Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-7drxs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T00:09:50.407Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Did Athanasius Deny Christ's Fear?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 February 2009

Alvyn Pettersen
Affiliation:
Exeter College, Oxford 0X1 3DP

Extract

In Contra Arianos 3 Athanasius considers two frightened cries of a man about to be crucified:

My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me;

nevertheless, not as I will, but as thou wilt.

My God, my God, why has thou forsaken me?

These he analyses in accordance with the general pattern of his explanation of the passions suffered by the Logos incarnate.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Scottish Journal of Theology Ltd 1986

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

page 327 note 1 Matt. 26.39.

page 327 note 2 Mark 15.34.

page 327 note 3 Cf. Pollard, T. E., Johannine Christology and the Early Church. Cambridge, 1970, p. 184f.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

page 327 note 4 Contra Arianos. 3.55.2–21 (References in both the text of the paper and in these footnotes refer to the Bibliotheke Hellenon Pateron kai Ekklesiastikon Syngrapheon. Athens, 1964.Google Scholar)

page 327 note 5 Richard, M.. ‘S.Athanase et la psychologie du Christ selon les Ariens’. MSR 4 (1947), p. 554.Google Scholar

page 327 note 6 Young, F. M., ‘A Reconsideration of Alexandrian Christology’. JEH 22 (1971), p. 103ff.Google Scholar

page 327 note 7 Contra Arianos 3.57.4–5.

page 328 note 8 Ibid., 57.15.

page 328 note 9 Ibid., 57.25–28.

page 328 note 10 Sellers, R. V., Two Ancient Christologies. London, 1940, p. 43.Google Scholar

page 328 note 11 Contra Arianos 3. 56.27–28; Ibid., 57.12.

page 328 note 12 Stead, G. C., Divine Substance. Oxford, 1977, p. 2122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

page 328 note 13 Contra Arianos 3.55.31ff.; Ibid., 57.30ff.

page 328 note 14 Turner, H. E. W., Jesus the Christ. London, 1975, p. 35.Google Scholar

page 328 note 15 Roldanus, J.. Le Christ et I'homme dans la théologie d'Athanase d'Alexandrie. Leiden, 1968, p. 270.Google Scholar

page 329 note 16 Contra Arianos 3.54.33–39.

page 329 note 17 Ibid., 55.32ff.; cf. Ibid., 32.10–11; Ibid., 31.31–33; Ibid., 56.14, 21–23; cf. F. M. Young. op. cit., 107: For Athanasius Christ's ‘tears, his fear of death … were … a means of displaying the reality of the Incarnation, a proof of the fact that he has assumed the weaknesses of human flesh for our salvation’.

page 329 note 18 Ibid., 3.55.27ff.; 55.4ff.

page 330 note 19 Young, op. cit., 107; cf. Richard, op. cit., 32f.

page 330 note 20 Contra Arianos 3.56.2–6.

page 331 note 21 Ibid., 57.15–16.

page 331 note 22 Ibid., 57.25–28.

page 331 note 23 Richard, op. cit., 35.

page 331 note 24 Similar clauses in Contra Arianos 3.57.8 and 11 pave the way for the phrase in 57.15–16.

page 331 note 25 Ibid., 57.25–27.

page 332 note 26 Ibid., 57.25ff.

page 332 note 27 Ibid., 57.14.

page 332 note 28 Cf. the use of νομιζουσι in Ibid., 55.28–29.

page 333 note 29 Richard, op. cil., 35.

page 333 note 30 Contra Arianos 3.56.27–29; Ibid., 57.10–13.

page 333 note 31 Cf. R. V. Sellers, op. cit., 43.

page 334 note 32 Cf. Athanasius' treatment of man's redemption from ignorance through the gradual unveiling of the godhead in its incarnate state; vid. R. V. Sellers, op. cit., 31 and Prestige, G. L., Fathers and Heretics. London, 1968, p. 158.Google Scholar

page 334 note 33 Contra Arianos 3.55.32; 57.3Off.

page 335 note 34 Ibid., 34.22–23.

page 335 note 35 Ibid., 34.22.

page 335 note 36 Richard, op. cit., 34.

page 336 note 37 Contra Arianos 3.34.37.

page 337 note 38 Ibid., 34.25–26.

page 337 note 39 Ibid., 33.19–21.

page 337 note 40 Cf. Richard, op. cit., 34: ‘il semble bien admettre la possibilité d'un mouvement psychologique de peur dans la chair du Sauveur. II ne va pas plus loin’.

page 338 note 41 Ibid., 34.

page 338 note 42 Roldanus, op. cit., 270.

page 339 note 43 Vid. Contra Arianos 3.54–55 passim; cf. Gregg, R. and Groh, D., Early Arianism: a View of Salvation. London, 1981, p. 16.Google Scholar