Skip to main content Accessibility help

Possible risk factors for keel bone damage in organic laying hens

  • L. Jung (a1), K. Niebuhr (a2), L. K. Hinrichsen (a3), S. Gunnarsson (a4), C. Brenninkmeyer (a1), M. Bestman (a5), J. Heerkens (a6), P. Ferrari (a7) and U. Knierim (a1)...


Keel bone damage (KBD) in laying hens is an important welfare problem in both conventional and organic egg production systems. We aimed to identify possible risk factors for KBD in organic hens by analysing cross-sectional data of 107 flocks assessed in eight European countries. Due to partly missing data, the final multiple regression model was based on data from 50 flocks. Keel bone damage included fractures and/or deviations, and was recorded, alongside with other animal based measures, by palpation and visual inspection of at least 50 randomly collected hens per flock between 52 and 73 weeks of age. Management and housing data were obtained by interviews, inspection and by feed analysis. Keel bone damage flock prevalences ranged from 3% to 88%. Compiled on the basis of literature and practical experience, 26 potential associative factors of KBD went into an univariable selection by Spearman correlation analysis or Mann–Whitney U test (with P<0.1 level). The resulting nine factors were presented to stepwise forward linear regression modelling. Aviary v. floor systems, absence of natural daylight in the hen house, a higher proportion of underweight birds, as well as a higher laying performance were found to be significantly associated with a higher percentage of hens with KBD. The final model explained 32% of the variation in KBD between farms. The moderate explanatory value of the model underlines the multifactorial nature of KBD. Based on the results increased attention should be paid to an adequate housing design and lighting that allows the birds easy orientation and safe manoeuvring in the system. Furthermore, feeding management should aim at sufficient bird live weights that fulfil breeder weight standards. In order to achieve a better understanding of the relationships between laying performance, feed management and KBD further investigations are needed.


Corresponding author


Hide All

Present address: Aeres University of Applied Sciences, De Drieslag 4, 8251JZ Dronten, The Netherlands.



