Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-k7p5g Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T01:29:33.394Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

When Performance Fails to Meet Expectations: Managers’ Objectives for Outsourcing

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2023

Suzanne Young  and
Johanna Macneil
Johanna Macneil
Affiliation:
Bowater School of Management and Marketing, Deakin University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Managers may implement outsourcing for one or more of a range of reasons: to improve strategic focus, to achieve numerical or functional flexibility, to reduce costs or risk, to change their own roles, to change organisational culture or workplace power structure, and to intensify work effort. However, often there are associated costs, either unanticipated or unquantified. This paper provides evidence from two food processing companies to address the following questions: (1) Why do managers pursue outsourcing? and (2) Have managers anticipated and quantified the potential costs as well as the benefits of outsourcing? We conclude that while it seems clear that managers do begin with clear objectives for outsourcing and anticipate that benefits will flow, sometimes these objectives are not met, unexpected costs are incurred, or objectives change as new information is available or situations change. In other cases managers have been unable to objectively substantiate the outsourcing decision.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Economic and Labour Relations Review , Volume 11 , Issue 1 , June 2000 , pp. 136 - 168
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abraham, K., Taylor, S. (1996), ‘Firms’ Use of Outside Contractors: Theory and Evidence’, Journal of Labor Economics, 14(3), pp. 394–424 Google Scholar
Anderson, G, Brosnan, P, Walsh, P. (1994), Flexibility, ‘Casualization and externalization in the New Zealand workforce’, The Journal of Industrial Relations, Dec, pp. 491–518 Google Scholar
Atkinson, J (1984), ‘Manpower Strategies for Flexible Organisations’, Personnel Management, August, pp. 28–31 Google Scholar
Ang, S (1994), ‘Towards conceptual clarity of outsourcing’, Glassan, Hawryszkiewycl, Underwood, , Weber, (eds), Proceedings of IFIPTCS Open Conference on Business Process Re-engineering, Gold Coast, May 8–11, pp. 131–141 Google Scholar
Arnett, K., Jones, M. (1994), ‘Firms that choose outsourcing: A profile’, Information & Management, 26, pp. 179–188 Google Scholar
Ascher, K (1987), The Politics of Privatisation: Contracting Out Public Sen/ices, Macmillan Education, London CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aubert, B., Rivard, S., Patry, M. (1996), ‘A transaction cost approach to outsourcing behavior: Some empirical evidence’, Information & Management, 30, pp. 51–64 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Benson, J., Leronimo, N. (1996), ‘Outsourcing decisions: Evidence from Australia-based enterprises’, International Labour Review, 135(1), pp. 59–73 Google Scholar
Blaxill, Mark F, Hout, M. (1991), ‘The fallacy of the overhead quick fix’, Harvard Business Review, 69(4), July-Aug, pp. 93–101 Google ScholarPubMed
Borland, J., Garvey, G. (1994), “Recent developments in the theory of the firm”, Australian Economic Review, First Quarter, pp. 60–82 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bramble, T (1988), ‘The flexibility debate: Industrial relations and new management production processes’, Labour and Industry, 1(2), June, pp. 187–209 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brunhes, B (1989), ‘Labour flexibility in enterprises: A comparison of firms in four European countries’ in OECD (ed) Labour Market Flexibility; Trends in Enterprises, OECD, Paris, pp. 11–36 Google Scholar
Burgess, J (1990), ‘The Australian labour market in the 1990s’, Australian Quarterly, 62(3), pp. 267–276 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgess, J., MacDonald, D. (1990), ‘The Labour Flexibility Imperative’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, November (27), pp. 15–35 Google Scholar
Campbell, I (1993), ‘Labour market flexibility in Australia; Enhancing management prerogative?’ Labour and Industry, 5(3), October, pp. 1–32 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cannon, D (1989), ‘Keeping Outsourcing in Hand’, Chief Executive Magazine, November-December, pp. 38–41 Google Scholar
Coase, R.H. (1986), ‘The Nature of the Firm’, in Barney, J., Ouchi, W. (eds), Organizational Economics, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco Google Scholar
Cooper, R (1987), ‘Does your company need a new cost system?’, Journal of Cost Management, 1, Spring, pp. 45–49 Google Scholar
Cubbin, J., Domberger, S., Meadowcroft, S. (1987), ‘Competitive Tendering and Refuse Collection: Identifying the Sources of Efficiency Gains’, Fiscal Studies, August, 8(3), pp. 49–58 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cullen, S (1994), Ernst and Young’s IT Outsourcing Survey; Exploding the Myths: Recommendations for Decision Makers, Ernst & Young, Melbourne Google Scholar
Domberger, S (1994), ‘Public Sector Contracting: Does It Work?’, The Australian Economic Review, Third Quarter, pp. 91–96 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Domberger, S., Farago, S., Hall, C., Li, E. (1993), ‘Competitive tendering and contracting in the NSW budget sector: Survey findings’, December, Working Paper, Treasury Google Scholar
Domberger, S., Hall, C. (1995), The Contracting Casebook: Competitive tendering in Action, University of Sydney, Australian Government Publishing Service Google Scholar
Domberger, S., Meadowcroft, S.A., Thompson, D.J. (1986), ‘Competitive Tendering and Efficiency: The Case of Refuse Collection’, Fiscal Studies, 7(4), November, pp. 69–87 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Domberger, S., Meadowcroft, S.A., Thompson, D.J. (1987), ‘The Impact of Competitive Tendering on the Costs of Hospital Domestic Services’, Fiscal Studies, 8(4), pp. 39–54 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Domberger, S., Meadowcroft, S.A., Thompson, D.J. (1988), ‘Competition and Efficiency in Refuse Collections Reply’, Fiscal Studies, 9(1), pp. 80–90 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Domberger, S, Rimmer, S. (1994), ‘Competitive Tendering and Contracting Out in the Public Sector: A Survey’, International Journal of Economics and Business, 1(3), pp. 439–453 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Donald, P (1995), ‘Leading Public Sector Management at the City of Melbourne’, HR Conference Proceedings: How to Run a Business within Government, SydneyGoogle Scholar
Dunleavy, R (1986) ‘Explaining the Privatisation Boom: Public Choice Versus Radical Approaches’, Public Administration, 64, pp. 13–34 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evatt Research Centre (1990), Breach of Contract: Privatisation and Management of Australian Local Government, Pluto Press/Evatt Research Centre, Leichhardt, New South Wales Google Scholar
Fraser, L (1997), Impact of Contracting Out on Female NESB Workers: Case Study of the NSW Government Cleaning Service, Canberra, Research and Statistics Branch, Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs Google Scholar
Gantz, J (1990), ‘Outsourcing: Threat or Salvation?’ Network Management, October, pp. 24–40 Google Scholar
Ghoshal, S., Moran, P. (1996), ‘Bad for practice: A critique of transaction cost theory’, Academy of Management Review, 21, pp. 13–47 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Graham, M., Scarborough, H. (1996), ‘Public sector outsourcing of information technology services’ Australian Journal of Public Administration, 56(3), pp. 30–39 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Handy, C.B. (1990), ‘The Age of Unreason’, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA, pp. 87–115 Google Scholar
Harley, B (1994), ‘Post-Fordist Theory, Labour Process and Flexibility and Autonomy in the Australian Workplaces’, Labour & Industry, October, 6(1), pp. 107–129 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harrison, B., Kelley, M.R. (1993), ‘Outsourcing and the search for flexibility’, Work, Employment & Society, 7(2), pp. 213–235 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodge, G (1996), Contracting out Government Services A Review of International Evidence, Monash University, Melbourne Google Scholar
Industry Commission (1995), Competitive Tendering and Contracting by Public Sector Agencies, Draft Report, 24 October, Australia Google Scholar
James, D (1992), ‘Outsourcing: The new gospel’, Business Review Weekly, November 13, pp. 46–52 Google Scholar
Kochan, T., Smith, M., Wells, S., Rebitzer, J. (1994), ‘Human Resource Strategies and Contingent Workers: The Case of Safety and Health in the Petrochemical Industry’, Human Resource Management, 33(1), pp. 55–77 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kotter, J., Heskett, J. (1992), Corporate Culture and Performance, The Free Press, New York Google Scholar
Lacity, M., Hirscheim, R. (1993), Information Systems Outsourcing: Myths, Metaphors and Realities, Wiley Google Scholar
