PhD thesis, University of Halle.Google Scholar
McGlew, J. F. (1993) Tyranny and political culture in ancient Greece, Ithaca, NY.Google Scholar
Magnien, V. (1907) ‘Deux fragments comiques dans Plutarque, Vie de Périclès ch. III’, RP 31, 22–7.Google Scholar
Mattingly, H. B. (1977a) ‘Poets and politicians in fifth-century Greece’, in Kinzl, K. H. (ed.) Greece and the eastern Mediterranean in ancient history and prehistory. Essays presented to Fritz Schachermeyr on the occasion of his 80th birthday, Berlin, 231–45.Google Scholar
Mattingly, H. B. (1977b) ‘Vocabulary change and epigraphic dating’, Mnemosyne 30, 66–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meineke, A. (1839–1857) Fragmenta comicorum graecorum, Berlin.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Menu, M. (1997) ‘Le motif de l'âge dans les tours proverbiaux de la comédie grecque’, in Eire, A. López (ed.) Sociedad, político y literatura: comedia griega antigua, Actas del I congreso internacional Salamanca, noviembre 1996, Salamanca, 133–50.Google Scholar
Milani, C. (1999) ‘Il lessico dell'opposizione politica nel mondo antico’, in Sordi, M. (ed.) Fazioni e congiure nel mondo antico, Milan, 3–22.Google Scholar
Norwood, G. (1931) Greek comedy, London.Google Scholar
Noussia, M. (2001) Solome. Frammenti dell'opera poetica, Milan.Google Scholar
Oliva, P. (1973) ‘Solon in der Darstellung der Komödie’, GLO 5, 25–33.Google Scholar
Paris, P. (1886) ‘Inscriptions d'Elatée’, BCH 10, 356–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parker, V. (1998) ‘Τύραννος: the semantics of a political concept from Archilochus to Aristotle’, Hermes 126, 145–72.Google Scholar
Pease, A. S. (1955–1958) M. Tulli Ciceronis, De natura deorum, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
Pieters, J. T. M. F. (1946) Cratinus: Bijdrage tot de Geschiedenis der vroeg-attische Comedie, Leiden.Google Scholar
Podlecki, A. J. (1998) Pericles and his circle, London and New York.Google Scholar
Pretagostini, R. (1984) Ricerche sulla poesia alessandrina. Teocrito. Callimaco, Sotade, Rome.Google Scholar
Radici Colace, P., Sergi, E. (2000) ‘Στάσι nel lessico politico greco’, ASNP 5.1, 223–36.Google Scholar
Revermann, M. (1997) ‘Cratinus' Διονυσαλέξανδρος and the head of Pericles’, JHS 117, 197–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosivach, V. J. (1988) ‘The tyrant in Athenian democracy’, QUCC n.s. 30, 43–57.Google Scholar
Ruffell, I. (2000) ‘The world turned upside down: Utopia and utopianism’, in Harvey, D., Wilkins, J. (eds.) The rivals of Aristophanes. Studies in Athenian Old Comedy, London, 473–506.Google Scholar
Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H. (2000) ‘The tyranny of Peisistratos’, in Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H. (ed.), Peisistratos and the tyranny. A reappraisal of the evidence, Amsterdam, 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schibli, H. S. (1990) Pherekydes of Syros, Oxford.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schwarze, J. (1971) Die Beurteilung des Perikles durch die attische Komödie und ihre historische und historiographische Bedeutung, Munich.Google Scholar
Tammaro, V. (1978–1979) ‘Note a Cratino’, MCr 13–14, 203–9.Google Scholar
Tammaro, V. (1984–1985) ‘Note a Cratino’, MCr 19–20, 39–42.Google Scholar
West, M. L. (1963) ‘Three Presocratic cosmologies’, CQ 13, 154–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
West, M. L. (ed.) (1992) Iambi et elegi graeci ante Alexandrum cantati (2nd. edn.), Oxford. (W2)Google Scholar
West, M. L. (1993) Greek lyric poetry, Oxford.Google Scholar
White, S. (2001) ‘Io's world: imitations of theodicy in Prometheus Bound’, JHS 121, 107–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar