Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of figures
- List of tables
- Acknowledgments
- List of abbreviations
- Introduction
- PART I Security, power or welfare? Eastern enlargement in a rationalist perspective
- PART II Expanding the Western community of liberal values and norms: Eastern enlargement in a sociological perspective
- PART III Association instead of membership: preferences and bargaining power in Eastern enlargement
- PART IV From association to membership: rhetorical action in Eastern enlargement
- 9 Rhetorical action
- 10 The decision to enlarge NATO
- 11 The decision to enlarge the EU
- Conclusion: solving the double puzzle of Eastern enlargement
- Strategic action in international community: concluding remarks
- Appendix (Interviews)
- List of references
- Index
9 - Rhetorical action
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 September 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of figures
- List of tables
- Acknowledgments
- List of abbreviations
- Introduction
- PART I Security, power or welfare? Eastern enlargement in a rationalist perspective
- PART II Expanding the Western community of liberal values and norms: Eastern enlargement in a sociological perspective
- PART III Association instead of membership: preferences and bargaining power in Eastern enlargement
- PART IV From association to membership: rhetorical action in Eastern enlargement
- 9 Rhetorical action
- 10 The decision to enlarge NATO
- 11 The decision to enlarge the EU
- Conclusion: solving the double puzzle of Eastern enlargement
- Strategic action in international community: concluding remarks
- Appendix (Interviews)
- List of references
- Index
Summary
The strategic conception of rules: Goffman's social theory
The hypotheses of habitual and normative action started from the assumption that social actors take community and organizational norms and values for granted or internalize them. By providing meanings and motives for action, norms and values affect social action at the dispositional level of cognitions and preferences. These hypotheses follow the cognitive and normative conceptions of institutions, rules and culture that have traditionally dominated sociological institutionalism. There is, however, an alternative, strategic conception of rules in sociological theory on which the mode of rhetorical action is based.
In the account of Robert Edgerton (1985: 7–14), the strategic conception of rules originated in anthropology and sociology as a reaction to the “oversocialized view of man” and the “over-integrated view of society” (Dennis Wrong) that dominated social analysis following the normativist theories of Durkheim and Parsons. “From the slave of custom in the normative model, man came full circle to become the strategic master of rules – artful, dissembling, posing, deceiving and calculating for his own advantage” (Edgerton 1985: 12–13). In the strategic conception, rules are not motives for action, nor are they merely constraints, they are “resources for human strategies” in social interactions and they “are used not followed.”
The seminal work in this tradition is the social theory of Erving Goffman.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The EU, NATO and the Integration of EuropeRules and Rhetoric, pp. 194 - 228Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2003