Conventional methods of somatic cell nuclear transfer either by electrofusion or direct nucleus injection have very low efficiency in animal cloning, especially interspecies cloning. To increase the efficiency of interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer, in the present study we introduced a method of whole cell intracytoplasmic injection (WCICI) combined with chemical enucleation into panda–rabbit nuclear transfer and assessed the effects of this method on the enucleation rate of rabbit oocytes and the in vitro development and spindle structures of giant panda–rabbit reconstructed embryos. Our results demonstrated that chemical enucleation can be used in rabbit oocytes and the optimal enucleation result can be obtained. When we compared the rates of cleavage and blastocyst formation of subzonal injection (SUZI) and WCICI using chemically enucleated rabbit oocytes as cytoplasm recipients, the rates in the WCICI group were higher than those in the SUZI group, but there was no statistically siginificant difference (p>0.05) between the two methods. The microtubule structures of rabbit oocytes enucleated by chemicals and giant panda–rabbit embryos reconstructed by WCICI combined with chemical enucleation were normal. Therefore the present study suggests that WCICI combined with chemical enucleation can provide an efficient and less labor-intensive protocol of interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer for producing giant panda cloned embryos.

In Bufo arenarum, progesterone is the physiological maturation inducer. However, in this species, oocytes reinitiate meiosis with no need of an exogenous hormonal stimulus when deprived of their enveloping cell, a phenomenon called spontaneous maturation. We demonstrated that in Bufo arenarum spontaneous maturation occurs only in oocytes obtained during the reproductive period, which can be considered competent to mature spontaneously, in contrast to those in the non-reproductive period, which are incompetent. Interestingly, full-grown Bufo arenarum oocytes always respond to progesterone regardless of the season in which they are obtained. There is a general consensus that both a transient increase in intracellular calcium and a decrease in cAMP-dependent protein kinase activity are the first steps in the mechanisms by which progesterone induces maturation in amphibians. In the present work we analysed the role of calcium in the spontaneous and progesterone-induced maturation of Bufo arenarum oocytes. Results demonstrated that the absence of calcium in the incubation medium or the prevention of Ca2+ influx by channel blockers such as CdCl2 or NiCl2 did not prevent meiosis reinitiation in either type of maturation. The inhibition of the Ca2+-calmodulin complex in no case affected the maturation of the treated oocytes. However, when the oocytes were deprived of calcium by incubation in Ca2+-free AR + A23187, meiosis resumption was inhibited. In brief, we demonstrated that in Bufo arenarum the reinitiation of meiosis is a process independent of extracellular calcium at any period of the year and that oocytes require adequate levels of intracellular calcium for germinal vesicle breakdown to occur.

The aim of the study was to evaluate the effect of insulin-like growth factors (IGF1 and IGF2), stem cell factor (SCF) and epidermal growth factor (EGF) on the development of embryos exposed to oxidative stress. C3B6F1 female mice were stimulated with 5 IU of pregnant mare serum gonadotropin and 5 IU of equine chorionic gonadotropin (eCG). Two-cell embryos were flushed out from the fallopian tubes 40 h after eCG administration and mating with DBA males. In each experiment embryos were divided into three groups and cultured in (1) control medium, (2) control medium with 0.1 mM hydrogen peroxide and (3) control medium with hydrogen peroxide and separately with IGF1, IGF2, SCF or EGF in concentrations of 1 ng/ml, 10 ng/ml and 100 ng/ml. Under phase-contrast microscopy, 8-cell and compacted embryos, and early, expanded, hatched and outgrown blastocysts were counted at 24 h. The total blastocyst (TB) and inner cell mass (ICM) cell numbers were established by differential staining. Blastocyst cell viability was examined under fluorescence microscopy. To detect apoptosis, TUNEL was performed and visualized under a laser scanning confocal microscope. Hydrogen peroxide decreased embryo growth, blastocyst rates, blastocyst cell viability as well as TB and ICM counts. The TUNEL reaction revealed significantly more apoptotic cells in oxidative stress conditions. Tested factors revealed a varying extent of protective activity against oxidative stress caused by hydrogen peroxide. In media containing hydrogen peroxide and one of the four tested factors (IGF1, IGF2, SCF or EGF) the embryos developed faster than in media with hydrogen peroxide alone. IGF1, IGF2 and EGF increased both TB and (or) ICM counts in embryos exposed to hydrogen peroxide. All tested factors reduced the number of apoptotic cells (TUNEL) in embryos exposed to hydrogen peroxide.

