Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- Acknowledgements
- Epigraph
- Introduction: Everywhere and Nowhere
- PART I BEFORE – FLIRTING WITH DEATH
- PART II DURING – DEPICTING DEATH
- 4 The Cinematic Language of Dying
- 5 Grammar Lessons: Dying and Difference
- 6 Watching Others Die: Spectatorship, Vulnerability and the Ethics of Being Moved
- PART III AFTER – RESPONDING TO DEATH
- Notes
- Bibliography
- Filmography
- Index
6 - Watching Others Die: Spectatorship, Vulnerability and the Ethics of Being Moved
from PART II - DURING – DEPICTING DEATH
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 September 2014
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- Acknowledgements
- Epigraph
- Introduction: Everywhere and Nowhere
- PART I BEFORE – FLIRTING WITH DEATH
- PART II DURING – DEPICTING DEATH
- 4 The Cinematic Language of Dying
- 5 Grammar Lessons: Dying and Difference
- 6 Watching Others Die: Spectatorship, Vulnerability and the Ethics of Being Moved
- PART III AFTER – RESPONDING TO DEATH
- Notes
- Bibliography
- Filmography
- Index
Summary
I launched this second section of the book with the notion, adapted from Elaine Scarry's work, that dying was both inexpressible and unshareable. The framework which this afforded allowed us to review the problem of representing dying within mainstream film culture where it was expressed, albeit distortedly. In the last two chapters I have shown that there is a cinematic language of dying. It is rich and multifaceted but heavily censored nevertheless. It suppresses, still, the banality and brutality of bodily decline to promote the sociocultural and positivist fantasies of late capitalist culture. Such normative fantasies, which cohere in the ‘triumph, betterment and futurity’ of Hollywood's terminally ill as well as in the not-so-good deaths of others, are hooked, unsurprisingly, on identity politics. As the full ideological weight of these fantasies became clear, their grammar of dying was revealed as fundamentally race bound. Dying is not inexpressible in cinema, then, but the language film forges for it is partial and partisan, and the grammar predetermining it necropolitical.
In this chapter, I move on to the question of the unshareability of dying, of its place as a profoundly personal experience that cannot be communicated to, and shared in by, others.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Death and the Moving ImageIdeology, Iconography and I, pp. 155 - 178Publisher: Edinburgh University PressPrint publication year: 2014