Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-8bljj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-24T16:17:19.411Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Traditions of Metal-Working in the Later Neolithic and Early Bronze Age of Britain: Part I

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 May 2014

Dennis Britton
Dennis Britton
Affiliation:
Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This paper is concerned with the earliest use in Britain of copper and bronze, from the first artifacts of copper in the later Neolithic until the transition from the Early to the Middle Bronze Age, as marked by palstaves and haft-flanged axes. It does not attempt to deal with all the material, but instead certain classes of evidence have been chosen to illustrate some of the main styles of workmanship. These groups have been considered both from the point of view of their archaeology, and of the technology they imply.

Such an approach requires on the one hand that the artifacts are sorted into types, their associations in graves and hoards studied, their distributions plotted, and finally a consideration of the evidence for their affinities and chronology. On the other hand there are questions also of interest that need a different standpoint. Of what metals or alloys are the objects made? Can their sources be located? How did the smiths set about their work? Over what regions was production carried out? If we are to understand as much as we might of the life of prehistoric times, then surely we should look at material culture from as many view-points as possible—in this case, the manner and setting of its production as well as its classification.

Type
Research Article
Information
Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society , Volume 29 , December 1963 , pp. 258 - 325
Copyright
Copyright © The Prehistoric Society 1963

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

page 258 note 1 Smith, M. A., PPS XXV (1959) 171–3Google Scholar.

page 259 note 1 Except when halberds occur, presumably as scrap, in Late Bronze Age hoards.

page 261 note 1 Mr T. G. E. Powell and Mr C. B. Burgess drew my attention to this recent find, and Mr J. Forde-Johnstone has very kindly allowed me to mention it in advance of publication. To all these I am especially grateful.

page 261 note 2 SirSinclair, John (editor), The Statistical Account of Scotland, vol. 16 (Edinburgh, 1795) 285–6Google Scholar: under the parish of Whithorn, by Isaac Davidson; Callander, J. G., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. LVII (1922–1923) 125, 127Google Scholar.

page 261 note 3 Callander, J. G., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. LVII (1922–1923) 125Google Scholar, fig. 1 on 126. In the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland (DA 64). It has recently been shown to be of copper. (For this information I am much obliged to the Keeper, Mr R. B. K. Stevenson).

page 261 note 4 For a general account of British Beaker graves, see Childe, V. G., Prehistoric Communities of the British Isles (3rd edition, London, 1949) 91–101Google Scholar; Ashbee, P., The Bronze Age Round Barrow in Britain (London, 1960) 120–2Google Scholar, shows the new nomenclature; Piggott, S., ‘Abercromby and After: the Beaker Cultures of Britain Re-examined’, in Culture and Environment, edited by Foster, I. Ll. and Alcock, L. (London, 1963) 53–91Google Scholar.

page 261 note 5 Abercromby, J., Bronze Age Pottery I (Oxford, 1912) 52 ffGoogle Scholar.

page 262 note 1 Winterslow: Hutchins, A. B., Archaeol. Journ. I (1844) 157Google Scholar. Roundway: MrCunnington, , Wilts. Archaeol. Mag. III (1857) 185–8Google Scholar; Thurnam, J., Archaeologia XLIII (1871) 449–50Google Scholar. Mere: SirHoare, Richard Colt, Ancient Wiltshire I (London, 1812) 44,Google Scholar pl. 2.

page 262 note 2 Case, H., Wilts. Archaeol. Mag. LV (1953) 135Google Scholar.

page 262 note 3 Hawkes, C. F. C., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 1 (London, 1955)Google Scholar; Coghlan, H. H. and Case, H., PPS XXIII (1957)Google Scholar fig. 3 on 95.

page 262 note 4 Thurnam, J., Archaeologia XLIII (1871) 457Google Scholar.

page 262 note 5 One, unlocated, from north-east Scotland: Childe, V. G., The Prehistory of Scotland (London, 1935) 87,Google Scholar fig. 23 (2) on 98. Another from East Pitdoulsie, Auchterless (Aberdeen): Aberdeen Regional Museum (37, 43, 2).

