Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-wxhwt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T07:26:04.807Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Jacobin Phrenzy: The Menace of Monarchy, Plutocracy, and Anglophilia, 1789–1798

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 August 2009

Marshall Smelser
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

InTheFolklore of our national past the Federalist Period is often thought of as a golden age of demigods, who were almost infallible. The noisy dissent from the program of the Federalist administrations has been regarded as only a temporary deviation from the true American tradition.

The most frequently read accounts of the period — especially in college textbooks and other short works of synthesis — have generally tended to reduce the political events of that age to a chapter in the history of the “Age of Reason” and have thereby done some damage to our understanding. Casual readers of the story of this age seem to finish their reading with a mental summary in which the emphasis is on the intellect and logic — in short, on reason. An excellent example of this image as it occurs in the lore of even the learned is a recent comment on Senator J. William Fulbright by Senator Paul Douglas: “He's a child of the eighteenth century, a throwback to that age of enlightenment, trust in reason, temperate argument, and slightly aristocratic tendencies. That, I think, explains why he seems a little aloof, a little different from the rest.”

Type
Research Article
Information
The Review of Politics , Volume 21 , Issue 1 , January 1959 , pp. 239 - 258
Copyright
Copyright © University of Notre Dame 1959

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Link, Eugene Perry, Democratic-Republican Societies, 1790–1800 (New York, 1942), p. ixGoogle Scholar (hereafter cited: Link, Democratic-Republican Societies) Adams, Henry, The Life of Albert Gallatin, new printing (New York, 1943), p. 159Google Scholar.

2 Seib, Charles B. and Otten, Alan L., “Fulbright: Arkansas Paradox,” Harper's Magazine, CCXII, No. 1273 (1956), p. 60Google Scholar.

3 Childs, Frances S., “A Secret Agent's Advice on America, 1797,” in Nationalism and Internationalism: Essays Inscribed to Carlton J. H. Hayes, ed. Earle, Edward M. (New York, 1950), p. 39Google Scholar; Jefferson, Thomas, “The Anas,” Writings, Memorial Edition, ed. Lipscomb, A. A. (Washington, 1903–1904), I, 281–283Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Jefferson, ed. Lipscomb.); Howard, Leon, The Connecticut Wits (Chicago, 1943), pp. 409–410Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Howard, Wits).

4 Charming, Edward, A History of the United States (New York, 1932–1936), IV, 35–37Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Charming, United States); Washington to Knox, 1 April 1789, Washington, George, Writings, ed. Fitzpatrick, John C. (Washington, 1931–1944), XXX, 268Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Washington: Writings).

5 Harlow, Ralph Volney, The History of Legislative Methods in the Period Before 1825 (New Haven, 1917), pp. 126–127Google Scholar; Channing, , United States IV, 39–41Google Scholar.

6 Maclay, William, Journal, ed. Maclay, E. S. (New York, 1890), [5 May 1789] p. 18Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Maclay, Journal). Maclay loved his fellow man but only in the abstract.

7 Oliver Wolcott, Jr., to Oliver Wolcott, Sr., 2 Dec. 1789, Gibbs, George, Memoirs of the Administrations of Washington and John Adams, Edited from the Papers of Oliver Wolcott (New York, 1846), I, 24Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Gibbs, Memoirs.) Oliver Wolcott, Jr. to Oliver Wolcott, Sr., 24 Nov. 1790, ibid., I, 59.

8 John Adams to Price, 19 April 1790, Adams, John, Works, ed. Adams, C. F. (Boston, 1850–1856), IX, 564Google Scholar.

9 Link, , Democratic-Republican Societies, p. 47–49Google Scholar; Kaplan, Sidney, “Veteran Officers and Politics in Massachusetts, 1783–1787,” William and Mary Quarterly, Third Series, IX (1952), 35–40, 51–55Google Scholar.

10 Hart, James, The American Presidency in Action, 1789 (New York, 1948), pp. 28–47Google Scholar; Maclay's remark on the diadem and scepter is in Maclay, , Journal, [1 05 1789] 12Google Scholar; Bassett, J. S., The Federalist System, 1789–1801 (New York, 1906), p. 155Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Bassett, Federalist System).

11 Channing, , United States, IV, 164Google Scholar; Jefferson, , “The Anas,” ed. Lipscomb, , I, 266, 344Google Scholar; Jefferson to Lafayette, 16 June 1792, Jefferson, Thomas, Writings, ed. Washington, H. A. (Washington, 1853), III, 450Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Jefferson, ed. Washington).

12 Jefferson to Thomas Mann Randolph, 16 Nov. 1792, to Madison, 29 June 1793, ed. Washington, III, 491, IV, 9. For the quotation on Fenno see Jefferson to Madison, 21 July 1791, Jefferson, ed. Lipscomb, XIX, 79; Jefferson, , “The Anas,” Jefferson, , ed. Lipscomb, I, 301, 413, 417Google Scholar.

13 Jefferson to Mazzei, 24 April 1796, ed. Washington, IV, 139–140; Brant, Irving, James Madison, Father of the Constitution, 1787–1800 (Indianapolis, 1950), pp. 453–454Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Brant, Madison).

14 Madison, , “Substance of a Conversation with the President,” 5 05 1792, James Madison, Writings, ed. Hunt, Gaillard (New York, 1900–1910), VI, 109–110Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Madison, Writings); Monroe to Jefferson, 23 July 1793, James Monroe, Writings, ed. S. M. Hamilton (New York, 1898–1903), I, 268–269 (hereafter cited: Monroe, Writings); Link, , Democratic Republican Societies, pp. 194–195Google Scholar.

15 Jefferson, , “The Anas,” ed. Lipscomb, , I, 353Google Scholar; Washington to Hamilton, 15 May 1796, Hamilton to Washington, 20 May 1796, King, Rufus, The Life and Correspondence of Rufus King, ed. King, C. R. (New York, 1894–1900), II, 50, 51Google Scholar (hereafter cited: King, Life and Correspondence); Washington to Lafayette, 25 Dec. 1798, Washington, , Writings, XXXVII, 66–67Google Scholar; Smelser, Marshall, “George Washington and the Alien and Sedition Acts,” American Historical Review, LIX (01 1954), 322–334CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Maclay, , Journal, [28 06 1790] p. 310Google Scholar, [15 July 1790] p. 329, [23 Feb. 1791] pp. 397–399, and many other Republicans in the following years. See also Maclay, , Journal, [21 03 1790] p. 220Google Scholar; Oliver Wolcott, Jr., to Morse, 4 March 1795, Gibbs, , Memoirs, I, 190Google Scholar.

17 Parsons, Theophilus Jr, Memoir of Theophilus Parsons (Boston, 1859), pp. 109–110Google Scholar. The story is attributed thus: “I have this anecdote from a friend, to whom it was related by one who was a guest at the table.” The dinner, he said, occurred “soon after the adoption of the Federal Constitution …” This is secondhand hearsay, printed about seventy years after the alleged event.

18 Jefferson, , “The Anas,” ed Lipscomb, , I, 279, 377Google Scholar; Malone, Dumas, Jefferson and His Time, II, Jefferson and the Rights of Man (Boston, 1951), p. 287Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Malone, Jefferson); Jefferson to Washington, 9 Sept. 1792, Hamilton, Alexander, A Few of Hamilton's Letters, ed. Atherton, Gertrude (New York, 1903), p. 162Google Scholar.

19 Brant, , Madison, pp. 378–379Google Scholar. Madison was especially alarmed when Hamilton explained that the Congress had the legislative power “herein granted” in the Constitution, but the President had “executive power” without qualification. Binkley, Wilfred E., President and Congress (New York, 1947), p. 42Google Scholar. Channing, , United States, IV, 162Google Scholar.

20 Haraszti, Zoltán, John Adams and the Prophets of Progress (Cambridge, Mass., 1952), pp. 40–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar (hereafter cited: Haraszti, Adams and the Prophets); Dauer, Manning J., The Adams Federalists (Baltimore, 1953), pp. 53–54Google Scholar; Maclay, , Journal, [28 05 1789] p. 54Google Scholar; Channing, , United States, IV, 152n.Google Scholar; Chinard, Gilbert, Honest John Adams (Boston, 1933), p. 242Google Scholar.

