Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2020
  • Online publication date: August 2020

3 - Expanding Revision Clauses in Democratic Constitutions

from Part I - Conceptual, Normative, and Empirical Issues

Summary

In democratic regimes, formal constitutional change is an important opportunity for the people to express their sovereign power and improve their constitutional system of government. But how should this process be designed in order to live up to this promise? Democratic theory prioritizes an open process that allows the people to bypass entrenched elites and restructure their democratic orders through extraordinary institutions. Yet this open process can create an even larger problem: That a self-interested majority faction captures these extraordinary institutions and uses constitutional law to entrench itself. This problem of faction is best solved through legal regulation and institutional checks and balances. Looking to comparative experience, this chapter will examine ways to balance the need for openness and regulation in democratic constitution making. This analysis in turn can help us design expanded revision clauses in democratic constitutions that will allow constitutions to improve the process of constitution making.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Adkins, Mary. 2016. “Organizing Florida’s Next Constitution Revision Commission: A Historical Perspective.” UF Law Faculty Blogs. https://facultyblogs.law.ufl.edu/210-2/.
Amar, Akhil Reed. 1984. “Choosing Representatives by Lottery Voting.” Yale Law Journal 93(7): 12831308.
Amar, Akhil Reed. 1994. “The Consent of the Governed: Constitutional Amendment outside Article V.” Columbia Law Review 94(2): 457508.
Australian Electoral Commission (AEC). “Electoral Backgrounder: Referendum Advertising.” Last updated, February 17, 2015. www.aec.gov.au/about_aec/Publications/Backgrounders/ref-advert.htm.
Australia’s First Citizens’ Parliament. 2009. newDemocracy Foundation. www.newdemocracy.com.au/docs/newDemocracy_Citizens_Parliament_Handbook.pdf.
Black, Charles L. Jr. 1972. “Amending the Constitution: A Letter to a Congressman.” Yale Law Journal 82(2): 189215.
Brown, Everett S. 1935. “The Ratification of the Twenty-First Amendment.” The American Political Science Review 29(6): 10051017.
Brown, Nathan J. 2008. “Reason, Interest, Rationality, and Passion in Constitution Drafting.” Perspectives on Politics 6(4): 675689.
Caplan, Russell L. 1988. Constitutional Brinksmanship: Amending the Constitution by National Convention. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
The Carter Center. 2011–2014. The Constitution-Making Process in Tunisia. Final Report. Atlanta, GA. www.cartercenter.org/resources/pdfs/news/peace_publications/democracy/tunisia-constitution-making-process.pdf.
Colantuono, Michael G. 1987. “The Revision of American State Constitutions: Legislative Power, Popular Sovereignty, and Constitutional Change.” California Law Review 75(4): 14731512.
Colón-Ríos, Joel. 2010. “The Legitimacy of the Juridical: Constituent Power, Democracy, and the Limits of Constitutional Reform.” Osgoode Hall Law Journal 48(2): 199245.
Colon-Rios, Joel. 2011. “Carl Schmitt and Constituent Power in Latin American Courts: The Cases of Venezuela and Colombia.” Constellations 18(3): 365388.
Cooter, Robert D., and Gilbert, Michael D.. 2010. “A Theory of Direct Democracy and the Single Subject Rule.” Columbia Law Review 110(3): 687730.
Dellinger, Walter E. 1979. “The Recurring Question of the “Limited” Constitutional Convention.” Yale Law Journal 88(8): 16231640.
Elkins, Zachary, Ginsburg, Tom, and Blount, Justine. 2008. “The Citizen As Founder: Public Participation in Constitutional Approval.” Temple Law Review 81(2): 361382.
Elster, Jon. 2013. Securities against Misrule: Juries, Assemblies, Elections. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Farrand, Max (ed.) 1966. The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787. Vol. 1. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Fritz, Christian. 2008. American Sovereigns: The People and America’s Constitutional Tradition before the Civil War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ghai, Yash. 2005. “The Role of Constituent Assemblies in Constitution Making.” International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. www.agora-parl.org/sites/default/files/the_role_of_constituent_assemblies_in_constitution_making.pdf.
Jameson, John Alexander. 2013. A Treatise on Constitutional Conventions: Their History, Powers, and Modes of Proceeding. Clark: Lawbook Exchange.
Kay, Richard S. 2011. “Constituent Authority.” American Journal of Comparative Law 59(3): 715762.
Landau, David. 2013a. “Constitution-Making Gone Wrong.” Alabama Law Review 64(5): 923980.
Landau, David. 2013b. “Abusive Constitutionalism.” UC Davis Law Review 47(1): 189260.
