Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-skm99 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-27T13:36:25.371Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

In Search of a Direction: Southern Higher Education after the Civil War

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Joseph M. Stetar
Joseph M. Stetar*
Affiliation:
Seton Hall University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The south did not share in the enormous expansion of American higher education in the years following the Civil War. Nationally, higher education enrollments grew over five-fold in the decades following the War. In 1870 there were 62,000 students in colleges, universities, professional, normal and teacher colleges in the United States. By 1890 the total higher education enrollment was 157,000 and by 1910 had risen to 355,000. Multipurpose institutions with programs characteristic of the leading twentieth-century universities began to appear in the East, West and Midwest. No such development was evident in the nineteenth-century South where colleges struggled to remain alive. Left virtually destitute by the War and lacking students, buildings and assets, college leaders clung more to romantic dreams and were unable to share in the bold expansion experienced by other regions. The point is etched clearly when one realizes that about the time Charles W. Eliot began to chart the transition of Harvard College to Harvard University, Landon C. Garland, President of the University of Alabama, and later of Vanderbilt, wrote:

The University buildings are all burned. Nothing was saved but the private residence of the officers. The most valuable part of my library … was consumed. This is a great loss to me just now.

I do not know that the University of Alabama will be rebuilt—if at all, it will be several years hence. I cannot await the final results, but must look for some employment.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 25 , Issue 3 , Fall 1985 , pp. 341 - 367
Copyright
Copyright © 1985 by History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. Burke, C.B., “The Expansion of American Higher Education,” in The Transformation of Higher Learning 1860–1930, ed. Jarausch, K.H. (Chicago, 1983), p. 111.Google Scholar

2. Letter, L.C. Garland to his father, May 30, 1865. Joint University Library, Vanderbilt University, John James Tiger IV Collection.Google Scholar

3. Sellers, J.B., History of University of Alabama, Vol. I: 1818–1902 (University of Alabama, 1953), pp. 292–313.Google Scholar

4. Somers, R., The Southern State Since the War 1870–1871 (New York, 1871) pp. 159–160. Somers, a visiting Englishman, stated “the professors at the close of the war were put under the ban of political proscription … and new men of inferior attainments were set down in their chairs. The consequence is that Alabama has still a University, with buildings and libraries, and professors, and expenditure, but no students….” Google Scholar

5. Letter, Quinche, A.J. to Johnson, J.L., February 1, 1873, Southern Historical Collection, University of North Carolina, John Lipscomb Johnson Papers. Note : Lipscomb, John Johnson joined the University of Mississippi faculty in 1873.Google Scholar

6. Wallace, D.D., History of Wofford College (Nashville, 1951), p. 152.Google Scholar

7. Chaffin, N.C., Trinity College, 1839–1892: The Beginnings of Duke University (Durham, 1950), pp. 255–256.Google Scholar

8. Battle, K.P., The Struggle and the Story of the Rebirth of the University (Chapel Hill, 1901), pp. 3–11. Also see Wagstaff, H.M., Impressions of Men and Movements at the University of North Carolina (Chapel Hill, 1950).Google Scholar

9. “The curricula of the university 1857–1858 and 1897–1898,” University [North Carolina] Record , January, 1898.Google Scholar

10. Paschal, G.W., History of Wake Forest College, Vol. II: 1865–1905 (Wake Forest, 1943), pp. 2–22 and 419.Google Scholar

11. Hollis, D.W., University of South Carolina, Vol. I: South Carolina College (Columbia, 1951), pp. 214–222.Google Scholar

12. Hollis, D.W., University of South Carolina, Vol. II: College to University (Columbia, 1956), pp. 44–79.Google Scholar

13. Barnard, F.A., Report on the organization of military schools, Made to the Trustees of the University of Mississippi (Jackson, 1861), p. 31. University of Mississippi Library, Mississippi Collections.Google Scholar

