Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-hfldf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-03T03:52:20.666Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

In Defence of the Concept of Mental Illness

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 September 2023

Zsuzsanna Chappell
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Many worry about the over-medicalisation of mental illness, and some even argue that we should abandon the term mental illness altogether. Yet, this is a commonly used term in popular discourse, in policy making, and in research. In this paper I argue that if we distinguish between disease, illness, and sickness (where illness refers to the first-personal, subjective experience of the sufferer), then the concept of mental illness is a useful way of understanding a type of human experience, inasmuch as the term is (i) apt or accurate, (ii) a useful hermeneutical resource for interpreting and communicating experience, and (iii) can be a good way for at least some of us to establish a liveable personal identity within our culture.

Type
Paper
Information
Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements , Volume 94: Lived Experience and Co-Production in Philosophy and Mental Health , October 2023 , pp. 77 - 102
Copyright
Copyright © The Royal Institute of Philosophy and the contributors 2023

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ahmed, Sara, The Cultural Politics of Emotion, 2nd edition, (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2014).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th ed., Text Rev. (2022).Google Scholar
Amoretti, Maria Cristina and Lalumera, Elisabetta, ‘The Concept of Disease in the Time of COVID-19’, Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 41 (2020): 203–21.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Antonetta, Susanne, A Mind Apart: Travels in a Neurodiverse World (New York: Jeremy P. Tarcher, 2014).Google Scholar
Appiah, Kwame Anthony, ‘The Politics of Identity’, Daedalus 135:4 (2006), 15–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arias, Daniel, Shekhar, Saxena, and Verguet, Stéphane, ‘Quantifying the Global Burden of Mental Disorders and Their Economic Value’, EclinicalMedicine, 54 (2022).10.1016/j.eclinm.2022.101675CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Benning, Tony B., ‘No Such Thing as Mental Illness? Critical Reflections on the Major Ideas and Legacy of Thomas Szasz’, BJPsych Bulletin, 40:6 (2016), 292–5.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Beresford, Peter, ‘“Mad”, Mad Studies and Advancing Inclusive Resistance’, Disability & Society, 35:8 (2020), 1337–42.10.1080/09687599.2019.1692168CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bergqvist, Anna, ‘Schizophrenia as a Transformative Evaluative Concept: Perspectives on the Psychiatric Significance of the Personal Self in the Ethics of Recognition’, Philosophy, Psychiatry & Psychology, 28:1 (2021), 23–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bolton, Derek, What Is Mental Disorder? An Essay in Philosophy, Science, and Values (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bolton, Derek and Gillett, Grant, The Biopsychosocial Model of Health and Disease: New Philosophical and Scientific Developments (Palgrave Macmillan, 2019).CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bonsall, M.B., Wallace-Hadrill, S.M.A., Geddes, J.R., Goodwin, G.M., and Holmes, E.A., ‘Nonlinear Time-Series Approaches in Characterizing Mood Stability and Mood Instability in Bipolar Disorder’, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 279:1730 (2012), 916–24.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bortolotti, Lisa, ‘Doctors without “Disorders”’, Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume, 94:1 (2020), 163–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boyd, Kenneth M., ‘Disease, Illness, Sickness, Health, Healing and Wholeness: Exploring Some Elusive Concepts’, Medical Humanities, 26:1 (2000), 9–17.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Brinkmann, Svend, Diagnostic Cultures: A Cultural Approach to the Pathologization of Modern Life (London: Routledge, 2016).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brossard, Baptiste and Chandler, Amy, Explaining Mental Illness: Sociological Perspectives (Bristol: Bristol University Press, 2022).Google Scholar
Carel, Havi, Phenomenology of Illness (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chamberlin, Judi, ‘Rehabilitating Ourselves: The Psychiatric Survivor Movement’, International Journal of Mental Health, 24:1 (1995), 39–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chapman, Robert, ‘A Critique of Critical Psychiatry’, Philosophy, Psychiatry & Psychology, 30:2 (2023), 103–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chapman, Robert, ‘Defining Neurodiversity for Research and Practice’, in Rosqvist, Hanna, Chown, Nick, and Stenning, Anna (eds.), Neurodiversity Studies: A New Critical Paradigm (Abingdon: Routledge, 2020), 218–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chappell, Zsuzsanna and Jeppsson, Sofia, ‘Recovery without Normalisation: It's Not Necessary to be Normal, Not Even in Psychiatry’, Clinical Ethics, online first (2023).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crenshaw, Kimberlé, ‘Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics’, University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1989:1 (1989), 139–67.Google Scholar