Landemore, Hélène. 2015. “Inclusive Constitution-Making: The Icelandic Experiment.” The Journal of Political Philosophy 23(2): 166191.
Levinson, Daryl J. 2011. “Parchment and Politics: The Positive Puzzle of Constitutional Commitment.” Harvard Law Review 124(3): 657746.
Levinson, Sanford. 2008. Our Undemocratic Constitution: Where the Constitution Goes Wrong (And How We the People Can Correct It). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Levinson, Sanford. 2012. Framed: America’s Fifty-One Constitutions and the Crisis of Governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lieb, Ethan J. 2006. “Supermajoritarianism and the American Criminal Jury.” Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly 33(2): 141196.
Lijphart, Arend. 2012. Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries. 2nd ed. New Haven: Yale University Press.
McGinnis, John O., and Rappaport, Michael B.. 2002. “Our Supermajoritarian Constitution.” Texas Law Review 80(4): 703806.
Madison, James, Hamilton, Alexander, and Jay, John. [1788] 1987. The Federalist Papers. London: Penguin Books.
Morgan, David Gwynn. 2015. “Referenda: Like the Egg That Was Excellent in Parts.” Constitutional Making & Constitutional Change. February 16, 2015. http://constitutional-change.com/referenda-like-the-egg-that-was-excellent-in-parts/.
Morse, Carroll Andrew. 2014. “A Constitutional Convention for Rhode Island? The History and Legal Framework.” The Ocean State Current. http://oceanstatecurrent.com/interview/a-constitutional-convention-for-rhode-island-the-history-and-legal-framework/.
Ntwari, Daniel S. 2015. “Rwandan Controversial Constitutional Reform Commission Members Sworn in Amidst Lawsuit.” Afrika Reporter, September 16. www.afrikareporter.com/rwandan-controversial-constitutional-reform-commission-members-sworn-in-amidst-lawsuit/.
Partlett, William. 2012. “The Dangers of Popular Constitution-Making.” Brooklyn Journal of International Law 38(1): 193238.
Partlett, William. 2015. “Restoration Constitution-Making.” Vienna Journal of International Constitutional Law 9(4): 514547.
Partlett, William. 2016a. “The Elite Threat to Constitutional Transitions.” Virginia Journal of International Law 56(2): 407458.
Partlett, William. 2016b. “Reforming Centralism and Supervision in Armenia and Ukraine” in Annual Review of Constitution-Building Processes: 2015. Bisarya, Sumit et al. (eds.) Stockholm: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, 8598. www.idea.int/publications/catalogue/annual-review-constitution-building-processes-2015?lang=en.
Partlett, William. 2017. “The American Tradition of Constituent Power.” International Journal of Constitutional Law, 15(4): 955987.
Saunders, Cheryl. 2012. “Constitution-Making in the 21st Century.” International Review of Law 2012(1): 110.
Setala, Maija. 2006. “On the Problems of Responsibility and Accountability in Referendums.” European Journal of Political Research 45(4): 699721.
“Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, September 6, 1789.” 2000. The Founders’ Constitution. Kurland, Philip B. and Lerner, Ralph (eds.) http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch2s23.html.
Tierney, Stephen. 2009. “Constitutional Referendums: A Theoretical Enquiry.” Modern Law Review 72(3): 360383.
Tierney, Stephen. 2014. “The Independence Referendum in Scotland: Constructing a Deliberative Process?” Presented at “Constitutional Challenges: Global and Local,” IXth World Congress of the International Association of Constitutional Law (IACL), Oslo, Norway (June 16–20, 2014). www.jus.uio.no/english/research/news-and-events/events/conferences/2014/wccl-cmdc/wccl/papers/ws16/w16-tierney.pdf.
Tribe, Laurence H. 1983. “A Constitution We Are Amending: In Defense of a Restrained Judicial Role.” Harvard Law Review 97(2): 433445.
Tushnet, Mark. 2006. “Popular Constitutionalism As Political Law.” Chicago-Kent Law Review 81(3): 9911006.
Tydings, Joseph. 1967. Statement of Senator Tydings, Maryland, 113 Congressional Record 10103.
Van Alstyne, William W. 1978. “Does Article V Restrict the States to Calling Unlimited Conventions Only?: A Letter to a Colleague.” Duke Law Journal 1979(6): 12951306.
Venice Commission. 2010. Report on Constitutional Amendment. No. CDL-AD(2010)001. 81st Plen. Sess. www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-AD(2010)001-e.
Weis, Lael. N.d. “Environmental Constitutionalism: Aspiration or Transformation?” (On file with author).
Williams, Robert F. 1996. “Are State Constitutional Conventions Things of the Past? The Increasing Role of the Constitutional Commission in State Constitutional Change.” Hofstra Law & Policy Symposium 1(1): 126.
Wood, Gordon S. 1969. The Creation of the American Republic, 1776–1787. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.