14. Veysey, L.R., The Emergence of the American University, (Chicago, 1970). For a critique of Veysey see Mattingly, P., “Structures Over Time: Institutional History,” in Historical Inquiry in Education , ed. Best, J.H. (Washington, D.C., 1983), pp. 34–55.Google Scholar

15. Woodward, C.V., Origins of the New South, 1877–1913, (Baton Rouge, 1951), pp. 436–438.Google Scholar

16. Degler, C., “The Two Cultures and the Civil War,” in The Development of an American Culture, eds. Cohen, S. and Ratner, L. (Englewood Cliffs, 1970), pp. 92–119.Google Scholar

17. Cash, W.J., The Mind of the South, (New York, 1941), p. vii.Google Scholar

18. Degler, , “Two Cultures and Civil War,” p. 117.Google Scholar

19. Woodward, , Origins of the New South, p. x.Google Scholar

20. Palmer, B.M., The Life and Letters of James Henley Thornwell, (Richmond, 1871), p. 357. Also Waddel, J.N. Nature and Advantage of the Course of Study in Institutions of the Higher Learning (Natchez, 1866), p. 13.Google Scholar

21. Brewer, F., “South Carolina University,” (manuscript, 1876), South Carolinian Library, University of South Carolina, Fisk Brewer Manuscript Collection.Google Scholar

22. Brewer, F., “Assorted class notes and notebook,” ca. 1877, South Carolinian Library, University of South Carolina, Fisk Brewer Manuscript Collection.Google Scholar

23. Porter, W.D., College and Collegians, (Charleston, 1871), p. 19. Porter was a Trustee of South Carolina College from 1858 to 1868.Google Scholar

24. Pusey, W.A., “Should the classics still be studied,” Vanderbilt Observer, 8, October, 1885, p. 2.Google Scholar

25. “The study of Latin and Greek,” Trinity Archive, VI, April, 1893, p. 283.Google Scholar

26. Waddel, , Nature and Advantage, p. 1.Google Scholar

27. Minutes of the Faculty Meeting, University of Mississippi, April 22, 1884. Note: Fulton joined the University of Mississippi in 1871 as a tutor and from 1892 to 1906 served as Chancellor.Google Scholar

28. Barnard, , Report to Trustees of University of Mississippi, p. 31.Google Scholar

29. Cabaniss, A., The University of Mississippi: Its First Hundred Years, (Hattiesburg, 1971), p. 64.Google Scholar

30. Catalogue of Trinity College, 1885–1886, p. 9.Google Scholar

31. Wallace, D.D., History of Wofford College, (Nashville, 1951), pp. 77–78.Google Scholar

32. Brewer, , “South Carolina University.” Google Scholar

33. Easterby, J.H., A History of the College of Charleston, (Charleston, 1935), p. 164.Google Scholar

34. Bullock, H.M., A History of Emory University, (Nashville, 1936), pp. 154–174. Also see: Bauman, M., “Confronting the New South Greed: The Genteel Conservative as Higher Educator,” in Education and the Rise of the New South , eds. Goodenow, R.K. and White, A.O. (Boston, 1981), pp. 91–113.Google Scholar

35. Hutson, C.W., “The South Carolina College of the late fifties,” Compiler: Snowden, Yates, Sermon and Lectures South Carolina College and University, 1830–1910, South Carolinian Library, University of South Carolina.Google Scholar

36. Taylor, J.W., The Young Men of the New South: The Education, Duties and Rewards, (Memphis, 1869), p. 8. Mississippi Collection, University of Mississippi Library.Google Scholar

37. Cash, W., Mind of the South, p. 80.Google Scholar

38. Whitman, W.M., “Address of the laying of the corner-stone of Wofford College,” (manuscript, July 4, 1851). Sandor Teszler Library, Wofford College Archives.Google Scholar

39. Catalogue of the officers and students of the University of Mississippi, 1879–1880. pp. 74–75. Also see: Trustees of the State University, Where shall I send my son? (Oxford, 1876), pp. 3–4. Mississippi Collection, University of Mississippi Library.Google Scholar

