Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- Preface
- Part I John Stewart Bell: The Physicist
- 1 John Bell – The Irish Connection
- 2 Recollections of John Bell
- 3 John Bell: Recollections of a Great Scientist and a Great Man
- Part II Bell's Theorem
- Part III Nonlocality: Illusion or Reality?
- Part IV Nonlocal Realistic Theories
- Index
- References
2 - Recollections of John Bell
from Part I - John Stewart Bell: The Physicist
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 September 2016
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- Preface
- Part I John Stewart Bell: The Physicist
- 1 John Bell – The Irish Connection
- 2 Recollections of John Bell
- 3 John Bell: Recollections of a Great Scientist and a Great Man
- Part II Bell's Theorem
- Part III Nonlocality: Illusion or Reality?
- Part IV Nonlocal Realistic Theories
- Index
- References
Summary
It is a pleasure to contribute to this anthology some of my recollections of John Bell.
I first met him at SLAC, where we were visitors during 1964–5 when he was on leave from CERN, and I was on leave from the Columbia University Physics Department. Soon I found that we had a common interest in the foundations of quantum mechanics, and we had lively discussions on this subject. We were concerned with the “reduction of the wave packet” after an experiment in quantum mechanics was completed, and wrote a tongue-incheek article on this subject for a festschrift in honor of Viki Weisskopf [1], stating that
We emphasize not only that our view is that of a minority but also that current interest in such questions is small. The typical physicist feels that they have long been answered, and that he will fully understand just how, if ever he can spare twenty minutes to think about it.
Now, 50 years later, this topic, known as the measurement problem, has become the source of numerous articles representing many different viewpoints. At the time, however, I confess that I did not realize that the main flaw in John von Neumann's presentation of this problem was his assumption that a measuring device can be represented by a pointer with only two quantum states. Actually, a measuring device must be able to record the outcome of an experiment, and for this purpose it has to have an enormous number of quantum states, leading to an irreversible macroscopic transition in the device. A correct discussion of the measurement problemwas given, for example, by Nico vanKampen [2], but recently he told me that he was unable to persuade Bell, who continued to be concerned about this problem for the rest of his life. Indeed, shortly before he died, he wrote a diatribe [3] entitled “Against Measurement,” where he continued to argue that this problem constituted a fundamental flaw in quantum mechanics. Kurt Gottfried, who referred to this problem as Bell's second major theme, called his article “a fervent jeremiad summarizing a lifetime of reflection on what he saw as the fatal flaws of the orthodox theory” [4].
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Quantum Nonlocality and Reality50 Years of Bell's Theorem, pp. 19 - 24Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2016