page 262 note 6 Ten, from Early Bronze Age contexts, analysed and shown to be of tin bronze: Britton, D. and Richards, E. E., Archaeometry 4 (1961) 47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

page 263 note 1 Coghlan, H. H. and Case, H., PPS XXIII (1957) 96Google Scholar; Coghlan, H. H., Sibrium V (1960) 149–52Google Scholar.

page 263 note 2 The example cited by Thurnam, J., Archaeologia XLIII (1871) 450Google Scholar, fig. 146 on 443, if in fact a mould and not just a representation—a possibility kindly suggested to me by Mr J. W. Brailsford—comes from Ireland. See the Catalogue of the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1892) 124Google Scholar; Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938)Google Scholar pl. 53 (c).

page 263 note 3 Case, H., Wilts. Archaeol. Mag. LV (1953) 135–8Google Scholar.

page 263 note 4 For the definition of the Highland and Lowland Zones: SirFox, Cyril, The Personality of Britain (4th edition, Cardiff, 1952) 28–9Google Scholar and Map B.

page 265 note 1 E.g. by Hodges, H. W. M., Sibrium IV (1958–1959) 135Google Scholar.

page 265 note 2 Stewart, M. E. C., Bulletin of the Inst. of Metallurgists, vol. 5, no 3 (Dec, 1955) 8–9Google Scholar.

page 266 note 1 Except for the mould from Bettws-y-Coed (Caernarvon).

page 266 note 2 Described as ‘steatite’ by Hodges, H. W. M., Ulster Journ. of Archaeol. (3rd series) XVII (1954) 66Google Scholar.

page 270 note 1 E.g. hoard from Yattendon (Berks.): Evans, J., Proc. Soc. Ant. (2nd series) VII (1876–1878) 480–5Google Scholar.

page 270 note 2 Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938) 280–1Google Scholar. Their Type I falls within the flat axes here discussed as of the Migdale group.

page 271 note 1 The tubular beads and decorated strip have been ingeniously interpreted as parts of a crescentic necklace by Stevenson, R. B. K., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. LXXXIX (1955–1956) 456–7Google Scholar, pl. 68.

page 272 note 1 Greenwell, W., Archaeologia LII (1890) 2–4Google Scholar; Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938) 283–5Google Scholar.

page 274 note 1 Bateman, T., Journ. Brit. Archaeol. Ass. VII (1852) 216–17Google Scholar; Fowler, M. J., Journ. Derby Archaeol. Soc. LXXV (1955) 112–13Google Scholar; Smith, M. A., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 19 (London, 1957)Google Scholar.

page 274 note 2 Banff Museum; unpublished; referred to by Smith, M. A., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 20, section 6 London, 1957)Google Scholar.

page 274 note 3 SirHoare, Richard Colt, Ancient Wiltshire I (London, 1812) 202–5Google Scholar; Piggott, S., PPS IV (1938)Google Scholar fig. 3 on 63. Definition of Bush Barrow type of dagger: ApSimon, A. M., 10th Ann. Rep., London Univ. Inst. of Archaeology (1954) 37–8, 54Google Scholar.

page 274 note 4 SirFox, Cyril, The Personality of Britain (4th edition, Cardiff, 1943)Google Scholar pl. 6. Decorated axes: Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938)Google Scholar fig. 8 (map) on 281.

page 274 note 5 Kinneff: Anderson, J., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. XVII (1882–1883) 449–51Google Scholar; Childe, V. G., The Prehistory of Scotland (London, 1935) 88, 94Google Scholar. Stobo: Seton, G., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. 11 (1854–1857) 276–8Google Scholar; Evans, J., Ancient Bronze Implements (London, 1881) 384Google Scholar.

page 274 note 6 Bateman, T., Ten Years' Diggings (London, 1861) 167Google Scholar; Fowler, M. J., Journ. Derby Archaeol. Soc. LXXV (1955) 91, 98, 114, 119Google Scholar, fig. 19 (n).

page 274 note 7 Callander, J. G., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. LIII (1918–1919) 17–20Google Scholar.

page 274 note 8 Piggott, S. and Stewart, M., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 27, section 6. (8) (London, 1958)Google Scholar. Brigmilston: SirHoare, Richard Colt, Ancient Wiltshire I (London, 1812)Google Scholar pl. 23. Leicester: Evans, J., Ancient Bronze Implements (London, 1881) 231Google Scholar. Derby: Bateman, T., Vestiges of the Antiquities of Derbyshire (London, 1848) 68–9Google Scholar.

page 274 note 9 Examples from the Early Bronze Age in Wessex: Piggott, S., PPS IV (1938) 102–6Google Scholar.

page 275 note 1 Curwen, E. C., The Archaeology of Sussex (2nd edition, London, 1954) 150,Google Scholar pl. 11.

page 275 note 2 Maclellan, K., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. XIX (1884–1885) 134–6Google Scholar; Powell, T. G. E., PPS XIX (1953) 169–70Google Scholar; Piggott, S. and Stewart, M., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 25 (London, 1958)Google Scholar.

page 275 note 3 Greenwell, W., British Barrows (London, 1877) 52, 223–4Google Scholar. Compare the ear-pendants from Stakor Low (Derby): Bateman, T., Ten Years' Diggings (London, 1861) 80Google Scholar; Fowler, M. J., Journ. Derby Archaeol. Soc. LXXV (1955) 75Google Scholar, fig. 3, 106.

page 275 note 4 Examples from the Early Bronze Age in Wessex: Piggott, S., PPS IV (1938) 102–6Google Scholar.

page 275 note 5 Anderson, J., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. XVII (1882–1883) 451–3Google Scholar.

page 275 note 6 Views of MrMancini, G., in Powell, T. G. E., PPS XIX (1953) 170Google Scholar.

page 276 note 1 A large selection of material in the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, Edinburgh, has been analysed by Dr M. Schröder (Stuttgart). For information about this work I am much obliged to the Keeper, Mr R. B. K. Stevenson.

page 276 note 2 At the Research Laboratory for Archaeology, University of Oxford (Director: Dr E. T. Hall).

page 276 note 3 See E. Voce's account of experimental casting in a stone mould of the Bronze Age, in Coghlan, H. H., Notes on the Prehistoric Metallurgy of Copper and Bronze in the Old World (Oxford, 1951) 112–5Google Scholar.

page 277 note 1 M. E. C. Stewart has suggested that the grooves in the mould from Burreldales (Aberdeen) could be for securing a cover of stone or wood, in the Bulletin of the Inst. of Metallurgists, vol. 5, no. 8 (Dec, 1955) 8Google Scholar. Might they not be matrices for bars?

page 277 note 2 Report by Maryon, H., in Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938) 279Google Scholar.

page 278 note 1 Views of Mancini, G., in Powell, T. G. E., PPS XIX (1953) 170Google Scholar.

page 279 note 1 Smith, J. A. and DrMacadam, S., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. IX (1870–1872) 429–33Google Scholar.

page 279 note 2 Tylecote, R. F., Metallurgy in Archaeology (London, 1962) 156Google Scholar.

page 279 note 3 In Banff Museum, where seen by the author; referred to by Smith, M. A., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 20, section 6. (1) (London, 1957)Google Scholar.

page 279 note 4 Knipton: The Duke of Rutland, Antiquaries Journ. XV (1935) 59–61Google Scholar; Smith, M. A., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 20 (London, 1957)Google Scholar. Berden: Maynard, G. and Benton, G. M., Trans. Essex Archaeol. Soc. (new series) XV (1921) 278–86Google Scholar, XVI (1923) 144.

page 279 note 5 In the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, Edinburgh. To be published by the excavators, Miss A. S. Henshall and J. C. Wallace, to whom I am greatly obliged for advance information, in Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot.

page 279 note 6 Castern: Bateman, T., Ten Years' Diggings (London, 1861) 166–7Google Scholar. Normanton: SirHoare, Richard Colt, Ancient Wiltshire I (London, 1812) 160Google Scholar; Thurnam, J., Archaeologia XLIII (1871) 469–70Google Scholar.

page 279 note 7 Waterman, D. M., Antiquaries Journ. XXVIII (1948) 179–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

page 281 note 1 Mortimer, J. R., Forty Years' Researches in British and Saxon Burial Mounds of East Yorkshire (London 1905) 232Google Scholar, pl. 79.

page 281 note 2 Piggott, S. and Stewart, M., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 27, section 6. (8) (London, 1958)Google Scholar.