21 Channing, , United States, IV, 171Google Scholar; Haraszti, Zoltán, “The 32nd Discourse on Davila,” William and Mary Quarterly, Third Series, XI (01 1954), 89–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Haraszti, , Adams and the Prophets, pp. 37–40Google Scholar; Maclay, , Journal, [18 09 1789] p. 155Google Scholar.

22 Brant, , Madison, p. 365Google Scholar; Adams, James Truslow, The Adams Family (Boston, 1930), p. 96Google Scholar.

23 Bassett, , Federalist System, p. 115Google Scholar; Schouler, James, History of the United States of America Under the Constitution, rev. ed. (New York, 1894–1913), I, 207Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Schouler, United States); Haynes, George H., The Senate of the United States (Boston, 1938), p. 911Google Scholar.

24 Jefferson, , “The Anas,” ed. Lipscomb, , I, 315, 333–334, 357Google Scholar; Morison, Samuel Eliot, Life and Letters of Harrison Gray Otis, Federalist, 1765–1848 (Boston, 1913), I, 126Google Scholar; Hamilton, to Washington, , Hamilton, Alexander, Works, ed. Lodge, Henry Cabot (New York, 1904), VIII, 83–87Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Hamilton, Works); Bassett, , Federalist System, pp. 151–154Google Scholar; Channing, , United States, IV, 153Google Scholar; Schouler, , United States, I, 126, 127Google Scholar.

25 Bassett, , Federalist System, p. 143 (the Paine quotation), 154Google Scholar; Channing, , United States, IV, 153–154Google Scholar; Brackenridge, Hugh Henry, Modern Chivalry, ed. Newlin, C. M. (New York, 1937), III (1793), 201Google Scholar; Maclay, , Journal, [5, 18 June, 1 Sept., 14 12 1789] pp. 69, 82, 144, 351Google Scholar; John Adams to Abigail Adams, 21 Jan. 1794, Adams, John, Works, I, 460–461Google Scholar.

26 Maclay, , Journal, [22 07 1790] p. 341Google Scholar, [25 Aug. 1789] p. 134; Jefferson, , ”The Anas,” ed. Lipscomb, , I, 295–296Google Scholar, Jefferson to Pendleton, 2 April 1798, ibid., X, 22. The fierce republicanism and equally warm antiroyalism of Thomas Paine's popular Rights of Man well illustrates this view.

27 Madison to Jefferson, 10 June 1793, Madison, , Writings, VI, 127n. 128n.Google Scholar; Brant, , Madison, p. 377–379Google Scholar.

28 Maclay, Journal, [14 06 1789] p. 75Google Scholar; see also Jefferson to Monroe, 21 March 1796, ed. Lipscomb, IX, 329.

29 Link, , Democratic-Republican Societies, pp. 186–200Google Scholar, gives many other instances of Federalist provocations and intimidations. The Republicans may be similarly indicted for their behavior during the fall of Genêt and the debate over the Jay Treaty.

30 Hamilton to Washington, 8 Nov. 1794, Hamilton, , Works, VI, 456Google Scholar; Jefferson to Madison, 28 Dec. 1794, ed. Washington, IV, 111; Brant, , Madison, p. 417Google Scholar; Madison, to Jefferson, 21 12 1794Google Scholar, Madison, , Writings, VI, 230Google Scholar; Baldwin, Leland D., Whiskey Rebels: The Story of a Frontier Uprising (Pittsburgh, 1939), p. 262CrossRefGoogle Scholar (hereafter cited: Baldwin, Whiskey Rebels).

31 Simms, Henry H., Life of John Taylor (Richmond, 1932), pp. 49–50Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Simms, Taylor); Channing, , United States, IV, 160n.Google Scholar; Henry Lee to Madison, 8 Jan. 1792, Madison, , Writings, VI, 82n.Google Scholar, 17 Jan. 1792, ibid., VI, 85n. For the quotation on Hamilton's fiscal mystery: Jefferson to Madison, 6 March 1796, ed. Washington, IV, 131.

32 Madison to Jefferson, 8 Aug. 1791, Madison, , Writings, VI, 59Google Scholar; Jefferson, , ”The Anas,” ed. Lipscomb, , I, 271Google Scholar; Channing, , United States, IV, 166–167Google Scholar; Rush, Benjamin, Autobiography, ed. Corner, George W. (Princeton, 1948), p. 227Google Scholar. Charles A. Beard thought that about thirty-two members of the Congress had large holdings in such obligations—ibid., p. 227n. Rush's entry was dated 27 August 1792.

