Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-xfwgj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-15T16:21:14.989Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Quality Challenge in Iran's Higher Education: A Historical Review

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2022

Maghsood Farasatkhah ,
Mahmood Ghazi  and
Abbas Bazargan
Maghsood Farasatkhah
Affiliation:
Institute for Research and Planning in Higher Education, Tehran.
Mahmood Ghazi
Affiliation:
Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Tehran.
Abbas Bazargan
Affiliation:
Faculty of Psychology and Education, University of Tehran.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Higher education at Iran's state-run universities is not supported by a deeply-rooted tradition of quality assessment. For several decades, Iranian universities have not been able to monitor themselves and develop efficient, internal structures of quality assurance. The academics' attempts at internal monitoring have failed, giving way to a system of bureaucratic supervision and control. Recent changes in Iran have given rise to new concepts, including the principle of universities' self-evaluation, based on academic autonomy and scientific freedom. But the dominant tendency in Iran's political structure and administration is still toward external, bureaucratic control. The conflict between more or less advanced texts and typically solid structures is a reflection of inconsistencies within the Iranian society, pursuing its transitional stage.

Type
Research Article
Information
Iranian Studies , Volume 41 , Issue 2 , April 2008 , pp. 115 - 137
Copyright
Copyright © Association For Iranian Studies, Inc 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Brennan, John and Shah, T., Managing Quality in Higher Education: An International Perspective on Institutional Assessment and Change (Buckingham, 2000), 20–24Google Scholar.

2 Husbands T., Christopher and Patricia, Fosh, “Students' Evaluation of Teaching in Higher Education: Experiences from Four European Countries and Some implications of Practice,” Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education (1993): 20–95Google Scholar.

3 CHEA, Regional Accreditation Organizations 2005–2006 (Washington, DC, 2006).

4 JUAA, Accreditation System (Tokyo, 2005).

5 The carriers of this movement were the new cultural, social and political groups and elite. People like Sani'oddoleh, Dolatabadi, Hassan and Hossein Pirnia, Abolhassan and Mohammadali Forooghi, Davar, Sadigh, Shafagh, Rahnama, Afshar and Siasi had a chance to be in public decision making centers and each somehow mediated in the country's development and modernization. Eesa Sadigh was one of the dispatched students to Europe in 1910 and the Constitution Movement period, who later on added the project of establishment of Tehran University to his thesis named as “Modern Persia and its Education System” in the Ministry of Sciences. As to this title, the establishment of Tehran University was regarded as a part of Iran's modernization project. See Sadigh, (1975), 372.

6 Sadigh, Easa, Fourteen Statements (Tehran, 1973), 31–39Google Scholar.

7 Bahrami, Mohsen, “The Necessity for Revising the Missions and Structures of Higher Education,” Rahiaft (1995): 11Google Scholar.

8 Khaliji, Mohsen, A Look at Iran's Higher Education System: Past, Present and Future (Tehran, 1997), 84–85Google Scholar.

9 Bazargan, Abbas, et al., “The Appropriate Approach towards Internal Evaluation for Continual Enhancement of Educational Departments in Medical Universities,” Journal of Psychology and Educational Sciences (2000): 1–27Google Scholar.

10 Abily, Khodayar, The Evaluation of the Nature of Supervision and Current Evaluation in Iran's Non-Medical Higher Education, The Articles Collection of the First Conference of Higher Education in Iran (Tehran, 1997)Google Scholar.

11 Mohammadi, , et al., Quality Evaluation in Higher Education: Concepts, Principles, Methods and Criteria (Tehran, 2005)Google Scholar.

12 The CD of Laws (collection of laws) Research Centre of Islamic Consultative Assembly (Tehran, 1996): The Act of Ministry of Sciences, Endowments and Fine Arts.