Cloning older adult rabbits can serve as a model in animal breeding, biodiversity preservation and in human therapeutic cloning. To establish the required exposure time of fibroblasts from these kind of animals to reprogramming factors, in the present study three different time intervals between fusion and activation were tested (30 min, 30-ADF group; 60 min, 60-ADF group; and 90 min, 90-ADF group). Vitrified epithelial fibroblasts derived from four older adult rabbit females (D1, D2, D3 and D4) and cultured from passages 0 to 4 were used as nuclear donors. Nuclear status of reconstructed embryos was not evaluated. No differences were observed in blastocyst rate (30-ADF 21% vs 60-ADF 19% vs 90-ADF 18%). Differences in hatching rates did not reach significance (30-ADF 11% vs 60-ADF 18% vs 90-ADF 18%). However, in the 60- and 90-ADF groups, embryos reached the blastocyst stage earlier than in the 30-ADF group (day 4: 40% and 50% vs 8%; p>0.05). Moreover, the quality of blastocysts (good vs poor) was lower in the 30-ADF group (good: 30-ADF 38% vs 60-ADF 90% vs 90-ADF 90%; p>0.05). Overall, these results suggest an unfavourable effect of the shortest exposure time tested (30 min). Differences between specimen origins were detected (blastocyst and hatching rates: D2 (26%; 25%) and D4 (25%; 27%) vs D1 (10%; 11%) and D3 (12%; 12%)), but significance were not reached. Effect of culture passage was not detected in any parameter studied.

A liquid crystal polarized light microscope (LC PolScope) was used to examine spindle dynamics in living mouse oocytes. Immature oocytes were cultured for 0–48 h and spindles were imaged with the PolScope at various time points of culture. Oocytes at metaphase I (M-I) and metaphase II (M-II) were also exposed to shifts of temperature from 25 to 41 °C to examine the effects of fluctuations of temperature on spindle dynamics. After examination with the PolScope, some oocytes were fixed and examined by immunocytochemical staining and confocal microscopy. After culturing for 6 h, 76% and 2% of the oocytes reached M-I and M-II stages and all oocytes had birefringent spindles. When the oocytes were cultured for 14–16 h, 88% and 6% of oocytes were at M-II and M-I stages respectively and all oocytes had birefringent spindles. However, when the oocytes were cultured for 22–48 h, the proportions of oocytes with birefringent spindles decreased as culture time was increased. Exposure of oocytes to 25 °C induced spindle disassembly within 10–20 min in both M-I and M-II oocytes. Most (93–100%) oocytes reassembled spindles after warming at 37 °C. Furthermore, exposure of oocytes at M-I stage but not at M-II stage, to 30 °C also induced significant microtubule disassembly. However, exposure of oocytes to 38–41 °C did not obviously change the quantity of microtubules in the spindles, which was measured by retardance. This study indicates that the PolScope can be used to examine spindle dynamics in living oocytes, and it has the advantage over the routine fluorescence microscope in that images can be obtained in the same individual oocyte and the quantity of microtubules can be measured by retardance in living oocytes. These results also indicate that the M-II spindle in mouse oocytes is sensitive to oocyte ageing and cooling, but not heating, and M-I spindle is more sensitive to temperature decline than M-II spindle.

In the current widely used round spermatid injection (ROSI) protocol for the mouse, the spermatid nucleus is separated from most of the cytoplasm before ROSI by drawing a spermatid in and out of a pipette. This results in the highest rate of normal fertilization. However, this separation method is not always consistent and can be time-consuming. An alternative separation method that cuts away the cytoplasm using the tip of an injection pipette was developed. After removing the cytoplasm, ROSI was performed following both post- and pre-activation protocols and development in vitro and in vivo were examined. The new method consistently removed the bulk of the cytoplasm, as shown by quantifying mitochondria. ROSI without the cytoplasm resulted in significantly higher rates of fertilization than ROSI with the cytoplasm into either post- or pre-activated oocytes. Furthermore, the offspring production rates of ROSI without the cytoplasm were also high (50% and 49% for the post- and pre-activation protocols, respectively). This new method for separating the cytoplasm is an alternative way of producing offspring using ROSI.

