Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-2lccl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T15:01:03.129Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Testing Equality: The National Teacher Examination and the NAACP's Legal Campaign to Equalize Teachers' Salaries in the South, 1936–63

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Scott Baker
Scott Baker*
Affiliation:
Wake Forest University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the middle of the twentieth century, the white elites who controlled public education in the South stood at a racial crossroads. Facing increasingly insistent demands for equality and access from the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), political and educational leaders had to choose between accommodation and resistance. Pressure from the NAACP and the courts did bring important accommodations, but in significant, and still unexamined, ways the white South chose to resist. The most durable resistance to the challenges posed by the NAACP's legal campaign came not in the courts or in politics but within educational institutions. While the South's legal and political defense of racial discrimination and segregation ultimately collapsed, resistance inside schools endured. Beginning in the 1940s, shrewd southern elites institutionalized new, more legally defensible forms of discrimination and inequality that continue to define educational arrangements in the region today.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 35 , Issue 1 , Spring 1995 , pp. 49 - 64
Copyright
Copyright © 1995 by the History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Baker, Scott, “Ambiguous Legacies: The NAACP's Legal Campaign against Segregation in Charleston, South Carolina, 1935–1975” (Ph.D. diss., Columbia University, 1993).Google Scholar

2 The salary equalization campaign has been examined by Tushnet, Mark V., The NAACP's Legal Strategy against Segregated Education, 1925–1950 (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1987), 88–104; Nieman, Donald G., Promises to Keep: African-Americans and the Constitutional Order, 1776 to the Present (New York, 1991), 130–39; Beezer, Bruce, “Black Teachers' Salaries and the Federal Courts before Brown v. Board of Education: One Beginning for Equity,” Journal of Negro Education 55 (Spring 1986): 200–213; Bullock, Henry Allen, A History of Negro Education in the South: From 1619 to the Present (Cambridge, Mass., 1967), 213–20. Anderson, James D., “Race, Meritocracy, and the American Academy during the Immediate Post–World War II Era,” History of Education Quarterly 33 (Summer 1993): 174; Cecelski, David S., Along Freedom Road: Hyde County, North Carolina, and the Fate of Black Schools in the South (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1994), 160.Google Scholar

3 Thurgood Marshall, Memorandum to Branch Presidents, 13 Sep. 1937, box I-C-290, NAACP Papers, Manuscripts Division, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.; Marshall, Thurgood, “An Evaluation of Recent Efforts to Achieve Racial Integration in Education through Resort to the Courts,” Journal of Negro Education 21 (Summer 1952): 318; Margo, Robert A., Race and Schooling in the South, 1880–1950: An Economic History (Chicago, 1990), 53, 62; Teachers' Salaries in Black and White, box II-B-176, NAACP Papers; Deiss, Jay to Scott, C. H., 4 Aug. 1941, box II-B-174, NAACP Papers.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4 Marshall, , “An Evaluation,” 318; Margold Report, 95, box I-C-200, NAACP Papers; Equalization of Teachers' Salaries, box I-C-198, NAACP Papers.Google Scholar

5 Mills v. Board of Trustees of Anne Arundel County, 30 F. Supp. 245 (1939) at 249, 251; Alston et al. v. School Board of the City of Norfolk et al., 112 F. 2d. 992 (1940) at 995.Google Scholar

6 Margold Report, 95; Mills at 249, 251; Alston at 996.Google Scholar

7 Kluger, Richard, Simple Justice: The History of Brown v. Board of Education and Black America's Struggle for Equality (New York, 1975), 270; Teachers' Salaries in Black and White; Thurgood Marshall, interview by Edward Erwin, 15 Feb. 1977, 88, Columbia Oral History Collection, Butler Library, Columbia University, New York, N.Y.; Myrdal, Gunnar, An American Dilemma: The Negro Problem and Modern Democracy (New York, 1944), 320.Google Scholar

8 Cremin, Lawrence A., American Education: The Metropolitan Experience, 1876–1980 (New York, 1988), 200; Kluger, , Simple Justice, 891.Google Scholar