Hide All
Bestman, M and Wagenaar, JP 2014. Health and welfare in Dutch organic laying hens. Animals 4, 374390.
Bestman, M, Verwer, C, Brenninkmeyer, C, Willett, A, Hinrichsen, LK, Smajlhodzic, F, Heerkens, JLT, Gunnarsson, S and Ferrante, V 2017. Feather-pecking and injurious pecking in organic laying hens in 107 flocks from eight European countries. Animal Welfare 26, 355363.
Casey-Trott, T, Heerkens, JLT, Petrik, M, Regmi, P, Schrader, L, Toscano, MJ and Widowski, T 2015. Methods for assessment of keel bone damage in poultry. Poultry Science 94, 23392350.
Cohen, J, Cohen, P, West, SG and Aiken, LS 2003. Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioural sciences. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ, USA.
Donaldson, CJ, Ball, MEE and O’Connell, NE 2012. Aerial perches and free-range laying hens: the effect of access to aerial perches and of individual bird parameters on keel bone injuries in commercial free-range laying hens. Poultry Science 91, 304315.
EU 2008. Commission regulation no. 589/2008 laying down detailed rules for the implementation of Council Regulation (EC) No 834/2007 on organic production and labelling of organic products with regard to organic production, labelling and control. Official Journal of the European Union 250, 184.
Fleming, RH, McCormack, HA, McTeir, L and Whitehead, CC 2004. Incidence, pathology and prevention of keel bone deformities in the laying hen. British Poultry Science 45, 320330.
Fleming, RH 2008. Nutritional factors affecting poultry bone health. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 67, 177183.
Gebhardt-Henrich, SG and Fröhlich, KF 2015. Early onset of laying and bumblefoot favor keel bone fractures. Animals 5, 11921206.
Heerkens, JLT, Delezie, E, Rodenburg, TB, Kempen, I, Zoons, J, Ampe, B and Tuyttens, FAM 2016. Risk factors associated with keel bone and foot pad disorders in laying hens housed in aviary systems. Poultry Science 95, 482488.
Kämmerling, D, Döhring, S, Arndt, C and Andersson, R 2017. Tageslicht im Stall – Anforderungen an das Spektrum von Lichtquellen bei Geflügel. Berliner und Münchner Tierärztliche Wochenschrift 130, 210221.
Käppeli, S, Gebhardt-Hinrich, SG, Fröhlich, E, Pflug, A, Schäublin, H and Stoffel, MH 2011. Effects of housing, perches, genetics, and 25-hydroxycholecalciferol on keel bone deformities in laying hens. Poultry Science 90, 16371644.
Lohmann Tierzucht GmbH without year. Layer management guide – Lohmann Brown Classic. Retrieved on 22 December 2018 from
Menard, S 1995. Applied logistic regression analysis. Sage University Series on Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences 106, Thousand Oaks, CA, USA.
Nasr, MAF, Nicol, CJ and Murrell, JC 2012a. Do laying hens with keel bone fractures experience pain? PLoS One 7, e42420.
Nasr, MAF, Murrell, JC, Wilkins, LJ and Nicol, CJ 2012b. The effect of keel fractures on egg-production parameters, mobility and behaviour in individual laying hens. Animal Welfare 21, 127135.
Nasr, MAF, Brownea, WJ, Caplena, G, Hothersalla, B, Murrell, JC and Nicol, CJ 2013a. Positive affective state induced by opioid analgesia in laying hens with bone fractures. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 147, 127131.
Nasr, MAF, Murrell, JC and Nicol, CJ 2013b. The effect of keel fractures on egg production, feed and water consumption in individual laying hens. British Poultry Science 54, 165170.
Nicol, CJ, Brown, SN, Glen, ES, Pope, JF, Short, JP, Warriss, D, Zimmerman, PH and Wilkins, LJ 2006. Effects of stocking density, flock size and management on the welfare of laying hens in floor aviaries. British Poultry Science 47, 135146.
Petrik, MT, Guerin, MT and Widowski, TM 2013. Keel fracture assessment of laying hens by palpation: inter-observer reliability and accuracy. Veterinary Record 173, 500.
Petrik, MT, Guerin, MT and Widowski, TM 2015. On-farm comparison of keel fracture prevalence and other welfare indicators in conventional cage and single tier-housed laying hens in Ontario, Canada. Poultry Science 94, 17.
Riber, AB and Hinrichsen, LK 2016. Keel-bone damage and foot injuries in commercial laying hens in Denmark. Animal Welfare 25, 179184.
Riber, AB and Hinrichsen, LK 2017. Welfare consequences of omitting beak trimming in barn layers. Frontiers in Veterinary Science 4, 222–22.
Rodenburg, TB, Tuyttens, FAM, de Reu, K, Herman, L, Zoons, J and Sonck, B 2008. Welfare assessment of laying hens in furnished cages and non-cage systems: an on-farm comparison. Animal Welfare 17, 363373.
Scholz, B, Rönchen, S, Hamann, H, Hewicker-Trautwein, M and Distl, O 2008. Keel bone condition in laying hens: a histological evaluation of macroscopically assessed keel bones. Berliner und Münchener Tierärztliche Wochenschrift 121, 8994.
Sherwin, CM, Richards, GJ and Nicol, CJ 2010. Comparison of the welfare of layer hens in 4 housing systems in the UK. British Poultry Science 51, 488499.
Staack, M, Gruber, B, Keppler, C, Zaludik, K, Niebuhr, K and Knierim, U 2009. Brustbeindeformationen bei Legehennen aus ökologisch wirtschaftenden Betrieben in Deutschland und Österreich. In Praxis trifft Forschung - Neues aus der Ökologischen Tierhaltung (ed. G Rahmann and U Schumacher), pp., 47–54, Braunschweig, Germany. Retrieved on 22 September 2018 from
Stratmann, A, Fröhlich, EKF, Gebhardt-Henrich, SG, Harlander-Matauschek, A, Würbel, H and Toscano, MJ 2015a. Modification of aviary design reduces incidence of falls, collisions and keel bone damage in laying hens. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 165, 112123.
Stratmann, A, Fröhlich, EKF, Harlander-Matauschek, A, Schrader, L, Toscano, MJ, Würbel, H and Gebhardt-Henrich, SG 2015b. Soft perches in an aviary system reduce incidence of keel bone damage in laying hens. PLoS One 10, e0122568.
Tarlton, JF, Wilkins, LJ, Toscano, MJ, Aver, NC and Knott, L 2013. Reduced bone breakage and increased bone strength in free range laying hens fed omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acid supplemented diets. Bone 52, 578586.
Tauson, R, Kjaer, J, Maria, GA, Cepero, R and Holm, KE 2005. Applied scoring of integument and health in laying hens. Animal Science Papers Reports 23, 153159.
Taylor, PE, Scott, GB and Rose, SP 2003. The ability of domestic hens to jump between horizontal perches: effects of light intensity and perch color. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 83, 99108.
Whitehead, CC 2004. Overview of bone biology in the egg-laying hen. Poultry Science 83, 193199.
Wilkins, LJ, Pope, S, Leeb, C, Glen, E, Phillips, A, Zimmerman, P, Nicol, C and Brown, SN 2005. Fracture rate in laying-strain hens at the end of the rearing period and the end of the laying period. In 7th European symposium on Poultry Welfare, 15–19 June 2005, Lublin, Poland.
Wilkins, LJ, McKinstry, JL, Avery, NC, Knowles, TG, Brown, SN, Tarlton, J and Nicol, CJ 2011. Influence of housing system and design on bone strength and keel bone fractures in laying hens. Veterinary Record 169, 414441.


Possible risk factors for keel bone damage in organic laying hens

  • L. Jung (a1), K. Niebuhr (a2), L. K. Hinrichsen (a3), S. Gunnarsson (a4), C. Brenninkmeyer (a1), M. Bestman (a5), J. Heerkens (a6), P. Ferrari (a7) and U. Knierim (a1)...


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed