Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-thh2z Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-06T20:01:55.888Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Americanism and Frontier Catholicism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 August 2009

Thomas T. McAvoy C.S.C.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

One of the most confusing incidents in the history of Roman Catholicism in the United States is the condemnation of Americanism by Pope Leo XIII. In his apostolic letter, Testem Benevolentiae, of January 22, 1899, Pope Leo condemned those methods of apologetics which stressed natural virtues to the neglect of dogmatic teachings and those notions of spiritual direction which insisted on individual inspiration and the active virtues in preference to external guidance and the passive virtues. These doctrines had acquired the name of Americanism in European theological circles, partly as a result of the French adaptation of the biography of Father Isaac Hecker written in English by Father Walter Elliott, and partly as a result of a controversy waged in several European Catholic periodicals. The subsequent denials of most of the American prelates that the heretical Americanism ever existed in the United States, together with the counter-charges of certain conservative prelates and foreign-language groups, only add to the confusion of the historical account. The astute silence of most Catholic historians on the controversy for fear of reawakening the sharp animosities of the time has given rise to many misconceptions about the affair, even causing some suspicion that Pope Leo in some way condemned American national traits or even the loyalty of American Catholics to American political institutions.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Review of Politics , Volume 5 , Issue 3 , July 1943 , pp. 275 - 301
Copyright
Copyright © University of Notre Dame 1943

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Bishop Camillus Maes to Father Daniel Hudson, C.S.C Mar. 3, 1899. Hudson papers—University of Notre Dame Archives. Cf. also “Americanism” by Fortescue, A. in Folia Fugitiva ed. by Rev. Cologan, W. H.. N. Y., 1907, pp. 265–90Google Scholar.

2 Clancy, Raymond J., “American Prelates at the Vatican Council,” Historical Records and Studies, 28: 7–135, U. S. Catholic Historical Society, New York, 1927Google Scholar.

3 Quoted in Leslie, Shane, Henry Edward Manning: His Life and Labors, New York, 1921, p. 350Google Scholar.

4 SisterPahorezki, M. Sevina, O.S.F., The Social and Political Activities of William J. Onahan, Washington, 1942, pp. 109–36Google Scholar.

5 Leslie, , op. cit., pp. 353–8Google Scholar. Will, Allen Sinclair, Life of Cardinal Gibbons, Archbishop of Baltimore. 2 v. N. Y. (1922), I, 361–78Google Scholar. Zwerlein, Frederick J., The Life and Letters of Bishop McQuaid. 3 v. Rochester, N. Y., 1927. III, 1–83Google Scholar.

6 Relatio de Quaeslione Cermanica in Slatibus Focderatis a Rev. P. M. Abbelen… Sacrae Congr. de Propaganda Fide Mense Novembris 1886 submissa. Cf. also. FatherZurcher's, GeorgeForeign Ideas in the Catholic Church in America. East Aurora, N.Y., 1896Google Scholar.

7 Reprinted as The Future of Foreign-Born Catholics, St. Louis, 1884. Pp. 88.

8 The Tablet. London. 78: 107, 07 18, 1891Google Scholar.

9 Reilly, J. T., Collections in the Life and Times of Cardinal Cibbons. Vol. 3, part 3, pp. 1–34Google Scholar.

10 Copy of letter of Gibbons to Pope Leo XIII, Jan. 14, 1892, Cathedral Archives, Baltimore.

11 The Review, vol. 5, no. 12, p. 3, 06 9, 1898, referring to Tyrrell's essay on “Liberal Catholicism” in Faith of Millions, pp. 68–84Google Scholar.

12 Messenger of the Sacred Heart. 11: 949–52. 11. 1896Google Scholar.

13 American Ecclesiastical Review, 16: 147–54. 02, 1897Google Scholar.

14 La Chiltá Catlolica, 1895, series XV, vol. V, pp. 119 ff.Google Scholar

15 Coppinger, E., La Polémique francaise sur la vie du Père Hecker. Paris. 1898Google Scholar. Also. Barry, William in The Freeman's Journal and Catholic Register, 12 24, 1898Google Scholar: Coppinaer, E.. Le P. Hecher après la Lettre Pontificate an Cardinal Cihbons. Cannes. 1899Google Scholar, and Gurian, Waldemar, Die politischen und sozialen Ideen des französischen Katholizismus 1789–1914. Volksverein Verlag, 1928. pp. 291 and 404–5Google Scholar. Houtin, Albert, L'Américanism. Paris, 1904Google Scholar, contains many interesting quotations on French Americanism, but personal bias undermines the value of his interpretation.

16 The English version was toned down: Maignen, Charles, Studies in Americanism—Father Hecker, is he a saint? Rome, 1898Google Scholar.

17 O'Connell, D. J., A New Idea in the Life of Father Hecker. Fribourg. 1897, P. 11Google Scholar.

18 The article is quoted and criticized in the Freeman's Journal and Catholic Register of June 19, 1897.

19 Cf. The Freeman's Journal and Catholic Register during the final months of 1898.

20 Etheridge, J. St. Clair (Archbishop Ireland). “The Genesis of Americanism” in the North American Review, 120: 679–93Google Scholar. Letter of Ireland to Father Walter Elliott. Feb. 22. 1899, in Paulisl Archives in New York.

21 Copy of letter of Cardinal Gibbons to Pope Leo XIII, March 17, 1899. in Cathedral Archives, Baltimore.

22 The Tablet, London, 05 30. 1899, 93: 779–80Google Scholar.

23 A similar charge of Jansenistic mind was made in the Civiltá Cattolica of Mar, 6. 1899. Cf. La Civiltá Caltolica, 1899. Series, XVI. vol. V, pp. 641–53Google Scholar.

24 The Great Encyclical Letters of Pope Leo XIII, with a preface by Wynne, John J.. S. J. New York, 1903, pp. 441–53Google Scholar.

25 Turner, Frederick Jackson, The Frontier in American History. New York, 1921, pp. 1–38Google Scholar.

26 Sweet, W. W., The History of Religions in America. New York, 1930. pp. 298–379Google Scholar. Mode, P. G., The Frontier Spirit in American Christianity. New York, 1923, pp 11–12Google Scholar; 146–164. Latourette, K. S., The Great Century A. D. 1800–1914. New York, 1941, pp. 175–223Google Scholar.

27 Zahm, J. A., Evolution and Dogma. Chicago, 1895Google Scholar.

28 Hecker, Isaac T., The Church and the Age. New York, 1887, p. 109Google Scholar.

29 Father George Zurcher, a German temperance advocate, of Buffalo published in 1898 a pamphlet, Monks and Their Decline, which was placed on the Index of Prohibited Books on Sept. 1, 1898.

30 Garraghan, G. J., , S.J., The Jesuits of the Middle United States. 3 v. New York, 1938, 1: 543–6Google Scholar.

31 Copy of letter of Cardinal Gibbons to Pope Leo XIII. March 17, 1899. in the Cathedral Archives, Baltimore.