40. Minutes of the Board of Trustees Meeting, University of Mississippi, June 24, 1886.Google Scholar

41. Minutes of the Board of Trustees Meeting, University of Mississippi, June 23, 1879.Google Scholar

42. Craven, B., “Mental discipline,” (eight page manuscript, n.d.). Perkins Library, Duke University, Braxton Craven Papers.Google Scholar

43. Woodward, C.V., Origins of the New South, pp. 142–174 provides an excellent analysis of Southern literary and religious values in the decades following the Civil War. For a highly relevant look at higher education and Southern culture see Wagoner, J.L., “Higher Education and Transitions in Southern Culture: An Exploratory Apolgia,” Journal of Thought, 18, Fall, 1983, pp. 104–118.Google Scholar

44. Harrington, D.P., Requirements for the Degree, A. B. Contained in Proceedings of the first annual session of the College Association of North Carolina, North Carolina Teacher , May, 1892. Linscott, H.F., “Pure Scholarship—Its Place in Civilization.” South Atlantic Quarterly, 1 (October, 1902):341–350.Google Scholar

45. Hawkins, H., Between Harvard and America, (New York, 1972), p. 264.Google Scholar

46. Ramage, B.J., “The Limitations of Elective Work in School and College,” Sewanee Review, 9 (July 1901):319.Google Scholar

47. Witherspoon, T.D., The appeal of the South to its educated men. (Memphis, 1867), pp. 8–9. Mississippi Collection, University of Mississippi Library.Google Scholar

48. Bertelson, D., The Lazy South, (New York, 1967), pp. 75 and 182–183.Google Scholar

49. Degler, C.N., Place Over Time (Baton Rouge, 1977), pp. 99–132. Degler outlines the substantial economic and cultural continuity between the pre and post war South.Google Scholar

50. Degler, C., “Two Cultures and Civil War,” p. 119.Google Scholar

51. Porter, E.W., Trinity and Duke, (Durham, 1964), pp. 70–144.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

52. Kilgo, J.C., “Christian Education: Its Aims and Superiority,” ca. 1896. Perkins Library, Duke University, John C. Kilgo Papers.Google Scholar

53. Kilgo, J.C., Untitled typescript, n.d., p. 5. Perkins Library, Duke University, John Carlisle Kilgo Papers.Google Scholar

54. Snyder, H.N., “The Denominational College in Southern Education,” South Atlantic Quarterly, 5 (January 1906):9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

55. Snyder, H.N., “The Case of the Denominational College,” Methodist Review, 58(January, 1909): 14.Google Scholar

56. Carlisle, J.H., An undated clipping from the Florence, South Carolina Centenary (January, 1892), Sandor Teszler Library, Wofford College, Carlisle, James H. Papers. Also see: Snyder, H.N., “James H. Carlisle—Educator,” South Atlantic Quarterly, 9 (January, 1910):10–20.Google Scholar

57. Carlisle, J.H. Jr., “Memories of Wofford College,” (manuscript, n.d.), Sandor Teszler Library, Wofford College, Wofford College Archives.Google Scholar

58. Henneman, J.B., “The Late Professor Baskerville,” Sewanee Review, 8 (January, 1900):26–44.Google Scholar

59. Snyder, H.N., “The college literary society,” Sewanee Review, 12 (January, 1904):83.Google Scholar

60. Catalogue of the Officers and Students of the University of Mississippi, 1876–1877, p. 46.Google Scholar

61. Historical and current catalogue of the officers and students of the University of Mississippi, 1886–1887, p. 152.Google Scholar

62. Minutes of the Board of Trustees, University of Mississippi, August 6, 1889.Google Scholar

63. Pugh, G.T., “Is Science an Incentive to Poetry?” Wofford College Journal, 7 (June, 1897):284–291.Google Scholar

64. Wiggins, J.B., “Does the Study of Science tend to Suppress the Spirit of Poetry and Romance?” Wofford College Journal, 9 (June, 1898):46–52.Google Scholar