Davis, Joseph E., Chemically Imbalanced: The Quest for Self-Mastery in the Age of the Brain (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dings, Roy and Glas, Gerrit, ‘Self-Management in Psychiatry as Reducing Self-Illness Ambiguity’, Philosophy, Psychiatry & Psychology, 27:4 (2020), 333–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Double, Duncan B., ‘Twenty Years of the Critical Psychiatry Network’, The British Journal of Psychiatry, 214:2 (2019), 61–2.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dowrick, Christopher and Frances, Allen, ‘Medicalising Unhappiness: New Classification of Depression Risks More Patients Being Put on Drug Treatment from Which They Will Not Benefit’, BMJ, 347:f7140 (2013).CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dumes, Abigail A., ‘Lyme Disease and the Epistemic Tensions of “Medically Unexplained Illnesses”’, Medical Anthropology, 39:6 (2020), 441–56.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Finley, Kate, ‘Narratives & Spiritual Meaning-Making in Mental Disorder’, International Journal for Philosophy of Religion, online first (2023).10.1007/s11153-023-09879-wCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foucault, Michel, The Birth of the Clinic: An Archaeology of Medical Perception, Sheridan, A.M. (trans.), (London: Routledge, 2010).Google Scholar
Foulkes, Lucy and Andrews, Jack L., ‘Are Mental Health Awareness Efforts Contributing to the Rise in Reported Mental Health Problems? A Call to Test the Prevalence Inflation Hypothesis’, New Ideas in Psychology, 69 (2023), 101010.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Garson, Justin, ‘What Is the Philosophy of Madness?’, The Philosopher's Magazine (2023), accessed 11 July 2023: https://www.philosophersmag.com/essays/315-what-is-the-philosophy-of-madness.Google Scholar
Gergel, Tania, ‘“Shock Tactics”, Ethics, and Fear: An Academic and Personal Perspective on the Case against ECT’, British Journal of Psychiatry, 220:3 (2021), 109–12.10.1192/bjp.2021.116CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gipps, Richard G.T., On Madness: Understanding the Psychotic Mind (New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 2022).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goffman, Erving, Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity (London: Penguin, 1990).Google Scholar
Hornbacher, Marya, Madness: A Bipolar Life (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2008).Google Scholar
Horwitz, Allan V. and Wakefield, Jerome C., All We Have to Fear: Psychiatry's Transformation of Natural Anxieties into Mental Disorders (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012).Google Scholar
Jamison, Kay Redfield, An Unquiet Mind: A Memoir of Moods and Madness (New York: Vintage Books, 1996).Google Scholar
Jebari, Karim, ‘Disease Prioritarianism: A Flawed Principle’, Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 19:1 (2016), 95–101.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jeppsson, Sofia, ‘Psychosis and Intelligibility’, Philosophy, Psychiatry & Psychology, 28:3 (2021), 233–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jeppsson, Sofia, ‘Solving the Self-Illness Ambiguity: The Case for Construction Over Discovery’, Philosophical Explorations, 25:3 (2022), 294–313.10.1080/13869795.2022.2051589CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jutel, Annemarie, Putting a Name to It: Diagnosis in Contemporary Society (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2011).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Karp, David Allen, Is It Me or My Meds? Living with Antidepressants (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2006).10.4159/9780674039339CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kleinman, Arthur, The Illness Narratives: Suffering, Healing, and the Human Condition, 2nd edition, (New York: Basic Books, 1988).Google Scholar
Kraepelin, Emil, Manic-Depressive Insanity and Paranoia (Edinburgh: Livingstone, 1921).10.1097/00005053-192104000-00057CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kvaale, Erlend P., Gottdiener, William H., and Haslam, Nick, ‘Biogenetic Explanations and Stigma: A Meta-Analytic Review of Associations among Laypeople’, Social Science & Medicine, 96 (2013), 95–103.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Leder, Drew, The Absent Body (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1990).Google Scholar
Linden, Michael and Schermuly-Haupt, Marie-Luise, ‘Definition, Assessment and Rate of Psychotherapy Side Effects’, World Psychiatry, 13:3 (2014): 306–9.10.1002/wps.20153CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lysaker, Paul H. and Lysaker, John T., ‘Schizophrenia and Alterations in Self-Experience: A Comparison of 6 Perspectives’, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 36:2 (2010), 331–40.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Marinker, Marshall, ‘Why Make People Patients?’, Journal of Medical Ethics, 1:2 (1975), 81–4.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Emily, Martin, Bipolar Expeditions (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2009).Google Scholar