9 Lagemann, Ellen Condliffe, Private Power for the Public Good: A History of the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching (Middletown, Conn., 1983), 104; Downey, Matthew T., Ben D. Wood: Educational Reformer (Princeton, N.J., 1965); Jarvella Wilson, Ann E., “Knowledge for Teachers: The National Teacher Examinations Program, 1940 to 1970” (Ph.D. diss., University of Wisconsin, 1984); Wood, Ben D., “Making Use of the Objective Examination as a Phase of Teacher Selection,” Harvard Educational Review 10 (May 1940): 278.Google Scholar

10 Wood, Ben D., “Making Use of the Objective Examination,” 280; idem, An Announcement of Teacher Examination Service (New York, 1939); Wilson, , “Knowledge for Teachers,” 85–162; Wood, Ben D. and Beers, F. S., “Knowledge versus Thinking?” Teachers College Record 37 (Mar. 1936): 487–99.Google Scholar

11 In 1940, the exam fee was five dollars per candidate. Eighty percent of those who took the test were from the Northeast. Downey, , Ben D. Wood, 60; Wilson, , “Knowledge for Teachers,” 163–65; Pilley, John G., “The National Teacher Examination Service,” The School Review 49 (Mar. 1941): 180; Wood, Ben D., “Dr. Wood's Statement,” Progressive Education 17 (Mar. 1940): 155–56. For an excellent review of the voluminous literature on the NTE, see Haney, Walter, Madaus, George, and Kreitzer, Amelia, “Charms Talismanic: Testing Teachers for the Improvement of American Education,” in Review of Research in Education , ed. Rothkopf, Ernest Z. (Washington, D.C., 1987), 169–238. For a discussion of the NTE's validity, see Quirk, Thomas J., Witten, Barbara J., and Weinberg, Susan F., “Review of Studies of the Concurrent and Predictive Validity of the National Teacher Examinations,” Review of Educational Research 43 (Winter 1973): 89–113.Google Scholar

12 Wood, Ben to Beers, F. S., 18 Feb. 1941, file 147, reel 18, Wood Papers, Ben D., Educational Testing Service Archives, Princeton, N. J.; Wilson, , “Knowledge for Teachers,” 165; Downey, , Ben D. Wood, 61.Google Scholar

13 Wood, to Stoddard, A. J., 29 Mar. and 15 Apr. 1941, file 143, reel 18, Wood Papers.Google Scholar

14 Stoddard, to Wood, , 28 Mar. 1941, file 143, reel 18, Wood Papers; Wood, to Thompson, M. E., 6 Apr. 1941, and Wood to Dean Lyman, 16 Apr. 1941, file 147, reel 18, Wood Papers.Google Scholar

15 Wood, Ben, Adaptation of Certification-Salary Classification Plan for Use by Local Educational Authorities, 11 Apr. 1941, file 149, reel 18, Wood Papers; Wood, to Stoddard, , 5 Jan. 1942 and 15 Apr. 1941, file 143, reel 18, Wood Papers; Wood, to Robinson, D. W., 18 Mar. 1941, file 149, reel 18, Wood Papers; Wood, to Thompson, , 6 Apr. 1941, file 148, reel 18, Wood Papers.Google Scholar

16 Caliver, Ambrose, “Certain Significant Developments in the Education of Negroes during the Last Generation,” Journal of Negro History 35 (Apr. 1950): 119; Myrdal, , An American Dilemma, 320; Thompson, Charles H., “The Negro Teacher and Desegregation of the Public Schools,” Journal of Negro Education 22 (Summer 1953): 97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17 Wood, to Beers, , 14 Apr. 1941, file 147, reel 18, Wood Papers; Ben Wood, Memo to the National Committee, 22 Jan. 1942, file 143, reel 18, Wood Papers; Beers, to Wood, , 25 Jan. 1941 and 5 Mar. 1940, file 147, reel 18, Wood Papers; Wood, to Copeland, D., 5 June 1941, file 148, reel 18, Wood Papers; Wood, to True, J. A., 13 Mar. 1941, file 145, reel 18, Wood Papers; Boehm, Ralph, ed., Papers of the NAACP, Part 3, The Campaign for Educational Equality: Legal Department and Central Office Records, 1913–50, frame 0652, reel 6, Teachers' Salaries, Virginia, series B, Legal Department and Central Office Records, 1940–50 (Frederick, Md., 1982).Google Scholar