13 The CD of Laws, Constitution of Sciences.

14 The CD of Laws, Act of Supreme Council of Sciences.

15 Sadigh, Easa, Fourteen Statements (Tehran, 1973), 31–39Google Scholar.

16 The CD of Laws, The Act of Tehran University.

17 Sadigh, Easa, History of Iran's Culture (Tehran, 1975), 372–380Google Scholar.

18 The CD of Laws, The Act of Establishment of Universities.

19 The CD of Laws, The Act of Establishment of the Ministry of Education.

20 The CD of Laws, The Act of Establishment of the Ministry of Education.

21 The CD of Laws, The Act of the Ministry of Sciences and Higher Education.

22 Barzegar, Ali, Scientific Policy and Social Modernization (Tehran, 1975)Google Scholar.

23 Coy, Lothan, Scientific Policy and Issues of Iran's Higher Education (Tehran, 1969)Google Scholar.

24 Secretariat for Cultural Revolution Supreme Council, Collection of Ratifications of Cultural Revolution Headquarter (Tehran, n.d.).

25 Premiership Research Centre, A Study of the Reasons of Specialists' Going Out from (Tehran) Universities and Higher Education Institutes: Results and Recommendations (Tehran, 1984).

26 Secretariat for Cultural Revolution Supreme Council, Collection of Ratifications of Cultural Revolution Headquarter (Tehran, n.d.).

27 Higher Education and Research Management, Higher Education Development Plan (Tehran, 1989).

28 Higher Education Research and Planning Institute, Report of Performance of (non-Medical) Higher Education and Research Section Plan 1989–92 (Tehran, 1993).

29 Sayari, Aliakbar, The Function and Importance of Providing the Comprehensive Plan of the Universities and Higher Education Institutes (Tehran, 1992)Google Scholar.

30 Ministry of Culture and Higher Education, Report of Performance of Education Supervision and Evaluation Council (Tehran, 1987).

31 Sayari, Aliakbar, 2nd Plan of Non-Medical Public Higher Education and Research Development (Tehran, 1993)Google Scholar.

32 Sorkhabi, Mohammad Yamani dozzi, Academic Development Planning: Theories and Experiences (Tehran, 2003), 7Google Scholar.

33 Noorshahi, Nasrin, History, Structure and Activities of the Headquarter Unit of Higher Education Evaluation Office (Tehran, 2004)Google Scholar.

34 Bazargan, Abbas, “Academic Internal Evaluation and its Application to Continual Enhancement of Higher Education Quality,” Quarterly Journal of Higher Education Research and Planning 3 & 4 (1995): 1–22Google Scholar.

35 Bazargan, Abbas, “Issues and Trends in Q.A Accreditation: A Case Study of Iran,” UNESCO, First Global Forum on International Quality Assurance Accreditation & The Recognition of Qualifications in H.E. (October 17–18, 2002), 54–69Google Scholar.

36 Higher Education Section of Administration and Planning Organization, The Act of 3rd Five-Year Development Plan, Higher Education Section, the Executive Programs (Tehran, 2000).

37 The latest version of this software along with a full manual was released in August 2005 (Secretariat for Internal Evaluation, 2005a).

38 Mohammadi, Reza, Manual and Framework for Compiling the Report of Internal Evaluation in the Level of Educational Department (Tehran, 2004)Google Scholar. Mohammadi, Reza, A Study of the Progress of Internal Evaluation Project in Iran's Universities (Tehran, 2003)Google Scholar.

39 The Project of Internal Evaluation of Performance of the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology and Designing its Appropriate Macro-System of Evaluation (Tehran, 2005b).

40 Ministry of Health, Treatment and Medical Education, Performance of Medical Higher Education Achievements in 2004 & 2005 (Tehran, 2005).

41 Bazargan, Abbas, “Internal Evaluation in Order to Academic Quality Improvement: A Look at One Decade Experience in Iran's Higher Education,” 2nd Conference of Internal Evaluation, 15/5/2006 (Tehran, 2006), 3–5Google Scholar.

42 Second Conference of Internal Evaluation in order to Academic Quality Enhancement: Achievements, Challenges and Perspectives (Tehran, 2006).

43 Ministry of Science, Research and Technology, Promotion Statute (Tehran, 1987 & 2001).

44 Roshan, Ahmadreza, Polling from Faculties about Promotion Statute (Tehran, 2006)Google Scholar.

45 Safari, Nasser, “Centres of Excellence: National and International Experiences,” in Articles Collection of the First Conference of Iran's Centres of Excellence (Tehran, 2004), 75–82Google Scholar.

