Book contents
- Comparing Cultures
- Comparing Cultures
- Copyright page
- Contents
- Figures
- Tables
- Contributors
- Introduction
- Part I Binary Comparisons
- Part II Regional Comparisons
- Part III Distant and Fluid Comparisons
- 7 Best, Worst, and Good Enough
- 8 Research across Cultures and Disciplines
- 9 Global Sport Industries, Comparison, and Economies of Scales
- Index
- References
8 - Research across Cultures and Disciplines
Methodological Challenges in an Interdisciplinary and Comparative Research Project on Emotion Socialization
from Part III - Distant and Fluid Comparisons
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 08 May 2020
Book contents
- Comparing Cultures
- Comparing Cultures
- Copyright page
- Contents
- Figures
- Tables
- Contributors
- Introduction
- Part I Binary Comparisons
- Part II Regional Comparisons
- Part III Distant and Fluid Comparisons
- 7 Best, Worst, and Good Enough
- 8 Research across Cultures and Disciplines
- 9 Global Sport Industries, Comparison, and Economies of Scales
- Index
- References
Summary
This chapter reflects on the methodological problems within a collaborative research project involving anthropology and developmental psychology. The project studied relations between child-rearing goals, emotionally arousing child-rearing practices, and the socialization and ontogenetic development of emotions in three different contexts (Indonesia, Madagascar, and Taiwan). I first discuss which demands were linked with the theoretical perspectives and methodological standards of the two disciplines. I then reflect on the problems encountered when trying to apply the same methods in all three contexts. One of the challenges for this interdisciplinary project was the differing kinds of empirical data gathered because of the need to adapt methods to local conditions. We needed a productive way to work between the methodological priorities of each discipline. Therefore, I designed a methodology that acknowledges the unique methodological advantages of anthropology – long-term field research, participant observation, using an explorative approach – while simultaneously making it possible to achieve theoretical and methodological equivalence in controlled cross-cultural comparisons.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Comparing CulturesInnovations in Comparative Ethnography, pp. 180 - 200Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2020
References
Briggs, Jean L. 1982. “Living Dangerously: The Contradictory Foundations of Value in Canadian Inuit Society.” In Politics and History in Band Societies, edited by Leacock, Eleanor and Lee, Richard B., 109–31. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Briggs, Jean L. 1998. Inuit Morality Play. The Emotional Education of a Three-Year-Old. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Chang, Lei, Schwartz, David, Dodge, Kenneth, and McBride-Chang, Catherine. 2003. “Harsh Parenting in Relation to Child Emotion Regulation and Aggression.” Journal of Family Psychology 17 (4): 598–606.Google Scholar
Cole, Pamela M., Dennis, Tracy A., Mizuta, Ichiro, and Zahn-Waxler, Carolyn. 2002. “Self in Context: Autonomy and Relatedness in Japanese and U.S. Mother-Preschooler Dyads.” Child Development 73 (6): 1803–17.Google Scholar
D’Andrade, Roy. 2000. “The Sad Story of Anthropology, 1950–1999.” Cross-Cultural Research 34 (3): 219–32.Google Scholar
Eisenberg, Nancy, Pidada, Sri, and Liew, Jeffrey. 2001. “The Relations of Regulation and Negative Emotionality to Indonesian Children’s Social Functioning.” Child Development 72 (6): 1747–63.Google Scholar
Fonagy, Peter, Gergely, György, Jurist, Elliot L., and Target, Mary. 2002. Affect Regulation, Mentalization, and the Development of the Self. New York: Other Press.Google Scholar
Friedlmeier, Wolfgang, and Trommsdorff, Gisela. 1999. “Emotion Regulation in Early Childhood: A Cross-Cultural Comparison between German and Japanese Toddlers.” Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 30 (6): 684–711.Google Scholar
Fung, Heidi. 1999. “Becoming a Moral Child. The Socialization of Shame among Young Chinese Children.” Ethos, Journal of the Society for Psychological Anthropology 27 (2): 180–209.Google Scholar
Funk, Leberecht. Forthcoming. Society, Cosmology, and Socialization of Emotion among the Tao in Taiwan.Google Scholar