page 281 note 3 Bush Barrow: Piggott, S., PPS IV (1938) 63Google Scholar, fig. 3. On the type and for details of most: ApSimon, A. M., 10th Ann. Rep., London Univ. Inst. of Archaeol. (1954) 37–62Google Scholar.

page 281 note 4 Drew, C. D. and Piggott, S., Proc. Dorset Nat. Hist. and Archaeol. Soc. LVIII (1936) 20–1, 24–5Google Scholar; Grinsell, L. V., Dorset Barrows (Dorchester, 1959) 141Google Scholar.

page 281 note 5 Map: Ashbee, P., The Bronze Age Round Barrow in Britain (London, 1960)Google Scholar fig. 50 on 144.

page 282 note 1 Cressingham: Thurnam, J., Archaeologia XLIII (1871) 454Google Scholar. Wilsford (Barrow G. 23, Normanton 139): ApSimon, A. M., 10th Ann. Rep., London Univ. Inst. of Archaeol. (1954) 54Google Scholar.

page 282 note 2 Evans, J., Ancient Bronze Implements (London, 1881) 237Google Scholar, fig. 296.

page 282 note 3 Mortimer, J. R., Forty Years' Researches in British and Saxon Burial Mounds of East Yorkshire (London, 1905) 5Google Scholar. Pl. 1: fig. 8.

page 283 note 1 Wilson, D., The Archaeology and Prehistoric Annals of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1851) 254Google Scholar; Piggott, S. and Stewart, M., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 30 (London, 1958)Google Scholar.

page 283 note 2 E.g. the hoard from Stoke Ferry (Norfolk): Evans, J., Ancient Bronze Implements (London, 1881) 270Google Scholar; Hawkes, C. F. C., Inventaria Archaeologica: GB. 8 (London, 1955)Google Scholar.

page 283 note 3 See, e.g. Forssander, J. E., Der ostskandinavische Norden während der ältesten Metallzeit Europas (Lund, 1936) 93–8Google Scholar; Rfordáin, S. P. Ó, Archaeologia LXXXVI (1936) 195–321Google Scholar; von Brunn, W. A., Die Hortfunde der frühen Bronzezeit aus Sachsen-Anhalt, Sachsen und Thüringen (Berlin, 1959)Google Scholar, passim.

page 284 note 1 Halberds in the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, Edinburgh, analysed by Dr M. Schröder (Stuttgart). For information about this work I am much obliged to the Keeper, Mr R. B. K. Stevenson.

page 284 note 2 General accounts as already cited. Add: Hachmann, R., Die frühe Bronzezeit im westlichen Ostseegebiet (Hamburg, 1957)Google Scholar, for discussions of kinds of rivets.

page 284 note 3 SirFox, Cyril, The Personality of Britain (Cardiff, 4th edition, 1943)Google Scholar pl. 7.

page 285 note 1 ApSimon, A. M., 10th Ann. Rep., London Univ. Inst. of Archaeol. (1954) 42 ffGoogle Scholar.

page 286 note 1 Comments by Evans, J., Ancient Bronze Implements (London, 1881) 50–1Google Scholar.

page 286 note 2 Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938) 272 ffGoogle Scholar.

page 289 note 1 MrLort, , Archaeologia V (1779) pl. 8, no. 27, opp. page 113Google Scholar.

page 292 note 1 Hodges, H. W. M., Ulster Journ. of Archaeol. (3rd series) XVII (1954) 66Google Scholar. The Bodwrdin mould is described as of ‘honestone’ already in 1846, which is before the word was first applied to specific minerals—1855 and 1882, according to The New English Dictionary (Oxford, 1901)Google Scholar.

page 292 note 2 SirFox, Cyril, The Personality of Britain (4th edition, Cardiff, 1943)Google Scholar pl. 7; Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938) 280–2Google Scholar.

page 292 note 3 Wallmead-barrow, Camerton: Thurnam, J., Archaeologia XLIII (1871)Google Scholar fig. 170 on 468; Piggott, S., PPS IV (1938)Google Scholar fig. 14 OP 76. Snowshill: Greenwell, W., Archaeologia LII (1890)Google Scholar fig. 33 on 72. Collingbourne Ducis: Piggott, S., PPS IV (1938)Google Scholar fig. 18 on 87. Loose Howe: H. W., and Elgee, F., PPS XV (1949)Google Scholar fig. 10 on 100.

