Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Print publication year: 2015
  • Online publication date: February 2015

2 - Consumption Tax Forms and Base Alterations



A direct tax on individuals that is measured by their level of consumption rather than their income is commonly referred to as a cash-flow or consumption-based income tax. Most taxes on consumption are indirect taxes. These taxes are collected by sellers of taxable goods and services and are expected to be borne by final consumers of those goods and services. The indirect tax on consumption may take the form of a single-stage tax such as the retail sales tax or a multistage tax such as a value added tax.

A value added tax is a generic name associated with a multistage tax that is levied on the value added by each business firm at every stage of production and distribution of goods and services. In part, the description of a VAT depends on the method used in calculating tax liability. In this chapter, there is a discussion of the addition, sales-subtraction, and credit-subtraction methods of calculating VAT liability.

The legislature may alter a VAT base by removing some sellers or some goods and services. This alteration of tax base is accomplished by providing an exemption for designated businesses (such as small businesses) or entities, such as units of government or nonproi t organizations. The legislature also can alter the tax base by granting exemption or altering the rate for particular goods and services, regardless of the nature of the seller. This chapter also discusses these various methods of providing special treatment under a value added tax.

Kaldor, N., An Expenditure Tax (George Allen & Unwin 1955)
Andrews, W., “A Consumption-Type or Cash Flow Personal Income Tax,” 87 Harvard Law Review1113 (1974)
Graetz, M., “Implementing a Progressive Consumption Tax,” 92 Harvard Law Review1575 (1979)
Andrews, W., “Fairness and the Personal Income Tax: A Reply to Professor Warren,” 88 Harvard Law Review947 (1975)
Warren, A., “Fairness and a Consumption-Type or Cash Flow Personal Income Tax,” 88 Harvard Law Review931 (1975)
Bradford, David F., The X Tax in the World Economy: Going Global with a Simple, Progressive Tax (AEI Press 2004)
Pepperell, H., “Thoughts on the Progressive Consumption Tax,” 85 Tax Notes529 (Oct. 25, 1999)
Due, J. & Mikesell, J., Sales Taxation: State and Local Structure and Administration 6 (Johns Hopkins University Press 1983)
Kaneko, H., “Proposal for International Humanitarian Tax – A Consumption Tax on International Air Travel,” 17 Tax Notes International1911 (Dec. 14, 1998)
Thuronyi, V., ed., Tax Law Design and Drafting (IMF 1996)
Shoup, C., “Choosing Among Types of VATs,” in Value Added Tax in Developing Countries (Gillis, M., Shoup, C., and Sicat, G., eds., World Bank, 1990)
Schenk, A., “Value Added Tax: Does This Consumption Tax Have a Place in the Federal Tax System?,” 7 Virginia Tax Review207 (1987)
Messere, K., “Consumption Tax Rules,” IBFD Bulletin, Dec. 1994, p. 665
Schenk, A., “The Plethora of Consumption Tax Proposals: Putting the Value Added Tax, Flat Tax, Retail Sales Tax, and USA Tax into Perspective,” 33 San Diego Law Review1281, 1305–1309 (1996)
Oldman, O. & Schenk, A., “The Business Activities Tax: Have Senators Danforth and Boren Created a Better Value Added Tax?,” 65 Tax Notes1547, 1551 (Dec. 19, 1994)
Tait, A., Value Added Tax: International Practice and Problems 5 (IMF 1988)