McCurry, Justin, ‘Anger in Japan as Report Reveals Children Were Forcibly Sterilised’, The Guardian, 22 June 2023, accessed 11 July 2023: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/22/anger-in-japan-as-report-reveals-children-were-forcibly-sterilised.Google Scholar
Michalak, Erin, Livingston, James, Hole, Rachelle, Suto, Melinda, Hale, Sandra, and Haddock, Candace, ‘“It's Something that I Manage but It Is Not Who I Am”: Reflections on Internalized Stigma in Individuals with Bipolar Disorder’, Chronic Illness, 7 (2011), 209–24.10.1177/1742395310395959CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Middleton, Hugh and Moncrieff, Joanna, ‘Critical Psychiatry: A Brief Overview’, BJPsych Advances, 25:1 (2019), 47–54.10.1192/bja.2018.38CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Newton-Howes, Giles and Mullen, Richard, ‘Coercion in Psychiatric Care: Systematic Review of Correlates and Themes’, Psychiatric Services, 62:5 (2011), 465–70.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Olberding, Amy, ‘Community Practices and Getting Good at Bad Emotions’, Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements, 93 (2023), 9–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parnas, Josef, Møller, Paul, Kircher, Tilo, Thalbitzer, Jørgen, Jansson, Lennart, Handest, Peter, and Zahavi, Dan, ‘EASE-Scale (Examination of Anomalous Self-Experience)’, Psychopathology, 38:5 (2005), 236–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parsons, T., ‘The Sick Role and the Physician Reconsidered’, The Milbank Fund Quarterly, Health and Society, 53:3 (1975), 257–78.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Potter, Nancy Nyquist, ‘Moral Tourists and World Travelers: Some Epistemological Issues in Understanding Patients’ Worlds’, Philosophy, Psychiatry & Psychology, 10:3 (2003), 209–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Prigerson, Holly G., Kakarala, Sophia, Gang, James, and Maciejewski, Paul K., ‘History and Status of Prolonged Grief Disorder as a Psychiatric Diagnosis’, Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 17:1 (2021), 109–26.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rashed, Mohammed Abouelleil, Madness and the Demand for Recognition: A Philosophical Inquiry into Identity and Mental Health Activism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ratcliffe, Matthew, Broome, Matthew, Smith, Benedict, and Bowden, Hannah, ‘A Bad Case of the Flu? The Comparative Phenomenology of Depression and Somatic Illness’, Journal of Consciousness Studies, 20:7–8 (2013), 198–218.Google Scholar
Reynolds, Joel Michael, The Life Worth Living: Disability, Pain, and Morality (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 2022).Google Scholar
Rocha, Vânia, Soares, Sara, Stringhini, Silvia, and Fraga, Sílvia, ‘Socioeconomic Circumstances and Respiratory Function from Childhood to Early Adulthood: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis’, BMJ Open 9:6 (2019), e027528.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rose, Nikolas S., Our Psychiatric Future: The Politics of Mental Health (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2019).Google Scholar
Rosenberg, Charles E., Our Present Complaint: American Medicine, Then and Now (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rüsch, Nicolas, Angermeyer, Matthias C., and Corrigan, Patrick W., ‘Mental Illness Stigma: Concepts, Consequences, and Initiatives to Reduce Stigma’, European Psychiatry, 20:8 (2005), 529–39.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ryder, Andrew G., Yang, Jian, Zhu, Xiongzhao, Yao, Shuqiao, Yi, Jinyao, Heine, Steven J., and Michael Bagby, R., ‘The Cultural Shaping of Depression: Somatic Symptoms in China, Psychological Symptoms in North America?’, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 117:2 (2008), 300–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sadler, John, ‘The Psychiatric Significance of the Personal Self’, Psychiatry, 70:2 (2007), 113–29.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sadowsky, Jonathan Hal, The Empire of Depression: A New History (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2021).Google Scholar
Saks, Elyn R., The Center Cannot Hold: My Journey through Madness (New York: Hyperion, 2007).Google Scholar
Sass, Louis, Pienkos, Elizabeth, Skodlar, Borut, Stanghellini, Giovanni, Fuchs, Thomas, Parnas, Josef, and Jones, Nev, ‘EAWE: Examination of Anomalous World Experience’, Psychopathology, 50:1 (2017), 10–54.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Scrutton, Tasia, Christianity and Depression: Interpretation, Meaning, and the Shaping of Experience (London: SCM Press, 2020).Google Scholar
Sheehan, Susan, Is There No Place on Earth for Me? (New York: Vintage Books, 2014).Google Scholar
