Hostname: page-component-68945f75b7-qvshk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-06T05:07:13.396Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

James Madison on Religion and Politics: Rhetoric and Reality

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 August 2014

Thomas Lindsay
Thomas Lindsay
Affiliation:
University of Northern Iowa
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The recent Oregon v.Smith decision's shifting of the burden in free exercise cases from legislatures to minority religious claims has brought fierce opposition, most conspicuously from leading nonpreferentialist Richard J. Neuhaus, who sees in it the foundation of majority tyranny. Against Smith, Neuhaus employs Madison's “Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments,” which is universally read to argue that the superiority of religion to politics proscribes majoritarian hegemony over religious practices. I contend that the Memorial's appeals are better understood as rhetoric than as reflecting Madison's true view. I find Madison hostile not only to religious establishments but also to religion itself. This hostility was the basis of his rejection of the nonpreferentialists' utility-based argument for government support of religion. In this light, I uncover a curious historical irony: the nonpreferentialist Neuhaus seeks today to protect religion from hostility by adhering to a position that was originally animated, in key respects, by hostility both to religion and to its nonpreferential support.

Type
Articles
Information
American Political Science Review , Volume 85 , Issue 4 , December 1991 , pp. 1321 - 1337
Copyright
Copyright © American Political Science Association 1991

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abington Township School District v. Schempp. 1963. 374 U.S. 203.Google Scholar
Alley, Robert S., ed. 1985. James Madison on Religious Liberty. Buffalo: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
Boak, Arthur E. 1959. The History of Our World. New York: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
Brann, Eva T. H. 1984. “Madison's ‘Memorial and Remonstrance’ Model of American Eloquence.” In Rhetoric and American Statesmanship, ed. Thurow, Glen E. and Wallin, Jeffrey D.. Durham: Carolina Academic.Google Scholar
Braunfeld v. Brown. 1961. 366 U.S. 599.Google Scholar
Clarke, Samuel. 1735. A Discourse Concerning the Being and Attributes of Cod, the Obligations of Natural Religion, and the Truth and Certainty of the Christian Revelation. London.Google Scholar
Diamond, Martin. 1971. “The Federalist.” In American Political Thought, ed. Frisch, Morton J. and Stevens, Richard. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.Google Scholar
Diamond, Martin. 1981. The Founding of the Democratic Republic. Itasca, IL: F. E. Peacock.Google Scholar
Department of Human Resources of Oregon et al. v. Smith et al. 1990. 110 S. Ct. 1595.Google Scholar
Epstein, David F. 1984. The Political Theory of the Federalist. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Everson v. Board of Education of Ewing Township. 1947. 330 U.S. 1.Google Scholar
Fleet, Elizabeth, ed. 1946. “Madison's ‘Detached Memoranda.’” William and Mary Quarterly 3:542–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glenn, Gary D. 1987. “Forgotten Purposes of the First Amendment Religion Clause.” Review of Politics 49:340–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hirschman, Albert O. 1977. The Passions and the Interests. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jefferson, Thomas. 1950. The Papers of Thomas Jefferson. 24 vols. Ed. Boyd, Julian P., et al. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Ketcham, Ralph L. 1985. “James Madison and Religion: A New Hypothesis.” In James Madison on Religious Liberty, ed. Alley, Robert S.. Buffalo: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
Levy, Leonard W. 1986. The Establishment Clause: Religion and the First Amendment. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Levy, Leonard. 1987. “The Establishment Clause.” In How Does the Constitution Protect Religious Freedom?, ed. Goldwin, Robert and Kaufman, Art. Washington: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research.Google Scholar
McConnell, Michael W. 1990. “The Origins and Historical Understanding of Free Exercise of Religion.” Harvard Law Review 103:1410–1517.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Madison, James. 1884. Letters and Other Writings of James Madison. 4 vols. New York: Worthington.Google Scholar
Madison, James. 1900–1910. The Writings of James Madison. 9 vols. Ed. Hunt, Gaillard. New York: Putnam.Google Scholar
Madison, James, Hamilton, Alexander, and Jay, John. 1961. The Federalist Papers. Ed. Rossiter, Clinton. New York: New American Library.Google Scholar
Madison, James. 1962. The Papers of James Madison. 13 vols. Ed. Hutchinson, W. T. et al. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Malbin, Michael J. 1978. Religion and Politics: The Intentions of the Authors of the First Amendment. Washington: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research.Google Scholar
Malone, Dumas. 1985. “The Madison-Jefferson Friendship.” In James Madison on Religious Liberty, ed. Alley, Robert S.. Buffalo: Prometheus.Google Scholar
Morgan, Robert J. 1988. James Madison on the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. New York: Greenwood.Google Scholar
Murray, John C. 1949. “Law and Prepossessions.” Law and Contemporary Problems 14:3–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Neuhaus, Richard. 1990. “Church, State, and Peyote.” National Review 1106.Google Scholar
Padover, Saul K., ed. 1953. The Complete Madison: His Basic Writings. New York: Harper & Brothers.Google Scholar
Pangle, Thomas. 1988. The Spirit of Modem Republicanism: The Moral Vision of the American Founders and the Philosophy of Locke. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Reichley, A. James. 1985. Religion in American Public Life. Washington: Brookings Institution.Google Scholar
Riemer, Neal. 1989. “Religious Liberty and Creative Breakthroughs: The Contributions of Roger Williams and James Madison.” In Religion and American Politics, ed. Dunn, Charles W.. Washington: Congressional Quarterly.Google Scholar
Rutland, Robert A. 1985. “James Madison's Dream: A Secular Republic.” In James Madison on Religious Liberty, ed. Alley, Robert S.. Buffalo: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
Sandler, S. Gerald. 1960. “Lockean Ideas in Jefferson's Bill for Establishing Religious Freedom.” Journal of the History of Ideas 21:110–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sherbert v. Verner. 1963. 347 U.S. 398.Google Scholar
Tocqueville, Alexis de. 1969. Democracy in America. Trans. Lawrence, George. Ed. Mayer, J. P.. Garden City: Anchor Books.Google Scholar
Williams, Roger. 1963. The Complete Writings of Roger Williams. New York: Russell & Russell.Google Scholar
Wisconsin v. Yoder. 1972. 406 U.S. 205.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Christopher. 1987. Essays on Faith and Liberal Democracy. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.Google Scholar
Submit a response

Comments

No Comments have been published for this article.