page 292 note 4 Ablington: Poore, D., Archaeol. Journ. X (1853) 248Google Scholar; Piggott, S., PPS IV (1938) 103Google Scholar, no. 30. Stanton Harcourt: Harden, D. B., Oxoniensia V (1940) 161–2Google Scholar; Harden, D. B. and Treweeks, R. C., Oxoniensia X (1945)Google Scholar fig. 9, no. 4b, on 27, pl. 5 D.

page 292 note 5 Map: Ashbee, P., The Bronze Age Round Barrow in Britain (London, 1960)Google Scholar fig. 51 on 145.

page 292 note 6 Bryce, T. H., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. XXXVI (1901–1902) 118–20Google Scholar.

page 293 note 1 I am grateful to C. B. Burgess for drawing my attention to this find. Archaeologia Cambrensis (4th series) IV (1873) 213–14Google Scholar; Chitty, L. F., Archaeologia Cambrensis (7th series) VII (1926) 406–9Google Scholar; Grimes, W. F., The Prehistory of Wales (2nd edition, Cardiff, 1951) 198Google Scholar, fig. 62, no. 11 on 250.

page 293 note 2 British Museum (WG 2021); Evans, J., Ancient Bronze Implements (London, 1881) 223Google Scholar. Childe, V. G., The Prehistory of Scotland (London, 1935) 145Google Scholar, fig. 38 (1); National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, Edinburgh (DG 88).

page 293 note 3 Greenwell, W. and Brewis, W. P., Archaeologia LXI (1909)Google Scholar pl. 60, fig. 8; pl. 61, fig. 10.

page 293 note 4 Dean Water: Catalogue of the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1892) 137–8Google Scholar (DG 23). Thames: Greenwell, W. and Brewis, W. P., Archaeologia LXI (1909)Google Scholar pl. 61, fig. 12.

page 293 note 5 In the barrow on Breach Farm, Llanbleddian (Glamorgan), was found a chisel of simple form, but too corroded for more details, and a small flat axe: Grimes, W. F.PPS IV (1938) 113Google Scholar.

page 293 note 6 Britton, D. and Richards, E. E., Archaeometry IV (1961) 39–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

page 294 note 1 Brown, M. A. and Blin-Stoyle, A. E., PPS XXV (1959) 188–208Google Scholar.

page 295 note 1 E.g. Hodges, H. W. M., Ulster Journ. of Archaeol. (3rd series) XVII (1954) 68–80Google Scholar.

page 295 note 2 Shown by unfinished chapes in the Isleham hoard (Cambs.), in the Moyses' Hall Museum, Bury St. Edmunds, Suffolk; compare Archaeologia LXXIII (1923)Google Scholar pl. 49, no. 56.

page 295 note 3 Tylecote, R. F., Metallurgy in Archaeology (London, 1962) 116Google Scholar.

page 295 note 4 Suggested by the experiments of Dr H. Drescher in casting palstaves, and his study of unfinished examples: Die Kunde (NF) VIII (1957) 56 ffGoogle Scholar.

page 296 note 1 E.g. at Jarlshof, Shetland. The matrices there were formed in two separate valves, both enclosed by a clay investment: Curle, A. O., Proc. Soc. Ant. Scot. LXVII (1932–1933) 112–24Google Scholar. Others listed by Hodges, H. W. M., Ulster Journ. of Archaeol. (3rd series) XVII (1954) 79Google Scholar.

page 296 note 2 E.g. the rarity of ‘casting seams’ contrasts with their commonness on the corresponding types of the Middle and Late Bronze Age.

page 296 note 3 Maryon, H., in Megaw, B. R. S. and Hardy, E. M., PPS IV (1938) 279Google Scholar.

page 296 note 4 Hachmann, R., Die frühe Bronzezeit im westlichen Ostseegebiet (Hamburg, 1957) especially 31 ff., 103 ffGoogle Scholar.

page 296 note 5 Maryon, H., Antiquaries Journal XVIII (1938) 243–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.