Bernard Dukore's “Clarification” of my review of the Analytical Sourcebook by Brownstein and Daubert raises some questions of sufficient importance to justify, I believe, some further discussion. The Diderot matter is a fairly minor one, though I must maintain that heading a section “Denis Diderot” which is made up of six short pieces, five actually by other writers, is potentially misleading, footnotes or not, the evidence being that Brownstein and Daubert were in fact so misled.