This study was performed to establish an individual bovine oocyte-IVP system using a chemically defined simple medium (mSOFaa containing 1 mg/ml polyvinyl alcohol: PVA) and to investigate the effects of epidermal growth factor (EGF) during oocyte maturation on in vitro maturation, fertilization and embryonic development. Cumulus–oocyte complexes were collected from bovine ovaries and were matured in mSOFaa containing PVA (control medium) supplemented with 0, 1, 10 or 50 ng/ml of EGF. Two further groups (TCM199 and mSOFaa, supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum were also included. In this study, mSOFaa containing PVA were used as a basic medium for fertilization and embryo development in vitro. Experiments were conducted in both group- and individual-IVP systems. In the group-IVP system, the proportion of matured oocytes (MII) in the control medium (62.7%±5.0%) was significantly (p<0.05) lower than in all other treatments, and in the individual-IVP system, the addition of 1 ng/ml EGF significantly (p<0.05) increased the maturation rate (1 ng/ml EGF vs control: 76.2%±5.4% vs 57.1%±14.4%). The addition of EGF did not affect the proportions of penetrated and normally fertilized oocytes in either individual- or group-culture systems. In the group-IVP system, no significant difference among treatments was found in the rate of blastocyst formation, whereas in the individual-IVP system the control medium supplemented with 10 ng/ml EGF resulted in a significantly (p<0.05) higher the rate of blastocyst formation (20.0±5.2%) than that in the control medium (6.2%±3.5%). These results indicate that bovine oocytes can successfully develop to blastocysts in an individual-IVP system using a single chemically defined medium, and that the group-IVP system also resulted in a similar level of blastocyst formation to that in a standard multiple-media system in our laboratory. The effect of EGF during oocyte maturation medium differed depending on whether embryos were cultured individually or in groups.

The current consensus in the literature is that ovulated oocytes that are not fertilized die by apoptosis, but the details of the proteins involved in the apoptotic pathways have not been elucidated. In this paper we confirm that caspase-3, the executioner of apoptosis, is expressed in mouse oocytes, and show that two initiators of apoptosis, caspase-8 and caspase-9, are expressed in mouse oocytes. Comparisons were made of caspase-3, -8, and -9 activities in superovulated oocytes that were freshly collected or allowed to age in vivo or in vitro. We found that caspase-3 activity significantly increased in aged oocytes compared with young oocytes (p<0.001), and that both caspase-8 activity and caspase-9 activity decreased in aged oocytes compared with young oocytes (p<0.001 for caspase-8 and p<0.05 for caspase-9 activity). A comparison of superovulated with naturally ovulated oocytes showed the same amount of caspase-8 activity in each, but a significant (p<0.001) decrease in caspase-9 activity in naturally ovulated compared with superovulated oocytes. There was no difference in caspase-3, -8, or -9 activity in oocytes compared with zygotes. Finally, we showed that culture of oocytes in staurosporine increased the activity of caspase-8 and caspase-9. In conclusion, the finding of both caspase-8 and caspase-9 activity in oocytes shows that unfertilized oocytes have the machinery to undergo apoptosis by using either the extrinsic (caspase-8 dependent) or intrinsic (caspase-9 dependent) pathways.

The presence and the distribution of carbohydrate moieties in ripe lancelet (Branchiostoma lanceolatum) oocytes (mean diameter 130 μm) was studied by lectin histochemistry in combination with enzyme and chemical treatments. Binding sites for eight lectins with specificities towards different glycan moieties were studied on sections of the whole body of mature female lancelets. Only three of the lectins tested reacted positively. Concanavalin-A (ConA)-binding glycoconjugates were localized in the cytoplasm, namely in yolk granules, whereas Artocarpus integrifolia (AIA) and Ricinus communis (RCA) agglutinins bound strongly to extracellular coats of the oocyte identified as the jelly coat and vitelline layer. No other tissues of the lancelet body were found to be positive to any lectin tested, except gut enterocytes which reacted strongly with AIA. Reactivity to ConA was abolished by pretreatment of sections with N-glycosidase F but not by mild alkaline hydrolysis, confirming that the glycoconjugates were of the N-linked type. On the contrary, chemical removal of O-linked chains by mild alkaline hydrolysis abolished AIA and RCA reactivity but had no effect on ConA positivity.