Littler, C., Dunford, R., Bramble, T., Hede, A. (1997), The Dynamics of Downsizing in Australia and New Zealand’, Asia Pacific Journal of Human Re-sources, 35, pp. 65–79 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morehead, A., Steele, M., Alexander, M., Stephen, K., Duffin, L. (1997), Changes at Work: 1995 Australian Workplace Industrial Relations Survey, Addison Wesley Longman, South Melbourne Google Scholar
Morgan, D.R. (1992), ‘The Pitfalls of Privatisation: Contracting Without Competition’, American Review of Public Administration, December, 22, pp. 251–269 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morkel, A (1993), ‘Industry clusters and value-system strategies for Australia’, in Lewis, G., Morkel, A., Hubbard, G. (eds), Australian Strategic Management concepts, contexts and cases, Prentice-Hall, pp. 388–399 Google Scholar
Pearce, J (1993), Toward an Organizational Behavior of Contract Laborers: Their Psychological Involvement and Effects on Employee Co-Worker’, Academy of Management Journal, 36(5), pp. 1082–1096 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pfeffer, J (1981), Power in Organisations, Pitman, Marshfield, Massachusetts Google Scholar
Pfeffer, J (1992), ‘Understanding power in organizations’, California Management Review, 34(2), pp. 29–50 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pfeffer, J (1994), ‘Competitive advantage through people’, California Management Review, 36(2), pp. 9–28 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pfeffer, J (1998), ‘Seven Practices of Successful Organisations’, California Management Review, 40(2), pp. 96–124 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pfeffer, J., Baron, J. (1988), Taking the Workers Backout: Recent trends in the Structure of Employment’, Research in Organizational Behavior, 10, pp. 257–303 Google Scholar
Porter, M.E. (1980), Competitive Strategy: Techniques for analyzing Industries and Competitors, The Free Press, New York Google Scholar
Pralahad, C., Hamel, G. (1990), ‘The Core Competence of the Corporation’, Harvard Business Review, 63, pp. 79–91 Google Scholar
Rebitzer, J.B. (1991), ‘Short-Term Employment Relations and Labor Market Outcomes: Contract Workers in the U.S Petrochemical Industry’, Unpublised Manuscript, Cambridge, MIT, Sloan School of ManagementGoogle Scholar
Reilly, P., Tamkin, P. (1996), ‘Outsourcing: A flexible option for the future?’, IES Report 320, The Institute for Employment Studies, Brighton, UKGoogle Scholar
Reponen, T (1993), ‘Outsourcing or Insourcing?’, in DeGross, J.I., Bostrom, R.P., Robey, D. (eds), Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Information Systems, December, Orlando, pp. 103–116 Google Scholar
Rimmer, S (1993), Aspects of Competitive Tendering and Contracting in Local Government Administration, PhD thesis, University of New EnglandGoogle Scholar
Rimmer, S (1994), ‘Competitive Tendering and Contracting: Theory and Research’, Australian Economic Review, Third Quarter, (107), pp. 79–85 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sharp, P (1995) ‘Competition as opposed to Outsourcing: The Commercial Support Program in the Defence Science and Technology Organisation’ in How to Run a Business within Government, Sydney, HR Conferences Pty Ltd Google Scholar
Smith, J (1991), ‘Corporate little helpers’, Australian Business, August 7, pp. 44–46 Google Scholar
Teresko, J (1992), ‘Outsourcing: Tie it to the right objectives’, Industry Week, June 1, pp. 42–44 Google Scholar
Quinn, J (1992), The Intelligent Enterprise: A new paradigm’, Academy of Management Executive, 6(4), pp. 48–63 Google Scholar
Walter, L (1992), ‘Outsourcing: Radical Surgery or Banking Cure-All’, Bankers Monthly, October, 109(10), pp. 44–45 Google Scholar
Walker, G (1988), ‘Strategic sourcing, vertical integration and transaction costs’, Interfaces, 18, pp. 62–73 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Willcocks, L (1994), ‘Managing Information Systems in UK Public Administration: Issues and Prospects’, Public Administration, 72(1), pp. 13–32 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williamson, O (1979), ‘Transaction-Cost Economics: The Governance of Contractual Relations’, Journal of Law and Economics, 22, pp. 233–261 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zampetakis, H (1997), ‘Why Bendigo went back in-house’, Financial Review, 6 February, p. 26 Google Scholar
Zeffane, R (1992), ‘Organizational structures: Design in the nineties’, Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 13(6), pp. 18–23 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zeffane, R. (1995), ‘The downsizing paradox: Problems in the quest for leaner organisations’, Journal of Industrial Affairs, 4(1), pp. 45–47 Google Scholar