65. Veysey, , Emergence of American University, p. 60.Google Scholar

66. Hutson, C.W., The Southern Renaissance, (Columbia, 1885), p. 29.Google Scholar

67. For a contemporary's view of the South in the decades after the Civil War see Otken, C.H., Ills of the South, (New York, 1894). Reprint (New York, 1973). Also see: Woodward, , Origins of the New South, pp. 107–112.Google Scholar

68. Current, R.N., Northernizing the South, (Athens, 1983), p. 84.Google Scholar

69. Grantham, D.W., Southern Progressivism: The Reconciliation of Progress and Traditions, (Knoxville, 1983), p. xviii.Google Scholar

70. Woodward, , Origins of the New South, pp. 139–141.Google Scholar

71. O'Brien, M., The Idea of the American South, 1920–1941, (Baltimore, 1979), p. 6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

72. Grantham, , Southern Progressivism, p. 84. Also see pp. 268–270 for an examination of the development of utility in Southern higher education and pp. 5–8 for the impact of urbanization and industrialization upon the professions.Google Scholar

73. Catalogue of Wofford College, 1876–77, p. 18. For a relevant analysis of President Eliot and the elective system at Harvard see: Joynes, E.S., “President Eliot's inaugural address,” Educational Journal of Virginia, 1 (March, 1870): 136–140.Google Scholar

74. McBryde, J.M., Agricultural education. An address before the South Carolina State Legislature, December 12, 1882. (Columbia, 1883), pp. 12–15.Google Scholar

75. Joynes, E.S., “Relation of the state to higher education in colleges and professional schools,” a paper read before the Southern Educational Association in Chattanooga on July 9, 1891. South Carolinian Library, University of South Carolina.Google Scholar

76. Lipscomb, P.P., Dedication and inauguration of Vanderbilt University (Nashville, 1875), p. 76.Google Scholar

77. Kirkland, J.H., The service of citizenship, 1911. Joint University library, Vanderbilt University, Kirkland, James H. Addresses.Google Scholar

78. Kilgo, J.C., “Up to date education,” State. Columbia, South Carolina, April 14, 1899. Clipping contained in Perkins Library, Duke University, Kilgo, John C. Papers.Google Scholar

79. Kilgo, J.C., “The mission of Trinity College,” The Trinity Archive, 15 (November 1901):127.Google Scholar

80. Glasson, W.H., “The college professor in the public service,” South Atlantic Quarterly, 1 (July 1902):254.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

81. Catalogue of Trinity College, 1887–88, pp. 31–44.Google Scholar

82. Hilgard, E.W., Report on Organization of the Department of Agriculture and Mechanical Arts, 1871. Mississippi Collection, University of Mississippi Library.Google Scholar

83. McLemore, R.A., “The Roots of Higher Education in Mississippi,” Journal of Mississippi History, 26(August 1964) Also Betterworth, J.K., People's College: A History of Mississippi State University (Tuscaloosa: 1953), pp. 8–11.Google Scholar

84. McBryde, J.M., Agricultural education, (Columbia, 1883), pp. 22–23. South Carolinian Library, University of South Carolina. Also see: McBryde, J.M. Papers, Southern Historical Collection, University of North Carolina Library.Google Scholar

85. Battle, K.P., The head and the hand, (June 23, 1886), pp. 5–6. Pamphlet located in the South Carolinian Library, University of South Carolina.Google Scholar

86. Alderman, E.A., “The university: Its work and its needs, University of North Carolina,” Record 1901–1902 (Chapel Hill, 1901), p. 51.Google Scholar

87. Alderman, E.A., Inaugural address, January 27, 1897. North Carolina Collection, University of North Carolina, p. 29.Google Scholar