33 Jefferson, , “The Anas,” ed. Lipscomb, , I, 318–319Google Scholar.

34 Ibid., I, 345; Jefferson to Edmund Randolph, 3 Feb. 1794, ed. Washington, IV, 101; Jefferson to Madison, 3 April 1794, ed. Lipscomb, IX, 282–283.

35 For one Republican's financial views see Simms, , Taylor, pp. 52–56Google Scholar; Brant, , Madison, p. 381Google Scholar; Jefferson to Monroe, 12 June 1796, ed. Lipscomb, IX, 337–338; Jefferson to Taylor, 26 Nov. 1798, ed. Washington, IV, 259–260.

36 Link, , Democratic-Republican Societies, pp. 130–131Google Scholar.

37 Morison, Samuel Eliot, “Elbridge Gerry, Gentleman-Democrat,” By Land and By Sea, Essays and Addresses (New York, 1954), p. 192Google Scholar; Darling, Arthur B., Our Rising Empire (New Haven, 1940), pp. 299–300Google Scholar.

38 Maclay, , Journal, [16 07 1789, 11 Feb. 1791], pp. 116, 389–390Google Scholar; Gore to King, 13 June 1791, King, , Life and Correspondence, I, 399Google Scholar.

39 Channing, , United States, IV, 162Google Scholar; Jefferson to Edmund Randolph, 8 May 1793 to Madison, 13 May 1793, ed. Washington, III, 552–553, 556.

40 Jefferson to Washington, 9 October 1792, ed. Washington, III, 463; Brant, , Madison, pp. 415–422Google Scholar; Jefferson to Burr, 17 June 1797, ed. Lipscomb, IX, 404, Jefferson to Monroe, 12 June 1796, ibid., IX, 337.

41 Jefferson to Taylor, 4 June 1796, Jefferson Papers, Massachusetts Historical Society Collection, Seventh Series, I (1900), 62Google Scholar.

42 Pickering, Timothy, A Review of the Correspondence between the Hon. John Adams … and the Late William Cunningham, Esq. (Salem, 1824), p. 38Google Scholar.

43 Channing, , United States, IV, 166–167Google Scholar; For examples see: Madison to Jefferson, 13 July 1791, 2 Sept. 1793, to Monroe, 15 Sept. 1793, Madison, Writings, VI, 57n., 197; Monroe to Jefferson, 18 Nov. 1795, Monroe, Writings, II, 421; Jefferson to Madison, 27 March 1796, ed. Washington, IV, 135–136, to E. Rutledge, 30 Nov. 1795, ibid., IV, 124; Jefferson to Monroe, 5 May 1793, ibid., III, 548.

44 Jefferson to Gilmer, 15 Dec. 1792, ibid., III, 494; Jefferson to Giles, 27 April 1795, ed. Lipscomb, IX, 305.

45 “Washington's Proclamation of Neutrality,” 22 April 1793, Commager, Henry Steele, ed., Documents of American History, 4th ed. (New York, 1948), I, 162–163Google Scholar.

46 Jefferson to Monroe, 5 May 1793, ed. Washington, III, 548; Jefferson to Madison, 13 May 1793, ed. Lipscomb, IX, 87.

47 Brant, , Madison, 374–375Google Scholar; Madison to Jefferson, 8 May, 10 June, 1793, Madison, , Writings, VI, 128, 127n.–128nGoogle Scholar.

48 Monroe to Jefferson, 27 June 1793, Monroe, , Writings, I, 266–267Google Scholar.

49 Madison to Jefferson, 27 August 1793, to Stuart, 1 Sept. 1793, to Jefferson, 2 Sept. 1793, Madison, , Writings, VI, 179, 189, 193Google Scholar. The last letter lists other correspondents of these seven days.

50 Monroe to John Brackenridge [Breckenridge?], 23 August 1793, to Jefferson, 3 Sept. 1793, Monroe, , Writings, I, 272–273, 274Google Scholar.

51 Brant, , Madison, 389–400Google Scholar; LeRoy to King, 19 March 1794, Lawrance to King, 23 March 1794, King, , Life and Correspondence, I, 554, 556Google Scholar.