In this study we isolated a murine mAsb-17 from mouse testis by RT-PCR using primers designed based on the sequences from the GenBank database. The sequence analysis showed that mAsb-17 encodes a 295 amino acid polypeptide with a molecular weight of approximately 34 kDa containing two ankyrin repeats and one SOCS box. The amino acid sequence of mASB-17 showed 87.5%, 98.3% and 92.9% identity with that of human, rat and dog, respectively. Interestingly, northern blot analysis showed that mAsb-17 was expressed only in the testis. The expression analysis by RT-PCR for mAsb-17 in mouse indicates that mAsb-17 is expressed from the fourth week after birth to adult, with the highest expression in round spermatids. Both northern blot and RT-PCR analyses suggest that mASB-17 may play essential roles in testis development and spermatogenesis.

It was found that in the Graafian oocytes of laboratory mice Mus musculus the population of electron-dense bodies contains two patterns of structures. One of these, designated as cortical granules, originated from the Golgi complex and was surrounded by a membrane. The other was discovered as cristae-containing mitochondrial derivatives lacked an outer membrane. It was found that the mitochondrial derivatives underwent progressive condensation and transformed into electron-dense bodies similar to germinal bodies of metazoan animals. Based on examination of Graafian follicle oocytes from 5 female individuals, about 15% of electron-dense bodies were cortical granules. However, about 85% of electron-dense bodies were condensing mitochondrial derivatives transforming into electron-dense bodies.

The present study was designed to examine the effects of overheating on meiotic spindle morphology within in vitro matured human oocytes using a polarized light microscope (Polscope). Immature human oocytes at either germinal vesicle or metaphase I stage were cultured in vitro for 24–36 h until they reached metaphase II (M-II) stage. After maturation, oocytes at M-II stage were imaged in the living state with the Polscope at 37, 38, 39 and 40 °C for up to 20 min. After heating, oocytes were returned to 37 °C and then imaged for another 20 min at 37 °C. The microtubules in the spindles were quantified by their maximum retardance, which represents the amount of microtubules. Spindles were intact at 37 °C during 40 min of examination and their maximum retardance (1.72–1.79) did not change significantly during imaging. More microtubules were formed in the spindles heated to 38 °C and the maximum retardance was increased from 1.77 before heating to 1.95 at 20 min after heating. By contrast, spindles started to disassemble when the temperature was increased to 39 °C for 10 min (maximum retardance was reduced from 1.76 to 1.65) or 40 °C for 1 min (maximum retardance was reduced from 1.75 to 1.5). At the end of heating (20 min), fewer microtubules were present in the spindles and the maximum retardance was reduced to 0.8 and 0.78 in the oocytes heated to 39 °C and 40 °C, respectively. Heating to 40 °C also induced spindles to relocate in the cytoplasm in some oocytes. After the temperature was returned to 37 °C, microtubules were repolymerized to form spindles, but the spindles were not reconstituted completely compared with the spindles imaged before heating. These results indicate that spindles in human eggs are sensitive to high temperature. Moreover, maintenance of an in vitro manipulation temperature of 37 °C is crucial for normal spindle morphology.

Germinal-vesicle-stage oocytes enclosed with compact cumulus cell layers (COCs) were recovered from adult or prepubertal minke whale ovaries, and were vitrified in a solution containing 15% ethylene glycol, 15% DMSO and 0.5 M sucrose using either a Cryotop or an open-pulled straw (OPS) as the cryodevice. The post-warm COCs with normal morphology were cultured for 40 h in a 390 mosmol in vitro maturation medium, and oocytes extruding the first polar body were considered to be matured. The proportion of morphologically normal COCs after vitrification and warming was higher when the COCs were cryopreserved by Cryotop (adult origin, 88.4%; prepubertal origin, 80.8%) compared with the OPS (adult origin, 67.7%; prepubertal origin, 64.2%). The oocyte maturation rate was higher in the adult/Cryotop group (29.1%) compared with those of the prepubertal/Cryotop group (14.4%), the adult/OPS group (14.3%) and the prepubertal/OPS group (10.6%). These results indicate that the Cryotop is a better device than the OPS for vitrification of immature oocytes from adult minke whales.

