Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-n9wrp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T17:13:43.786Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Effects of Ruralism, Bureaucratic Structure, and Economic Role on Right-Wing Extremism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 November 2009

Rodney Schneck
Affiliation:
University of Alberta
Douglas Russell
Affiliation:
University of Alberta
Ken Scott
Affiliation:
University of Alberta

Extract

In discussion of the social structure of modern capitalist societies the distinction between the “old” and “new” middle class is common. The old middle class is epitomized by the small businessman and the new middle class by the bureaucratic manager and employee. It has been postulated that the political sentiments and attitudes are different among these two subsets of the middle class. Specifically, it is hypothesized that the old middle class in a mature industrial and capitalistic system is especially vulnerable to right-wing extremism. It is the purpose of this paper to report research testing the above general hypothesis by using three factors of explanation.

Type
Notes
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Political Science Association (l'Association canadienne de science politique) and/et la Société québécoise de science politique 1974

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Corey, Lewis, “The Middle Class,” The Antioch Review, (Spring, 1945), 120Google Scholar; and Wright Mills, C., While Collar (New York, 1956), 376.Google Scholar

2 Lipset, Seymour M., “Social Stratification and ‘Right-Wing Extremism,’” British Journal of Sociology, 10 (1959), 138CrossRefGoogle Scholar, “The Radical Right: A Problem for American Democracy,” British Journal of Sociology, 6(155), 176–209, and Political Man (New York, 1963), chap. 5; Parsons, Talcott, “Some Sociological Aspects of the Fascist Movement,” in his Essays of Sociological Theory (Glencoe, 1954), 133–4Google Scholar; Trow, Martin, “Small Businessmen, Political Tolerance and Support For McCarthy,” American Journal of Sociology, 64 (1958), 270–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kornhauser, William, The Politics of Mass Society (Glencoe, 1959), 194211Google Scholar; The Radical Right, ed. Bell, Daniel, (New York, 1964)Google Scholar; Hofstadter, Richard, “The Pseudo-Conservative Revolt,” American Scholar, 24 (1954), 927Google Scholar; Mills, White Collar, chap. 3; Bunzel, John H., The American Small Businessman (New York, 1962)Google Scholar, and “The General Ideology of American Small Business,” Political Science Quarterly, 70 (1955), 87–102; Shils, Edward A., The Torment of Secrecy (Glencoe, 1955)Google Scholar; Campbell, Peter, “Le Mouvement Poujade,” Parliamentary Affairs, 10 (1957), 362–77Google Scholar; and Ehrmann, Henry W., Organized Business in France (Princeton, 1957).Google Scholar

3 In essence this research is attempting to test the predictability of each theory.

4 Kornhauser, The Politics of Mass Society; Trow, “Small Businessmen, Political Tolerance and Support for McCarthy,”; Gusfield, Joseph, “Mass Society and Extremism,” American Sociological Review, XXVII (February, 1962), 1930CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Joel I. Nelson, “Anomie: Comparisons Between the Old and New Middle Class,” Amercian Journal of Sociology, 74, 184–5.

5 Nelson, “Anomie: Comparisons Between the Old and New Middle Class.”

6 Bunzell, The American Small Businessman; Rogers, D. and Berg, I. E., “Occupation and Ideology: The Case of the Small Businessman,” Human Organizations, 6 (1961)Google Scholar; Rohrer, W.C. and Douglas, L.H., The Agrarian Transition in American (New York, 1969)Google Scholar; Haer, John L., “Conservatism-Radicalism and the Rural-Urban Continuum,” Rural Sociology, 17 (December, 1952), 343–7Google Scholar; and Lipset, Political Man.

7 To complete the analysis it would have been useful to have four more groups: rural employees of non-bureaucratic organizations; rural managers in bureaucratic organizations; rural employees in bureaucratic organizations; and urban managers of non-bureaucratic organizations. In our sample we were able to find 14 in the first group but they were dropped from the analysis because of their small number. It was impossible to find any of the remaining three groups in the sample area.

8 Some Implications of Value Differentiation in Pharmacy,” Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology, 3, no. 1 (February, 1966), 23–37.

