Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 9
  • Print publication year: 2013
  • Online publication date: June 2014

7 - Increasing Equivalence in Small-Sample Place-Based Experiments

Summary

INTRODUCTION

In recent years, places (such as small geographic locations, schools, classrooms, and clinics) rather than people have come into focus as the unit of analysis in randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Places can be both the physical location and the organizational unit for human behavior (Boruch, Weisburd, and Berk 2010). As such, many social reform interventions involve larger units of organization, and often policies developed by or for agencies such as police departments and schools are not always hypothesized to work directly at the level of the individual person (Boruch et al. 2004; Campbell 1969). Influential place-based experiments have been conducted in the fields of healthcare (e.g., Donner and Klar 2000; Grimshaw et al. 2005; Sikkema 2005; Imai, King, and Nall 2009), social welfare (Bloom and Riccio 2005), education (Flay and Collins 2005; Parker and Teruel 2005), and criminal justice (e.g., Braga and Bond 2008; Braga et al. 1999; Sherman and Weisburd 1995; Taylor, Koper, and Woods 2011; Weisburd and Green 1995; Weisburd, Morris, and Ready 2008).

Place-based experiments in criminal justice have been particularly influential. Studies of “hot spots policing,” which necessarily focus on small units of geography, have led to encouraging findings regarding the ability of the police to prevent crime (Durlauf and Nagin 2011; Skogan and Frydl 2004; Weisburd and Eck 2004). Indeed, in 2004 the National Research Council of the National Academy of Sciences concluded that “…(S)tudies that focused police resources on crime hot spots provide the strongest collective evidence of police effectiveness that is now available” (Skogan and Frydl 2004: 250). These research findings have had important consequences for police reform in practice (Kochel 2011; Weisburd and Lum 2005). Most larger police agencies in the United States, for example, now use hot spots policing tactics (Weisburd and Braga 2006; Weisburd and Lum 2005; Weisburd et al. 2003).