The present study aimed to demonstrate the dependence of meiotic maturation in pig oocytes on the activity of the protease complex proteasome. The proteasome inhibitor MG132 blocked the exit of maturing pig oocytes from metaphase I stage. Seventy-five per cent of the oocytes were blocked at metaphase I when they were cultured with 10 μM MG132. The blocking effect of MG132 was expressed only when the oocytes were exposed to an inhibitor before the 18th hour of in vitro culture. The effects of MG132 are fully reversible. However, a significant proportion of oocytes (46%) cultured for 48 h in MG132-supplemented medium and then for 24 h in MG132-free medium did not block meiosis at the stage of metaphase II and underwent spontaneous parthenogenetic activation. On the basis of our data we can conclude that exit from the metaphase I stage of meiosis is proteasome-dependent in pig oocytes matured in vitro. On the other hand, our data also indicate that other proteasome-independent events are involved in regulating the exit from metaphase I.

Phagocytic resorption during spermatogenesis was studied in the sea urchin Anthocidaris crassispina. Nutritive phagocytes in gonad absorbed both waste sperm cells and residual bodies discarded from maturing spermatids, and these materials were subsequently compartmented in heterophagosomes. Based on 180 heterophagosomes examined by transmission electron microscopy, over 99% of heterophagosomes contained either residual bodies or sperm cells only. Simultaneous resorption of sperm cells and residual bodies in a heterophagosome was uncommon, with only ∼0.56% occurrence, suggesting that heterophagosomes have a selective resorption ability in nutritive phagocytes.

This study was aimed at developing a hormonal treatment protocol in order to optimize the proportion of pronuclear-stage embryos to be used for DNA microinjection in a goat transgenic founder production programme. A total of 46 adult BELE® and 47 adult standard goats (1–5 years old) were used as donors and recipients, respectively. They were heat-synchronized using intravaginal sponges containing 60 mg medroxyprogesterone acetate for 10 days with an injection of 125 μg cloprostenol on the morning of the eighth day. Recipients were injected with 400 IU eCG at the time of sponge removal while donors received a total of 133 mg NIH-FSH-P1 (Folltropin-V) given twice daily in decreasing doses over 3 days starting 48 h before sponge removal. Ovulation was induced in donors by injecting 100 μg of GnRH at 24 h (GnRH24) or 36 h (GnRH36) after sponge removal. Embryo recovery was performed by oviduct flushing following a standard mid-ventral laparotomy procedure. The proportion of embryos in the pronuclear stage of development was higher in the GnRH36 group (90% vs 34%, p<0.01). Embryos were microinjected with a DNA expression cassette followed by transfer to the oviduct of synchronized recipients. A higher, yet not statistically significant, pregnancy rate was found in the recipients transferred with pronuclear-stage embryos compared with those transferred with 2-cell-stage embryos (64% vs 37%, chi-square p=0.06). One transgenic female founder was produced from the group of recipients transferred with pronuclear-stage microinjected embryos.

This study was carried out to investigate the effects of sperm concentrations and culture media on fertilization and development of in vitro matured pig oocytes. The concentrations of frozen-thawed sperm were 0.2×107, 2×107, 20×107 and 200×107/ml, respectively. Culture media were NCSU-23, HEPES-buffered (25 mM) NCSU-23, PZM-3 and PZM-4, respectively. Increasing the sperm concentration from 0.2×107 to 2×107/ml, significantly increased the penetration rate. Also, increasing the sperm concentration from 20×107 to 200×107/ml increased the penetration rate from 62.1% to 69.9%, respectively, with no differences between these two concentrations. A similar pattern was observed for polyspermic penetration and male pronucleus formation. The mean number of sperm per oocyte significantly increased in the 20×107/ml and again in the 200×107/ml sperm concentrations. The percentage of blastocysts from cleaved oocytes at the 2×107/ml sperm concentration was significantly higher than that at the 0.2×107, 20×107 and 200×107/ml sperm concentrations. The percentage of blastocysts from cleaved oocytes and the cell numbers per blastocyst were significantly higher in the HEPES-buffered NCSU-23 culture medium than in the NCSU-23, PZM-3 and PZM-4 culture media under a gas atmosphere of 5% CO2 in air.