88. Shepherd, A.E., “Higher education in the south,” Sewanee Review, 1 (May 1893):287.Google Scholar

89. Dreher, J.D., “Colleges North and Colleges South,” National Educational Association, Journal of Proceedings and Addresses 1886, pp. 370–375.Google Scholar

90. Woodward, , Origins of the New South, p. 437.Google Scholar

91. Kilgo, J.C. “Some Phases of Southern Higher Education,” South Atlantic Quarterly, 2 (April 1903):141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

92. Few, W.P., “Trinity College and Her Present Opportunity.” Trinity Archive, 15 (November, 1901): 113. Few elsewhere stated: “For the good of the country as a whole [educational] centers should be distributed over the country rather than concentrated in sections. Draw a line across the map of the United States from a point just below the latitude of Washington and Baltimore on the Atlantic coast, and all the leading centers of research in graduate studies will be north of the line. The Northeast has Harvard, Columbia, Yale, and other great centers. Johns Hopkins is near the border line. The Central West has the University of Chicago, University of Michigan, University of Wisconsin, and other centers of note. The Pacific coast has the University of California, Stanford University, and California Institute of Technology. The South is making progress in four or five places and in some of these centers the progress is apt to be notable. Even so, it will be a good while before the southern states can do their share in scientific study and research.” Few, W.P., “The Beginnings of an American University.” (typescript, n.d.) Perkins Library, Duke University. William Preston Few Papers.Google Scholar

93. Minutes of the Board of Trustees, Vanderbilt University, April 29, 1874.Google Scholar

94. Minutes of the Board of Trustees, Vanderbilt University, June 19, 1876.Google Scholar

95. Kirkland, J.H., Proceedings and addresses at the installation and inauguration of James Hampton Kirkland, Ph.D., (Nashville, 1893), p. 37.Google Scholar

96. Kirkland, J.H., “Sketch of Vanderbilt University,” unpublished paper (1926), Joint University Library, Vanderbilt University, Kirkland, James H. Papers.Google Scholar

97. Boyd, W.K., “Trinity College before its removal to Durham,” (typescript copy, n.d.). Perkins Library,; Duke University, William Kenneth Boyd Papers.Google Scholar

98. Boyd, W.K., “Trinity and Duke,” (typescript copy, n.d.). Perkins Library, Duke University, Boyd, William Kenneth Papers.Google Scholar

99. Crowell, J.F., “Plan of a Methodist University in North Carolina,” (manuscript, ca. 1890). Perkins Library, Duke University, Crowell, John F. Papers.Google Scholar

100. Catalogue and Announcements of Trinity College, 1892–93.Google Scholar

101. Few, W.P., “Trinity College and her Present Opportunity,” p. 113.Google Scholar

102. Minutes of the Faculty Meeting, University of Mississippi, November 25, 1879.Google Scholar

103. Minutes of the Board of Trustees, University of Mississippi, June 22, 1886. Also see: Minutes of the Board of Trustees, University of Mississippi, June 27, 1889.Google Scholar

104. Minutes of the Board of Trustees, University of Mississippi, June 22, 1891.Google Scholar

105. Brown, M.R., Graduate programs in Mississippi to 1900, unpublished Master's thesis, History, University of Mississippi, 1968, pp. 15–16.Google Scholar

106. According to my research of the twenty-eight members with the Ph.D. at the University of South Carolina, University of Mississippi and University of North Carolina in 1903, seven received their doctorate from Hopkins, Johns, six from German Universities, four from University of North Carolina, four from Harvard University, three from other Eastern universities, two from other Southern universities, one from a Midwestern university and one was unknown.Google Scholar

107. Branson, D.C., “Letter from Johns Hopkins,” Trinity Archive, IV, March, 1891.Google Scholar

108. Ramage, B.S., Notes. Sewanee Review, 9(July, 1901):379.Google Scholar

109. Wagoner, , “Higher Education and Transitions,” p. 114.Google Scholar