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
References
Ariel, Barak, and Farrington, David P.. 2010. “Randomized Block Designs.” In Handbook of Quantitative Criminology, edited by Piquero, Alex R. and Weisburd, David, pp. 437–54. New York: Springer.
Bloom, Howard S. 2005. “Randomizing Groups to Evaluate Place-based Programs.” In Learning More from Social Experiments: Evolving Analytic Approaches, edited by Bloom, Howard S., pp. 115–72. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Bloom, Howard S., and Riccio, James A.. 2005. “Using Place Random Assignment and Comparative Interrupted Time-series Analysis to Evaluate the Jobs Plus Employment Program for Public Housing Residents.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 599: 19–51.
Boruch, Robert, May, Henry, Turner, Herbert, Lavenberg, Julia, Petrosino, Anthony, Moya, Dorothy De, Grimshaw, Jeremy, and Foley, Ellen. 2004. “Estimating the Effects of Interventions that Are Deployed in Many Places: Place-randomized Trials.” American Behavioral Scientist 47(5): 608–33.
Boruch, Robert, Weisburd, David, and Berk, Richard. 2010. “Place Randomized Trials.” In Handbook of Quantitative Criminology, edited by Piquero, Alex R. and Weisburd, David, pp. 481–502. New York: Springer.
Box, Joan Fisher. 1980. “R. A. Fisher and the Design of Experiments.” American Statistician 34(1): 1–7.
Braga, Anthony A., and Bond, Brenda J.. 2008. “Policing Crime and Disorder Hot Spots: A Randomized Controlled Trial.” Criminology 46(3): 577–607.
Braga, Anthony A., Papachristos, Andrew V., and Hureau, David M.. 2012. Hot Spots Policing Effects on Crime. Campbell Systematic Reviews. Retrieved from: (Accessed May 1, 2013).
Braga, Anthony A., Weisburd, David L., Waring, Elin J., Mazerolle, Lorraine Green, Spelman, William, and Gajewski, Francis. 1999. “Problem-oriented Policing in Violent Crime Places: A Randomized Controlled Experiment.” Criminology 37(3): 541–80.
Campbell, Donald T. 1969. “Reforms as Experiments.” American Psychologist 24: 409–29.
Donner, Allan, and Klar, Neil. 2000. Design and Analysis of Cluster Randomization Trials in Health Research. London: Arnold.
Durlauf, Steven N., and Nagin, Daniel S.. 2011. “Imprisonment and Crime: Can Both Be Reduced?Criminology and Public Policy 10(1): 13–54.
Farrington, David P. 1983. “Randomized Experiments on Crime and Justice.” Crime & Justice 4: 257–308.
Farrington, David P., Ohlin, Lloyd E., and Wilson, James Q.. 1986. Understanding and Controlling Crime: Toward a New Research Strategy. New York: Springer-Verlag.
Farrington, David P., and Petrosino, Anthony. 2001. “The Campbell Collaboration Crime and Justice Group.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 578: 35–49.
Farrington, David P., and Ttofi, Maria M.. 2009. School-based Programs to Reduce Bullying and Victimization. Campbell Systematic Reviews. Retrieved from: (Accessed May 1, 2013).
Farrington, David P., Weisburd, David L., and Gill, Charlotte. 2011. The Campbell Collaboration Crime and Justice Group: A Decade of Progress. In Handbook of International Criminology edited by Smith, Cindy, Zhang, Sheldon, and Barberet, Rosemary, pp. 53–63. New York: Routledge.
Farrington, David P., and Welsh, Brandon C.. 2005. “Randomized Experiments in Criminology: What Have We Learned in the Last Two Decades?Journal of Experimental Criminology 1(1): 9–38.
Fisher, Ronald A. 1926. “The Arrangement of Field Experiments.” Journal of the Ministry of Agriculture 33: 503–13.
Fisher, Ronald A. 1935. The Design of Experiments. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd.
Flay, Brian R., and Collins, Linda M.. 2005. “Historical Review of School-based Randomized Trials for Evaluating Problem Behavior Prevention Programs.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 599: 115–46.
Grimshaw, Jeremy, Eccles, Martin, Campbell, Marion, and Elbourne, Diana. 2005. “Cluster Randomized Trials of Professional and Organizational Behavior Change Interventions in Health Settings.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 599: 71–93.
Imai, Kosuke, King, Gary, and Nall, Clayton. 2009. “The Essential Role of Pair Matching in Cluster-randomized Experiments, with Application to the Mexican Universal Health Insurance Evaluation.” Statistical Science 24(1): 29–53.
Jolliffe, Darrick, and Farrington, David P.. 2007. A Rapid Evidence Assessment of the Impact of Mentoring on Reoffending. London: Home Office Online Report. Retrieved from: (Accessed May 1, 2013).
Kochel, Tammy R. 2011. “Constructing Hot Spots Policing: Unexamined Consequences for Disadvantaged Populations and for Police Legitimacy.” Criminal Justice Policy Review 22(3): 350–74.
McCord, Joan. 2003. “Cures that Harm: Unanticipated Outcomes of Crime Prevention Programs.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 587: 16–30.
Skogan, Wesley, and Frydl, Kathleen (Eds.). 2004. Fairness and Effectiveness in Policing: The Evidence, edited by Skogan, Wesley and Frydl, Kathleen. Committee to Review Research on Police Policy and Practices. Committee on Law and Justice, Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
Parker, Susan W., and Teruel, Graciela M.. 2005. “Randomization and Social Program Evaluation: The Case of Progresa.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 599: 199–219.
Petrosino, Anthony, Turpin-Petrosino, Carolyn, and Buehler, John. 2003. “Scared Straight and Other Juvenile Awareness Programs for Preventing Juvenile Delinquency: A Systematic Review of the Randomized Experimental Evidence.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 589(1): 41–62.
Powers, Edwin, and Witmer, Helen. 1951. An Experiment in the Prevention of Delinquency. New York: Columbia University Press.
Raudenbush, Stephen W., Martinez, Andres, and Spybrook, Jessaca. 2007. “Strategies for Improving Precision in Group-randomized Experiments.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 29(1): 5–29.
Robinson, Laurie O., and Slowikowski, Jeff. 2011. “Scary – and Ineffective: Traumatizing At-risk Kids Is Not the Way to Lead Them Away from Crime and Drugs.” Baltimore Sun, January 31. Retrieved from: (Accessed May 1, 2013).
Sherman, Lawrence W., Farrington, David P., Welsh, Brandon C., and MacKenzie, Doris L. (Eds.). 2006. Evidence-based Crime Prevention (rev. ed.). New York: Routledge.
Sherman, Lawrence W., Gartin, Patrick R., and Buerger, Michael E.. 1989. “Hot Spots of Predatory Crime: Routine Activities and the Criminology of Place.” Criminology 27(1): 27–56.
Sherman, Lawrence W., Gottfredson, Denise, MacKenzie, Doris, Eck, John, Reuter, Peter, and Bushway, Shaun. 1997. Preventing Crime: What Works, What Doesn’t, What’s Promising. Washington, DC: United States Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice.
Sherman, Lawrence W., and Weisburd, David. 1995. “General Deterrent Effects of Police Patrol in Crime ‘Hot Spots’: A Randomized, Controlled Trial.” Justice Quarterly 12(4): 625–48.
Sikkema, Kathleen J. 2005. “HIV Prevention among Women in Low Income Housing Developments: Issues and Intervention Outcomes in a Place Randomized Trial.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 599: 52–70.
Taylor, Bruce, Koper, Christopher S., and Woods, Daniel J.. 2011. “A Randomized Controlled Trial of Different Policing Strategies at Hot Spots of Violent Crime.” Journal of Experimental Criminology 7(2): 149–81.
Travis, Alan. 2009. “CCTV Schemes in City and Town Centres Have Little Effect on Crime, Says Report.” The Guardian, May 18. Retrieved from: (Accessed May 1, 2013).
Weisburd, David. 2005. “Hot Spots Policing Experiments and Criminal Justice Research: Lessons from the Field.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 599(1): 220–45.
Weisburd, David, and Braga, Anthony A.. 2006. Hot Spots Policing as a Model for Police Innovation. In Police Innovation: Contrasting Perspectives, edited by Weisburd, David and Braga, Anthony A., pp. 225–44. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Weisburd, David, and Eck, John E.. 2004. “What Can Police Do to Reduce Crime, Disorder, and Fear?Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 593(1): 42–65.
Weisburd, David, and Green, Lorraine. 1995. “Policing Drug Hot Spots: The Jersey City Drug Market Analysis Experiment.” Justice Quarterly 12(4): 711–35.
Weisburd, David, and Lum, Cynthia. 2005. “The Diffusion of Computerized Crime Mapping in Policing: Linking Research and Practice.” Police Practice and Research 6(5): 419–34.
Weisburd, David, Mastrofski, Stephen D., McNally, Ann Marie, Greenspan, Rosann, and Willis, James J.. 2003. “Reforming to Preserve: Compstat and Strategic Problem solving in American Policing.” Criminology and Public Policy 2(3): 421–56.
Weisburd, David, Morris, Nancy A., and Ready, Justin. 2008. “Risk-focused Policing at Places: An Experimental Evaluation.” Justice Quarterly 25(1): 163–200.