We have investigated the possibility that mitotic nuclei originating from preimplantation stage embryos and placed in the oocyte cytoplasm can undergo remodelling that allows them to undergo meiosis in the mouse. To address this question, we have used enucleated germinal vesicle (GV) ooplasts as recipients and blastomeres from the 2-, 4- or 8-cell stage as nuclear donors. We employed two methods to obtain ooplasts from GV oocytes: cutting and enucleation. Although efficiency of the reconstruction process was higher after enucleation than after cutting (90% and 70% respectively), the developmental potential of the oocytes was independent of how they had been produced. Nuclei from the 2-, 4-, or 8-cell stage embryos supported maturation in about 35%, 55% and 60% of cases, respectively. The time between nuclear envelope breakdown and the first meiotic division was shortened by up to 5 h in reconstructed oocytes, a period equivalent to the mitotic division of control blastomeres. About one-third of oocytes reconstituted with blastomere nuclei divided symmetrically instead of extruding a polar body; however, in the majority of them metaphase plates were found, suggesting that reconstructed oocytes (cybrids) underwent a meiotic rather than mitotic division. The highest percentage of asymmetric divisions accompanied by metaphase plates was found in cybrids with 8-cell-stage blastomere nuclei, suggesting that the nuclei from this stage appear to conform best to the cytoplasmic environment of GV ooplasts. Our results indicate that the oocyte cytoplasm is capable of remodelling blastomere nuclei, allowing them to follow the path of the meiotic cell cycle.

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) can be inactivated by heating at 56 °C for 30 min, treating with 50% ethanol at room temperature for 10 min, or treating with 2% sodium hypochlorite solution (NaClO) at room temperature for 60 min. Using a mouse model, we evaluated the risk of generating chromosome damage in spermatozoa following these treatments. The spermatozoa were all dead after the treatments. Although 41.3% of oocytes injected with ethanol-treated spermatozoa successfully activated, none of the oocytes injected with heated or NaClO-treated spermatozoa activated. When artificial stimulation with strontium was used, the fertilization of oocytes with heated or ethanol-treated spermatozoa was completely rescued. Sperm nuclei treated with NaClO neither decondensed nor developed to a male pronucleus. The incidences of structural chromosome aberrations in 1-cell zygotes derived from the heated spermatozoa (45.6%) and ethanol-treated spermatozoa (91.2%) were significantly higher than those in the matched controls (5.5% and 10.5%, respectively). Further study is needed to develop a methodology for the protection of spermatozoa against chromosome damage or the separation of damaged spermatozoa before intracytoplasmic sperm injection.

This study assessed the effects of oocyte age, cumulus cells and injection methods on in vitro development of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) rabbit embryos. Oocytes were recovered from female rabbits superovulated with PMSG and hCG, and epididymal sperm were collected from a fertile male rabbit. The oocyte was positioned with the first polar body at 12 o'clock position, and a microinjection needle containing a sperm was inserted into the oocyte at 3 o'clock. Oolemma breakage was achieved by aspirating ooplasm, and the aspirated ooplasm and sperm were re-injected into the oocyte. The injected oocytes were cultured in M199 medium containing 10% fetal calf serum at 38 °C with 5% CO2 in air. The results showed that oocytes injected at 1 h post-collection produced a higher (p<0.05) fertilization rate than those injected at 4 or 7 h post-collection. Blastocyst rate in the 1 h group was higher (p<0.05) than in the 7 h group. Denuded oocytes (group A) and oocytes with cumulus cells (group B) were injected, respectively. Rates of fertilization and development of ICSI embryos were not significantly different (p<0.05) between the two groups. Four ICSI methods were applied in this experiment. In methods 1 and 2, the needle tip was pushed across half the diameter of the oocyte, and oolemma breakage was achieved by either a single aspiration (method 1) or repeated aspiration and expulsion (method 2) of ooplasm. In methods 3 and 4, the needle tip was pushed to the oocyte periphery opposite the puncture site, and oolemma breakage was achieved by either a single aspiration (method 3) or repeated aspiration and expulsion (method 4) of ooplasm. Fertilization rate in method 2 was significantly higher (p<0.05) than in methods 1 and 3. Blastocyst rates were not significantly different (p<0.05) among methods 1, 3 and 4, but method 2 produced a higher (p<0.05) blastocyst rate than method 3.