46 Centres of Excellence Statute, Research and Technology Report (Tehran, 2004).

47 Centres of Excellence's Report (Tehran, 2004).

48 Davari, Abdorreza, “The Pathology of the Project of Establishing Centres of Excellence in Iran's Universities,” in The Articles Collection of the First Conference of Iran's Centres of Excellence (Tehran, 2004), 101–110Google Scholar.

49 Jokar, Najaf, “An Introduction to the Criteria and Methods of Recognizing Centres of Excellence and Their Problems,” in The Articles Collection of the First Conference of Iran's Centres of Excellence (Tehran, 2004), 125–131Google Scholar.

50 Vahidi, Paridokht, Higher Education Indicators in Iran (Tehran, 1985)Google Scholar. Shams, Nasser and Moballegh, Mehdi, Designing and Explaining the Indicators of Productivity (Tehran, 2001)Google Scholar. Naghizadeh, Sima, Indicators of Evaluation (Tehran, 2000)Google Scholar. Shafia, Mohammadali, Appropriate Indicators for Quality Evaluation of Higher Education Performance (Tehran, 2001)Google Scholar. Farasatkhah, Maghsood, A Study of Increase in Higher Education Accessibility (Tehran, 2003)Google Scholar. Keizoori, Amirhossein, Designing and Formulating the Appropriate Approach towards Academic Budget Allocation in Iran based on Quality Indicators of Academic System (Tehran, 2005)Google Scholar.

51 Cultural and Scientific Supervision and Evaluation Body, Indicators of Iran's Science and Technology Evaluation (Tehran, 2002). Cultural and Scientific Supervision and Evaluation Body, Indicators of Higher Education Evaluation (Tehran, 2004). Administration and Planning Organization, The Act of Fourth Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of Islamic Republic of Iran 2005–2009 (Tehran, 2004). Higher Education Supervision and Evaluation Office, The Indicators of Supervision and Evaluation of the Universities and Research and Higher Education Institutes (Tehran, 2001). Ministry of Science, Research and Technology, The Project of Internal Evaluation of Performance of the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology and Designing its Appropriate Macro-System of Evaluation (Tehran, 2005).

52 Secretariat for Cultural Revolution Supreme Council, Collection of Ratifications of Cultural Revolution Headquarter (Tehran, n.d.).

53 Bazargan, Abbas, “Evaluation in Higher Education: Concepts, Definitions, Theories and Models,” presented in Specialized Forum for Higher Education Evaluation, 14/3/2005 (Tehran, 1995), 25–31Google Scholar. Parand, Koorosh, “A Report of Activities Concerning Higher Education Evaluation,” presented in 2nd Conference of Internal Evaluation, 15/5/2006; Tehran University & National Organization for Educational Testing (Tehran, 2006)Google Scholar. Mohammadi, Reza, et al., Quality Evaluation in Higher Education: Concepts, Principles, Methods and Criteria (Tehran, 2005)Google Scholar. Mehralizadeh, Yadollah, “Ambiguities in Iranian Universities Ranking,” in Higher Education Letter (2006), 3–12Google Scholar.

54 Ministry of Health, Cure and Medical Education, Information Bank of Iranian Medical Schools Ranking (Tehran, 2001).

55 Hajizadeh, Ma'soomeh, “A Look at the Project of Ranking Iran's Medical Schools,” in National Organization for Educational Testing (Tehran, 2002), 56–72Google Scholar.

56 Report of Faculties Ranking in 2002 (Tehran, 2004).

57 Report of Faculties Ranking in 2002 (Tehran, 2004).

58 Bazargan, Abbas, “Internal Evaluation in Order to Academic Quality Improvement: A Look at One Decade Experience in Iran's Higher Education,” in 2nd Conference of Internal Evaluation, 15/5/2006, Tehran University & National Organization for Educational Testing (Tehran, 2006)Google Scholar.

59 Report of the Secretariat for Supervision, Evaluation and Development of Medical Universities Council (Tehran, 2004).

60 Administration and Planning Organization, The Act of Fourth Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of Islamic Republic of Iran 2005–2009 (Tehran, 2004).