Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Print publication year: 2012
  • Online publication date: June 2012

5 - Shootout at United Nations Plaza


It was a warm evening in June 2006, and delegates to the Small Arms Review Conference crowded the narrow atrium at United Nations headquarters. An official had just dedicated the Five Year Report on the UN's Programme of Action to control the illicit trade in small arms and light weapons (SALW), a policy activists and diplomats had worked years to develop. Celebrating the fight against the global “gun crisis,” the throng of dark suits and knee-high dresses sipped drinks at the open bar and munched shrimp, cheeses, and petits fours.

But just below the surface, things were amiss. The event's organizers had forgotten to check the recorded music track. As the delegates gobbled and gabbed, Bob Marley's “I Shot the Sheriff” blared – its refrain, “but I swear it was in self-defense,” sounding a consistent theme of the Programme's sworn enemies, the National Rifle Association (NRA) and the World Forum on the Future of Sport Shooting Activities (WFSA). For them, gun deaths were not one of the world's most pressing human rights problems. On the contrary: the real threat came from firearms control, undermining the most basic of human rights – preserving life, if necessary at the barrel of a gun. Thanks to the NRA and WFSA, the UN festivities were bittersweet. Despite high hopes, the Programme of Action had become, in the words of one early proponent, Human Rights Watch (HRW), little more than a “program of inaction,” its bland principles nonbinding. Much of the responsibility for this gutting could be laid at the feet of the gun groups, whose representatives sat in their own dark suits on the U.S. delegation.

Small Arms Survey (SAS)Small Arms Survey 2007: Guns and the CityCambridgeCambridge University Press 2007
Carpenter, Ted Galen 1991
Preventing Deadly Conflict: Final ReportNew YorkCarnegie Corporation 1997
Center, Human SecurityHuman Security Report 2005: War and Peace in the 21st CenturyOxfordOxford University Press, 2005
Mueller, JohnOverblown: How Politicians and the Terrorism Industry Inflate National Security Threats, and Why We Believe ThemNew YorkFree Press 2006
Karp, AaronSmall Arms – The New Major WeaponsLethal Commerce: The Global Trade in Small Arms and Light WeaponsCambridge, MAAAAS 1995
Goldring, Natalie J.Domestic Laws and International ControlsLight Weapons and Civil Conflict: Controlling the Tools of Violence, Carnegie Commission on Preventing Deadly Conflict SeriesLanham, MDRowman & Littlefield 1999
Injuries, FirearmsGun Ownership Rights in Small Arms Conference DebateThe Global War on Your Guns: Inside the U.N. Plan to Destroy the Bill of RightsNashvilleNelson Current 2006
Kopel, Dave 2006
Karp, AaronLaudable FailureSAIS Review 22 2002 177
Garcia, DeniseSmall Arms and Security: New Emerging International NormsNew YorkRoutledge 2006 50
interview, LauranceCukier, WendySidel, Victor W.The Global Gun Epidemic: From Saturday Night Specials to AK-47sNew YorkPraeger 2005
Karp, AaronSmall Arms: Back to the FutureBrown Journal of World Affairs 1 2002 179
Merchants of DeathNew YorkMead 1934
Lott, John R.More Guns, Less Crime: Understanding Crime and Gun Control LawsChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press 1998
Rissanen, JenniJohnson, RebeccaLow-Key First Committee Seeks to Maximise Common Ground,Disarmament Diplomacy 52 2000