Funk, Leberecht, Röttger-Rössler, Birgitt, and Scheidecker, Gabriel. 2012. “Fühlen(d) Lernen: Zur Sozialisation und Entwicklung von Emotionen im Kulturvergleich.” Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft 15: 217–38.Google Scholar
Gielen, Uwe P. 2004. “The Cross-Cultural Study of Human Development: An Opinionated Historical Introduction.” In Childhood and Adolescence: Cross-Cultural Perspectives and Applications, edited by Gielen, Uwe P. and Roopnarine, Jaipaul L., 3–45. Westport, CT: Praeger.Google Scholar
Harper, Douglas. 2002. “Talking about Pictures: A Case for Photo Elicitation.” Visual Studies 17 (1): 13–26.Google Scholar
Henrichs, Joseph, Heine, Steven J., and Norenzayan, Ara. 2010. “The Weirdest People in the World?” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 33 (2–3): 61–135.Google Scholar
Hewlett, Barry S. 1991. Intimate Fathers: The Nature and Context of Aka Pgymy Paternal Infant Care. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holodynski, Manfred. 2004. “Die Entwicklung von Emotion und Ausdruck. Vom biologischen zum kulturellen Erbe.” ZiF-Mitteilungen 6: 1–16.Google Scholar
Holodynski, Manfred. 2009. “Milestones and Mechanisms of Emotional Development.” In Emotions as Bio-cultural Processes, edited by Röttger-Rössler, Birgitt and Markowitsch, Hans J., 139–63. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
Holodynski, Manfred. 2013. “The Internalization Theory of Emotions: A Cultural Historical Approach to the Development of Emotions.” Mind, Culture, and Activity 20 (1): 4–38.Google Scholar
Holodynski, Manfred, and Friedlmeier, Wolfgang. 2006. The Development of Emotions and Emotion Regulation. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
Holodynski, Manfred, and Friedlmeier, Wolfgang. 2012. “Affect and Culture.” In The Oxford Handbook of Culture and Psychology, edited by Valsiner, Jaan, 957–86. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Izard, Carroll E., and Malatesta, Carol Z.. 1987. “Perspectives on Emotional Development I: Differential Emotions Theory of Early Emotional Development.” In Handbook of Infant Development, 2nd ed., edited by Osofsky, Joy D., 494–554. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Johnson, Allan. 1975. “Time Allocation in a Machiguenga Society.” Ethnology 14 (3): 301–10.Google Scholar
Jung, Susanne. Forthcoming. Sozialisation von Emotionen in einer indonesischen Gesellschaft (Minangkabau).Google Scholar
Keller, Heidi, and Otto, Hiltrud. 2009. “The Cultural Socialization of Emotion Regulation during Infancy.” Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 40 (6): 996–1011.Google Scholar
Kleinman, Arthur. 1992. “Pain and Resistance: The Delegitimation and Relegitimation of Local Worlds.” In Pain as Human Experience: An Anthropological Perspective, edited by DelVecchio Good, Mary-Jo, Brodwin, Paul, Good, Byron J., and Kleinman, Arthur, 169–97. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
LeDoux, Joseph E. 2002. The Synaptic Self. How Our Brains Become Who We Are. New York: Viking.Google Scholar
LeVine, Robert A., and LeVine, Barbara B.. 1966. Nyansongo: A Gusii Community in Kenia. Huntington, NY: Robert E. Krieger Publishing Company.Google Scholar
LeVine, Robert A., Dixon, Suzanne, LeVine, Sarah, Richman, Amy, Leiderman, P. Herbert, Keefer, Constanze H., and Brazelton, T. Berry. 1994. Child Care and Culture: Lessons from Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Lieber, Eli, Fung, Heidi, and Leung, Patrick W. L.. 2006. “Chinese Child-Rearing Beliefs: Key Dimensions and Contributions to the Development of Culture-Appropriate Assessment.” Asian Journal of Social Psychology 9 (2): 140–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lutz, Catherine. 1988. Unnatural Emotions. Everyday Sentiment on a Micronesian Atoll and Their Challenge to Western Theory. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Miller, Peggy J., Wiley, Angela R., Fung, Heidi, and Liang, Chung-Hui. 1997. “Personal Storytelling as a Medium of Socialization in Chinese and American Families.” Child Development 8 (3): 557–68.Google Scholar
Miller, Peggy J., Fung, Heidi, and Mintz, Judith. 1996. “Self-Construction through Narrative Practices: A Chinese and American Comparison of Early Socialization.” Ethos, Journal of the Society for Psychological Anthropology 24 (2): 237–80.Google Scholar