9 “Retail Pharmacy: Professional Contingencies in Business Settings,” (phd dissertation, University of North Carolina, 1968).

10 “Occupational Structure and Criminal Behavior: Prescription Violation by Retail Pharmacists,” Social Problems, 11 (Fall, 1963), 179–85.

11 The term “qualified pharmacist” refers to those so designated by the government of the province of Alberta and who were members of the Alberta Pharmaceutical Association.

12 The population of Edmonton in 1966 was 401,299 with a growth rate of 18.9 per cent over the 1961–6 period. The National growth rate for the same period was 9.7 per cent, as seen in the 1967 Canada Year Book, published by the Dominion Bureau of Statistics (Ottawa, 1968).

13 Toward a Definition of the Extreme Right,” Pacific Sociological Review, 6 (1963), 86–92, “Status Consistency and Right-Wing Extremism,” American Sociological Review, 32 (1967), 86–92, “Insert for the Expanded Version of Status Consistency and Right-Wing Extremism,” in draft, and “Crystalization and Right-Wing Extremist Attitudes,” (phd dissertation, University of Oregon, 1965).

14 A question may arise as to the applicability of Rush's scale to Alberta. Even though his empirical study was done on the west coast of the United States the theoretical base of his scale was derived from the work of scholars who have analysed the extreme right in terms of western capitalistic society rather than American society alone. For example, Lipset has discussed the characteristics and attitudes of the extreme right across Europe and the United States. Since such theoretical analysis would seem to be equally valid for Canadian society and, given the “face validity” of the items, the use of Rush's scale seems justified. Also, from a practical viewpoint it is one of a very few existing scales which have attempted to empirically measure this ideology.

15 Helmstodter, G.C., Principles of Psychological Measurement (New York, 1964), 85.Google Scholar

16 Garson, David G., Handbook of Political Science Methods, (Boston, 1971), 151.Google Scholar

17 The total sample was comprised of 388 respondents. In the separation of the data into the five basic groups, 367 respondents were thus classified. Twenty-one of the respondents did not fall into any of the five categories.

18 See Winer, B.J., Statistical Principles in Experimental Design (New York, 1962), 102.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

19 This research examined the possible effects of age, religion, ethnic origin and social back-ground, size of home, and community and marital status on right-wing extremism. Sex and activity in church membership were isolated as two variables which significantly relate to right-wing extremism. Further analysis showed that differences between the five groups were present which could be attributed to these two variables. It was found that the above differences among the five groups were maintained and strengthened with respondents who were either female or inactive church members. The relationship of church activity to political beliefs is some-what consistent with other findings but the relationship between sex and right-wing ideology is new. The results of relating sex and right-wing extremism is in draft.

20 The modern franchise system, in its various forms, is an important economic instrument that may increase the economic security and decrease the complexity and uncertainty of small business. This method of business operation may increase the chances of small business success by (1) increasing the probabilities of a stable market, (2) standardizing and rationalizing operations and managerial decision, and (3) providing essential services. Also, through the franchise system the small businessman has, to some degree, become an integral part of big business within the local community. He is an important appendage to big business and has a direct stake in the success of the giant corporation.

In summary the franchise system may be an important factor decreasing economic insecurity and alienation and thus decreasing the small businessman's susceptibility to right-wing extremism.

21 It should be recognized that there is a small sample of only four urban owners in sales over $150,000.

22 Again, there is the small sample size of only four urban owners.

23 “Anomie: Comparisons Between the Old and New Middle Class.”

24 See Lipset, “The Radical Right: A Problem for American Democracy,” The British Journal of Sociology, 176–209.

25 Lipset, Seymour M., The First New Nation (New York, 1963), 251.Google Scholar

26 The above summary of Canadian values is from Clark, S.D., The Developing Canadian Community (Toronto, 1968)Google Scholar and Lipset, Seymour M., “Revolution and Counter-Revolution - The United States and Canada,” in The Revolutionary Theme in Contemporary America, ed. Ford, Thomas R. (Lexington, Kentucky, 1965) 2164.Google Scholar