While Richard Wagner had declared as early as 1851 that historical topics were utterly obsolete for artistic purposes, such operas were still very much alive at the time of the completion and first performance of the Ring cycle. Tannhäuser and Lohengrin, both recognisably set in the medieval period, were just reaching the height of their popularity on German stages in the years of the Reichsgründung, and some of the most successful operas of the 1870s centred on historical subject matter while following the traditional format of grand opéra. Cosima Wagner herself had to admit that the genre continued to have contemporary appeal when she noted in 1879:

Of these three operas, which in the 1870s were amongst the most widely performed and which in the short run were certainly more successful than Wagner's contemporary music dramas, Armin was the only one based on a story from German national history, which explains its obvious patriotism. The story of the Germanic leader Arminius/Hermann was not just one of the many heroic narratives from early German history, but the key to the national imagination.