Munroe, Robert L., and Munroe, Ruth H.. 1975. Cross-Cultural Human Development. Monterey, CA: Brooks-Cole.Google Scholar
Munroe, Robert, Munroe, Ruth H., and Whiting, Beatrice B., eds. 1981. Handbook of Cross-Cultural Human Development. New York: Garland STPM Press.Google Scholar
Munroe, Ruth H., and Munroe, Robert L.. 1971. “Household Density and Infant Care in an East African Society.” Journal of Social Psychology 83 (1): 295–315.Google Scholar
Munroe, Ruth H., Munroe, Robert L., and Shimming, Harold S.. 1984. “Children’s Work in Four Cultures: Determinants and Consequences.” American Anthropologist 86 (2): 369–79.Google Scholar
Quinn, Naomi. 2005. “Universals of Child Rearing.” Anthropological Theory 5 (4): 477–516.Google Scholar
Ragin, Charles C. 1998. “The Logic of Qualitative Comparative Analysis.” International Review of Social History 43 (56): 105–24.Google Scholar
Röttger-Rössler, Birgitt. 2000. “Selbstrepräsentation und Kultur. Malaiische und indonesische Formen autobiographischen Erzählens.” In Erzählte Identitäten, edited by Neumann, Michael, 135–52. München: Fink Verlag.Google Scholar
Röttger-Rössler, Birgitt. 2013. “In the Eyes of the Other: Shame and Social Conformity in the Context of Indonesian Societies.” In Shame between Punishment and Penance, edited by Sére, Bénédicte and Wettlaufer, Jörg, 405–19. Paris: Micrologus.Google Scholar
Röttger-Rössler, Birgitt, Scheidecker, Gabriel, Funk, Leberecht, and Holodynski, Manfred. 2015. “Learning (by) Feeling: A Cross-Cultural Comparison of the Socialization and Development of Emotions.” Ethos. Journal of the Society for Psychological Anthropology 43 (3): 187–220.Google Scholar
Röttger-Rössler, Birgitt, Scheidecker, Gabriel, Jung, Susanne, and Holodynski, Manfred. 2013. “Socializing Emotions in Childhood: A Cross-Cultural Comparison between the Bara in Madagascar and the Minangkabau in Indonesia.” Mind, Culture, and Activity. An International Journal. Special Issue, “Psychology of Emotions and Cultural Historical Activity Theory” 20 (3): 260–87.Google Scholar
Scheidecker, Gabriel. 2017. Kindheit, Kultur und moralische Emotionen. Zur Sozialisation von Furcht und Wut im ländlichen Madagaskar. Bielefeld: Transcript.Google Scholar
Scheidecker, Gabriel, Gernhardt, Ariane, Rübeling, Hartmut, Holtmannspötter, Jona, and Keller, Heidi. 2019. “How Young Adolescents Draw Themselves: A Comparison across Three Ecosocial Contexts in Southern Madagascar.” Cross Cultural Research 53 (1): 33–57.Google Scholar
Schnegg, Michael. 2014. “Anthropology and Comparison: Methodological Challenges and Tentative Solutions.” Zeitschrift für Ethnologie 139: 55–71.Google Scholar
Shipman, Kimberly L., and Zeman, Janice. 2001. “Socialization of Children’s Emotion Regulation in Mother–Child Dyads: A Developmental Psychopathology Perspective.” Development and Psychopathology 13 (2): 317–36.Google Scholar
Shweder, Richard A., Haidt, Jonathan, Horton, Randall, and Craig, Joseph. 2008. “The Cultural Psychology of the Emotions. Ancient and Renewed.” In Handbook of Emotions, 3rd ed., edited by Lewis, Michael, Haviland-Jones, Jeannette M. and Barrett, Lisa F., 409–27. New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
Sroufe, L. Alan. 1996. Emotional Development: The Organization of Emotional Life in the Early Years. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stenberg, Craig R., and Campos, Joseph J.. 1990. “The Development of Anger Expressions in Infancy.” In Psychological and Biological Approaches to Emotion, edited by Stein, Nancy L., Leventhal, Bennett and Trabasso, Tom R., 247–82. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Trommsdorff, Gisela. 2003. “Kulturvergleichende Entwicklungspsychologie.” In Kulturvergleichende Psychologie: Eine Einführung, edited by Thomas, Alexander, 139–79. Göttingen: Hogrefe.Google Scholar
Whiting, Beatrice B., and Edwards, Carolyn P.. 1988. Children of Different Worlds: The Formation of Social Behavior. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Whiting, Beatrice B., and Whiting, John W. M.. 1975. Children of Six Cultures: A Psycho-cultural Analysis. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Whiting, John W. M., Child, Irvin L., and Lambert, William W.. 1966. Field Guide for a Study of Socialization. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
- 1
- Cited by