18 Memorandum from Marshall, Latest Developments in Teacher Salary Cases, 28 July 1941, and Marshall to Walter White, 23 Sep. 1943, box II-B-176, NAACP Papers; Tushnet, , The NAACP's Legal Strategy, 90; Morris v. Williams, 149 F. 2d 703 (1945).Google Scholar

19 NAACP Press Release, Dade Co. Teachers' Salary Case, no date, box II-B-175, NAACP Papers; Memo From the Legal Department for Press Release, 11 June 1942, box II-B-175, NAACP Papers; Edwin Clark to Walter White, 23 Apr. 1942, box II-B-175, NAACP Papers.Google Scholar

20 Turner v. Keefe Chairman of Board of Public Instruction et al., 50 F. Supp. 647 (1943) at 651; Teachers' Salary Cases Pending as of 1 May 1943, and NAACP Press Release, box II-B-175, NAACP Papers; Ransom, Leon A., “Education and the Law,” Journal of Negro Education 11 (Oct. 1942): 569; Marshall, Thurgood, “The Legal Battle,” NAACP Branch Bulletin (Apr. 1943).Google Scholar

21 Reynolds, et al. v. Board of Public Instruction for Dade County, Fla. et al., NAACP brief, box II-B-175, NAACP Papers.Google Scholar

22 Reynolds et al. v. Board of Public Instruction for Dade County, Fla. et al., 148 F. 2d 754 (1945) at 757; Turner v. Keefe, at 651, 653; McDaniel v. Bd. of Public Instruction for Escambia Co., Florida et al., 39 F. Supp. 638 (1941); two of the salary cases in Florida were settled by consent decrees.Google Scholar

23 Bracey, Helen H., “Negro Higher and Professional Education in Florida,” Journal of Negro Education 17 (Summer 1948): 275–76; Margo, , Race and Schooling, 73, 76, 85; Orazem, Peter T., “Black–White Differences in Schooling Investment and Human Capital Production in Segregated Schools,” American Economic Review 77 (Sep. 1987): 714–23; U.S. Office of Education, Biennial Survey of Education in the United States, 1944–1946 (Washington, D.C., 1950), 29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

24 Marshall, Thurgood, “Teachers' Salary Cases,” in The Negro Handbook: 1946–1947, ed. Murray, Florence (New York, 1947), 45; Memo, to Messrs, . White and Marshall from Leslie Perry, 6 Nov. 1944, and Marshall, to Perry, , 25 Sep. 1944, box II-B-176, NAACP Papers.Google Scholar

25 Wood interview by Saretsky, Gary, 7 Nov. 1977, Princeton, N.J., vol. II, 35, Educational Testing Service Archives, Princeton, N.J.; Excerpts of Special Committee to Investigate State Laws Dealing with Education, 1–2, file 149, reel 18, Wood Papers.Google Scholar

26 McCall, to Wood, , 15 Nov. 1940, and Wood, to Robinson, , 24 Mar. 1941, file 149, reel 18, Wood Papers; Baker, , “Ambiguous Legacies,” 81–97.Google Scholar

27 Yarborough, Tinsley E., A Passion for Justice (New York, 1987), 42–47; Duvall v. Seignious, unpublished consent decree, J. Waites Waring Papers, box 110–27, Moorland Spingarn Library, Howard University, Washington, D.C.; Rhett, A. B. to Wood, , 19 Oct. 1943, file 149, reel 18, Wood Papers; Charleston News and Courier, undated clipping, box II-B-180, NAACP Papers.Google Scholar

