Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2009
  • Online publication date: July 2009

10 - In Defense of Prisoner Disenfranchisement

Summary

In this chapter, I argue that limited disenfranchisement of prisoners is normatively consistent with liberal democratic principles. I make this argument in full recognition that it runs counter to the emerging consensus of constitutional courts outside of the United States (see European Court of Human Rights [ECHR] 2005). Indeed, the argument I make here was rejected – although by only one vote – by the Supreme Court of Canada in Sauvé v. Canada (Supreme Court of Canada 2002, hereafter Sauvé [No. 2]). That decision, of course, stands in stark contrast to the controlling judgment of the U.S. Supreme Court on the same issue. In Richardson v. Ramirez (U.S. Supreme Court 1974), a six-justice majority of the U.S. Supreme Court held that states possess broad constitutional authority to disenfranchise persons convicted of crimes. The majority based its decision on section 2 of the Fourteenth Amendment, which allows states to deny citizens the right to vote “for participation in rebellion, or other crime.” According to Justice William Rehnquist, the text of section 2 establishes an “affirmative sanction” for the “exclusion of felons from the vote” that was broad enough to justify even permanent disenfranchisement of convicted persons. Despite scholarly criticism (Tribe 1988: 1094; Note 1989: 1300–17), Richardson has remained settled law in the United States.

The Canadian Court's majority judgment in Sauvé (No. 2), authored by Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin, was dismissive – to the point of hostility – toward the state of American law in this area.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
References
,ABT Associates. 1995. Report on File with the Author (April 10).
Andenaes, Johannes. 1975. “General Prevention Revisited: Research and Policy Implications,” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 66: 341.
Aristotle, . Politics. 1996. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Bickel, Alexander. 1975. The Morality of Consent. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Booth, William James. 1997. “Foreigners: Insiders, Outsiders and the Ethics of Membership,” The Review of Politics 59: 271–7.
,Correction Services Canada/National Parole Board. 1992. Basic Facts about Corrections in Canada, 1992 Edition. Ottawa: Supply and Services.
,European Court of Human Rights. 2005. Hirst v. United Kingdom (No. 2), App. No. 7402/01 (October 6).
Ewald, Alec C. 2002. “‘Civil Death’”: The Ideological Paradox of Criminal Disenfranchisement Law in the United States,” Wisconsin Law Review1045: 1045–137.
,Federal Court of Appeal. 1992. Belczowski v. Canada, 2 F.C. 440.
,Federal Court of Appeal. 2000. Sauvé v. Chief Electoral Officer of Canada, 2 F.C. 117.
,Federal Court, Trial Division. 1991. Belczowski v. Canada, 3 F.C. 151.
,Federal Court, Trial Division. 1995. Sauvé v. Chief Electoral Officer of Canada et al.; McCorrister et al. v. Attorney General of Canada, 132 D.L.R. (4th) 136.
Goodwin-Gill, Guy S. 1994. Free and Fair Elections: International Law and Practice. Geneva: Inter-Parliamentary Union.
Hogg, Peter W. and Bushell, Allison A.. 1997. “The Charter Dialogue between Courts and Legislatures (or Maybe the Charter of Rights and Freedoms Isn't Such a Bad Thing after All),” Osgoode Hall Law Journal 35: 75–124.
Kahan, Dan. 1997. “Social Influence, Social Meaning and Deterrence,” Virginia Law Review 83: 349–95.
Knopff, Rainer and Morton, F. L.. 1992. Charter Politics. Toronto: Nelson.
LaPrairie, Carol. 1990. “The Role of Sentencing in the Over-Representation of Aboriginal People in Correctional Institutions,” Canadian Journal of Criminology 32: 429–40.
Madison, James. 1788a. “Federalist No. 55,” in Federalist Papers. New York: J. & A. McLean.
Madison, James. 1788b. “Federalist No. 57,” in Federalist Papers. New York: J. & A. McLean.
Manfredi, Christopher P. 1998. “Judicial Review and Criminal Disenfranchisement in the United States and Canada,” The Review of Politics 60: 277–305.
Manfredi, Christopher P. 2002. “Expressive Freedom and Tobacco Advertising: A Canadian Perspective,” American Journal of Public Health 92: 360–2.
Manitoba, . 1991. Report of the Aboriginal Justice Inquiry of Manitoba: Volume I: The Justice System and Aboriginal People. Available at http://www.ajic.mb.ca/volumel/toc.html.
,Manitoba Court of Appeal. 1988. Badger v. Canada, 55 Man. R. (2d) 198.
,Manitoba Court of Queen's Bench. 1988. Badger v. Canada, 55 Man. R. (2d) 211.
Mill, John Stuart. 1926 [1861]. Considerations on Representative Government. London: Longmans, Green and Co.
Moyer, Sharon. 1992. “Race, Gender, and Homicide: Comparisons between Aboriginals and Other Canadians,” Canadian Journal of Criminology 34: 387–402.
Note, . 1989. “The Disenfranchisement of Ex-Felons: Citizenship, Criminality, and the ‘Purity of the Ballot Box,’Harvard Law Review 102: 1300–17.
O'Brien, David M. 2005. Constitutional Law and Politics, Volume 1: Struggles for Power and Government Accountability (6th ed.). New York: W.W. Norton.
,Ontario Court of Appeal. 1992. Sauvé v. Canada (Attorney General), 7 O.R. (3d) 481.
,Ontario High Court of Justice. 1988. Sauvé v. A.-G. Canada, 66 O.R. (2d) 234.
Planinc, Zdravko. 1987. “Should Imprisoned Criminals Have a Constitutional Right to Vote?,” Canadian Journal of Law and Society 2: 153–64.
Powers, William Ashby. 2006. “Note & Comment: Hirst v. United Kingdom (No. 2): A First Look at Prisoner Disenfranchisement by the European Court of Human Rights,” Connecticut Journal of International Law 21: 243.
Rawls, John. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Scruton, Roger. 1983. A Dictionary of Political Thought. London: Pan Books.
Smith, Rogers M. 1988. “The ‘American Creed’ and American Identity: The Limits of Liberal Citizenship in the United States,” Western Political Quarterly 41: 225–51.
Canada, Statistics. 1994. Adult Correctional Services, 1993–94. Ottawa: Supply and Services.
,Supreme Court of Canada. 1993. Attorney-General of Canada v. Sauvé, 2 S.C.R. 438.
,Supreme Court of Canada. 1995. RJR-MacDonald v. Canada, 3 S.C.R. 199.
,Supreme Court of Canada. 1998. Vriend v. Alberta, 1 S.C.R. 493.
,Supreme Court of Canada. 2002. Sauvé v. Canada, 3 S.C.R. 519.
Tocqueville, Alexis. 1945 [1835]. Democracy in America, Volume 1. New York: Vintage Books.
Tribe, Laurence. 1988. American Constitutional Law (2nd ed.). Mineola, NY: Foundation Press.
,U.S. Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit. 2005. Johnson v. Bush, 405 F. 3d1214.
,U.S. Supreme Court. 1974. Richardson v. Ramirez, 418 U.S. 24.
Hirsch, Andrew. 1976. Doing Justice: The Choice of Punishments. New York: Hill and Wang.
Hirsch, Andrew. 1985. Past or Future Crimes. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
Wilbanks, William. 1987. The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
Wilson, James Q. 1991. On Character. Washington, D.C.: AEI Press.
Wilson, James Q. 1993. The Moral Sense. New York: The Free Press.
Wilson, James Q. and Herrnstein, Richard. 1985. Crime and Human Nature. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Manfredi, Christopher P. and Rush, Mark, Judging Democracy (Broadview Press, 2008).