52 Jay, William, The Life of John Jay, with Selections from his Correspondence and Miscellaneous Papers (New York, 1833), I, 357–359Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Jay, Jay).

53 McMaster, John Bach, A History of the: People of the United States from the Revolution to the Civil War (New York, 1883–1926), II, 213n., 225n.–226n.Google Scholar; Bailey, Thomas A., A Diplomatic History of the American People, 2d ed. (New York, 1942), p. 63Google Scholar; Freneau, Philip, “Parody, On the Attempt to Force the British Treaty on the People of the United States,” Poems, ed. Pattee, Fred L. (Princeton, 1902–1907), III, 133Google Scholar (hereafter cited: Freneau, Poems); Jay, , Jay, I, 362Google Scholar.

54 Jefferson to Page, 30 Aug. 1795, to Rutledge, 30 Nov. 1795; ed. Washington, IV, 120, 124.

55 Madison to Livingston, 10 Aug. 1795, to Monroe, 20 Dec. 1795, Madison, , Writings, VI, 235, 259–260Google Scholar; Brant, , Madison, p. 425Google Scholar.

56 Monroe to Madison, 8 Sept. 1795, 24 Oct. 1795, Monroe, , Writings, II, 354, 403–404Google Scholar.

57 Brant, , Madison, pp. 452–453Google Scholar; Madison to Jefferson, 29 Jan. 1797, Madison, , Writings, VI, 307Google Scholar; Monroe to Jefferson, 12 Feb. 1798, Monroe, , Writings, III, 101Google Scholar.

58 Jefferson to Madison, 22, 30 Jan., 15 June 1795, to Stroker, 8 June 1797, ed. Washington, IV, 162, 167, 181, 183.

59 Brant, , Madison, p. 455Google Scholar.

60 Madison to Jefferson, 10 June 1798, Madison, , Writings, VI, 323–325Google Scholar.

61 Monroe to Jefferson, 16 June 1798, Monroe, , Writings, III, 126–127Google Scholar.

62 Jefferson, , “The Anas,” ed. Lipscomb, , I, 298–299, 321–323, 354Google Scholar; Jefferson to Monroe, 5 May 1793, ed. Washington, III, 548.

63 Monroe to Jefferson, 16 March 1794, to Washington, 8 April 1794, Nicholas to Washington [no date], Monroe, , Writings, I, 289, 291–292, 292n.–293nGoogle Scholar.

64 Madison to Jefferson, 27 May 1789, Madison, , Writings, V, 371n.Google Scholar; Brant, , Madison, pp. 252–253Google Scholar.

65 Brant, , Madison, pp. 389–400Google Scholar; Bassett, , The Federalist System, pp. 123–125Google Scholar.

66 “Baring,” Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th ed.; Channing, , United States, IV, 96–97, 166–168Google Scholar.

67 Ibid., IV, 95.

68 “Camillus,” No. 22 (1795)Google Scholar, Hamilton, , Works, V, 467–468Google Scholar.

69 Howard, , Wits, pp. 319–321Google Scholar; Parton, James, The Life and Times of Aaron Burr (New York, 1858), pp. 222–223Google Scholar; Link, , Democratic-Republican Societies, p. 99Google Scholar; Maclay, , Journal,[5 06 1789] p. 68Google Scholar; Jefferson to Washington, 8 May 1791, ed. Washington, III, 258.

70 Monaghan, Frank, John Jay, Defender of Liberty (New York, 1935), pp. 309–310Google Scholar.

71 King, , Life and Correspondence, II, 37Google Scholar (quoting Richard Hildreth), Hamilton to King, 14 Dec. 1795, King to Hamilton, 16 Dec. 1795, ibid., II, 36, 37.

72 Freneau, , Poems, III, 240Google Scholar; G. D. H. Cole, Cobbett's biographer, saw no reason to believe that Cobbett was the recipient of a British subsidy. Cobbett, William, Letters ‥ to Edward Thornton ‥ 1797 to 1800, ed. Cole, G. D. H. (London, 1937), p. xxivGoogle Scholar.

73 Jefferson to Madison, 13 May 1793, ed. Washington, III, 557.

74 Monroe to Pickering, 10 March 1796, Monroe, , Writings, II, 465Google Scholar.