28 Daniel, J. McT., Excellent Teachers: Their Qualities and Qualifications (Columbia, S.C., 1944), 236, 238, 275, 280; Frick, H. L., A Proposed Plan for the Certification of Teachers in South Carolina (Columbia, S.C., 1944), 55; Hunter, E. C., Education of Teachers: Report of the Investigation of Educational Qualifications of Teachers in South Carolina (Columbia, S.C., 1944); Brewton, John, Excellent Schools: Their Characteristics: Report of the Investigation of Educational Qualifications of Teachers in South Carolina (Columbia, S.C., 1944).Google Scholar

29 United States v. South Carolina, 445 F. Supp. 1094 (1977) at 1101; White, J. B. to Wood, , 18 July 1944, file 149, reel 18, Wood Papers.Google Scholar

30 Key, V. O., Southern Politics in State and Nation (New York, 1949), 154; Deficiency Appropriation Act, 1945–46, Section 76, 86, box 110–34, Waring Papers.Google Scholar

31 Thompson v. Gibbes et al., 60 F. Supp. 872 (1945) at 875, 876; DeCosta, Frank A., “The Education of Negroes in South Carolina,” Journal of Negro Education 16 (Summer 1947): 410; “Negro Higher and Professional Education in South Carolina,” Journal of Negro Education 17 (Summer 1948): 350–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

32 George Peabody College for Teachers, The Public Schools of South Carolina: A Report (Nashville, Term., 1948), 100; U.S. Office of Education, Biennial Survey of Education in the United States, 1946–1948 (Washington, D.C., 1952), 41; Wood, to Robinson, D. W., 24 Mar. 1941, file 149, reel 18, Wood Papers; Charleston Board of School Commissioners, Minute Books, 18 Mar. 1948, Office of Records and Archives, Charleston County School District, Charleston, S.C.; Charleston News and Courier, 5 Sep. 1947.Google Scholar

33 Teachers' Salaries in Black and White, box II-B-176, NAACP Papers; U.S. Office of Education, Biennial Survey of Education in the United States, 1948–1950 (Washington, D.C., 1954), 49; Margo, , Race and Schooling, 56; Bullock, , History of Negro Education, 219; Beezer, , “Black Teachers' Salaries,” 212; Nieman, , Promises to Keep, 139.Google Scholar

34 Wood, to Ryans, David, 22 Feb. 1946, file 134, reel 17, Wood Papers; Wilson, , “Knowledge for Teachers,” 221–71; Rivlin, Harry N., “National Teacher Examinations,” in The Fourth Mental Measurements Yearbook , ed. Buros, Oscar K. (Highland Park, N.J., 1953), 802; Benson, Arthur L., “Testing Procedures in the Administration of Educational Personnel,” Education 75 (Dec. 1954): 245; idem, “Problems of Evaluating Test Scores of White and Negro Teachers,” Southern Association of Colleges and Secondary Schools, Proceedings (Atlanta, Ga., 1955), 176.Google Scholar

35 Educational Testing Service, Annual Report, 1953–1954 (Princeton, N.J., 1954), 53, 63; Educational Testing Service, Annual Report, 1954–1955 (Princeton, N.J., 1955), 70; Educational Testing Service, Annual Report, 1955–1956 (Princeton, N.J., 1956), 91–92; Educational Testing Service, Annual Report, 1959–1960 (Princeton, N.J., 1960), 36, 58–59; Educational Testing Service, School Systems Using Tests Prepared by Educational Testing Service, Sep. 1959, NTE History File, Educational Testing Service Archives, Princeton, N.J.; Wilson, , “Knowledge for Teachers,” 205–69; Haney, , Madaus, , and Kreitzer, , “Charms Talismanic,” 227; Pritchey Smith, G., The Effects of Competency Testing on the Supply of Minority Teachers (Washington, D.C., 1987), 15–18; Foster, Michele, “The Politics of Race: Through the Eyes of African American Teachers,” in What Schools Can Do: Critical Pedagogy and Practice , ed. Weiler, Kathleen and Mitchell, Candace (Albany, N.Y., 1992), 188.Google Scholar