Simkovich, Suzanne M., Goodman, Dina, Roa, Christian, Crocker, Mary E., Gianella, Gonzalo E., Kirenga, Bruce J., Wise, Robert A., and Checkley, William, ‘The Health and Social Implications of Household Air Pollution and Respiratory Diseases’, NPJ Primary Care Respiratory Medicine, 29:1 (2019), 1–17.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sontag, Susan, Illness as Metaphor and, AIDS and Its Metaphors (New York: Picador USA, 2001).Google Scholar
Spelman, Elizabeth V., ‘On Treating Persons as Persons’, Ethics, 88:2 (1978), 150–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stanghellini, Giovanni, Raballo, Andrea, Broome, Matthew, Fernandez, Anthony Vincent, Fusar-Poli, Paolo, and Rosfort, René (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Phenomenological Psychopathology (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strohminger, Nina, Knobe, Joshua, and Newman, George, ‘The True Self: A Psychological Concept Distinct From the Self’, Perspectives on Psychological Science, 12:4 (2017), 551–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Szasz, Thomas S., The Myth of Mental Illness: Foundations of a Theory of Personal Conduct (New York, NY: Harper Perennial, 1961).Google Scholar
Thoits, Peggy A., ‘“I'm Not Mentally Ill”: Identity Deflection as a Form of Stigma Resistance’, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 57:2 (2016), 135–51.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Thoits, Peggy A., ‘Resisting the Stigma of Mental Illness’, Social Psychology Quarterly, 74:1 (2011), 6–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tickle, Louise, ‘High Court Judge “Deeply Frustrated” by NHS Delays in Suicidal Girl's Care’, The Guardian, 17 February 2023, accessed 11 July 2023: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/feb/17/high-court-judge-deeply-frustrated-by-nhs-delays-in-suicidal-girls-care.Google Scholar
Toombs, S. Kay, The Meaning of Illness: A Phenomenological Account of the Different Perspectives of Physician and Patient (Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands, 1992).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsou, Jonathan Y., Tekin, Şerife, and Bluhm, Robyn, ‘Philosophy of Science, Psychiatric Classification, and the DSM’, in Tekin, Serife and Bluhm, Robyn (eds.), The Bloomsbury Companion to Philosophy of Psychiatry (London: Bloomsbury Academic, 2019), 177–96.Google Scholar
Vigo, Daniel, Thornicroft, Graham, and Atun, Rifat, ‘Estimating the True Global Burden of Mental Illness’, The Lancet Psychiatry, 3:2 (2016), 171–8.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wakefield, Jerome C., ‘Disorder as Harmful Dysfunction: A Conceptual Critique of DSM-III-R's Definition of Mental Disorder’, Psychological Review, 99:2 (1992), 232.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wakefield, Jerome C., ‘The Concept of Mental Disorder: Diagnostic Implications of the Harmful Dysfunction Analysis’, World Psychiatry, 6:3 (2007), 149–56.Google ScholarPubMed
Wakefield, Jerome C., Schmitz, Mark F., First, Michael B., and Horwitz, Allan V., ‘Extending the Bereavement Exclusion for Major Depression to Other Losses: Evidence from the National Comorbidity Survey’, Archives of General Psychiatry, 64:4 (2007), 433–40.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jo, Watson, Drop the Disorder!: Challenging the Culture of Psychiatric Diagnosis (Wyastone Leys, Monmouth, UK: PCCS Books, 2019).Google Scholar
Weiner, Talia, ‘The (Un)Managed Self: Paradoxical Forms of Agency in Self-Management of Bipolar Disorder’, Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry, 35 (2011), 448–83.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Whiteley, Ella Kate, ‘A Woman First and a Philosopher Second: Relative Attentional Surplus on the Wrong Property’, Ethics, 133:4 (2023), 497–528.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wikman, Anders, Marklund, Staffan, and Alexanderson, Kristina, ‘Illness, Disease, and Sickness Absence: An Empirical Test of Differences between Concepts of Ill Health’, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, 59:6 (2005), 450–4.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wilkinson, Iain, Suffering: A Sociological Introduction (Cambridge, UK and Malden, MA: Polity Press, 2005).Google Scholar
Winder, Terrell J.A., ‘Unspoiling Identity: An Intersectional Expansion of Stigma Response Strategies’, Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 9:2 (2023), 195–207.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wisdom, Jennifer P., Bruce, Kevin, Saedi, Goal Auzeen, Weis, Teresa, and Green, Carla A., ‘“Stealing Me from Myself”: Identity and Recovery in Personal Accounts of Mental Illness’, The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 42:6 (2008), 489–95.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wittgenstein, Ludwig, Philosophical Investigations, Anscombe, G.E.M., Hacker, P.M.S., and Schulte, Joachim (trans.), 4th edition, (Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, 2009).Google Scholar
World Health Organization, Comprehensive Mental Health Action Plan 2013–2030 (Geneva: World Health Organisation, 2021).Google Scholar
Zerubavel, Eviatar, Taken for Granted: The Remarkable Power of the Unremarkable (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2018).Google Scholar